Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Shermer: "We believe in the supernatural because we believe in the natural and we cannot discriminate between the two. We create gods because we are natural-born supernaturalists, driven by our tendency to find meaningful patterns and impart to them intentional agency.

No one said Shermer was claiming gods were real. He said the belief in god was innate, that they are hard-wired into our brains.But he does go on to say it is natural to believe in the supernatural because we are natural born supernaturalist.

The argument I was raising was the pathology of disbelief because belief in god is both innate and natural.
 
The research is not to prove that god exist. It is to prove atheist still believe in god even thought they claim they are atheists.

I was brought up on fantasy folk tales and fairy stories, such as those of George MacDonald and the brothers Grimm; now I would maintain that I don't believe in goblins or trolls, but I was sufficiently emotionally involved with them as a child (often fearfully) that it is quite likely that if I were to be presented with related material today, I would have a detectable non-conscious emotional reaction in apparent contradiction to my conscious, rational lack of belief.

Does this mean I still believe in goblins and trolls despite claiming not to?
 
Even if we grant that a tendancy to attribute agency to the inanimate forces of nature (being an unfortunate byproduct of natural cognitive biases) is innate, that doesn't make nonbelief a pathology. It could be argued that a tendancy to rape and murder are also innate, would you argue that those who manage to restrain themselves from doing either are diseased?
 
justintime;9392131The argument I was raising was the pathology of disbelief because belief in god is both innate and natural.[/QUOTE said:
Assuming, for the sake of argument, that belief in god is innate (let's not get into what is and isn't 'natural'), are you suggesting that conscious or unconscious suppression or contradiction of what is (believed to be) innate is therefore pathological?

Seriously?

Should we all have lobotomies so our innate behaviours can be freely expressed without the 'unnatural' interference of rational, critical thought (and social and cultural conditioning)?
 
I was brought up on fantasy folk tales and fairy stories, such as those of George MacDonald and the brothers Grimm; now I would maintain that I don't believe in goblins or trolls, but I was sufficiently emotionally involved with them as a child (often fearfully) that it is quite likely that if I were to be presented with related material today, I would have a detectable non-conscious emotional reaction in apparent contradiction to my conscious, rational lack of belief.

Does this mean I still believe in goblins and trolls despite claiming not to?

But that is the nature of experience and memory. You get flash backs and Déjà vu. Do atheists still believe in god? Their strong emotional arousal (reaction) suggests they do or the results would have indicated the opposite.

I would have a detectable non-conscious emotional reaction in apparent contradiction to my conscious, rational lack of belief.

That is exactly what the test showed. Atheists even when they claim they are non-believers show an even stronger reaction at the mention of god which is quite the opposite of what is expected. The explanation offered is, they are unable to erase or dislodge god completely from their psyche.

According to Dawkins natural selection confers and evolutionary advantage on religious believers because when something is so wide spread (religion) it must have a Darwinian survival value or it would not be there.

Is rape and murder innate? It is the by-product of religion that suppresses these instincts and creates an environment of mutual support, co-operation and advancement of the group that translates into an evolutionary advantage the group has over other groups that lack the benefits of religion beliefs making them less altruistic towards the survival of the group.

Interestingly, research is just beginning to uncover the depth of religion/god in human consciousness. Work by Dr Newberg, Dr Persinger are finally able to put context and offer a scientific explanation for the role of religion in a modern society.

I just believe more research should be done on the pathology of disbelief and skepticism. So we don't have skeptics raging on the internet because they are low in dopamine.
 
Atheists don't hate imaginary gods. The research proves it. If they did hate imaginary gods, research would show it.

So far, there is no respectable research showing that atheists are upset with imaginary deities.

Any questions?
 
I noticed there were several skeptics claiming to be atheists. Little do they realize they are awashed in controversy and are contradictory in their unholy union.

Atheists do not want to be lumped with the skeptics.
http://www.skepticblog.org/2013/04/09/try-not-to-lump-us-atheists-in-with-the-skeptics/

1. The “skeptic” euphemism in particular is an especially problematic one for atheists to adopt. To begin with, an awful lot of active movement skeptics believe in god—something like a fifth to a third, depending on the measure. For example, in a 1995 survey of Skeptics Society members, 35 percent answered the question, “Do you think there is a God (a purposeful higher intelligence that created the universe)?” with responses of “Very likely” or “Possibly.” In a more precise 1998 followup survey of Skeptics Society members conducted by Michael Shermer and Frank Sulloway, 18 percent of the 1,700 respondents said “Definitely yes” or “Very likely yes” there is a god.2 Recent surveys of attendees of the James Randi Educational Foundation’s The Amazing Meeting conference similarly find that almost a third of TAM-goers identify as something other than atheist or agnostic.

2. many atheists do not share the beliefs, views, or attitudes that skeptics promote. Nor are the atheists who hold paranormal or pseudoscientific beliefs some sort of dismissible fringe within the atheist community. The opposite is true: we can be confident that a majority of people without theistic beliefs are paranormal believers, just as is true for the hefty majority of the population at large. As Bader et al wrote regarding the findings of the Baylor Religion Survey,

What this suggests is Atheists believe it is normal to accept the paranormal. Skeptics are determined to debunk the paranormal. Atheist do not believe in god, skeptics are mixed on this issue.

Article truncated to keep it short.

Atheists more likely to be superstitious, study reveals

A survey released this month by Baylor University reveals that those who identify themselves as Christians are much less likely to hold paranormal beliefs, such as the existence of ghosts, the Loch Ness Monster, and Atlantis.

The finding that people who expressed no belief in God leaned politically to the left was not new. However, the survey also found those people more prone to believe in communication with the dead, haunted houses, and UFOs,

This finding contrasts idea that those who do not believe in a higher power are more rational and educated than those who embrace fundamental Christian beliefs.

In fact, those with a higher education are more likely to hold paranormal beliefs.

Could G.K. Chesterton’s Father Brown character have been on to something when he said, “It’s the first effect of not believing in God that you lose your common sense, and can’t see things as they are�??
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122178219865054585.html
http://blog.lib.umn.edu/kochx149/3101newsfall08/2008/09/atheists_more_likely_to_be_sup.html
 
Man has an innate curiosity/tendency to search for the origin of the life and the Universe and we know life and the Universe exists and that is why the curiosity and tendency also exist in humans.

So mans innate belief in god by that same logic god must exist or why have that wired in his brain.

Research that found even Atheist secretly believe in god.
http://www.salon.com/2013/04/27/do_atheists_secretly_believe_in_god_partner/

It is time scientist focused on the pathology of disbelief and skeptics in particular. Now that Atheist have been exposed.

God must exist because the belief that god exists was wired into the brain by god.

I think that argument is around the bend.
 
I noticed there were several skeptics claiming to be atheists. Little do they realize they are awashed in controversy and are contradictory in their unholy union.
No, just no. There is no controversy apart from the one you wish to imagine. Try reading the article again. And there is no such thing as 'unholy' since there is no such thing as holy in the first place.

Let me get this straight:
1. There are those who are atheists but not skeptics.
2. There are those who are skeptics but not atheists.
3. There are those who are both atheists and skeptics.
4. There are those who are neither.
And finally
5. There are members of each grouping who have no desire to be associated with the other groupings.

I am certain that the Nobel Committee will shortly be calling you.


What this suggests is Atheists believe it is normal to accept the paranormal. Skeptics are determined to debunk the paranormal. Atheist do not believe in god, skeptics are mixed on this issue.
What spin. Atheists accept that others may believe whatever they wish to believe. Nothing wrong in that. Atheism is also no magic bullet against believing in any other parnanormal woo either. So what?

Article truncated to keep it short.
Admission of cherry-picking up front. Bravo.

The first is risible in that it couldn't even get basic facts right.
The second is simply a commentary on the first risible article.

Colour me unimpressed.
 
I noticed there were several skeptics claiming to be atheists. Little do they realize they are awashed in controversy and are contradictory in their unholy union.

Atheists do not want to be lumped with the skeptics.
http://www.skepticblog.org/2013/04/09/try-not-to-lump-us-atheists-in-with-the-skeptics/

That's because skepticism and atheism are not synonyms.

What this suggests is Atheists believe it is normal to accept the paranormal. [...]

No. That's a non-sequitur. Some atheists follow astrology. Some atheists follow UFOlogy. Other atheists do not.


This from a WSJ article listed under "Houses of Worship"?

Get out of town.
 
No, just no. There is no controversy apart from the one you wish to imagine. Try reading the article again. And there is no such thing as 'unholy' since there is no such thing as holy in the first place.

Let me get this straight:
1. There are those who are atheists but not skeptics.
2. There are those who are skeptics but not atheists.
3. There are those who are both atheists and skeptics.
4. There are those who are neither.
And finally
5. There are members of each grouping who have no desire to be associated with the other groupings.

I am certain that the Nobel Committee will shortly be calling you.


What spin. Atheists accept that others may believe whatever they wish to believe. Nothing wrong in that. Atheism is also no magic bullet against believing in any other parnanormal woo either. So what?

Admission of cherry-picking up front. Bravo.

The first is risible in that it couldn't even get basic facts right.
The second is simply a commentary on the first risible article.

Colour me unimpressed.
You can start with the basic understanding of the word atheist and its definition.
Free Online definition of Atheist: One who disbelieves or denies the existence of God or gods.

Oxford definition of Atheist: a person who disbelieves or lacks belief in the existence of God or gods:


Atheism is only the absence of belief in gods, which means that there is nothing self-contradictory about atheists who believe in astrology, alien abductions, Bigfoot, psychic powers, and a host of other mystical, supernatural, and paranormal things.

If you are not true to the definition of the word you are some form of hybrid.

Skeptic definition: 1. One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

Scientist definition: A practitioner of science is known as a scientist.

Skeptics who claim they are also atheist or practice science do not know the difference between these occupations and beliefs and might be in denial or in search of some new definition for their condition.
 
You can start with the basic understanding of the word atheist and its definition.
Free Online definition of Atheist: One who disbelieves or denies the existence of God or gods.

Oxford definition of Atheist: a person who disbelieves or lacks belief in the existence of God or gods:




If you are not true to the definition of the word you are some form of hybrid.

Skeptic definition: 1. One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

Scientist definition: A practitioner of science is known as a scientist.

Skeptics who claim they are also atheist or practice science do not know the difference between these occupations and beliefs and might be in denial or in search of some new definition for their condition.

Skepticism is not a "belief".
Science is not a "belief".

That is why your weak arguments fail.
 
I came across this quote and was wondering if that is the primary reason skeptic forums are inundated with BigFoot but very little discussion on the scientific evidence backing Biblical events and narratives:

"American Skeptics are afraid to be seen criticizing religion because religion is pervasive in the US – it’s probably a good idea to avoid alienating a great percentage of your audience/potential members. If it suits to ring-fence the majority of religious concepts as immune from skepticism then so be it. Just realize how bizarre it seems to a listener in the UK (or most of the rest of the world). I’ve never encountered it in the UK skepticism circuit."

For example: Evidence Suggests Noah's Ark Flood Existed, Says Robert Ballard
http://abcnews.go.com/2020/video/noahs-biblical-flood-evidence-suggests-happened-18041950
 
I came across this quote and was wondering if that is the primary reason skeptic forums are inundated with BigFoot but very little discussion on the scientific evidence backing Biblical events and narratives:

"American Skeptics are afraid to be seen criticizing religion because religion is pervasive in the US – it’s probably a good idea to avoid alienating a great percentage of your audience/potential members. If it suits to ring-fence the majority of religious concepts as immune from skepticism then so be it. Just realize how bizarre it seems to a listener in the UK (or most of the rest of the world). I’ve never encountered it in the UK skepticism circuit."

For example: Evidence Suggests Noah's Ark Flood Existed, Says Robert Ballard
http://abcnews.go.com/2020/video/noahs-biblical-flood-evidence-suggests-happened-18041950

I take it you've never visited the Religion and Philosophy section of the forum.

As for the flood, knock yourself out: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=257225
 
I came across this quote and was wondering if that is the primary reason skeptic forums are inundated with BigFoot but very little discussion on the scientific evidence backing Biblical events and narratives:

"American Skeptics are afraid to be seen criticizing religion because religion is pervasive in the US – it’s probably a good idea to avoid alienating a great percentage of your audience/potential members. If it suits to ring-fence the majority of religious concepts as immune from skepticism then so be it. Just realize how bizarre it seems to a listener in the UK (or most of the rest of the world). I’ve never encountered it in the UK skepticism circuit."

For example: Evidence Suggests Noah's Ark Flood Existed, Says Robert Ballard
http://abcnews.go.com/2020/video/noahs-biblical-flood-evidence-suggests-happened-18041950

My advise would be to spend some time in the R&P subforum.
 
My advise would be to spend some time in the R&P subforum.

I have looked at the Religion and Philosopy section and have not found any discussion on the scientific evidence forwarded by scientists that corroborates Biblical events and narratives.
For example.
1. All the topics on Atheism. Atheism is not a scientific position, it is the rejection of deities or a belief in the non-existence of deities. Atheism is not a discussion based on scientific evidence.
2. Discussion on the Miracle of the Shroud. Can scientists conclusively prove the existence of Jesus based on a single piece of evidence (the shroud) or even the non-existence of Jesus based on the same evidence? Just as it is wishful thinking for the Vatican to use it as evidence of Jesus so too it is when scientists apply their trade to disprove its authenticity. All the Bible said was Jesus was wrapped in linen a practice followed for all burials.
3. Other discussion on beliefs, church dogma and religiosity are not discussion that have been scientifically investigated or evidence found to support one position or another and therefore hardly productive.

But there are scientific theories and hypothesis that corroborate Biblical events and narratives which deserve discussion on a skeptic forums because they are theories and hypothesis forwarded by scientists and not just theological or theistic positions.

Surely skeptics can be taught the difference so they can focus on what is in the realm and scope of scientists which can be subject to critical thinking or scientific method. Skeptics should consider this rather sophisticated and profound proposition.
 
I have looked at the Religion and Philosopy section and have not found any discussion on the scientific evidence forwarded by scientists that corroborates Biblical events and narratives.
For example.
1. All the topics on Atheism. Atheism is not a scientific position, it is the rejection of deities or a belief in the non-existence of deities. Atheism is not a discussion based on scientific evidence.
An atheist does not believe in any god on the basis of a total lack of any evidence whatsoever for the existence of such. That is a scientific position.

2. Discussion on the Miracle of the Shroud. Can scientists conclusively prove the existence of Jesus based on a single piece of evidence (the shroud) or even the non-existence of Jesus based on the same evidence? Just as it is wishful thinking for the Vatican to use it as evidence of Jesus so too it is when scientists apply their trade to disprove its authenticity. All the Bible said was Jesus was wrapped in linen a practice followed for all burials.
Except for the fact that the Vatican does not support the authenticity of the holy tablecloth. Also, that debate is about the authenticity of the shroud itself not the authenticity of jeebus.

3. Other discussion on beliefs, church dogma and religiosity are not discussion that have been scientifically investigated or evidence found to support one position or another and therefore hardly productive.
No evidence at all has been found for any god. Thus the null hypothesis of no gods existing pertains until evidence is found. Again a scientific position.

But there are scientific theories and hypothesis that corroborate Biblical events and narratives which deserve discussion on a skeptic forums because they are theories and hypothesis forwarded by scientists and not just theological or theistic positions.
You can only refer to the historical aspects and these are well discussed in the R&P forum. The fantasy aspects are bereft of any supporting evidence.
Surely skeptics can be taught the difference so they can focus on what is in the realm and scope of scientists which can be subject to critical thinking or scientific method. Skeptics should consider this rather sophisticated and profound proposition.
It is not within your remit to determine what may or may not be subject to scientific enquiry.

If you want to pursue this line further then I suggest you start your own thread in R&P, as it is off topic here IMO.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom