Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

So if someone believes there is a god, that person is not making a claim.

That is correct. You can believe in talking carrots if you wish.

If a person says it is possible that god exists and that it is worth looking for, that does not mean that they believe that it exists.

Not so fast. This 'god' creature you are about to posit must have some identifiable properties.

Why would you search for something if did not believe it exist?

This has been explained to you dozens of times. If anyone reading this thread needs this explained to them, then let that person speak out.

Carl Sagan according to you did not make a claim but he only believed ETI possibly existed. But the instant he started looking for them because that was worth looking for, that does not mean that he believe that it exists.

Do you have some other, less factually tortured point?

I guess that was how his pot addiction enhanced his perception. He no longer had to believe in aliens or make claims about them. He just knew they were worth looking for and started looking for them while reminding everyone to be scientifically skeptical of ever finding any.

What pot addiction? Is this another imaginary rant from page 78 of The Demon Haunted World? :D

What is your favorite woo that the very memory of Carl Sagan torques you off so much?
 
Wouldn't that be an extraordinary claim by Carl Sagan to believe there could be more advanced civilizations than our own?


I don't think it would have been an extraordinary claim for Sagan to say that he believed there could be more advanced civilizations than our own in the vastness of the cosmos. In fact I think it's perfectly reasonable to assume that Sagan would agree that given the scale and age of the universe, that the chances of life more advanced life than our own existing out there someplace is so great as to be a virtual certainty. Where Sagan had to tread much more carefully was when he was commenting on whether or not any such life had visited Earth.

Carl Sagan contradicted himself by claiming the Earth is the only known world to harbor life. The rest were all speculations of extraordinary magnitude.


It's not a speculation of "extraordinary magnitude" to suggest that in the totality of the universe there must be advanced life on other worlds. However to claim the same for any specific star system would be. So in that context, I don't see any contradiction.
 
I don't think it would have been an extraordinary claim for Sagan to say that he believed there could be more advanced civilizations than our own in the vastness of the cosmos. In fact I think it's perfectly reasonable to assume that Sagan would agree that given the scale and age of the universe, that the chances of life more advanced life than our own existing out there someplace is so great as to be a virtual certainty. Where Sagan had to tread much more carefully was when he was commenting on whether or not any such life had visited Earth.

It's not a speculation of "extraordinary magnitude" to suggest that in the totality of the universe there must be advanced life on other worlds. However to claim the same for any specific star system would be. So in that context, I don't see any contradiction.

OTH, you are dispassionately considering reality, rather than ritually beating a dead hobby-horse...
 
I don't think it would have been an extraordinary claim for Sagan to say that he believed there could be more advanced civilizations than our own in the vastness of the cosmos. In fact I think it's perfectly reasonable to assume that Sagan would agree that given the scale and age of the universe, that the chances of life more advanced life than our own existing out there someplace is so great as to be a virtual certainty. Where Sagan had to tread much more carefully was when he was commenting on whether or not any such life had visited Earth.




It's not a speculation of "extraordinary magnitude" to suggest that in the totality of the universe there must be advanced life on other worlds. However to claim the same for any specific star system would be. So in that context, I don't see any contradiction.

Wow.

I largely disagree with you on pretty much everything, but you are spot on here. Kudos.
 
From Wiki:

August 2007 the Independent Investigations Group (IIG) awarded Sagan posthumously a Lifetime Achievement Award. This honor has also been awarded to Harry Houdini and James Randi.
Not to take anything away from James Randi or Harry Houdini. Houdini and Randi are famous performers but not scientists. So to put Carl Sagan in the same league as them suggests Sagan was just another performer. Sagan was also awarded the SFWA Solstice Award for science fiction and for popularizing fantasy. Any wonder why Harold Urey a Nobel Laureate found Sagan's achievement trivial and derivative.

No tenure at Harvard, no National Academy of Sciences membership and no Nobel prize...no evidence of extraterrestrial intelligent life either. Just an award for making up stuff out of pure fantasy.
 
From Wiki:


Not to take anything away from James Randi or Harry Houdini. Houdini and Randi are famous performers but not scientists. So to put Carl Sagan in the same league as them suggests Sagan was just another performer. Sagan was also awarded the SFWA Solstice Award for science fiction and for popularizing fantasy. Any wonder why Harold Urey a Nobel Laureate found Sagan's achievement trivial and derivative.
Houdini, Randi? That's OK. Sagan somehow is not. Yet you are unable to provide any reason for that.

No tenure at Harvard, no National Academy of Sciences membership and no Nobel prize...no evidence of extraterrestrial intelligent life either. Just an award for making up stuff out of pure fantasy.
Yes, we discussed that and you comprehensively lost. Doing the same thing again does not make it better.
 
From Wiki:


Not to take anything away from James Randi or Harry Houdini. Houdini and Randi are famous performers but not scientists. So to put Carl Sagan in the same league as them suggests Sagan was just another performer. Sagan was also awarded the SFWA Solstice Award for science fiction and for popularizing fantasy. Any wonder why Harold Urey a Nobel Laureate found Sagan's achievement trivial and derivative.

No tenure at Harvard, no National Academy of Sciences membership and no Nobel prize...no evidence of extraterrestrial intelligent life either. Just an award for making up stuff out of pure fantasy.

What awards have you won? What university has granted you tenure? Do you have a membership in the NAS or a Nobel Prize? Have you got any evidence of ET?

Me either, but I'm not sitting in judgement of Carl Sagan or you on that account.
 
What awards have you won? What university has granted you tenure? Do you have a membership in the NAS or a Nobel Prize?


I have a Nobel Prize in Chemistry. They're actually pretty easy to get assuming you're really, really good at chemistry. Anyway, I approve of the work of Carl Sagan.
 
I have a Nobel Prize in Chemistry. They're actually pretty easy to get assuming you're really, really good at chemistry. Anyway, I approve of the work of Carl Sagan.


Drat. And all I got was a crummy publication in the Journal of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists International. (JAOAC)
 
I have a Nobel Prize in Chemistry. They're actually pretty easy to get assuming you're really, really good at chemistry. Anyway, I approve of the work of Carl Sagan.

Carl Sagan could not even earn a Nobel Prize even though you found it easy to get assuming one was really, really good at what he does which suggests Sagan was not really, really good at what he did.

Sagan won an award for writing science fiction and popularizing fantasy. It is not the Nobel Prize but he must have been really, really good at writing fiction and making stuff up out of pure fantasy.

While the world looked up to him for some scientific achievements Sagan was edging his way into the performing arts the likes of escape artist Harry Houdini and magician James Randi.

Sagan's stage act was:
1. To show how extraterrestrial aliens escaped our detection....demonstrate a few Houdini escapades.

2. To show they are not some mythical magical creatures by applying conjuring tricks he saw James Randi performing.

Sagan got so good at it "the Independent Investigations Group (IIG) awarded Sagan posthumously a Lifetime Achievement Award."
 
Carl Sagan could not even earn a Nobel Prize even though you found it easy to get assuming one was really, really good at what he does which suggests Sagan was not really, really good at what he did.


As far as I know, Mr. Sagan was not a chemist. Nor is there a Nobel Prize for popularizing and explaining concepts in science. So, it's not really surprising that he didn't win a Nobel Prize. Since I doubt you've been awarded such an honor, what field are you not really, really good in?
 
As far as I know, Mr. Sagan was not a chemist. Nor is there a Nobel Prize for popularizing and explaining concepts in science. So, it's not really surprising that he didn't win a Nobel Prize. Since I doubt you've been awarded such an honor, what field are you not really, really good in?

You got that right. Smoking pot does not make him a chemist any more than chasing extraterrestrial aliens makes him a skeptic. I am a critical analyst, I analyze critical thinkers. Am I really good at what I do? It is a very new discipline so I am a pioneer of sorts. I am bound by contractual agreement to remain anonymous in anticipation of your next question.
 
You got that right. Smoking pot does not make him a chemist any more than chasing extraterrestrial aliens makes him a skeptic. I am a critical analyst, I analyze critical thinkers. Am I really good at what I do? It is a very new discipline so I am a pioneer of sorts. I am bound by contractual agreement to remain anonymous in anticipation of your next question.

Classic straw man fallacy. If this is the best you got, critical thinkers have nothing to fear from your 'analyses'.
 
Hi JiT

Just for my two cents worth I've read some of this thread and from my viewpoint JiT, your flogging a dead horse on this one. I'm afraid you lost the argument several times about 40 or so pages ago. Carl Sagan it could have worked out could have been a bit of a nut when it comes to SETI. But after all the evidence is in, looks like he wasnt at all, which if you look at everything else he has done and said isnt really a big surprise. The facts just dont support your assertions.

So if someone believes there is a god, that person is not making a claim.

If a person says it is possible that god exists and that it is worth looking for, that does not mean that they believe that it exists.


Why would you search for something if did not believe it exist?

Carl Sagan according to you did not make a claim but he only believed ETI possibly existed. But the instant he started looking for them because that was worth looking for, that does not mean that he believe that it exists.

I guess that was how his pot addiction enhanced his perception. He no longer had to believe in aliens or make claims about them. He just knew they were worth looking for and started looking for them while reminding everyone to be scientifically skeptical of ever finding any.

Scientists generally dont just make some isolated assertions and then go and test it. Like, "I think Fairies exist at the bottom of my Garden, so I'm going to spend three years camping out with cameras to prove my theory". There's usually some observable natural phenomenon that requires an explanation or some maths or physics that is making a prediction that is then pursued with scientific endeavour. The question of the existence of God never arose from a scientific predicate in the first place. Only the question of why humans believe in a god or gods in the first place. Thats a scientific question.

To check the fairy story you would probably start off by researching the history of Fairy stories to see when they were first introduced into popular fiction. You wouldn't start by trying to figure out how to build a fairy detector because theres no scientific reason to think they may exist in the first place.

With SETI however, there are very good reasons to think that intelligent beings exist on other planets and even that we maybe able to detect them. There are also other scientific reasons why that may not be the case. So the scientific investigation for SETI starts from the basis of our relatively new knowlege of the universe, how stars and planets are formed, how old the universe is, the fact that biological evolution exists etc. All science.
 
Hi JiT

Just for my two cents worth I've read some of this thread and from my viewpoint JiT, your flogging a dead horse on this one. I'm afraid you lost the argument several times about 40 or so pages ago. Carl Sagan it could have worked out could have been a bit of a nut when it comes to SETI. But after all the evidence is in, looks like he wasnt at all, which if you look at everything else he has done and said isnt really a big surprise. The facts just dont support your assertions.



Scientists generally dont just make some isolated assertions and then go and test it. Like, "I think Fairies exist at the bottom of my Garden, so I'm going to spend three years camping out with cameras to prove my theory". There's usually some observable natural phenomenon that requires an explanation or some maths or physics that is making a prediction that is then pursued with scientific endeavour. The question of the existence of God never arose from a scientific predicate in the first place. Only the question of why humans believe in a god or gods in the first place. Thats a scientific question.

To check the fairy story you would probably start off by researching the history of Fairy stories to see when they were first introduced into popular fiction. You wouldn't start by trying to figure out how to build a fairy detector because theres no scientific reason to think they may exist in the first place.

With SETI however, there are very good reasons to think that intelligent beings exist on other planets and even that we maybe able to detect them. There are also other scientific reasons why that may not be the case. So the scientific investigation for SETI starts from the basis of our relatively new knowlege of the universe, how stars and planets are formed, how old the universe is, the fact that biological evolution exists etc. All science.

Well, pretty much yes. The ongoing discovery of so many exoplanets adds further weight.
 
Hi JiT

Just for my two cents worth I've read some of this thread and from my viewpoint JiT, your flogging a dead horse on this one. I'm afraid you lost the argument several times about 40 or so pages ago. Carl Sagan it could have worked out could have been a bit of a nut when it comes to SETI. But after all the evidence is in, looks like he wasnt at all, which if you look at everything else he has done and said isnt really a big surprise. The facts just dont support your assertions.



Scientists generally dont just make some isolated assertions and then go and test it. Like, "I think Fairies exist at the bottom of my Garden, so I'm going to spend three years camping out with cameras to prove my theory". There's usually some observable natural phenomenon that requires an explanation or some maths or physics that is making a prediction that is then pursued with scientific endeavour. The question of the existence of God never arose from a scientific predicate in the first place. Only the question of why humans believe in a god or gods in the first place. Thats a scientific question.

To check the fairy story you would probably start off by researching the history of Fairy stories to see when they were first introduced into popular fiction. You wouldn't start by trying to figure out how to build a fairy detector because theres no scientific reason to think they may exist in the first place.

With SETI however, there are very good reasons to think that intelligent beings exist on other planets and even that we maybe able to detect them. There are also other scientific reasons why that may not be the case. So the scientific investigation for SETI starts from the basis of our relatively new knowlege of the universe, how stars and planets are formed, how old the universe is, the fact that biological evolution exists etc. All science.
Where is the evidence? After 50 years of searching not a single alien microbe or even a living spore has been found when the universe should be humming with extraterrestrial intelligent life and advanced civilizations according to Carl Sagan.

Where are they? A question asked in 1950 by Enrico Fermi, physicist, of his colleagues a question that would become famous. So why haven't they come to Earth? This is known as the Fermi paradox.

Despite the enveloping nebula of uncertainties, extraterrestrial life has become an increasingly exciting area of scientific inquiry. The field is called exobiology or astrobiology or bioastronomy—every few years it seems as though the name has been changed to protect the ignorant.

What is said about the Drake Equation the statistical probability of finding extraterrestrial intelligent life.

"I thought it was just a gimmick. It's amazing to me now that it's in the astronomy textbooks,"

"The Drake equation is a wonderful way to organize our ignorance."
 
So why haven't they come to Earth?


"Space is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist's, but that's just peanuts to space, listen..." - Douglas Adams.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom