Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Graduated and published at 21 years old, PhD and multiple publications at 25, faculty at 29. What the hell are you expecting, recognition at 5 based on midichlorian count?

We are talking about Einstein here.. one of the greatest thinkers in human history... and he couldn't get a teaching job.

Really? You can't see where I am coming from here? Something is wrong.
 
We are talking about Einstein here.. one of the greatest thinkers in human history... and he couldn't get a teaching job.
We are talking about a newly graduated Einstein who was unknown, had a new teaching diploma and could not get a teaching job :jaw-dropp!
His first paper was a minor paper on capillary action in 1900. Then nothing until 1905.
 
Last edited:
SkepticalTheorist: Who in 1900 knew that Einstein would publish 4 papers in 1905

If you were a ground breaking theoretical physicist...
You need to learn about a guy called Albert Einstein who became a "revolutionary physicist" 5 years after he failed to get a teaching job. I will emphasize this with a simple question:
12 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Who in 1900 knew that Einstein would publish 4 "revolutionary" papers in 1905 and so should be given a teaching position?
 
Last edited:
You need to learn about a guy called Albert Einstein who became a "revolutionary physicist" 5 years after he failed to get a teaching job. I will emphasize this with a simple question:
12 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Who in 1900 knew that Einstein would publish 4 "revolutionary" papers in 1905 and so should be given a teaching position?

You are making my point for me.. no one knew. That's the point! I don't think Einstein would have been as successful as he was if he followed the mainstream path.

If the mainstream path doesn't lead to success then what does that tell you about the mainstream path?
 
Last edited:
I saw a documentary that said Einstein's father died thinking his son was a failure.
12 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Who in 1900 knew that Einstein would publish 4 "revolutionary" papers in 1905 and so should be given a teaching position?

Hermann Einstein (30 August 1847 – 10 October 1902) was the father of Albert Einstein died 3 years before Albert's 1905 papers. He wanted Albert to pursue a career in his business of electrical engineering. No mention of any disappointment that Albert did not.
 
You are making my point for me..
Is your point is that there were time machines in1900 :p?
12 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Who in 1900 knew that Einstein would publish 4 "revolutionary" papers in 1905 and so should be given a teaching position?

Einstein followed a typical mainstream path - university + graduation + look for job. This is not a "mainstream path" fantasy that every graduate from university automatically gets an academic position. It is the real world of 1900 where graduates compete in a job market.
 
Last edited:
12 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Who in 1900 knew that Einstein would publish 4 "revolutionary" papers in 1905 and so should be given a teaching position?

Hermann Einstein (30 August 1847 – 10 October 1902) was the father of Albert Einstein died 3 years before Albert's 1905 papers. He wanted Albert to pursue a career in his business of electrical engineering. No mention of any disappointment that Albert did not.

Are you saying I didn't see this in a documentary?

Just because you couldn't find this info after a random search you don't think it is valid?

That says a lot about your thinking process to me.
 
Is your point is that there were time machines in1900 :p?
12 June 2017 SkepticalTheorist: Who in 1900 knew that Einstein would publish 4 "revolutionary" papers in 1905 and so should be given a teaching position?

Einstein followed a typical mainstream path - university + graduation + look for job. This is not a "mainstream path" fantasy that every graduate from university automatically gets an academic position. It is the real world of 1900 where graduates compete in a job market.

A mainstream path for your average student? You sure don't expect much from schools or science.
 
Am I the only one who has no idea what "mainstream" is being used to mean in this thread?

Einstein, for example, built on the work of Newton, Maxwell, and Michelson and Morley, just to name a few, to come up with Special Relativity. The pieces were all there; his brilliance was to connect them in a counter-intuitive way.

Sounds mainstream to me.
 
Am I the only one who has no idea what "mainstream" is being used to mean in this thread?

Einstein, for example, built on the work of Newton, Maxwell, and Michelson and Morley, just to name a few, to come up with Special Relativity. The pieces were all there; his brilliance was to connect them in a counter-intuitive way.

Sounds mainstream to me.

If Einstein was mainstream then why couldn't others do what he did? Why was he such a superstar in his era?

I don't think it was just intelligence that set him apart. He set himself apart - that was the difference.
 
Last edited:
If Einstein was mainstream then why couldn't others do what he did? Why was the such a superstar in his era?

I don't think it was just intelligence that set him apart. He set himself apart - that was the difference.


My implicit question was, "What, exactly, do you mean by 'mainstream'?" Mind addressing it rather than sidestepping it? Only then would addressing your question back to me make any sense.
 
My implicit question was, "What, exactly, do you mean by 'mainstream'?" Mind addressing it rather than sidestepping it? Only then would addressing your question back to me make any sense.

Mainstream means jumping through hoops. It means not questioning the status quo. It means following the conventional path.

If Einstein had been conventional I think he would have "played the game".

He would have been a scholastic superstar destined for success.

Take Bill Gates. He was a college dropout. Is that the conventional path to success? Is that mainstream? I don't think so. Mainstream would mean positioning yourself for surefire success. The safe path someone interested in conventional success would take.

If Einstein had taken the conventional/mainstream path with his brilliance others would have seen his success coming.
 
This seems to boil down to: No one mainstream advances science. Einstein advanced science. Therefore Einstein wasn't mainstream.

I think that is accurate. If you are in the system it's difficult to see out of it.

Leonardo da Vinci was not part of the mainstream. He was an illegitimate child and couldn't be part of the mainstream. Yet he became the greatest thinker of them all IMO.
 
We are talking about Einstein here.. one of the greatest thinkers in human history... and he couldn't get a teaching job.

Really? You can't see where I am coming from here? Something is wrong.
What's wrong is that you can't figure out that Einstein got a "teaching job". A great one. At a young age.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom