Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

I saw a documentary that said Einstein's father died thinking his son was a failure.
That's not convincing. Who knows what you actually saw when you came to that conclusion. You get your facts wrong constantly. That's not going to help you convince anyone around here.
 
That's not convincing. Who knows what you actually saw when you came to that conclusion. You get your facts wrong constantly. That's not going to help you convince anyone around here.

I got facts wrong according to you...

The problem is you all are focused on the wrong facts anyway. You can't see the forest for the trees. That's by design.
 
If Einstein was mainstream then why couldn't others do what he did? Why was he such a superstar in his era?

I don't think it was just intelligence that set him apart. He set himself apart - that was the difference.

As RC said, others WERE doing what he was doing, he was just the first to get things published in a mainstream journal.

As for his 'super star' status, that came much later. And those in mainstream science do remember the others like Bohr, Bose, Feynman, Fermi, Pauli etc etc.
But since people find a cooperative narrative harder to relate to than a single person, those not understanding how science works tend to focus on a single person.

As for his teaching job, I've known many brilliant chemists who were/are awful teachers. And noone gets anywhere in science without publishing, which shows exactly what you are capable of. Saying you are brilliant without something to show for it doesn't cut it.
 
If it was orthodox then why didn't anyone see him coming?

WTF are you thinking? He was recognized when he did something recognizable. Are you seriously suggesting he can't be "orthodox" unless some clairvoyant prophesied his coming? Seriously, what are you expecting??
 
A mainstream path for your average student?.
You misquote me: The word average does not appear in my post, Nor does the word student.
Is your point is that there were time machines in1900 :p?
12 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Who in 1900 knew that Einstein would publish 4 "revolutionary" papers in 1905 and so should be given a teaching position?

Einstein followed a typical mainstream path - university + graduation + look for job. This is not a "mainstream path" fantasy that every graduate from university automatically gets an academic position. It is the real world of 1900 where graduates compete in a job market.
Graduates from universities go looking for a job because they want to eat, etc. :jaw-dropp!
One graduate in 1900 went looking for a teaching job maybe because they had a Zürich Polytechnic teaching diploma. They did not have a published thesis until 1905. They had 2 published papers on capillary action which were wrong (Einstein characterizes these two papers as "worthless" in 1907.[24])! They did not find a teaching post. They ended up n a patent office. Followed by 3 studies on thermodynamics of which only 1 seems to have anything new.
 
WTF are you thinking? He was recognized when he did something recognizable. Are you seriously suggesting he can't be "orthodox" unless some clairvoyant prophesied his coming? Seriously, what are you expecting??

I expect him to get a decent job out of college.. or do well enough in college that his father didn't die thinking he was a failure...

Do you guys know that many people, including Temple Grandin(has autism and is an expert on autism), believe Einstein likely had autism?
 
Are you saying I didn't see this in a documentary?

Just because you couldn't find this info after a random search you don't think it is valid?

That says a lot about your thinking process to me.
Sure. You can see Ancient Aliens in documentaries too.

Do you seriously think that one spends years in university studying science and automatically get a job?

Are you really proposing such a naive idea? Seriously, it doesn't work that way. Most of the science grads I knew flipped burgers for a few years and ultimately ended up in unrelated jobs. "Science" is not the vague monolith you imagine, it is a cut-throat pit of extreme darwinism.

When I graduated, my first job was teaching. Why? It was the first paying job that came along and I had to fight the competition to get it.
 
Last edited:
I expect him to get a decent job out of college..

He did for crying out loud. Patent inspector at his level is a great job for someone his age.

or do well enough in college that his
father didn't die thinking he was a failure...
And so far that is just your delusional thinking at work. In the real world Albert's father died when his son was about 22 and there was simply no way to judge Albert a failure at that age.
 
Most of the science grads I knew flipped burgers for a few years and ultimately ended up in unrelated jobs. "Science" is not the vague monolith you imagine, it is a cut-throat pit of extreme darwinism.

We are talking about Einstein here... and this wasn't in this era where everyone goes to college with an immense population.
 
In any race, someone has to come in first.

Most races, the winner just has to be faster, or start earlier.

You're the one saying that the winner must be magic.

I am saying that if Einstein didn't shine in school then something is wrong with school.

I think the problem is that schools cater to the mainstream. Not someone like Einstein.
 
I think that is accurate. If you are in the system it's difficult to see out of it.

Leonardo da Vinci was not part of the mainstream. He was an illegitimate child and couldn't be part of the mainstream. Yet he became the greatest thinker of them all IMO.

Leo? The greatest thinker of them all?

He didn't solve gravity. He didn't solve general purpose computation. He didn't solve relativity. He didn't discover germ theory or evolution. He didn't even discover basic surgical sanitation.

He was an inspired artist and a half-assed inventor. This is your greatest thinker? Clearly you have no idea what great thinking actually looks like in the real world.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom