Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

The Extraterrestrial Intelligent Life was a myth after all.

Carl Sagan similarly embraced the ETI myth. Yet, the Cornell exobiologist recognized that this belief structure is based on speculation rather than sufficient empirical evidence to deem it scientific. “I would guess that the Universe is filled with beings far more intelligent, far more advanced than we are. But, of course, I might be wrong. Such a conclusion is at best based on a plausibility argument, derived from the numbers of planets, the ubiquity of organic matter, the immense timescales available for evolution, and so on. It is not a scientific demonstration” (Sagan, 1994, p.33).

The Place of Evolution in the ETI Myth
http://www.counterbalance.org/astrotheo/place-frame.html
 
And that kind of torpedoes your entire premise, doesn't it.

How so?

I have systematically presented arguments by evolutionists and biologist expressing the improbability of finding Extraterrestrial Intelligent Life or advanced civilizations as fantasized by Carl Sagan and fellow physicists/astronomers.

The last link shows:"The ETI myth is structured around evolutionary assumptions." And how this evolutionary belief has worked its way into the ETI myth.

It also lists the flawed evolutionary assumptions which biologists and evolutionist have rejected.

Quoted from "The SETI Debate: Also check post# 2955
A Critique of the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence."
"How many species have existed since the origin of life? This figure is as much a matter of speculation as the number of planets in our galaxy. But if there are 30 million living species, and if the average life expectancy of a species is about 100,000 years, then one can postulate that there have been billions, perhaps as many as 50 billion species since the origin of life. Only one of these achieved the kind of intelligence needed to establish a civilization."
 
How so?

I have systematically presented arguments by evolutionists and biologist expressing the improbability of finding Extraterrestrial Intelligent Life or advanced civilizations as fantasized by Carl Sagan and fellow physicists/astronomers.
Wrong

The last link shows:"The ETI myth is structured around evolutionary assumptions." And how this evolutionary belief has worked its way into the ETI myth.
Wrong

It also lists the flawed evolutionary assumptions which biologists and evolutionist have rejected.

Quoted from "The SETI Debate: Also check post# 2955
Wrong.

I'm sorry. It is not my problem to resolve the flaws in your premises when they have been repeatedly pointed out.

I'm sorry. It is not my problem that you will not read responses, nor the sources which you quote which do not agree with your premise..

I'm sorry. it is not my problem that you will not read those books which you claim to critique.

I cannot in any way force you to do those things. I can ask, but you always refuse.

In the face of such obdurate behaviour, all I can do is appeal to other gentle readers to read and learn from those books, and the replies in this thread.

You are also most welcome to do so, but also at liberty to refuse.
 
Wrong


Wrong

Wrong.

I'm sorry. It is not my problem to resolve the flaws in your premises when they have been repeatedly pointed out.

I'm sorry. It is not my problem that you will not read responses, nor the sources which you quote which do not agree with your premise..

I'm sorry. it is not my problem that you will not read those books which you claim to critique.

I cannot in any way force you to do those things. I can ask, but you always refuse.

In the face of such obdurate behaviour, all I can do is appeal to other gentle readers to read and learn from those books, and the replies in this thread.

You are also most welcome to do so, but also at liberty to refuse.

I would reccommend reading "The Demon Haunted World" its a little dated now but the premise is still strong.

http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/17349.The_Demon_Haunted_World
 
Wrong


Wrong

Wrong.

I'm sorry. It is not my problem to resolve the flaws in your premises when they have been repeatedly pointed out.

I'm sorry. It is not my problem that you will not read responses, nor the sources which you quote which do not agree with your premise..

I'm sorry. it is not my problem that you will not read those books which you claim to critique.

I cannot in any way force you to do those things. I can ask, but you always refuse.

In the face of such obdurate behaviour, all I can do is appeal to other gentle readers to read and learn from those books, and the replies in this thread.

You are also most welcome to do so, but also at liberty to refuse.
Carl Sagan lost a lot of his credibility when his major blunders were uncovered.
http://www.csicop.org/si/show/carl_sagans_life_and_legacy_as_scientist_teacher_and_skeptic

"In the autumn of 1990, Sagan made his most serious scientific blunder. Threatened with military opposition to its invasion of Kuwait, Iraq threatened to set fire to the nation’s oil wells. Sagan became concerned that the quantity of petrochemical smoke generated by these oil-field fires could generate a small-scale nuclear winter, endangering crops across Asia and threatening world food production."

The oil fields were torched in January 1991, blackening the sky over most of Kuwait and disrupting the coastal ecosystem, but there were no climatic effects, even on a local scale. Sagan was widely criticized, and the episode had the further effect of undermining the credibility of the entire nuclear winter scenario.

Other problems multiplied. In 1993 the NASA SETI program, which he had defended on critical occasions in the past, was abruptly terminated by Congress. His book on nuclear winter, written with Turco, sold only a few thousand copies; no one cared much any more about issues of nuclear war. Perhaps worst of all, a book that he and Annie put a great deal of themselves into, Shadows of Forgotten Ancestors, did not receive the enthusiastic welcome they expected.

No longer a media star, Sagan was slipping from public consciousness."
Is it any wonder why "Carl Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard University and was unable to become a member of the National Academy of Sciences as early as 1967 because Harold Urey the Nobel Prize winner whose pioneering work on the chemical origins of life inspired Sagan's similar work correctly informed the relevant tenure committee that Sagan's scientific "achievements" were trivial and derivative." Sagan's scientific blunders were later exposed undermining the credibility of much of his scientific achievements.

No tenure at Harvard, no National Academy of Sciences membership and no Nobel prize...no evidence of extraterrestrial intelligent life either. Just an award for making up stuff out of pure fantasy.

Was an attack on pseudoscience Sagan's last bid to redeem himself? Could The Demon Haunted World alone erase his life long obsession to search and find UFOs, Aliens and extraterrestrial intelligent life and advanced civilizations?

I am afraid Carl Sagan will forever be remembered for uttering his quantitative billions and billions of galaxies and his unshakeable belief in distant planets humming with extraterrestrial intelligent life and more advanced civilizations.

How much can be attributed to Sagan's pot addiction or his predisposition to dwell in science fiction and fantasy is the subject of much speculation? But being awarded a Solstice Award by The Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America for science fiction and fantasy and his known pot addiction removes such speculation.
 
Carl Sagan lost a lot of his credibility when his major blunders were uncovered.
http://www.csicop.org/si/show/carl_sagans_life_and_legacy_as_scientist_teacher_and_skeptic


Is it any wonder why "Carl Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard University and was unable to become a member of the National Academy of Sciences as early as 1967 because Harold Urey the Nobel Prize winner whose pioneering work on the chemical origins of life inspired Sagan's similar work correctly informed the relevant tenure committee that Sagan's scientific "achievements" were trivial and derivative." Sagan's scientific blunders were later exposed undermining the credibility of much of his scientific achievements.

No tenure at Harvard, no National Academy of Sciences membership and no Nobel prize...no evidence of extraterrestrial intelligent life either. Just an award for making up stuff out of pure fantasy.

Was an attack on pseudoscience Sagan's last bid to redeem himself? Could The Demon Haunted World alone erase his life long obsession to search and find UFOs, Aliens and extraterrestrial intelligent life and advanced civilizations?

I am afraid Carl Sagan will forever be remembered for uttering his quantitative billions and billions of galaxies and his unshakeable belief in distant planets humming with extraterrestrial intelligent life and more advanced civilizations.

How much can be attributed to Sagan's pot addiction or his predisposition to dwell in science fiction and fantasy is the subject of much speculation? But being awarded a Solstice Award by The Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America for science fiction and fantasy and his known pot addiction removes such speculation.

Why does any of this matter? Feynman liked alcohol, so what? You never address this point.
 
No tenure at Harvard, no National Academy of Sciences membership and no Nobel prize../QUOTE]

You realize that describes the vast majority of scientists, right? He got tenure at Cornell - no easy feat. Very few scientists win Nobel prizes.

And he admitted his speculation about extraterrestrial life was speculation - we know this because you posted the quotes yourself.
 
Carl Sagan lost a lot of his credibility when his major blunders were uncovered.
You think scientists never make mistakes? Guess again.

http://www.csicop.org/si/show/carl_sagans_life_and_legacy_as_scientist_teacher_and_skeptic

"In the autumn of 1990, Sagan made his most serious scientific blunder. Threatened with military opposition to its invasion of Kuwait, Iraq threatened to set fire to the nation’s oil wells. Sagan became concerned that the quantity of petrochemical smoke generated by these oil-field fires could generate a small-scale nuclear winter, endangering crops across Asia and threatening world food production."

The oil fields were torched in January 1991, blackening the sky over most of Kuwait and disrupting the coastal ecosystem, but there were no climatic effects, even on a local scale. Sagan was widely criticized, and the episode had the further effect of undermining the credibility of the entire nuclear winter scenario.

Other problems multiplied. In 1993 the NASA SETI program, which he had defended on critical occasions in the past, was abruptly terminated by Congress. His book on nuclear winter, written with Turco, sold only a few thousand copies; no one cared much any more about issues of nuclear war. Perhaps worst of all, a book that he and Annie put a great deal of themselves into, Shadows of Forgotten Ancestors, did not receive the enthusiastic welcome they expected.

No longer a media star, Sagan was slipping from public consciousness."
I invite everyone to read the actual linked article and see exactly how mangled JiT's cherry-picked version really is.

The article is, in fact, a remembrance and tribute by David Morrison.

Is it any wonder why "Carl Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard University and was unable to become a member of the National Academy of Sciences as early as 1967 because Harold Urey the Nobel Prize winner whose pioneering work on the chemical origins of life inspired Sagan's similar work correctly informed the relevant tenure committee that Sagan's scientific "achievements" were trivial and derivative." Sagan's scientific blunders were later exposed undermining the credibility of much of his scientific achievements.

No tenure at Harvard, no National Academy of Sciences membership and no Nobel prize...no evidence of extraterrestrial intelligent life either. Just an award for making up stuff out of pure fantasy.
Dealt with earlier. Repetition does not help your case. Even your cited article disagrees with you. Did you not read it all?

Was an attack on pseudoscience Sagan's last bid to redeem himself? Could The Demon Haunted World alone erase his life long obsession to search and find UFOs, Aliens and extraterrestrial intelligent life and advanced civilizations?
The book you didn't read again.

I am afraid Carl Sagan will forever be remembered for uttering his quantitative billions and billions of galaxies and his unshakeable belief in distant planets humming with extraterrestrial intelligent life and more advanced civilizations.
Wrong. Even the article you yourself cite demonstrates that this is flat out wrong.

How much can be attributed to Sagan's pot addiction or his predisposition to dwell in science fiction and fantasy is the subject of much speculation?
Only to you.

But being awarded a Solstice Award by The Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America for science fiction and fantasy and his known pot addiction removes such speculation.
Still not able to figure out that he got a science fiction award for a science fiction book.
 
Here is a quote by Carl Sagan from his book The Demon Haunted World.

"For me, it is far better to grasp the Universe as it really is than to persist in delusion, however satisfying and reassuring."

1. So what was he doing smoking pot a mind altering drug that he claimed enhanced and altered his perceptions?

2. Why was he writing science fiction instead of grasping the Universe as it really was, writing about aliens and UFOs which remained an obsession and persisted in his delusional recreations? He was vicariously living in a fantasy world of aliens and UFOs which he found satisfying and reassuring.

Was Sagan successful in his endeavours to promote/popularize science and expose UFOs and alien encounters as fraud?

Some statistics:

• The World Economic Forum ranks the United States 52nd in the quality of mathematics and science education, and 5th (and declining) in overall global competitiveness [v]
• The United States ranks 27th in developed nations in the proportion of college students receiving undergraduate degrees in science or engineering [vi]
• There are more foreign students studying in U.S. graduate schools than the number of U.S. students [vii] and over 2/3 of the engineers who receive Ph.D.’s from United States universities are not United States citizens [viii]
http://www.lpfi.org/how-does-us-compare-other-countries-stem-education

UFO Sightings Increase 67 Percent In 3 Years, History Channel Investigates Unexplained Aerial Phenomena
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/08/26/ufos-pilots-history-channel_n_935847.html

So the US is lagging in science and UFO sighting are on the rise and no extraterrestrial intelligent life has been found making it 3 strikes against Sagan’s legacy. But legalizing pot is gaining momentum which may be the only lasting contribution we can credit to Carl Sagan.

What about people who read his book The Demon Haunted World?

Be warned wrote one member.

One word: avoid. Avoid the Demon Haunted World at all costs. I got dumber after reading it. It's true.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=55278
 
Your quote doesn't contradict Mojo's statement, if you're implying it does. Here's Dr. Sagan again:

Nope. I wasn't implying a contradiction to Mojo. I was however presenting the open minded viewpoint of Sagan to the possibility that there exists extraterrestrial life that could be far in advance of our own.

As for what Sagan personally believed about the actual existence of such life, or it visiting us, none of us can know that without being inside Sagan's head, which is impossible. All we can do is quote what he said and wrote and try to read it both literally and between the lines. It's my impression from this that Sagan would have thought it unreasonable, even in the absence of concrete scientific evidence sufficient to prove the existence of alien life, to believe that no such life exists in the vastness of the cosmos. By extension, I think it's reasonable to suggest that the believed there must be life out there someplace, and that it's just a matter of where to look.
 
Here is a quote by Carl Sagan from his book The Demon Haunted World.

"For me, it is far better to grasp the Universe as it really is than to persist in delusion, however satisfying and reassuring."

1. So what was he doing smoking pot a mind altering drug that he claimed enhanced and altered his perceptions?
Altering and enhancing his perceptions. Obviously.

2. Why was he writing science fiction instead of grasping the Universe as it really was, writing about aliens and UFOs which remained an obsession and persisted in his delusional recreations? He was vicariously living in a fantasy world of aliens and UFOs which he found satisfying and reassuring.
Are scientists barred from writing science fiction? You seem to think so.

Was Sagan successful in his endeavours to promote/popularize science and expose UFOs and alien encounters as fraud?
Yup.

Some statistics:

• The World Economic Forum ranks the United States 52nd in the quality of mathematics and science education, and 5th (and declining) in overall global competitiveness [v]
• The United States ranks 27th in developed nations in the proportion of college students receiving undergraduate degrees in science or engineering [vi]
• There are more foreign students studying in U.S. graduate schools than the number of U.S. students [vii] and over 2/3 of the engineers who receive Ph.D.’s from United States universities are not United States citizens [viii]
http://www.lpfi.org/how-does-us-compare-other-countries-stem-education

UFO Sightings Increase 67 Percent In 3 Years, History Channel Investigates Unexplained Aerial Phenomena
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/08/26/ufos-pilots-history-channel_n_935847.html
The state of your educational system is immaterial to me and the other 95% of the worlds population.

So the US is lagging in science and UFO sighting are on the rise and no extraterrestrial intelligent life has been found making it 3 strikes against Sagan’s legacy. But legalizing pot is gaining momentum which may be the only lasting contribution we can credit to Carl Sagan.
Sagan did not contribute to the state of your education system. Nothing wrong with legalising pot.

What about people who read his book The Demon Haunted World?

Be warned wrote one member.

One word: avoid. Avoid the Demon Haunted World at all costs. I got dumber after reading it. It's true.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=55278

Please. Not the Amy Wilson nonsense yet again.
 
Nope. I wasn't implying a contradiction to Mojo. I was however presenting the open minded viewpoint of Sagan to the possibility that there exists extraterrestrial life that could be far in advance of our own.

As for what Sagan personally believed about the actual existence of such life, or it visiting us, none of us can know that without being inside Sagan's head, which is impossible. All we can do is quote what he said and wrote and try to read it both literally and between the lines. It's my impression from this that Sagan would have thought it unreasonable, even in the absence of concrete scientific evidence sufficient to prove the existence of alien life, to believe that no such life exists in the vastness of the cosmos. By extension, I think it's reasonable to suggest that the believed there must be life out there someplace, and that it's just a matter of where to look.

Wouldn't that be an extraordinary claim by Carl Sagan to believe there could be more advanced civilizations than our own?

In his book Pale Blue Dot: A Vision of the Human Future in Space, astronomer Carl Sagan related his thoughts:
The Earth is the only world known, so far, to harbor life.
Our planet is a lonely speck in the great enveloping cosmic dark. In our obscurity – in all this vastness – there is no hint that help will come from elsewhere to save us from ourselves.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pale_Blue_Dot

Carl Sagan contradicted himself by claiming the Earth is the only known world to harbor life. The rest were all speculations of extraordinary magnitude.
 
Wouldn't that be an extraordinary claim by Carl Sagan to believe there could be more advanced civilizations than our own?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pale_Blue_Dot
OK, go ahead and provide proof that there are no more advanced civilisations in the observable universe than ours. You cannot.

Carl Sagan contradicted himself by claiming the Earth is the only known world to harbor life. The rest were all speculations of extraordinary magnitude.
Orly? Now you claim extra-terrestrial life when it suits? Which is it? No extra-solar life or not?

Make up your mind, because you oscillate between both positions, as suits your argument du jour.

Pick one.
 
Wouldn't that be an extraordinary claim by Carl Sagan to believe there could be more advanced civilizations than our own?


1. Believing something isn't a claim.
2. If someone says that it is possible that something exists, and that it is worth looking for, that does not mean that they belive that it exists.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pale_Blue_Dot

Carl Sagan contradicted himself by claiming the Earth is the only known world to harbor life. The rest were all speculations of extraordinary magnitude.


You've changed the statement slightly. He didn't say that "the Earth is the only known world to harbor life"; the actual quotation is "The Earth is the only world known, so far, to harbor life." This doesn't contradict anything he said or wrote.
 
1. Believing something isn't a claim.

So if someone believes there is a god, that person is not making a claim.


2. If someone says that it is possible that something exists, and that it is worth looking for, that does not mean that they belive that it exists.


If a person says it is possible that god exists and that it is worth looking for, that does not mean that they believe that it exists.


Why would you search for something if did not believe it exist?

Carl Sagan according to you did not make a claim but he only believed ETI possibly existed. But the instant he started looking for them because that was worth looking for, that does not mean that he believe that it exists.

I guess that was how his pot addiction enhanced his perception. He no longer had to believe in aliens or make claims about them. He just knew they were worth looking for and started looking for them while reminding everyone to be scientifically skeptical of ever finding any.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom