Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

It wasn't "most of Einstein's work" and see that's the problem. If "everyone is trying to be like Einstein and come up with these ideas that seem to be as weird as Einstein's" then they've got it all wrong. Einstein utilized and relied on the work of others both previous and current. Planck, De Broglie, Galileo and Maxwell just to name a few off the top of my head. Heck, it was even Minkowski not Einstein who first came up with the concept of space-time.

To me it's not just what you take or what you use it's how you use it. A chef doesn't have to create all his ingredients to get credit for making the perfect dish. It's how he uses them.. In an era when things are so complex that seems to be the only way to come up with ground breaking discoveries. (I believe this is the major problem with science and society today - that we are too specialized. This may be what allowed Einstein to be so successful because he could survey everything from afar rather than missing the forest for the trees like most people who are so caught up in their little corner of the scientific world.

If you want to be successful in science today you can't be a jack of all trades. You have to specialize. It's very risky to not specialize. You won't get conventional success if you don't follow the conventional path. If you don't follow the conventional path and don't get conventional success then like Mills few will take you seriously.
 
To me it's not just what you take or what you use it's how you use it. A chef doesn't have to create all his ingredients to get credit for making the perfect dish. It's how he uses them.. In an era when things are so complex that seems to be the only way to come up with ground breaking discoveries. (I believe this is the major problem with science and society today - that we are too specialized. This may be what allowed Einstein to be so successful because he could survey everything from afar rather than missing the forest for the trees like most people who are so caught up in their little corner of the scientific world.

Great so a lot of the work wasn't Einstein's. Ever consider that all this work having already been done that there are a lot fewer areas open to just general advancement thus requiring a certain degree of not only specialization but connected coordination just to advance further?


If you want to be successful in science today you can't be a jack of all trades. You have to specialize. It's very risky to not specialize. You won't get conventional success if you don't follow the conventional path. If you don't follow the conventional path and don't get conventional success then like Mills few will take you seriously.

Well, "few will take you seriously" if you just spout nonsense even if you enjoyed "conventional success". Just look at Linus Pauling.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linus_Pauling

If Mills could perhaps take himself seriously first then others might be inclined to do likewise.
 
Without people like us there would be no Einsteins Wright brothers.. do you really want a world like that?
Oh You were there in 1906, is that your claim? Airflight is simply down to you?

You seem to be stereotyping again.
Why not? You are making claims out of whole cloth, everyone else has evidence. How do you explain that?

Those people sound like skeptics... funny you would have a problem with that being a skeptic. How can you know all those people are wrong?
Wow. How do know they are right?

Again, I think it's very telling you lump all these people into one group. It's almost as if your brand of skepticism is a religion in itself...
Cranks have a pattern every time. You seem to think your claims are new. They are not.

More stereotyping and condescension.. You assume you can't be wrong.. that people shouldn't even question the things you present.
Wrong. If you have a claim, it is your job to demonstrate that you are correct. So far, you have tried to demonstrate that everyone else is wrong.

Suppose that is true for a moment. Everybody else is wrong.

You still have not made any effort to demonstrate that you are right.

It still doesn't explain how a scam could avoid being outed by people like yourself. The legal system must be completely broken to allow people to be bilked out of millions of dollars and no one can do anything about it. If the legal system can be so broken in modern society why can't the scientific establishment be just as broken? And that's the reality.. people know it's all broken. And you are blaming them for pointing out the elephant in the room.
No. I am pointing out your failure. However. on this site we are constrained to be within the MA of this site. You do not want to hear what I really think of mills. You dont want a PM from me either.

If you want to defend Mills nonsense go right ahead. You have yet to do it.

From first principles, prove that a hydrino lower state exists. You can't do it. Even Mills can't do it. Mills promised to hand out samples for testing, and then those vanished without without trace.

Why is that?
 
The credulous non-scientist sees Mills as an elevated, inspired outsider.

The scientific literate sees Mills as at best an incompetent operating outside his area of expertise, and at worst a cynical scammer.

The problem is that the scientific literate are brainwashed. And they have too much to lose to go against the mainstream. Look at Pons and Fleischmann.
 
The problem is that the scientific literate are brainwashed. And they have too much to lose to go against the mainstream. Look at Pons and Fleischmann.
May I ask, how many scientists do you know, personally?

It's been said, here, many times before, that most if not nearly all physicists and chemists would leap at the chance to have their names associated with a revolution as dramatic as what Mills' claims imply. Not to mention hundreds of "dark actors" who'd devote lots of resources into weaponizing hydrinos (in secret).

Clearly, neither has happened, despite the ideas being out in the open for several decades.

Why not?

One reason - yours? - involves a conspiracy to suppress the truth.

Another, posited by many here, is that there are no hydrinos, that it's just a long-running scam.

Curiously, or not, none of those who have posted here subscribing to the former reason seem to have any significant contact with real scientists. OTOH, the "scam subscribers" seem to include real scientists, and those very familiar with how science works.

An odd dichotomy, wouldn't you say?
 
The problem is that the scientific literate are brainwashed.
The whole point of the scientific method is that any scientist can replicate any other scientist's work. Hard to brainwash someone when they can check what you say for themselves, and pride themselves on doing so. The motto of The Royal Society, the original scientific academy, is "Take nobody's word for it".

And they have too much to lose to go against the mainstream.
Those who go against the mainstream and prove themselves right usually gain a Nobel prize and a place in the history books.

Look at Pons and Fleischmann.
An excellent example. An intriguing possibility, thoroughly and fairly investigated, shown to be unfounded.
 
May I ask, how many scientists do you know, personally?

This is irrelevant. Scientists are humans. They are as susceptible as anyone to brainwashing. Maybe even more so because they have so much at stake and it is so easy to have your career destroyed by going against the mainstream.
 
This is irrelevant. Scientists are humans. They are as susceptible as anyone to brainwashing. Maybe even more so because they have so much at stake and it is so easy to have your career destroyed by going against the mainstream.

Nothing could be further from the truth. The scientific method is the very antithesis of brainwashing, and going against the mainstream will not destroy anyone's career as long as they adhere to the scientific method whilst doing so.

One of my favourite scientists was Fred Hoyle, who went against the mainstream on many occasions and was frequently wrong (he was the main proponent of the Steady State Theory, and continued to argue for it even after the discovery of the cosmic microwave background pretty much proved the competing Big Bang Theory). He was greatly admired throughout the scientific community.
 
Last edited:
This is irrelevant. Scientists are humans. They are as susceptible as anyone to brainwashing. Maybe even more so because they have so much at stake and it is so easy to have your career destroyed by going against the mainstream.
Fair enough.

Let me see if I understand ... Mills fans are human. They are as susceptible as anyone to brainwashing. Maybe even more so because they have so much at stake and it is so easy to have your credibility (and investment) destroyed by going against Mills.

Not perfect, but with a few tweaks the logic could be made to be exactly the same, couldn't it?

How to break out then? I have an idea ... look at the objective evidence, ask about independent verifiability, that sort of thing ... :)
 
Nothing could be further from the truth. The scientific method is the very antithesis of brainwashing, and going against the mainstream will not destroy anyone's career as long as they adhere to the scientific method whilst doing so.

I know of someone who was fired just for publicly pursuing something that was deemed politically incorrect. This refutes your claim.
 
Fair enough.

Let me see if I understand ... Mills fans are human. They are as susceptible as anyone to brainwashing. Maybe even more so because they have so much at stake and it is so easy to have your credibility (and investment) destroyed by going against Mills.

Not perfect, but with a few tweaks the logic could be made to be exactly the same, couldn't it?

How to break out then? I have an idea ... look at the objective evidence, ask about independent verifiability, that sort of thing ... :)

I never said we weren't susceptible to brainwashing.. believe it or not but I am someone who is very skeptical about things myself. A lot of my views on things were totally turned upside down. This Mills saga played into that. Things I learned from watching debates like this and people's psychology.

So I was brainwashed. I may still be brainwashed about a lot of things. It is my view that if you and other critics here weren't so brainwashed you would realize how all the arguments you hold onto so dearly aren't built on anything solid.
 
I know of someone who was fired just for publicly pursuing something that was deemed politically incorrect. This refutes your claim.
Even if that is true - and it does sometimes happen - it is because the scientific method is being corrupted in the service of a political agenda, and it is easily identified by outside observers. There is no reason to think this is happening in the case of Mills, his work simply does not stand up to the slightest scrutiny by anyone with the knowledge to assess it, regardless of any agenda they might have (and most would have considerably incentive to jump on board if there was anything to it).
 
I could show you who the person is but I don't want to open that can of worms.



I just thought of another example in that can of worms.


Yes. Vague claims of unspecified evidence are TOTALLY going to convince us that the theories that guided the development of the semiconductors in the very computers we're using to communicate are bunk, and a guy who has spent close to 30 years producing NOTHING but easily doctored crap is the real deal.
 
I'm still mystified as to why anyone would brainwash anyone into doubting Mills' claims if they were true. There can't be many people who wouldn't think it was totally awesome, and want to jump straight on the bandwagon.

Why did mainstream science crucify Pons and Fleischmann and then later their work was shown to be legitimate?

Why would they jump to such a premature conclusion when something was so incredibly important? And at that time they even accused P&F of jumping to a conclusion when they themselves jumped to a conclusion immediately that was later proven wrong.
 
Last edited:
Why did mainstream science crucify Pons and Fleischmann and then later their work was shown to be legitimate?
.
Shown to be legitimate? This is not a claim that aligns with reality.

ETA. Because it wasn't legitimate?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom