Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

My memory may be a bit foggy but didn't the military test LENR and say it was legit? And yet where is all the funding pursuing something so important?
No, it's not legit. Wasn't then, isn't now. The funding isn't there because, like Mills, there's nothing there.
 
Why did mainstream science crucify Pons and Fleischmann and then later their work was shown to be legitimate?
That is an irrelevant fantasy, SkepticalTheorist.
Mainstream science found that it was consistently impossible to replicate the Pons and Fleischmann experiment which is a fundamental part of experimental science. Cold fusion
On 1 May 1989 the American Physical Society held a session on cold fusion in Baltimore, including many reports of experiments that failed to produce evidence of cold fusion. At the end of the session, eight of the nine leading speakers stated that they considered the initial Fleischmann and Pons claim dead, with the ninth, Johann Rafelski, abstaining.[6] Steven E. Koonin of Caltech called the Utah report a result of "the incompetence and delusion of Pons and Fleischmann," which was met with a standing ovation.[51] Douglas R. O. Morrison, a physicist representing CERN, was the first to call the episode an example of pathological science.[6][52]
...
Reproducibility
...
Groups that did report successes found that some of their cells were producing the effect, while other cells that were built exactly the same and used the same materials were not producing the effect.[143] Researchers that continued to work on the topic have claimed that over the years many successful replications have been made, but still have problems getting reliable replications.[144] Reproducibility is one of the main principles of the scientific method, and its lack led most physicists to believe that the few positive reports could be attributed to experimental error.[143][text 9]
Pons and Fleischmann-type cold fusion was essentially abandoned by mainstream as a waste of time by the late 1990's - even by Pons. What is left are a handful of research groups getting the same dubious results and publishing in obscure or their own journal.

Water-fueled cars are extremely important - let us just forget that they are physically impossible and spend billions producing them :p!
The situation with cold fusion is similar but not as bad. For example, it is impossible for the pressures in the materials to overcame the repulsion between atoms to produce fusion at the rates to explain the anomalous heat that the researchers sometimes detect.
 
Last edited:
Actually I would disagree with that. No one has convinced me Einstein was a part of mainstream science when he made his discoveries which are most responsible for the technology we have today. If Einstein had forced himself to conform to mainstream science I highly highly doubt he would have ever achieved what he did. And that shows how flawed mainstream thinking is.
Haha no.

Einstein graduated in mainstream physics from a mainstream school. Then he got a job in a patent office, subjecting patent applications to the judgement of mainstream physics.

I bet you thought he was a patent clerk or something, right? Like, he couldn't even get a job doing physics? Wrong. Einstein's job at the patent office was Literally Mainstream Physics.

And while he was doing mainstream physics at work, he was also pursuing his postgraduate studies in mainstream physics, at another mainstream school, under the supervision of another mainstream physicist. It was as a part of these studies that he stayed informed of the latest developments in the field of mainstream physics.

It was from this position, as a mainstream physics insider, doing mainstream physics in his day job, and studying mainstream physics, that he achieved the major breakthroughs of his early career. And he did it by mastering and then extending the field of mainstream physics.
 
This is 2017, not 2009 :eye-poppi. That is yet another outdated and not replicated claim of neutrons from cold fusion in a conference paper. This was published by United States Navy researchers at the Space and Naval Warfare Systems Center in Naturwissenschaften - a German journal "covering all aspects of the natural sciences relating to questions of biological significance" :eek:!

ETA: You really need to learn how extremely irrelevant cold fusion is to this thread about BLP's claims. BLP are not claiming any kind of fusion or nuclear reactions. The delusion is that there are states below the ground state of all elements (e.g. hydrogen) + there are "catalysts" that allow an electron to fall into those imaginary states. That is chemistry, not nuclear physics.
 
Last edited:
Haha no.

Einstein graduated in mainstream physics from a mainstream school. Then he got a job in a patent office, subjecting patent applications to the judgement of mainstream physics.

I bet you thought he was a patent clerk or something, right? Like, he couldn't even get a job doing physics? Wrong. Einstein's job at the patent office was Literally Mainstream Physics.

And while he was doing mainstream physics at work, he was also pursuing his postgraduate studies in mainstream physics, at another mainstream school, under the supervision of another mainstream physicist. It was as a part of these studies that he stayed informed of the latest developments in the field of mainstream physics.

It was from this position, as a mainstream physics insider, doing mainstream physics in his day job, and studying mainstream physics, that he achieved the major breakthroughs of his early career. And he did it by mastering and then extending the field of mainstream physics.


This is a strawman argument. Saying Einstein was a student and worked at a patent office, even if it was associated with physics, does nothing to show that mainstream science recognized his ability before he proved it.

This is typical skeptic spin to try to ignore the reality of mainstream sciences problems.
 
This is a strawman argument. Saying Einstein was a student and worked at a patent office, even if it was associated with physics, does nothing to show that mainstream science recognized his ability before he proved it.

This is typical skeptic spin to try to ignore the reality of mainstream sciences problems.

Hmmm... Move the goal posts much? You were insisting Einstein was operating outside the mainstream. Now you appear to accept his working within or based upon mainstream lines of thought. But now you're suggesting that because the mainstream was not clairvoyant in recognizing Einstein's genius *before* demonstrating such proves mainstream science's incompetence.

Did I read that correctly?
 
Hmmm... Move the goal posts much? You were insisting Einstein was operating outside the mainstream. Now you appear to accept his working within or based upon mainstream lines of thought. But now you're suggesting that because the mainstream was not clairvoyant in recognizing Einstein's genius *before* demonstrating such proves mainstream science's incompetence.

Did I read that correctly?

Was it mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?

That's like saying Will Hunting was mainstream because he was a Janitor at MIT and did calculations in his spare time...

That you would call that moving the goal post is ridiculous to me. What did other people working with Einstein at the patent office achieve? Were they world class scientists?

Was working at the patent office considered a prestigious post and Einstein was on his path to mainstream scientific success? What was stated in that post does nothing to refute what I originally said. It simply puts a more positive spin on his representation than the straw man he created.
 
Was it mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?

That's like saying Will Hunting was mainstream because he was a Janitor at MIT and did calculations in his spare time...

That you would call that moving the goal post is ridiculous to me. What did other people working with Einstein at the patent office achieve? Were they world class scientists?

Was working at the patent office considered a prestigious post and Einstein was on his path to mainstream scientific success? What was stated in that post does nothing to refute what I originally said. It simply puts a more positive spin on his representation than the straw man he created.
You never heard of Bohr, Pauli, Schrodinger, Planck et al. None of those? Never heard of them? Really?
 
This is a strawman argument. Saying Einstein was a student and worked at a patent office, even if it was associated with physics, does nothing to show that mainstream science recognized his ability before he proved it.
Haha no.

Einstein had already graduated with a physics degree when he started work at the patent office. His job at the patent office was explicitly a recognition of his ability as a physicist--only a competent physicist could do the job.

His post-graduate studies in physics were another recognition of his ability as a pysicist--only someone who had completed their graduate studies could continue on to post-graduate work. Alfred Kleiner, Professor of Experimenal Physics at the University of Zurich, supervised his doctoral thesis during this period, further recognition of his ability as a physicist.

Albert Einstein was trained in the physics mainstream, proved himself in the physics mainstream, and continued on to master and ultimately extend the physics mainstream. Your attempt to paint him as an outsider to that field is ignorant and misguided.

This is typical skeptic spin to try to ignore the reality of mainstream sciences problems.
It's pretty obvious that you have no idea of the reality of mainstream science problems.
 
Albert Einstein was trained in the physics mainstream, proved himself in the physics mainstream, and continued on to master and ultimately extend the physics mainstream. Your attempt to paint him as an outsider to that field is ignorant and misguided.


It's pretty obvious that you have no idea of the reality of mainstream science problems.

Was Einstein taking the mainstream path of a world class theoretical physicist?

Again.. this is a lawyerly debate. Technically he was mainstream.. but was he mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?

Show me proof that Einstein was on the conventional path of a world class theoretical physicists. Unless you do that you aren't refuting the point I was making. You are refuting the point you imagine I made.
 
This is typical skeptic spin to try to ignore the reality of mainstream sciences problems.
Oh you aren't one of those skeptics who claims an entire form of media is irrelevant? Talk about Luddites. You are joking right? You can't be one of them...

Please explain to me why a video would be any less valid than any other form of communication? It's not like the videos aren't referencing documented events and actual scientists and factual history.

I posted an article as well and you ignored that too.. funny.. nothing is of value to the critics it seems. Accept journal articles which are controlled. How convenient....
So now you post evidence refuting your own stance and ignore that it refutes your own stance and act like it bolsters it?

And you wonder why I state critics here have closed minds. You don't want the truth. This is just a game to you.

Maybe the reason cold fusion hasn't developed is because the amount of funds directed to it is minimal? Compare that to mainstream projects that haven't developed anything of value and see how much they have been funded.
Was it mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?

That's like saying Will Hunting was mainstream because he was a Janitor at MIT and did calculations in his spare time...

That you would call that moving the goal post is ridiculous to me. What did other people working with Einstein at the patent office achieve? Were they world class scientists?

Was working at the patent office considered a prestigious post and Einstein was on his path to mainstream scientific success? What was stated in that post does nothing to refute what I originally said. It simply puts a more positive spin on his representation than the straw man he created.
How is that a derail? That has always been my stance.. I may have not mentioned it before but we just hadn't gotten into it. Just because I provide more info showing my stance doesn't mean I just made it up.

And just because journals post some things doesn't mean they aren't controlled.

They post some of Mills work too. But you don't know what is happening behind the scenes either just like what happened to Mills patents behind the scenes.
Was Einstein taking the mainstream path of a world class theoretical physicist?

Again.. this is a lawyerly debate. Technically he was mainstream.. but was he mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?

Show me proof that Einstein was on the conventional path of a world class theoretical physicists. Unless you do that you aren't refuting the point I was making. You are refuting the point you imagine I made.
NONE of this is germane to this thread about Mills and his scam.

It fools no one here with your constant attempts to fog the topic and deflect off of Mills.
 
Look at Einstein.. was he mainstream? Who predicted Einstein would revolutionize theoretical physics?
A bit late but:
Of course Einstein was mainstream. He learned his physics at the equivalent of a university. He published in mainstream journals on mainstream physics. His 1905 papers were:
  • On a Heuristic Viewpoint Concerning the Production and Transformation of Light
    Photoelectric effect
  • On the Motion of Small Particles Suspended in a Stationary Liquid, as Required by the Molecular Kinetic Theory of Heat.
    Brownian motion
  • On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies
    Special Relativity
  • Does the Inertia of a Body Depend Upon Its Energy Content?
    Matter–energy equivalence
The mainstream scientists who were also working on same topics as Einstein would predict that any of them could revolutionize theoretical physics.
For example, it is basically a publishing accident that Einstein published his SR paper first. Lorentz had been working on the same problem since 1892. About 1900 for Larmor and Cohn. Poincaré was involved since before 1900. This was all before Einstein graduated university.
Lorentz got close to SR.
On June 5, 1905, Henri Poincaré submitted the summary of a work which closed the existing gaps of Lorentz's work (the full paper was received July 23 1905 and published January 1906). Einstein's paper was received on June 30 1905 and published on September 26, 1905.
 
lence
[/LIST]
The mainstream scientists who were also working on same topics as Einstein would predict that any of them could revolutionize theoretical physics.
For example, it is basically a publishing accident that Einstein published his SR paper first. Lorentz had been working on the same problem since 1892.

Did any of those guys work in the patent office with Einstein?
 
Did any of those guys work in the patent office with Einstein?
No one would have the fantasy that scientists working on the same topics as Einstein had to work in the same patent office.
The situation is very simple . At the time as now, university graduates went looking for work appropriate to the degrees that they had earned. Some went into inappropriate jobs just to earn money. Some went into academia. Some went into business. Some into education. Some went into government. Albert Einstein had a teaching diploma, went looking for a teaching job and did not find one for almost 2 years. He then got the patent office job through a friend's father.

ETA: My personal experience when I graduated with a physics degree included looking at further post-graduate work in the USA and interviews with the weather office, army, banks, and a spy agency!
 
Last edited:
ETA: My personal experience when I graduated with a physics degree included looking at further post-graduate work in the USA and interviews with the weather office, army, banks, and a spy agency!

If you were a ground breaking theoretical physicist then I would say you weren't mainstream as well. I don't see how you can't see this... He couldn't even get a teaching job... yet you claim he was mainstream as a revolutionary physicist.
 
If you were a ground breaking theoretical physicist then I would say you weren't mainstream as well. I don't see how you can't see this... He couldn't even get a teaching job... yet you claim he was mainstream as a revolutionary physicist.
Einstein was on the faculty at the Universities of Bern and Zurich (and other prestigious titles).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom