Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

In most cases applying a label logical fallacy to a position is a sign of laziness,

Please support that position with some evidence.

an attempt to abruptly end the discussion

you mean, like your post?

and more often than not the label is incorrectly applied.

"More often than not"? Please support that position with evidence, showing this happens more than 50% of the time.

In reality, applying a label to a fallacy is an attempt to show exactly where the error in thinking has arisen. It is an attempt to shift the discussion away from fallacious logic to a rational basis, one supported by evidence. Also, by naming (and explaining) the fallacy, it becomes a teachable moment - it helps other people understand how to do critical thinking in future. What do you suggest we do when someone replies with a logical fallacy?
 
You appear to have misread the research article.
Here is what the article said about the type of questions that raised strong emotional arousal in Atheists.

1. “The results imply that atheists’ attitudes toward God are ambivalent, in that their explicit beliefs conflict with their affective response,

2. This suggests that taunting God made the atheists more upset than they were letting on (even to themselves).

3. Of course, perhaps it wasn’t the presence of God, but rather the subject matter of the statements (such as the death of their parents) that caused the atheists’ emotional arousal.


4. The results: The atheists showed greater emotional arousal when reading the God-related statements than while reading the otherwise nearly identical sentences that omitted the almighty.

5. To the researchers, this indicates that “even atheists have difficulty daring God to harm themselves and their loved ones.

6. If so, it suggests that even for committed non-believers, it’s difficult to totally erase the idea of God from one’s psyche.

It is clear your own strong emotional arousal is quite different from the controlled research. Maybe it is because the subjects in the experiment were Atheists and you are a skeptic.


Can you please explicitly state which link you're citing, and include the page#s?

You have a history of questionable citing and making unattributed 'quotes'.

I want to see exactly the information you claim to be citing.

Thank you.
 
Wrong. Read it again.


Wrong. Read it again.

Ya think?


Yup. Because atheists in general find it irritating when iron age superstitions are trotted out. I know I do. It is all superstitious, iron age nonsense, and I am tired of hearing it.

Wrong. Read it again.

Wrong. I have no god. End of story.

Wrong. I am an atheist. There is no such thing as a god or gods.

Are you saying those points don't apply to you or they are wrong? They are points taken from the research conducted under strict controlled environment and published in a peer-review International Journal for the Psychology of Religion.

Are you different from those Atheists subjects? Have you been subjects to the same type of test with different results or it is just your emotional state that begs to differ. Can you offer an explanation for each point you disagree with and why?

Marjaana Lindeman has several peer-reviewed publications and is well respected by her peers.
 
Something that people are predisposed to be curious about exists, therefore anything which people are predisposed to believe in exists? Are you serious?

Curiosity is a reaction to stimulus. The interpretation of that stimulus is balanced with ones motivation and reward. Example, life and life forms exists and to the religious observer it is real. His interpretation of that observed is associated with a creator (logical deduction/inference) and based on motivation and reward attributes/credits that to god or as in the case of skeptics denies a creator. Religious people see gods hand in creation and are comfortable with that inference.

The presence of life is not disputed which my inference and logic points to a creator much as some would like to believe it all came from nothing. So it is only the predisposition of skeptics to deny a creator which according to research finds belief in god as a natural tendency and even innate in humans.

People believed that the earth was flat for thousands of years, because that's what their common sense (the way their brains were wired) told them. According to your logic, that mean that everyone alive today who doesn't believe the earth is flat is suffering from some sort of pathological problem which should be investigated by scientists. Have you any idea how ridiculous you sound?

You are confusing knowledge with beliefs. People who thought the world was flat followed the prevailing knowledge of the earth at that time. People also practiced alchemy and believe blood letting could cure almost every illness.
Today, many of those misconceptions have been corrected and some new ones introduced. But in all it is progressive knowledge.

Beliefs on the other hand about god are innate. It is knowledge by inference. Beliefs are episodically-stored material influenced by personal experiences or cultural and institutional sources. The universality of religious beliefs and of god is overwhelming evidence it is innate in humans. It is this universality of beliefs that raises question on the pathology of disbelief.
 
Most cases? Isn't that a hasty generalization (aka Fallacy of Insufficient Statistics, Fallacy of Insufficient Sample, Leaping to A Conclusion, Hasty Induction*)?

"People also commonly commit Hasty Generalizations because of laziness or sloppiness. It is very easy to simply leap to a conclusion and much harder to gather an adequate sample and draw a justified conclusion."*

So was this a justified conclusion based on an adequate sample, or just an opinion from some blogger?

*http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/hasty-generalization.html

RayG

That is my experience from the many skeptic forums I have participated in. It is not possible to point to every instance of the inappropriate use of common fallacies such as ad hominem, begging the question, appealing to authority etc.etc.There are just too many and if you don't think they are overused then you haven't debated much. Besides, there is very little for a skeptic to debate on a skeptic forum. What position could you possible hold?

The debate then is consumed by debating the correctness or inappropriate use of the fallacy by using more logical fallacies because there is renewed justification for terminating the debate as it erodes into a semantic war.

There is nothing like a well constructed argument which expresses clearly and unequivocally the positions and articulates it with consideration for the reader who has to deal with the written text with all its nuanced reading.
 
That is my experience from the many skeptic forums I have participated in. It is not possible to point to every instance of the inappropriate use of common fallacies such as ad hominem, begging the question, appealing to authority etc.etc. There are just too many and if you don't think they are overused then you haven't debated much.

I've been here on the JREF nearly 12 years, you?

Besides, there is very little for a skeptic to debate on a skeptic forum. What position could you possible hold?
Stick around, I suspect you'll be surprised.

There is nothing like a well constructed argument which expresses clearly and unequivocally the positions and articulates it with consideration for the reader who has to deal with the written text with all its nuanced reading.
I agree. Would you agree that using hasty generalizations does not strengthen an argument?

RayG
 
Are you saying those points don't apply to you or they are wrong? They are points taken from the research conducted under strict controlled environment and published in a peer-review International Journal for the Psychology of Religion.

Are you different from those Atheists subjects? Have you been subjects to the same type of test with different results or it is just your emotional state that begs to differ. Can you offer an explanation for each point you disagree with and why?

Marjaana Lindeman has several peer-reviewed publications and is well respected by her peers.
No. I am saying you are wrong. Your interpretation is wrong. What you state is wrong, and you read it wrong.

I am no different from any other atheist. There is no god, period. End of story.

The only part of god that gets me steamed up is anything predicated on the existence of some superstitious sky fairy. That I find irritating.
 
if you don't think they are overused then you haven't debated much.


Evidence?


The debate then is consumed by debating the correctness or inappropriate use of the fallacy


Evidence?


by using more logical fallacies


Evidence?


because there is renewed justification for terminating the debate as it erodes into a semantic war.


Evidence


There is nothing like a well constructed argument which expresses clearly and unequivocally the positions and articulates it with consideration for the reader who has to deal with the written text with all its nuanced reading.


There's certainly nothing like it in your post.
 
Beliefs on the other hand about god are innate.

So what? Simpler superstitious beliefs are even more fundamental, but that doesn't mean magic is real, that stepping on the cracks in the pavement (sidewalk) brings bad luck, that black cats are either lucky or unlucky, that breaking a mirror brings 7 years bad luck, or that touching wood or throwing salt wards off evil. It's irrational nonsense.

Likewise, that a selection of Finnish atheists show an emotional reaction to god-related nastiness doesn't mean god exists. It's irrational nonsense.
 
I've been here on the JREF nearly 12 years, you?

Stick around, I suspect you'll be surprised.

I agree. Would you agree that using hasty generalizations does not strengthen an argument?

RayG

I think your labeling of my post is itself an inappropriate use of the fallacy Hasty Generalization.

1. This fallacy is committed when a person draws a conclusion about a population based on a sample that is not large enough. It has the following form:

I did not draw conclusions about a population based on a sample (study). I have drawn the conclusion from personal experience spread across several skeptic forums and over an extended period of time to be adequate and indicative of a large cross-section of the skeptic population.

2. The reasons I offered do not even match the examples offered under the definition of Hasty Generalization.

3. I provided the most cited reason where the use of argumentum abusi fallacia is misused and why its use is not helpful in a debate. That is not a generalization. It is pointing to a cited fact.

The use of argumentum abusi fallacia is something of an argument by assertion, in which an attempt is made to refute an argument simply by citing the name of a fallacy, without any further explanation of why.

This is often a result of falling into skeptical jargon, or just discovering that there are terms not just to describe that someone is wrong but why they’re wrong. So, thanks to convenience and in an effort to show off this new-found knowledge – and, hey, some of it’s in Latin! – someone might be very keen to drop the name of a formal or informal fallacy into conversation. However, just because you can reduce why someone is wrong to a single, fancy name, doesn’t mean the names of fallacies can be thrown around at will and automatically be correct. Arguments need to be demonstrated as being fallacious, and usually this is possible without using any Latin at all.
 
That is my experience from the many skeptic forums I have participated in. It is not possible to point to every instance of the inappropriate use of common fallacies[...]

So we're supposed to just take your word for it? You have a poor history of factual research.

Better luck next time, pal.
 
Can you please explicitly state which link you're citing, and include the page#s?

You have a history of questionable citing and making unattributed 'quotes'.

I want to see exactly the information you claim to be citing.

Thank you.

I guess not.
 
Curiosity is a reaction to stimulus. The interpretation of that stimulus is balanced with ones motivation and reward. Example, life and life forms exists and to the religious observer it is real. His interpretation of that observed is associated with a creator (logical deduction/inference) and based on motivation and reward attributes/credits that to god or as in the case of skeptics denies a creator. Religious people see gods hand in creation and are comfortable with that inference.

The presence of life is not disputed which my inference and logic points to a creator much as some would like to believe it all came from nothing. So it is only the predisposition of skeptics to deny a creator which according to research finds belief in god as a natural tendency and even innate in humans.

You are confusing knowledge with beliefs. People who thought the world was flat followed the prevailing knowledge of the earth at that time. People also practiced alchemy and believe blood letting could cure almost every illness.
Today, many of those misconceptions have been corrected and some new ones introduced. But in all it is progressive knowledge.

1Beliefs on the other hand about god are innate. It is knowledge by inference. 2Beliefs are episodically-stored material influenced by personal experiences or cultural and institutional sources. 3The universality of religious beliefs and of god is overwhelming evidence it is innate in humans. 4It is this universality of beliefs that raises question on the pathology of disbelief.
Highlighted numbers added.

I am not going to simply repeat what others have said about your tendency to mis-report, mis-interpret, and misrepresent the conclusions of studies that you claim support your agenda; but which on plain reading, do nothing of the kind.

I will, however, address the points I have numbered.

1. Since you offer no support for this claim, as is your habit, I will simply point out that your claim appears to be based upon an inaccurate reading of Dr. Justin Barrett's work. Dr, Barrett never claimed that belief in 'god' is "innate". Instead, the results of his studies indicate that children have a "tendency" to believe in "supernatural agents" more easily than in abilities of their parents, which they, the children, do not (yet) understand. Tellingly, that "tendency" does not directly result in belief in the xianist 'god', but in whatever one of several 'gods' is promulgated by the child's culture, and may not result in beleif in 'god' at all.

Dr. Barrett also refers to what has been called the "Hyperactive Agency Detection Device" (HADD). Dr. Barrett claims that the functioning of the HADD can lead to identification of agency, even in situations where there is none; and that that identification of agency can be reinforced into belief in a "supernatural agent", or whatever 'god' (or 'gods') is/are part of the societal milieu. He goes on to claim that if the world were not sinful and broken, everyone would come to realize that the "agent" that isn't even there is, in fact, the 'god' in which Dr. Barrett believes (a conclusion not supported by the results of his own study).

In other words,your claim that belief in 'god' is "innate" is not supported.

2. Would you mind, terribly, providing your source for this claim? Given your posting habits, i would like to read the study, article, or link fromn which you appropriated this definition.

3. It is dishonest of you to equivocate "the universality of religious belief and of god". While the human tendency to ascribe agency, even in situations where there is not, cannot be, an agent, may be common enough to casually call it "universal"; "religious beliefs" are not 'god'. Not every human, not even the majority of humans, who have their HADD-driven tendency to detect agentless agency reinforced into belief in a 'god' end up believing in the xianist 'god'.

4. Since it is not a specific belief that Dr. Barrett claims is universal, but instead a tendency to overdetect agency, not believing in 'god', a 'god', nor any 'gods' is not a pathology. This does not mean that you do not have the right to adopt whatever set of superstitions gives you comfort. Instead, it means that it is disingenuous, at best (even dishonest), to pretend that a person who does not share your particular superstition is demonstrating a pathology.
 
Last edited:
That is my experience from the many skeptic forums I have participated in. It is not possible to point to every instance of the inappropriate use of common fallacies such as ad hominem, begging the question, appealing to authority etc.etc
You can't back up your claim then. Didn't think so.
 
So what? Simpler superstitious beliefs are even more fundamental, but that doesn't mean magic is real, that stepping on the cracks in the pavement (sidewalk) brings bad luck, that black cats are either lucky or unlucky, that breaking a mirror brings 7 years bad luck, or that touching wood or throwing salt wards off evil. It's irrational nonsense.

Likewise, that a selection of Finnish atheists show an emotional reaction to god-related nastiness doesn't mean god exists. It's irrational nonsense.

The research is not to prove that god exist. It is to prove atheist still believe in god even thought they claim they are atheists.
 
No. I am saying you are wrong. Your interpretation is wrong. What you state is wrong, and you read it wrong.

I am no different from any other atheist. There is no god, period. End of story.

The only part of god that gets me steamed up is anything predicated on the existence of some superstitious sky fairy. That I find irritating.

As long as you agree with the research I don`t have a problem with your position. Because my position is the same as the article and that is why I introduced it here. Do Atheists secretly believe in God? Yes they do.
 
I don`t know where Slowvehicle got the impression I was quoting Dr Justin Barrett`s research. I have pointed to the link and author Dr Shermer several times through out my posts and again in post #2846.
Why Belief in God Is Innate:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304198004575172233981688208.html

...which is why you ought to identify the source of your claims, so that others can read what the articles and studies, which you claim support you, actually say, like this:

From your link:

On numbering believers: "... 5.7 billion people who belong to about 10,000 distinct religions, each of which may be further subdivided and classified..."

Which does not support, in any way, that belief in the xianist 'god', nor in any specific 'god' or 'gods' is innate. Instead, Shermer's claim parallels and supports Barrett's.

Again, from your link:

"Of course, genes do not determine whether one chooses Judaism, Catholicism, Islam or any other religion. Rather, belief in supernatural agents (God, angels, demons) and commitment to certain religious practices (church attendance, prayer, rituals) appears to reflect genetically based cognitive processes (inferring the existence of invisible agents) and personality traits (respect for authority, traditionalism)."

Which actually goes against your claim that belief in the xianist 'god' is innate, and, again, parallels and supports Barrett's.

And again, from your link:

"Gods (sic) are agents and agents are essences, and agenticity is everywhere. Subjects watching reflective dots move about in a darkened room (especially if the dots take on the shape of two legs and two arms) infer that they represent a person or intentional agent."

...describing in very similar terms, the mechanism Barrett calls the HADD.

One more, from your link:

"We believe in the supernatural because we believe in the natural and we cannot discriminate between the two. We create gods because we are natural-born supernaturalists, driven by our tendency to find meaningful patterns and impart to them intentional agency.
(emphasis added)

Do notice that the "gods" to which Shermer refers are constructs of our own minds. They do not exist; they are not real. They are a side-effect. It is disingenuous, if not outright dishonest, of you to pretend that Shermer's claim is anything otherwise.

All of which sort-of answers my questions #1 & #4. Would you mind, terribly, addressing the other two?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom