There are at least 8.8 Billion Earth-size, just-right planets in the Milky Way alone, study finds.
http://news.nationalpost.com/2013/1...t-planets-in-the-milky-way-alone-study-finds/
From the article you cite:
Scientists then extrapolated that figure to the rest of the galaxy, which has hundreds of billions of stars.
That's right, a big fat guess.
Based on the 1-in-5 estimate,
Another guess.
Kepler has identified only 10 planets that are about Earth’s size circling sun-like stars and are in the habitable zone
I.e. under 0.1% of confirmed exoplanets are conducive to life.
bringing the total of planets they’ve spotted to 3,538
Um, no. Blatant fabrication on the part of the writer. Including candidate planets is a flat out lie. Candidates are unconfirmed.
Journalistic hyperbole intended for consumption by the layman. That's all it is.
However, if we take that report at face value (as you seem to desire us so to do) and we further take at face value your earlier numbers with regard to speciatiation, what do we find?
8,800,000,000 planets times 0.2 (one in five in the habitable zone per your source) times 50,000,000,000 species evolving on each planet gets you where exactly?
88,000,000,000,000,000,000 chances in the Milky Way alone for intelligence to evolve. Yes 88 million billion chances.
In other words, your own sources indicate that the chances are good that intelligence has emerged elsewhere and that is restricting the numbers to our own galaxy alone and ignoring stars in the MW which are not like Sol. Let's take other types of stars into account.
Again, per your source,
Put those together and that’s probably 40 billion right-size, right-place planets, Marcy said.
Yup, we are now up to 400,000,000,000,000,000,000. Four hundred million billion chances.
But wait, there's more. What about all of the other galaxies? How many of those are there? It's difficult to be certain, but current estimates put it at 100 to 200 billion galaxies, and that's just the visible universe. Let's take the middle of the road and say 150 billion galaxies.
Now we have four hundred million billion chances in this galaxy times 150 billion galaxies.
That's 60,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 chances.
That's a lot of chances. In all likelihood, intelligence has emerged elsewhere.
The sources that you yourself quoted have put a torpedo amidships of your own argument. I simply cannot figure out if you misread the sources you quoted or did not read them at all.