Meteor over Moscow

If air caused friction (which results in heat),...


If? The SR-71 had to be made out of titanium because air friction generated so much heat that aluminum wouldn't be able to hold up. The meteor over Russia was traveling about 14 times faster when it hit the atmosphere.

Steve S
 
My message was meant as a reply to r-j's non sequitur comment that "If air caused friction (which results in heat), then all the surfaces of the space shuttle would heat up" and as a result it was also an analogous and somewhat sarcastic non sequitur.
I agree that r-j's comment was a bit terse, yet in context I understood the point that simple friction does not well explain what goes on with a meteor, and it was not a non sequitur at all.
 
I apologize if I misunderstood your point.

My message was meant as a reply to r-j's non sequitur comment that "If air caused friction (which results in heat), then all the surfaces of the space shuttle would heat up" and as a result it was also an analogous and somewhat sarcastic non sequitur.

We are talking about two different but related things (or you could also classify it as one thing which can be divided into two types of things*) which can be referred to by the word "friction". This refers to all of the forces which oppose the vector of motion of an traveling object (either one traveling in a gaseous or liquid medium or one traveling while in contact with a stationary object and as a result of traveling through the medium or of being in contact with the stationary object**). In the case of air friction (also known as drag) one contribution to these forces comes from the compression of the fluid ahead of the traveling object.

These forces all have the potential of creating heat (at least when work is being done). That does not mean that where they are in effect heat shielding will always be required since it's not an all or nothing proposition (sometimes things heat up a lot and requite it and most of the time things don't heat up so much and we don't even notice the heating effect).

* Six of one, half a dozen of the other --since how you talk about it does not change the underlying realities and concepts.
** Yes, I'm ignoring static friction (which would be even less relevant to an object traveling through a medium).
 
If air caused friction (which results in heat), then all the surfaces of the space shuttle would heat up. But obviously that doesn't happen. Just the surfaces exposed to the hot plasma in front of the shuttle. It's why it was designed as it was, and the special tiles were only placed on areas exposed to the heat.


Hang on. There will still be some heating going on in the form of boundary layer skin friction. Take, for example, the Concorde. It flew at around Mach 2.0 at a cruising altitude of around 56,000 ft where the ambient air temperature is about -60°C. Typically the nose would heat up to around 125°C and the wing leading edges to around 105°C. This would be caused mostly by the compression of air, but the fuselage and aerodynamic flow surfaces and tailing edges of the wings and empennage would also heat up to around 90 to 95°C. This would mostly be caused by boundary layer skin friction, although admittedly, the physics of the supersonic wave-front could have some involvement too.

Interestingly, these temperature variations cause the length of the Concorde's fuselage to increase by as much as 0.4% during supersonic flight, i.e. Concorde was a foot longer in supersonic flight than it was on the ground!

Now, this aircraft was designed to stretch, and I'm guessing that meteors are not. Also, Concorde is smooth, so there would in all likelihood the boundary layer skin friction would help to lower the temperature gradient and therefore the stresses across different parts of the aircraft's surface.

However, a meteor is anything but smooth, and entering the atmosphere at around 40 m/s, would quickly lead to a massive compression wave building up "in front" with virtually no boundary layer skin friction. This would quickly cause a huge temperature differential between different parts of the meteor both internal and external, and leading to enormous stresses. This will be partially responsible for the breakup or explosion. How long the meteor lasts will be down to its size, and composition.
 
Right now the Science Channel is airing a show about the meteor and the asteroid called Fire in the Sky. It will repeat later tonight.

Steve S
 
Take, for example, the Concorde. It flew at around Mach 2.0 at a cruising altitude of around 56,000 ft where the ambient air temperature is about -60°C. Typically the nose would heat up to around 125°C and the wing leading edges to around 105°C.

According to the Wiki article on the SR-71, the canopy temperature would be 300C (572F) after landing. Also, some of the skin was corrugated to control how it expanded when heated. Flat skin would buckle.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_SR-71_Blackbird#Airframe


Steve S
 
According to the Wiki article on the SR-71, the canopy temperature would be 300C (572F) after landing. Also, some of the skin was corrugated to control how it expanded when heated. Flat skin would buckle.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_SR-71_Blackbird#Airframe


Steve S


True, but the problem of aerodynamic heating was approached differently in the Blackbird than it was in Concorde; in fact almost from the opposite direction.

In Concorde, the heat was dissipated by designing the structure to use high-temperature materials and heat-sinks to effectively conduct the heat away from the heat loaded areas such as leading edges into the structure of the aircraft.

The Blackbird is is a hypersonic aircraft (speed exceeding mach 3) and it flew at 80,000 feet where the air is a lot thinner. Under those conditions, heat loading becomes more problematic They used insulating material rather than heat conduction, and this lead to the anecdotal stories of Blackbirds being so hot when they landed that you could "fry an egg on the wing" or of observers being able to see that some surfaces were still "cherry red".
 
Russia meteor's origin tracked down

Astronomers have traced the origin of a meteor that injured about 1,000 people after breaking up over central Russia earlier this month. [...]

Using the footage and the location of an impact into Lake Chebarkul, Jorge Zuluaga and Ignacio Ferrin, who are based at the university in Medellin, were able to use simple trigonometry to calculate the height, speed and position of the rock as it fell to Earth.

To reconstruct the meteor's original orbit around the Sun, they used six different properties of its trajectory through Earth's atmosphere. Most of these are related to the point at which the meteor becomes bright enough to cast a noticeable shadow in the videos.

The researchers then plugged their figures into astronomy software developed by the US Naval Observatory.

The results suggest the meteor belongs to a well known family of space rocks - known as the Apollo asteroids - that cross Earth's orbit.
 
This is poorly written and unclear. In a given medium, the speed of sound is a constant. There are wave types that can travel slower, but none can travel faster.

That's not correct (as the references I cited note).

What is not clear is that the description of the the meteor pressure wave and breakup as an "explosion" is an analogy, since most people can visualize the pressure wave generated by a detonation. It would be more accurate to say that the pressure wave shattered the meteor.

No. The meteor exploded because of the rapid heat build-up inside it.

It didn't detonate in the technical sense of the word. I linked to the article on detonation because it explains that a shock wave can travel faster than the speed of sound.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
There is a lot of talk about all the video of the event (car cameras, security cameras), but there isn't any actual footage of what happened. No detail of what happened. And even if a high resolution camera was zoomed in on it, the light would have prevented seeing anything during the important part.

We don't actually know what happened.

Of course we do: meteor fall, heat, explode, crash.
 
FYI the Blackbird heating was the exact same reason, air pressure, not friction.

And it makes much more sense when you realize that the meteor compressed a column of air a hundred miles long (or more) down to almost nothing in 12 seconds. Just pumping up a bike tire makes the pump hot really fast.

That surface of a really cold rock went from -200C to over 10,000C in seconds would explain why it split in half. All figures are guesses of course. But the idea remains.
 
Another great example of a person declaring their intuition to be more accurate than the science.
Somehow I missed your commentary before. I wasn't talking about the apparent brightness of the object, but the temperature of the plasma that resulted in light. Obviously the brightness of the meteor wasn't anything close to the brightness of the sun, in an absolute sense.

Your "short amount of friction from air" only has to make the fireball one six-millionth as bright as the Sun for them to appear equal brightness in the sky.
Of course, but it's a misunderstanding. I was commenting on the intense temperatures reached by the air, not the appearance of it.

The plasma created by the space shuttle was around 1,400 degrees C, which was created by a long slow descent, anything faster and even the heat tiles would not protect the shuttle from burning up. The photosphere of the sun is around 5,500 degrees C, but the temperature of the plasma in front of the meteor was most likely far greater than that.

But, we don't know. That is why I said even if somebody had a telescope tracking it as it burned up, you couldn't see what happened. It was far too bright. Even if the hot plasma was only 5000 C (only?) it's still too bright to see anything.

I'm sure some physics person here can calculate what temperature the plasma would reach based on the velocity of the rock, and the time. It's obvious that unless it was a metal object, at some point the temperature (and pressure) will rise to the point that rock is going to lose out to the pressure and heat of the compressed air in front of it.

At those kinds of speeds the air is going to reach the point where it "feels" like a solid object to the meteor. Like how hitting water really fast causes an impact like hitting concrete. (or you go skidding off of it, depends on the angle)

The big difference being the air is also heating (expansion) which will make it a lot worse than hitting water really fast.
 
Last edited:
Asian news, NHK, had an interesting piece. They showed the light flash in a school hallway and the shockwave arriving ~2.5 minutes later. That was a surprise. There really was quite the delay. Some scientist they interviewed said he believed the flash was the point of meteor breakup.

I don't know why the argument continues over friction vs compression. It was easy to look up.
 
Last edited:
FYI the Blackbird heating was the exact same reason, air pressure, not friction.
And as long as you are not suggesting that the net forces of this pressure applied over all the surfaces of the aircraft are zero (or that they actually contribute to forward motion rather than oppose it) then they are part of what we call air friction or drag.
 
Ever since I was a young kid, I remember people telling me how air friction slows objects moving through the atmosphere. The problem with this claim is that it's wrong. Well, technically it's partially right: there is a friction force at play and it does have a slowing effect. The thing is that the effect of air friction is so negligible compared to what is really slowing moving objects down that it can safely be ignored in just about all cases. The claim that air friction is what slows moving objects down is akin to saying that the recoil of a rifle is due to the backward force of your finger upon the trigger.

http://thesciencepundit.blogspot.com/2010/04/air-friction-myths.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom