Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

But there are scientific theories and hypothesis that corroborate Biblical events and narratives which deserve discussion on a skeptic forums because they are theories and hypothesis forwarded by scientists and not just theological or theistic positions.

Surely skeptics can be taught the difference so they can focus on what is in the realm and scope of scientists which can be subject to critical thinking or scientific method. Skeptics should consider this rather sophisticated and profound proposition.

These are ideas that would best be examined over in R&P. I encourage you to begin a thread there.
 
I have looked at the Religion and Philosopy section and have not found any discussion on the scientific evidence forwarded by scientists that corroborates Biblical events and narratives.
Theists may want to think about that for a minute.

For example.
1. All the topics on Atheism. Atheism is not a scientific position, it is the rejection of deities or a belief in the non-existence of deities. Atheism is not a discussion based on scientific evidence.
Theism makes their gods unfalsifiable, keeping them out of the realm of science. Give your gods falsifiable characteristics and we can create testable hypotheses concerning them, thus putting them in the realm of science. Atheism as it stands now is based on a lack of evidence.

2. Discussion on the Miracle of the Shroud. Can scientists conclusively prove the existence of Jesus based on a single piece of evidence (the shroud) or even the non-existence of Jesus based on the same evidence? Just as it is wishful thinking for the Vatican to use it as evidence of Jesus so too it is when scientists apply their trade to disprove its authenticity. All the Bible said was Jesus was wrapped in linen a practice followed for all burials.
The shroud has been scientifically proven to be a 14th century forgery. It didn't exist at the time of Jesus and so has no bearing.

3. Other discussion on beliefs, church dogma and religiosity are not discussion that have been scientifically investigated or evidence found to support one position or another and therefore hardly productive.
Check out the LDS thread where the BoA has been investigated and proven to be a fraud perpetrated by Joseph Smith.

But there are scientific theories and hypothesis that corroborate Biblical events and narratives which deserve discussion on a skeptic forums because they are theories and hypothesis forwarded by scientists and not just theological or theistic positions.
So name one and let's discuss it. How about: Is the Earth only 6000 years old? Are bats really birds? Should we reinstitute slavery as the Bible condones it?

Surely skeptics can be taught the difference so they can focus on what is in the realm and scope of scientists which can be subject to critical thinking or scientific method. Skeptics should consider this rather sophisticated and profound proposition.
As you can see, there wasn't anything profound nor sophisticated about your proposition as it was based on... well, I'm not sure what you based it on.
 
<respectful snip for space>

originally posted by justintime
But there are scientific theories and hypothesis that corroborate Biblical events and narratives which deserve discussion on a skeptic forums because they are theories and hypothesis forwarded by scientists and not just theological or theistic positions.

So name one and let's discuss it. How about: Is the Earth only 6000 years old? Are bats really birds? Should we reinstitute slavery as the Bible condones it?

I would actually like to see this happen.

How about it, justintime?

Pick a specific scientific theory or hypothesis that "corroborates" a specific biblical event. Provide on point sources. Then we can discuss.
 
Nope. While he said that it was likely that they exist, he didn't "insist alien life exists"; he tried to find evidence for it.

Carl Sagan: "That doesn't say that extraterrestrial life is impossible. Quite the contrary. I think that many of the stars in the sky have planetary systems. We know enough now about the origin of life now to make it appear likely that life arises naturally on the vast bulk of these planets. It's possible but by no means certain that life on many of these planets evolves into beings which are as advanced as we, or more advanced, and I don't see any reason why we can't imagine that there are civilizations that are thousands or millions of years in advance of ourselves capable of technical feats that we can hardly imagine."
 
Carl Sagan: "That doesn't say that extraterrestrial life is impossible. Quite the contrary. I think that many of the stars in the sky have planetary systems. We know enough now about the origin of life now to make it appear likely that life arises naturally on the vast bulk of these planets. It's possible but by no means certain that life on many of these planets evolves into beings which are as advanced as we, or more advanced, and I don't see any reason why we can't imagine that there are civilizations that are thousands or millions of years in advance of ourselves capable of technical feats that we can hardly imagine."


Your quote doesn't contradict Mojo's statement, if you're implying it does. Here's Dr. Sagan again:

Carl Sagan said:
I'm frequently asked, "Do you believe there's extraterrestrial intelligence?" I give the standard arguments--there are a lot of places out there, the molecules of life are everywhere, I use the word billions, and so on. Then I say it would be astonishing to me if there weren't extraterrestrial intelligence, but of course there is as yet no compelling evidence for it.
Often, I'm asked next, "What do you really think?"
I say, "I just told you what I really think."

"Yes, but what's your gut feeling?"

But I try not to think with my gut. If I'm serious about understanding the world, thinking with anything besides my brain, as tempting as that might be, is likely to get me into trouble. Really, it's okay to reserve judgment until the evidence is in.

- Carl Sagan, The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark

Highlighting added.
 
Carl Sagan did not just believe extraterrestrial life was possible. He believed extraterrestrial intelligent life and even advanced civilizations much older and wiser than ours exists and would be found if they did not already destroy themselves.
http://www.bigear.org/vol1no2/sagan.htm

Sagan wrote: The question of extraterrestrial civilizations seems to me entirely open. Personally, I think it far more difficult to understand a universe in which we are the only technological civilization, or one of but a few, than to imagine a cosmos brimming over with intelligent life.
 
Carl Sagan did not just believe extraterrestrial life was possible. He believed extraterrestrial intelligent life and even advanced civilizations much older and wiser than ours exists and would be found if they did not already destroy themselves.

No he didn't. He made that clear on page 78. :D
 
Your quote does not support your claim about what Sagan believed.

If Carl Sagan did not believe in extraterrestrial intelligent life. Then why did he setup such an elaborate program to contact them using radio technology.

Sagan's last interview with NOVA. Carl Sagan said: I personally have been captured by the notion of extraterrestrial life, and especially extraterrestrial intelligence, from childhood. It swept me up, and I've been involved in sending space craft to nearby planets to look for life and in the radio search for extraterrestrial intelligence.

What is even more ridiculous Carl Sagan pioneered exobiology and promoted the search for Extraterrestrial intelligent life in the absence of any evidence of their existence. Either his pot smoking or his obsession with aliens clouded his judgement, or possible both.
Exobiology: The branch of biology that deals with the search for extraterrestrial life and the effects of extraterrestrial surroundings on living .
 
If Carl Sagan did not believe in extraterrestrial intelligent life. Then why did he setup such an elaborate program to contact them using radio technology.



What is even more ridiculous Carl Sagan pioneered exobiology and promoted the search for Extraterrestrial intelligent life in the absence of any evidence of their existence. Either his pot smoking or his obsession with aliens clouded his judgement, or possible both.
Exobiology: The branch of biology that deals with the search for extraterrestrial life and the effects of extraterrestrial surroundings on living .

Who cares? Why does it matter? Sagan's views have no effect on my life, what effects do they have on yours?
 
JT once again dispalying your ignorance of Carl sagan's life and work.

Carl Sagan posited the possibility and liklihood of life on other worlds, keys words, possibility and liklihood, also he was one of the key players in the field of exobiology.

Again you efforts to besmirch him are pititful based as they are on ignorance.
 
If Carl Sagan did not believe in extraterrestrial intelligent life. Then why did he setup such an elaborate program to contact them using radio technology.

1) It's called science, and
...A) radio technology isn't an elaborate program.
...B) Except for the The Arecibo message, I can't think of any attempt to contact ET.
...C) SETI in its various incarnations is a listening exercise.


What is even more ridiculous Carl Sagan pioneered exobiology and promoted the search for Extraterrestrial intelligent life in the absence of any evidence of their existence.

That is a ridiculous objection. You often won't have any evidence if you refuse to look for it.

Either his pot smoking or his obsession with aliens clouded his judgement, or possible both.

non-sequitur. Didn't we settle this almost a year ago when you cited page 78 of The Demon Haunted World? Why yes! Yes we did settle this!

The conclusion was that you hadn't read any of Sagan's works, and therefore had no informed opinion to offer.

It's all coming back to me. What a hoot that was. :D
 
1) It's called science, and
...A) radio technology isn't an elaborate program.
...B) Except for the The Arecibo message, I can't think of any attempt to contact ET.
...C) SETI in its various incarnations is a listening exercise.




That is a ridiculous objection. You often won't have any evidence if you refuse to look for it.



non-sequitur. Didn't we settle this almost a year ago when you cited page 78 of The Demon Haunted World? Why yes! Yes we did settle this!

The conclusion was that you hadn't read any of Sagan's works, and therefore had no informed opinion to offer.

It's all coming back to me. What a hoot that was. :D
You are confusing Carl Sagan's pot addiction and obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life with his other fixation with UFO's and alien encounters. His book The Demon Haunted World was a compilation of anecdotal stories about alien encounters and UFO's which he attempts to discredit. Carl Sagan tried to make a clear distinction between the public's fascination with UFO and SETI(search for extraterrestrial intelligent life).

"Carl’s oldest worries: that the public’s inability to distinguish between UFO claptrap and SETI science would doom the latter."

Sagan wrote: "I had been interested in the possibility of extraterrestrial life from childhood, from long before I ever heard of flying saucers. I've remained fascinated long after my early enthusiasm for UFOs waned."

To read about his pot addiction you have to read this:
Mr. X by Carl Sagan
http://marijuana-uses.com/mr-x/

To read about his obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life you should read his book Contact, what is said to be a culmination of his life's work and obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life. He wrote it as a fiction because he never found the evidence of their existence.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contact_(novel)
 
You are confusing Carl Sagan's pot addiction and obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life with his other fixation with UFO's and alien encounters.
You are confusing your ill conceived Sagan/pot ideas with reality.

His book The Demon Haunted World was a compilation of anecdotal stories about alien encounters and UFO's which he attempts to discredit.
You mean the book you so proudly declared back up thread that you have not read? That book? The one with the magic disappearing page 78? That one?

Carl Sagan tried to make a clear distinction between the public's fascination with UFO and SETI(search for extraterrestrial intelligent life).

"Carl’s oldest worries: that the public’s inability to distinguish between UFO claptrap and SETI science would doom the latter."
A valid distinction that you refuse to make. Please do tell what it is exactly that you find about seeking evidence for a hypothesis to be unscientific. Why should it not be a legitimate concern that valid science might be hijacked by UFO loonies?

Sagan wrote: "I had been interested in the possibility of extraterrestrial life from childhood, from long before I ever heard of flying saucers. I've remained fascinated long after my early enthusiasm for UFOs waned."

To read about his pot addiction you have to read this:
Mr. X by Carl Sagan
http://marijuana-uses.com/mr-x/
Every word of it perfectly valid, pot or no pot.

To read about his obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life you should read his book Contact, what is said to be a culmination of his life's work and obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life. He wrote it as a fiction because he never found the evidence of their existence.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contact_(novel)

That was sci-fi. Fiction. Fantasy. Made up stuff. Guess what, anyone can write a work of fiction. Even Sagan. Even me. Even you. Some are more experienced at making things up than others. Some use facts to invent plausible scenarios. That's a genre known as "faction". Others simply throw their hands in the air and make things up out of whole cloth. That is several diverse genres. Others still take odd unscientific beliefs and construct whole universes around them.

Some examples:

E. E. "Doc" Smith with his Lensman series based entirely on a premise for interstellar travel which was borked in his own lifetime. Still classics of the genre.

Arthur C. Clarke, who's ideas actually came to fruition in real life many times. See satellites.

Philip K. Dick, who used unlikely sci-fi scenarios to illuminate the human condition.

Robert Silverberg, who uses sci-fi to explore the meaning of death to a human being. (Poorly, IMHO)


So Sagan wrote a novel, a work of fiction. He leavened it with some science and some fantasy in order to create a fictional tale which might have some merit or appeal to fans of such fiction. This demonstrates what precisely? It certainly seems to have some deep meaning to you, but you are coy about stating what, exactly. I could compose a novel, and it would likely reflect my interests were I to do so. So could you, and yours would reflect your interests. My novel, and yours, and Sagan's would all still be fiction.

Or we could simply plagiarise and call ourselves Dan Brown. :D
 
You are confusing Carl Sagan's pot addiction and obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life with his other fixation with UFO's and alien encounters. His book The Demon Haunted World was a compilation of anecdotal stories about alien encounters and UFO's which he attempts to discredit.


Uhm, no, it wasn't. You should try actually reading the book.
 
Many have argued Carl Sagan's search for extraterrestrial intelligent life was based on science and scientific inquiry. It might come as a surprise to many that Sagan's premise was challenged and doubts raised about the probability of finding intelligent life by biologists and evolutionists. In short scientists questioned the science behind SETI(search for extraterrestrial intelligence) and even debated the improbability of finding intelligent life just as I have vigorously questioned the scientific objectivity of a pot smoking star gazing alien hunter turned skeptic (Carl Sagan) throughout this thread.

Here is a excerpt from the article. The evolutionists' critique of SETI.

"The next session was on the key variable of the Drake Equation, L, or the lifetime of a technical civilization (see lifetime of extraterrestrial civilizations). Shklovskii had been assigned the job of lead speaker. As he began his remarks he made it clear that the discussion that had just ended still weighed heavily on him. As noted, he remained virtually silent during the discussion. Perhaps he needed the time until now to formulate his reaction. In any event, instead of introducing his assigned topic he dropped a bombshell. "I have some difficulty defining the subject of our symposium." He went on to remind the conferees that "all the natural sciences rely on observations and experiments," and that scientific postulates "are generalizations of experimental findings." Shklovskii noted that SETI did not follow these basic principles of the scientific method. Instead, its postulate that ETIs exist "rests on logic alone." In other words, SETI-Science did not begin with observations, from which generalizations – theories – were formulated and tested. SETI looked for observations. SETI-Science reversed the traditional process of the scientific method. Shklovskii pointed out that SETI was thus similar to geometry in its reliance on a priori assumptions. "But I think that even the most faithful among us are not as convinced of [the existence of ETIs] as the experts in geometry have always been convinced of the fact that parallel lines do not meet."
 
Uhm, no, it wasn't. You should try actually reading the book.

For those who missed it, Justin cited a page (#78) in Sagan's Demon Haunted World where he claimed Sagan said this-and-that-and-the-other.

When pressed for details, rather than admitting an error, he listed ISBN edition numbers for the alleged books.

In every edition he cited, page #78 was completely void of any printing.

In other words, he was caught in an outright fabrication.

After a lot of hemming and hawing, Justin then admitted that he hadn't read any of Carl Sagan's works, and was relying on abstracts from authors that favored his own conspiracy theory.

So here we are all these months later.
 
For those who missed it, Justin cited a page (#78) in Sagan's Demon Haunted World where he claimed Sagan said this-and-that-and-the-other.

When pressed for details, rather than admitting an error, he listed ISBN edition numbers for the alleged books.

In every edition he cited, page #78 was completely void of any printing.

In other words, he was caught in an outright fabrication.

After a lot of hemming and hawing, Justin then admitted that he hadn't read any of Carl Sagan's works, and was relying on abstracts from authors that favored his own conspiracy theory.

So here we are all these months later.

You got your facts wrong.
You are back to debating a blank page. Well, my electronic copy does not have page 78 as blank. It reads as follows.....

THE DEMON-HAUNTED WORLD​


reliably reported cases that are unexotic, and exotic cases that are unreliable. There are no cases - despite well over a million UFO reports since 1947 - in which something so strange that it could only be an extraterrestrial spacecraft is reported so reliably that misapprehension, hoax or hallucination can be reliably excluded. There's still a part of me that says, 'Too bad.' We're regularly bombarded with extravagant UFO claims vended in bite-sized packages, but only rarely do we get to hear about their comeuppance. This isn't hard to understand: which sells more newspapers and books, which garners higher ratings, which is more fun to believe, which is more resonant with the torments of our time - real crashed alien ships, or experienced conmen preying on the gullible; extraterrestrials of immense powers toying with the human species, or such claims deriving from human weakness and mperfection?
Over the years I've continued to spend time on the UFO problem. I receive many letters about it, frequently with detailed first-hand accounts. Sometimes momentous revelations are promised if only I will call the letter writer. After I give lectures - on almost any subject - I often am asked, 'Do you believe in UFOs?' I'm always struck by how the question is phrased, the suggestion that this is a matter of belief and not of evidence. I'm almost never asked, 'How good is the evidence that UFOs are alien spaceships?'
I've found that the going-in attitude of many people is highly predetermined. Some are convinced that eyewitness testimony is reliable, that people do not make things up, that hallucinations or hoaxes on such a scale are impossible, and that there must be a long-standing, high-level government conspiracy to keep the truth from the rest of us. Gullibility about UFOs thrives on widespread mistrust of government, arising naturally enough from all those
circumstances where, in the tension between public well-being and 'national security', the government lies. As government deceit and conspiracies of silence have been exposed on so many other matters, it's hard to argue that a cover-up on this odd subject is impossible, that the government would never hide important information from its citizens. A common explanation
on why there would be a cover-up is to prevent worldwide panic or

78​

Because it is an electronic copy I am able to apply key search words for specific information. I don't need to read the entire piece of crap. Besides we all know what it did to members who actually read Sagan's book.

Amy Wilson wrote: One word: avoid. Avoid the Demon Haunted World at all costs. I got dumber after reading it. It's true.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=55278
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom