Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

Want the script? Sure.

Somebody made a wild claim? Support it with evidence.

End.

So far, neither you nor Mills has done so. For 30 frakkin' years. All promise and no delivery. Like Steorn.

How long did Steorn go?

Have you ever considered the the Steorn situation is tainting your view?
 
How long did Steorn go?
Your google is broken? Years. I could look up how many, but so could you. You simply can't be bothered. Simply put, one of my customers had offices in the same facility as Steorn. In fact they were a mere 10 minute drive from my home. I followed along the entire saga with an inside track as an aside. I know a lot more about it than you.

Have you ever considered the the Steorn situation is tainting your view?
Have you ever considered that the Steorn debacle informed my view?
 
Well here we are on page 4, and so far there's been lots of asserting a position with vague posturing and mystical waving of hands, but a serious lack of evidence.

Indeed, there's been active avoidance of anything that might state an actual position and what, specifically it's based upon.

A cynic (not a skeptic) would observe that the thread is attempting to set up a big reveal along the lines of...

"I'm (allegedly) autistic and Einstein was (allegedly) autistic, so anything I say is amazing and I shouldn't have to explain myself, especially as you wouldn't understand it anyway. So, shut up and accept that what I say is true."

Just as well I'm not a cynic.
 
Mainstream means jumping through hoops. It means not questioning the status quo. It means following the conventional path.

Most curious definition you have there. It boils down to 'mainstream science' = 'not science'.

That is not very useful as definitions go. It is more just self-serving word-play so you can secret in equivocation to mask your argument.

If Einstein had been conventional I think he would have "played the game".

He would have been a scholastic superstar destined for success.

His success was a product of his intelligence. He used it to do very high-quality science, not this "not science" stuff you seem so focused on.

Take Bill Gates. He was a college dropout. Is that the conventional path to success? Is that mainstream? I don't think so. Mainstream would mean positioning yourself for surefire success. The safe path someone interested in conventional success would take.

Bill Gates is not a scientist. Is your argument dependent on this Gish Gallop?

If Einstein had taken the conventional/mainstream path with his brilliance others would have seen his success coming.

Now it's 'conventional/mainstream'? You continue to use words in ways with which I am unfamiliar. You also are engaging in a baseless deduction there.
 
Considering you all follow the same script there must be something like that.
The script is the scientific method. And yes, we all follow it. Because no serious progress was made understanding the world around us until it was invented, and then masses of progress was made very quickly. We stick with it because it works.
 
A cynic (not a skeptic) would observe that the thread is attempting to set up a big reveal along the lines of...

"I'm (allegedly) autistic and Einstein was (allegedly) autistic, so anything I say is amazing and I shouldn't have to explain myself, especially as you wouldn't understand it anyway. So, shut up and accept that what I say is true."

Just as well I'm not a cynic.

Have you ever heard this quote from Einstein -

"I am well aware that I have no special talent; curiosity, obsession and stubborn endurance, combined with self-criticism have brought me to my ideas"

Those traits he talks about are autistic traits. Not exclusively of course. But people on the autism spectrum get obsessed with things. To a level that I don't think many people can. For good reason because it allows them to function in society properly. So this trait is a blessing and a curse for autistic people.

Also, it's not just an obsession about one thing.. but it's constant obsessions. I feel this is what allows people with autism disorders to do things others can't. But that's not the only reason i feel I have discovered the things I have. But explaining that is the problem.
 
Last edited:
Back in the day, if you had a mental disorder it was considered a disability. Now that Einstein has one it's all the rage. I suppose that's progress of a sort.
 
Back in the day, if you had a mental disorder it was considered a disability. Now that Einstein has one it's all the rage. I suppose that's progress of a sort.

Don't you understand that everyone has deficits and strengths? With autism it's just more extreme. So we all have disabilities and exceptional abilities.
 
Was Einstein taking the mainstream path of a world class theoretical physicist?

Again.. this is a lawyerly debate. Technically he was mainstream.. but was he mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?

Show me proof that Einstein was on the conventional path of a world class theoretical physicists. Unless you do that you aren't refuting the point I was making. You are refuting the point you imagine I made.

I highly recommend you check out the book The Hunt for Vulcan: . . . And How Albert Einstein Destroyed a Planet, Discovered Relativity, and Deciphered the Universe. It's a fascinating look at not only the development of Newtonian physics but at Einstein's path to developing Special and General Relativity, all within the framework of examining a core problem Einstein solved that had stumped Newton, the orbit of Mercury.

One thing we learn is just how interconnected both men were with the mainstream scientists of their days. While Einstein is largely hailed as a revolutionary in popular culture, his real genius was more in finding ways to connect existing concepts into a cohesive whole. The basic principle of Relativity, for example, was fairly well known before Einstein published, but the lack of a robust framework for exploring it had kept it, not on the fringe, but neglected on the shelf.

When Einstein set out to develop general relativity, he took a lot of bits and pieces from other mainstream scientists. Even the core mathematics used to describe curved space-time in General Relativity was an existing non-Euclidian geometry system that was, at Einstein's prodding bolted on by the existing experts in the field. He'd had his friends scouring the published literature to find a suitable mathematical framework before one was recommended to him! In the beginning, curved space-time was a mathematical shortcut to avoid the vast tracts of mathematics needed to calculate General Relativity in Euclidian space.

In the well-researched book, we really get a good look at how Einstein's General Theory of Relativity grew out of mainstream physics more than anything else. He took bits and pieces of genius from others and, using his own genius, connected them. To an outsider, it looked like he'd created something new from scratch, when he had, in fact, merged the work of the day's geniuses in a way that they had not thought to do on their own.

Einstein was not an outsider or a maverick. He was a mainstream scientist doing mainstream work who was getting increasingly prestigious academic positions as he progressed.
 
Last edited:
Einstein was not an outsider or a maverick. He was a mainstream scientist doing mainstream work who was getting increasingly prestigious academic positions as he progressed.

As I have said I don't deny Einstein became mainstream. I just don't accept that that is how became successful.

Why can't Einstein using a more holistic approach than others of the time be considered non-mainstream?

Again, a revolutionary new chef isn't using food that others haven't. Like molecular gastronomy. But that doesn't mean it isn't outside the mainstream.
 
As I have said I don't deny Einstein became mainstream. I just don't accept that that is how became successful.

Why can't Einstein using a more holistic approach than others of the time be considered non-mainstream?

Again, a revolutionary new chef isn't using food that others haven't. Like molecular gastronomy. But that doesn't mean it isn't outside the mainstream.

Throw the word quantum in there a few times so people will know you're a serious poster
 
As I have said I don't deny Einstein became mainstream. I just don't accept that that is how became successful.

Why not? Again, I recommend the book The Hunt for Vulcan: . . . And How Albert Einstein Destroyed a Planet, Discovered Relativity, and Deciphered the Universe assuming, of course, you want to actually learn the specifics of how Einstein's career progressed as opposed to propping up a convenient mythology about him.

If Einstein was such an "outsider" why did his Special Relativity paper early in his career earn him a University job, which in turn ensured he got plenty of attention, assistance, and review as he progressed towards General relativity? The mythology of Einstein as an outsider simply is not supportable if you take an even cursory look at his career.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom