Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Because it is an electronic copy I am able to apply key search words for specific information. I don't need to read the entire piece of crap.


You need to read "the entire piece of crap" if you are going to make statements like:
His book The Demon Haunted World was a compilation of anecdotal stories about alien encounters and UFO's which he attempts to discredit.


At least, you do if you want your assessment taken seriously.

Besides we all know what it did to members who actually read Sagan's book.

Amy Wilson wrote: One word: avoid. Avoid the Demon Haunted World at all costs. I got dumber after reading it. It's true.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=55278


Have you figured out what Amy's worldview was yet?
 
You got your facts wrong.
You are back to debating a blank page. Well, my electronic copy does not have page 78 as blank. It reads as follows.....



Because it is an electronic copy I am able to apply key search words for specific information. I don't need to read the entire piece of crap. Besides we all know what it did to members who actually read Sagan's book.

Amy Wilson wrote: One word: avoid. Avoid the Demon Haunted World at all costs. I got dumber after reading it. It's true.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=55278

You're making generalizations about members based on a sample size of 1?

Nobody is debating a blank page but you.

When I asked you before the ISBN of the copy of The Demon-Haunted world you were using, you gave me one for a printed edition that I own. Page 78 is blank. Period. Not even a page #
 
You got your facts wrong.
You are back to debating a blank page. Well, my electronic copy does not have page 78 as blank. It reads as follows.....



Because it is an electronic copy I am able to apply key search words for specific information. I don't need to read the entire piece of crap. Besides we all know what it did to members who actually read Sagan's book.

Amy Wilson wrote: One word: avoid. Avoid the Demon Haunted World at all costs. I got dumber after reading it. It's true.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=55278


The fact that you rely on crackpot "reviews" rather than reading the actual work speaks volumes.

Plus, you're rehashing your failed arguments from months ago. You obviously have nothing new or of value to add to the thread. Why are you here?
 
You're making generalizations about members based on a sample size of 1?

Nobody is debating a blank page but you.

When I asked you before the ISBN of the copy of The Demon-Haunted world you were using, you gave me one for a printed edition that I own. Page 78 is blank. Period. Not even a page #

What kind of reply is that? That is the ISBN number as printed on the electronic copy. You are trying to prove I don`t have a copy because there are no blank pages in my electronic copy. So you are debating about a blank page and missing the fact my copy has 426 printed pages. Below is a copy of the last page.
Your argument has no merit because most of my references point to links that are outside of the book.

THE DEMON-HAUNTED WORLD
Oersted Medal, included the following citation: 'Carl Sagan has . . . acknowledged the responsibility of the scientist to call to the public's attention important and difficult national policy issues related to science such as the arms race, nuclear proliferation, and environmental concerns like the greenhouse effect and the ozone layer. As a debater who acted always in a thoughtful manner towards those with contrary views, he has sought to raise the intellectual and moral level of the discussion and greatly increased
the public's awareness of these vital issues . . . The Oersted Medal, given for notable contributions to the teaching of physics, is the highest honor the AAPT can bestow on an individual. Carl Sagan, master communicator and teacher in the broadest and deepest sense of the word, brings honor to the award.'

Canada's Queens University, in presenting Dr Sagan with one of his twenty-two honorary degrees, commented: '[Carl Sagan is an] awesomely gifted astrophysicist and arguably science's best living literary stylist . . . As readers, we appreciate his implicit confidence in our intelligence and interest, his illuminating insights and his playful wit. As a community of scholars, we acknowledge with admiration his relentless pursuit of the really big questions . . . and the twin philosophies by which he lives and teaches: that "Science is never finished" and that "We make our world significant by the courage of our questions and the depth of our answers."


426​
 
Much as I hate to weigh in on Justintime's side here I have a 1997 UK paperback edition of 'The Demon Haunted World' and the quote in post #2940 is indeed on page 78 of that edition. In all other respects he remains wrong but that one particular he is correct. ISBN of my copy is 0-7472-5156-8
 
What kind of reply is that? That is the ISBN number as printed on the electronic copy. You are trying to prove I don`t have a copy because there are no blank pages in my electronic copy.
No. The point is that you have never read it in either electronic or treeware versions.

So you are debating about a blank page and missing the fact my copy has 426 printed pages. Below is a copy of the last page.
Your argument has no merit because most of my references point to links that are outside of the book.
No, again. The point is that you have not read it, and are therefore in no position to critique content which you have not read, despite your original attempts to pretend you did. Your notions were comprehensively blown out of the water, they will be again, if you chose to simply repeat the same arguments.

<snip pointless copypasta>
So you can copy and paste from the last page of a pdf. And? Have you read it all yet?
 
Much as I hate to weigh in on Justintime's side here I have a 1997 UK paperback edition of 'The Demon Haunted World' and the quote in post #2940 is indeed on page 78 of that edition. In all other respects he remains wrong but that one particular he is correct. ISBN of my copy is 0-7472-5156-8


OK, I had some time to waste, and I went back up-thread.

What JustinTime quoted in post#2940 is not what he originally said was on page 78 of The Demon-Haunted World.

He first said that page 78 contained a discussion about Carl Sagan and Michael Shermer disagreeing over whether the human brain was hard-wired to believe in gods.

Later he said that page 78 was about UFO sightings. Later still he again said he hadn't read it.

It can't be all three ways. In no ISBN offered have Sagan's and Shermer's names appeared on page 78 of The Demon Haunted World. Neither was there any discussion of a hard-wired belief in gods.

This was all discussed somewhere around post#2700.

I've done my homework for the night. If someone wants to pin the post numbers down even closer, I'll check back in and correct what I have posted, if I have misspoken.

I think that's fair.
 
Many skeptics believe Carl Sagan the advocate of scientific skepticism actually became a skeptic by applying critical thinking and scientific objectivity, that he was critical of pseudoscience in his fading years.

But that is not true.

He wrote a letter to Muller (1954) defending the presence of UFOs.
He argued flying saucers were not all Soviet build and that legitimate sightings had occurred much earlier than when the Soviets came to power.

He also argued that the Soviets would not take the risk of flying their saucers over U.S. territory, where many sightings had happened, because if one crashed or was shot down and its origin was discovered, that might start a war. In addition, some of the saucers had been observed making flying maneuvers that would require materials much stronger than anything on Earth and which a human being would not be able to survive.

That letter was Sagan’s last known defense of UFOs. Thereafter, his faith was shaken by two books—Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science (1952) by Martin Gardner (another University of Chicago graduate, and later the mathematics editor of Scientific American) and Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds (1841) by Charles Mackay.

So here you have it.
Sagan was influenced by 2 books that changed his worldview. In one Sagan was startled to find that it included a devastating chapter on UFOs and in the other the repeated instances in which humans have been gulled by false notions, ranging from get-rich-quick schemes to fortune telling. Gradually, Sagan began to recognize what flying saucers really are: not a physical phenomenon, but a psychological and a sociological one.

But Sagan did not fully relinquish his fascination with UFOs and continued to conduct private investigations of alien abductees and compiled anecdotal stores of their alien encounters and sightings.

By the 1960s, Sagan had long since rejected the thesis that UFOs are extraterrestrial spaceships. Yet he could not quite put the subject out of his mind. Like a disappointed lover, he continued to hang around this subject. He discussed it with reporters, testified about saucers before Congress, served on an Air Force UFO panel, personally investigated lurid UFO reports, and starred in the first scientific “debate” on the subject. Sentimental journeys, all.

His real obsession was with extraterrestrial intelligent life which he admitted to in his last NOVA interview.

Carl Sagan: I personally have been captured by the notion of extraterrestrial life, and especially extraterrestrial intelligence, from childhood. It swept me up, and I've been involved in sending space craft to nearby planets to look for life and in the radio search for extraterrestrial intelligence.

And then he jumped on the bandwagon of UFO mania and pseudoscience by selling books on those subjects very much like the ones that influenced him. He also had a co-write his wife Ann Druyan. Both were habitual pot users and complimented each other well.

You will find my quoted references here: http://www.csicop.org/si/show/universe_and_carl_sagan/
 


Yes we will, which includes several important passages you chose to skip:
Sagan turned his early enthusiasms about UFOs to rigorous but open-minded skepticism.

In time, Sagan would become a devastatingly effective critic of the UFO cult—indeed, of the flood of pseudoscience and superstition engulfing America in the second half of the twentieth century.

Sagan was a contradiction. To critics like Urey, the young astronomer was a reckless speculator. But to laypeople absorbed by pseudosciences and occultism, Sagan was the Dark Prince of skepticism—the party pooper who coldly shot down their ideas about UFOs, psychic phenomena, and other silliness.

Simple fact is that like a lot of people, myself included, Sagan was fascinated by the possibility that UFOs were alien spacecraft. What separates him from so many others is that when he saw that the evidence for UFOs being such craft was composed of delusions, misidentifications, and hoaxes he embraced that reality and changed his view point. He continued to believe in the possibility of extraterrestrial life, which is a perfectly respectable scientific hypothesis for which many scientists are still trying to gather evidence.
 
Yes we will, which includes several important passages you chose to skip:






Simple fact is that like a lot of people, myself included, Sagan was fascinated by the possibility that UFOs were alien spacecraft. What separates him from so many others is that when he saw that the evidence for UFOs being such craft was composed of delusions, misidentifications, and hoaxes he embraced that reality and changed his view point. He continued to believe in the possibility of extraterrestrial life, which is a perfectly respectable scientific hypothesis for which many scientists are still trying to gather evidence.

What separated Carl Sagan from other scientist is his pot addiction and flights into fantasy. He was even awarded the SFWA Solstice Award in recognition of his fictitious works and for popularizing fantasy excursions.

The Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America are pleased to announce Carl Sagan and Ginjer Buchanan as the recipients of the Solstice Awards for 2012. The Solstice Awards are granted to up to three persons, living or dead, who have consistently had a positive, transformative influence on the genre of science fiction and fantasy.

When it comes to his scientific achievements (not science fiction and fantasy escapades into the twilight zone) you have to go to his peers to get their assessments.

Carl Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard University and was unable to become a member of the National Academy of Sciences because Harold Urey the Nobel Prize winner whose pioneering work on the chemical origins of life inspired Sagan's similar work correctly informed the relevant tenure committee that Sagan's scientific "achievements" were trivial and derivative.

Credit should be given to the two books—Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science (1952) by Martin Gardner (another University of Chicago graduate, and later the mathematics editor of Scientific American) and Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds (1841) by Charles Mackay that changed Sagans worldview forever and turned him into a skeptic.

Some might even accuse Sagan of lacking in originality because he repeated the themes from the 2 books he read that influenced him and he began attacking UFOs and pseudoscience in much the same manner the original authors presented them. Any wonder why Harold Urey found Sagan's scientific "achievements" trivial and derivative.
 
What is even more ridiculous Carl Sagan pioneered exobiology and promoted the search for Extraterrestrial intelligent life in the absence of any evidence of their existence. Either his pot smoking or his obsession with aliens clouded his judgement, or possible both.
Exobiology: The branch of biology that deals with the search for extraterrestrial life and the effects of extraterrestrial surroundings on living .

Yeah, I wonder how many exoplanets we would have discovered if we hadn't started looking for them because there was no evidence of their existence. ;)
 
When it comes to his scientific achievements (not science fiction and fantasy escapades into the twilight zone) you have to go to his peers to get their assessments.


Carl Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard University and was unable to become a member of the National Academy of Sciences because Harold Urey the Nobel Prize winner whose pioneering work on the chemical origins of life inspired Sagan's similar work correctly informed the relevant tenure committee that Sagan's scientific "achievements" were trivial and derivative.


Previously you introduced the claim about tenure with a quotation from a page which stated, in the very next sentence, that "Urey later apologized to Sagan". Incidentally, I doubt that Urey had much to do with the NAS membership thing because by then he had been dead for over a decade.

And once again, you're ignoring the fact that three years after Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard he became a full professor at Cornell.

Where did you get your new quotation from, by the way? You don't give a source, and it doesn't currently show up on a Google search.
 
What separated Carl Sagan from other scientist is his pot addiction and flights into fantasy. He was even awarded the SFWA Solstice Award in recognition of his fictitious works and for popularizing fantasy excursions.

If you think the consumption of drugs set Sagan apart from all other scientists you have some very nasty shocks coming to you. Yes he wrote science fiction, again hardly the only scientist to do so and of course unlike believers in UFOs and psychic phenomena he understood the difference between fantasy and reality.


When it comes to his scientific achievements (not science fiction and fantasy escapades into the twilight zone) you have to go to his peers to get their assessments.

By which you appear to mean cherry picking any quote that puts Sagan in a bad light.

Credit should be given to the two books—Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science (1952) by Martin Gardner (another University of Chicago graduate, and later the mathematics editor of Scientific American) and Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds (1841) by Charles Mackay that changed Sagans worldview forever and turned him into a skeptic.

Ah so at last you concede he was a skeptic; progress!

Some might even accuse Sagan of lacking in originality because he repeated the themes from the 2 books he read that influenced him and he began attacking UFOs and pseudoscience in much the same manner the original authors presented them. Any wonder why Harold Urey found Sagan's scientific "achievements" trivial and derivative.

He was inspired to change his world-view by acquiring more understanding of a subject and you somehow see that as a bad thing? And not everyone in the scientific community likes each other, more non-shocking news. Oh and I suppose it goes without say you have read none of the books you are so eager to reference?
 
Previously you introduced the claim about tenure with a quotation from a page which stated, in the very next sentence, that "Urey later apologized to Sagan". Incidentally, I doubt that Urey had much to do with the NAS membership thing because by then he had been dead for over a decade.

And once again, you're ignoring the fact that three years after Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard he became a full professor at Cornell.

Where did you get your new quotation from, by the way? You don't give a source, and it doesn't currently show up on a Google search.

Page 78 of The Demon Haunted World? :)
 
Yeah, I wonder how many exoplanets we would have discovered if we hadn't started looking for them because there was no evidence of their existence. ;)

It was already known there are billions and billion of planets in the Milky Way alone. So it was only a matter of developing the technology and means to discover them.

But biologist and evolutionist have advanced the improbability of finding extraterrestrial intelligent life and advanced civilizations as fantasized by Carl Sagan.

Aside from Carl Sagan's obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life and his life long search for ETI life and advanced civilizations and his popularization of alien culture. His view is supported mainly by Physicists and ironically the skeptical community.

To the question. What Percentage of Planets on Which Life Has Originated Will Produce Intelligent Life?

Physicists, on the whole, will give a different answer to this question than biologists. Physicists still tend to think more deterministically than biologists. They tend to say, if life has originated somewhere, it will also develop intelligence in due time. The biologist, on the other hand, is impressed by the improbability of such a development.

Biologist and evolutionists on the other hand argue the improbability of intelligent life based on science not speculation. Their case:

"How many species have existed since the origin of life? This figure is as much a matter of speculation as the number of planets in our galaxy. But if there are 30 million living species, and if the average life expectancy of a species is about 100,000 years, then one can postulate that there have been billions, perhaps as many as 50 billion species since the origin of life. Only one of these achieved the kind of intelligence needed to establish a civilization."

So why have we not heard from those advanced civilizations?

Is Every Civilization Able To Send Signals into Space and To Receive Them?

The answer quite clearly is no. In the last 10,000 years there have been at least 20 civilizations on Earth, from the Indus, the Sumerian, and other near Eastern civilizations, to Egypt, Greece, and the whole series of European civilizations, to the Mayas, Aztecs, and Incas, and to the various Chinese and Indian civilizations. Only one of these reached a level of technology that has enabled them to send signals into space and to receive them.

Is it any wonder Carl Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard University and was unable to become a member of the National Academy of Sciences?

Instead he was awarded the SFWA Solstice Award in recognition of his fictitious works(science fiction) and for popularizing fantasy excursions.
 
Yeah, I wonder how many exoplanets we would have discovered if we hadn't started looking for them because there was no evidence of their existence. ;)

It was already known there are billions and billion of planets in the Milky Way alone. So it was only a matter of developing the technology and means to discover them.
Incorrect. There are only just over a thousand confirmed exoplanets. The billions number is speculation. And since the first of these was only confirmed in 1992, it wasn't then and isn't now known that there are in fact "billions and billions" of planets in the Milky Way.

But biologist and evolutionist have advanced the improbability of finding extraterrestrial intelligent life and advanced civilizations as fantasized by Carl Sagan.
No, your opinion is that it may be unlikely. That is no reason to not look. That reasoning would leave mankind in the dark ages.

Aside from Carl Sagan's obsession with extraterrestrial intelligent life and his life long search for ETI life and advanced civilizations and his popularization of alien culture. His view is supported mainly by Physicists and ironically the skeptical community.
The physicists are all wrong? How arrogant. And just where do you come by this sweeping generalisation?

To the question. What Percentage of Planets on Which Life Has Originated Will Produce Intelligent Life?

Physicists, on the whole, will give a different answer to this question than biologists. Physicists still tend to think more deterministically than biologists. They tend to say, if life has originated somewhere, it will also develop intelligence in due time. The biologist, on the other hand, is impressed by the improbability of such a development.
More speculation.

Biologist and evolutionists on the other hand argue the improbability of intelligent life based on science not speculation. Their case:

"How many species have existed since the origin of life? This figure is as much a matter of speculation as the number of planets in our galaxy. But if there are 30 million living species, and if the average life expectancy of a species is about 100,000 years, then one can postulate that there have been billions, perhaps as many as 50 billion species since the origin of life. Only one of these achieved the kind of intelligence needed to establish a civilization."
I have no idea where you got that quote, but the numbers are bogus.

So why have we not heard from those advanced civilizations?
Cos the universe is vewy, vewy big.

Is Every Civilization Able To Send Signals into Space and To Receive Them?

The answer quite clearly is no. In the last 10,000 years there have been at least 20 civilizations on Earth, from the Indus, the Sumerian, and other near Eastern civilizations, to Egypt, Greece, and the whole series of European civilizations, to the Mayas, Aztecs, and Incas, and to the various Chinese and Indian civilizations. Only one of these reached a level of technology that has enabled them to send signals into space and to receive them.
More speculation. We have only one case of the emergence and evolution of life. Earth. A single known example does not make for a convincing argument. There is absolutely no reason why Earth should be considered a template of any sort. It would be ludicrous to believe so.

Is it any wonder Carl Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard University and was unable to become a member of the National Academy of Sciences?
Non sequitur. None of the errors and speculations above remotely refer to this return to your particular obsession.

Instead he was awarded the SFWA Solstice Award in recognition of his fictitious works(science fiction) and for popularizing fantasy excursions.
Oooo, he got a science fiction award for a work of science fiction. So what?
 
There are at least 8.8 Billion Earth-size, just-right planets in the Milky Way alone, study finds.
http://news.nationalpost.com/2013/1...t-planets-in-the-milky-way-alone-study-finds/

From the article you cite:

Scientists then extrapolated that figure to the rest of the galaxy, which has hundreds of billions of stars.
That's right, a big fat guess.

Based on the 1-in-5 estimate,
Another guess.

Kepler has identified only 10 planets that are about Earth’s size circling sun-like stars and are in the habitable zone
I.e. under 0.1% of confirmed exoplanets are conducive to life.

bringing the total of planets they’ve spotted to 3,538
Um, no. Blatant fabrication on the part of the writer. Including candidate planets is a flat out lie. Candidates are unconfirmed.

Journalistic hyperbole intended for consumption by the layman. That's all it is.

However, if we take that report at face value (as you seem to desire us so to do) and we further take at face value your earlier numbers with regard to speciatiation, what do we find?

8,800,000,000 planets times 0.2 (one in five in the habitable zone per your source) times 50,000,000,000 species evolving on each planet gets you where exactly?

88,000,000,000,000,000,000 chances in the Milky Way alone for intelligence to evolve. Yes 88 million billion chances.

In other words, your own sources indicate that the chances are good that intelligence has emerged elsewhere and that is restricting the numbers to our own galaxy alone and ignoring stars in the MW which are not like Sol. Let's take other types of stars into account.

Again, per your source,
Put those together and that’s probably 40 billion right-size, right-place planets, Marcy said.
Yup, we are now up to 400,000,000,000,000,000,000. Four hundred million billion chances.

But wait, there's more. What about all of the other galaxies? How many of those are there? It's difficult to be certain, but current estimates put it at 100 to 200 billion galaxies, and that's just the visible universe. Let's take the middle of the road and say 150 billion galaxies.

Now we have four hundred million billion chances in this galaxy times 150 billion galaxies.

That's 60,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 chances.

That's a lot of chances. In all likelihood, intelligence has emerged elsewhere.

The sources that you yourself quoted have put a torpedo amidships of your own argument. I simply cannot figure out if you misread the sources you quoted or did not read them at all.
 
There are at least 8.8 Billion Earth-size, just-right planets in the Milky Way alone, study finds.
http://news.nationalpost.com/2013/1...t-planets-in-the-milky-way-alone-study-finds/

Didn't read the article, did you? As usual...

Astronomers using NASA data have calculated for the first time that in our galaxy alone, there are at least 8.8 billion stars with Earth-size planets in the habitable temperature zone.

The Kepler telescope peered at 42,000 stars, examining just a tiny slice of our galaxy to see how many planets like Earth are out there. Scientists then extrapolated that figure to the rest of the galaxy, which has hundreds of billions of stars.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom