Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

"The Drake equation is a wonderful way to organize our ignorance."
Whether it was sincere or not, I think there's a lot of truth to that - the more precisely we can identify the gaps in our knowledge, the better placed we are to specifically address those gaps.
 
So what if Sagan believed intelligent extraterrestrial life exists someplace else in vastness of the cosmos? That's by far the most reasonable position to take. Why? Because in the grand scheme, the probability that there aren't any others is so vanishingly small as to amount to a zero. Yet without conclusive evidence of the affirmative, he still admited he may be wrong. Does that make him a skeptic? Or was he just playing it safe for political purposes? On this issue I think it was largely the latter. On other issues in general, I think it's safe to say that Sagan's role in CSICOP ( now just CSI ) made him a significant player in the arena of skeptical inquiry, and if there ever was a model of behavior for skepticism in general, Sagan was the epitome of the best. His articulate and engaging style introduced science to the masses in a way that left a positive and lasting impression on all those who were fans of Cosmos and his work with SETI.
 
SETI (search for extraterrestrial inteligent life) is not a scientific theory. It is an experiment. Radio signals are sent out with the hope that it gets picked up by some advanced civilization familiar with radio technology and responds in kind. That then becomes the evidence for ETI.

The same approach is taken when it is anybody's guess. So we throw everything at a wall to see what sticks.

The only problem with the approach is the support it has from scientists who fully endorse this wild speculation when there is no available data to even formulate a theory/hypothesis.
 
SETI (search for extraterrestrial inteligent life) is not a scientific theory. It is an experiment. Radio signals are sent out with the hope that it gets picked up by some advanced civilization familiar with radio technology and responds in kind. That then becomes the evidence for ETI.

The same approach is taken when it is anybody's guess. So we throw everything at a wall to see what sticks.

The only problem with the approach is the support it has from scientists who fully endorse this wild speculation when there is no available data to even formulate a theory/hypothesis.

The highlighted is factually, demonstrably, incorrect (just like your idea of the "next generation of interstellar rockets" that were actually proposed, interplanetary, solar sails). the question than becoems: is this an error, or is this fraud on your part?
 
For those interested you can find the various projects that targeted Stars to which messages were sent from the link below.

Active SETI (wiki)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_SETI

Did you read the wiki? It shows your claim to be demonstrably, fraudulently incorrect. ASETI and METI are not part of the work of the SETI institute.
 
Sagan had 2 warnings for Humanity.
http://www.collective-evolution.com...y-last-interview-you-might-want-to-hear-this/

His first concern was with regards to science and technology. Sagan expressed great concern that “if the general public doesn’t understand science and technology, then who is making all of the decisions about science and technology that are going to determine what kind of future our children live in, some members of congress? There are only a handful who have any background in science at all, and some of them don’t even want to know about it.” – Carl Sagan


Sagan’s second warning for humanity was that science is more than a body of knowledge, that it is a way of thinking, a way of skeptically interrogating the universe. He expressed that if we are not able to ask skeptical questions, to interrogate those who tell us that something is true, to be skeptical of those in authority, then we as a human race are up for grabs. This is a great point, and a great reminder to always question what you are told. 17 years ago, when Sagan was alive, the human race did not ask as many questions as they are asking now. Questioning leads to answers, and threaten the control structure.

But how are his warnings even related to his life long advocacy to legalize marijuana and his quest for extraterrestrial intelligent aliens or advanced civilizations much older and wiser than ours?
 
But how are his warnings even related to his life long advocacy to legalize marijuana and his quest for extraterrestrial intelligent aliens or advanced civilizations much older and wiser than ours?


They're not. That's what people have been telling you for the last eleven hundred pages. And that's what you just admitted. Carl Sagan's main focus was on popularizing science education. The charges that you've leveled against him, even if true, took up only a small part of his attentions. Isaac Newton spent the last years of his life trying to turn lead into gold; but that doesn't take anything away from everything he got right.

I'm glad you've noticed this flaw in your own argument.
 
They're not. That's what people have been telling you for the last eleven hundred pages. And that's what you just admitted. Carl Sagan's main focus was on popularizing science education. The charges that you've leveled against him, even if true, took up only a small part of his attentions. Isaac Newton spent the last years of his life trying to turn lead into gold; but that doesn't take anything away from everything he got right.

I'm glad you've noticed this flaw in your own argument.

What science is Sagan known for? He was a space/galactic junkie and his Cosmos TV series made him a media star. But that was a TV series about astronomy and not your everyday science.

His theory about a nuclear winter was discredited. His actual scientific achievements were judged by his peers to be trivial and derivative (Harold Urey). His rejection of UFO was controversial because he was and remained convinced of the existence of extraterrestrial intelligent being. He admitted in his last NOVA interview his life long obsession with ETI and his mission to search for them.

He was an entertainer and appeared on the Tonight Show as a celebrity of sorts....no Einstein by any stretch of the imagination.
 
What science is Sagan known for? He was a space/galactic junkie and his Cosmos TV series made him a media star. But that was a TV series about astronomy and not your everyday science.

Are you saying that astronomy isn't a science?
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
What science is Sagan known for? He was a space/galactic junkie and his Cosmos TV series made him a media star. But that was a TV series about astronomy and not your everyday science.

Are you saying that astronomy isn't a science?

It is not your everyday science (see highlighted text).
 
Dr Carl Sagan was an astronomer and one of the original exo biologists.
The Cosmos series was about a lot more than Astronomy I watched it when it first aired in the UK on the BBC and I was also given the book that was released along side it, it is full of information about science.
 
To connect to the OP, what do you think of Steven Novella's attempt at a definition?

Steven Novella said:
A skeptic is one who prefers beliefs and conclusions that are reliable and valid to ones that are comforting or convenient, and therefore rigorously and openly applies the methods of science and reason to all empirical claims, especially their own. A skeptic provisionally proportions acceptance of any claim to valid logic and a fair and thorough assessment of available evidence, and studies the pitfalls of human reason and the mechanisms of deception so as to avoid being deceived by others or themselves. Skepticism values method over any particular conclusion.
 
Steven Novella's definition and role of skeptics sounds tame and naive. So is it to believe skeptics are competently prepared to deal with scientific multidimensional theories such as bio centrism, multiverse, quantum possibilities versus realities determined by consciousness, in a credible way

What skeptic method is applicable when the scientific method applied by scientists produces theories that are so far fetched, they resemble scientific mysticism unchecked by scientific skepticism. All checks and balances are off and unbridled speculation is in.


One of these things is not like the other...

Here is an example.
Quantum physics proves that there IS an afterlife, claims scientist
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...ics-proves-IS-afterlife-claims-scientist.html

Or were the Vedas right? Because scientists are discovering the only language that can describe what they are discovering are found in the Vedic literature.
Quantum Physics came from the Vedas: Schrödinger, Einstein and Tesla were all Vedantists.
http://www.krishnapath.org/quantum-...inger-einstein-and-tesla-were-all-vedantists/

...and a rational person, preferring method over conclusion, will observe the method by which these "ideas" were reached, and decide whether to accept, reject, or suspend judgement upon these "ideas".

Sometimes it requires deferred gratification, and a tolerance for ambiguity.
 
Steven Novella's definition and role of skeptics sounds tame and naive. So is it to believe skeptics are competently prepared to deal with scientific multidimensional theories such as bio centrism, multiverse, quantum possibilities versus realities determined by consciousness, in a credible way

What skeptic method is applicable when the scientific method applied by scientists produces theories that are so far fetched, they resemble scientific mysticism unchecked by scientific skepticism. All checks and balances are off and unbridled speculation is in.

Here is an example.
Quantum physics proves that there IS an afterlife, claims scientist
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencet...ics-proves-IS-afterlife-claims-scientist.html

Or were the Vedas right? Because scientists are discovering the only language that can describe what they are discovering are found in the Vedic literature.
Quantum Physics came from the Vedas: Schrödinger, Einstein and Tesla were all Vedantists.
http://www.krishnapath.org/quantum-...inger-einstein-and-tesla-were-all-vedantists/

The book by Lanza appears to be -- at its best -- the philosophical speculations of a physician-scientist outside of his field. From the reviews, it doesn't appear that he actually understands quantum physics, or has researched much of the relevant science and philosophy.

Quantum, therefore no time, therefore no death, therefore afterlife.

That's not a solid chain.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom