Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

On the whole I think historically scientists have got the amount of evidence required before a new hypothesis is taken seriously about right. Yes, there have been a few cases where a correct one has taken a little longer to be accepted than seems necessary in hindsight, but that's a small price to pay for the time that would be wasted giving unwarranted credence to every crackpot indulging in unsupported speculation.

Indeed. I think in the cases that SG mentioned, we'll probably find that the people in question followed the scientific principle, and that their work was reproducible, and didn't rely on scientific impossibilities. With the exception of Wegener, who couldn't propose a mechanism for continental drift, IIRC.

Mills does have a mechanism - it is scientifically impossible. If it isn't, then there is a very easy way to show that it isn't. This does not include transparently fake "independent" reviews. Or 30 years of claiming success is just around the corner, whilst raking in as much moolah as possible to keep the scam going.
As for the EU loons; it is easy to see where their nonsense comes from - yet more scientifically impossible woo, based on the nutter Velikosky's unscientific ramblings, and/or a desire to hero worship long dead scientists, whose ideas have long since been shown to be wrong. They have never proposed anything that wouldn't take a competent physics undergrad a few minutes to disprove.

One thing which seems to tie all cranks together is Galileo syndrome - the evil mainstream are too blinkered/ biased/ corrupt to see my genius for what it is. This, to me, is a whole lot different than a mainstream, albeit possibly maverick, scientist using the scientific principle to eventually gain acceptance for an idea that doesn't violate some basic law of physics or other.
 
Then your understanding is wrong.
Einstein was mainstream and while of course noone could predict it was him of the various scientists working to solve a known problem, he was not considered a failure.
People did of course challenge his theories, but he managed to prove them by letting others look at every detail of his theory (unlike Mills), by adapting his theory when criticism turned out to be right (unlike Mills) and by having a sound mathematical and experimental basis which combined to a predictive model (unlike Mills).

As I and many others have pointed out. Mills claims a problem where there is none, his mathematics are wrong on a level any grad student can spot, and if he were right any chemistry involving Hydrogen would simply not work. Which would mean we would not exist.

I'm sorry to burst your bubble, but the persecuted loner who is hounded by the evil mainstream scientists for overturning their theories while being right all along is a myth belonging to comic books and movies. There are literally no examples in actual science.

I have to agree. When something is referred to as outside 'mainstream', it means they are operating outside the known principles of science, and are almost certainly in error. We make new discoveries all the time, but our understanding of science is actually quite good, and most new discoveries fall within the bounds of what we already understand. Once in a while, something weird will come along, such as Quantum Physics, but it is very rare.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom