SkepticalTheorist
Critical Thinker
- Joined
- May 18, 2017
- Messages
- 418
There is no "skeptic FAQ". How could you not know that?
Considering you all follow the same script there must be something like that.
There is no "skeptic FAQ". How could you not know that?
Considering you all follow the same script there must be something like that.
Want the script? Sure.
Somebody made a wild claim? Support it with evidence.
End.
So far, neither you nor Mills has done so. For 30 frakkin' years. All promise and no delivery. Like Steorn.
Your google is broken? Years. I could look up how many, but so could you. You simply can't be bothered. Simply put, one of my customers had offices in the same facility as Steorn. In fact they were a mere 10 minute drive from my home. I followed along the entire saga with an inside track as an aside. I know a lot more about it than you.How long did Steorn go?
Have you ever considered that the Steorn debacle informed my view?Have you ever considered the the Steorn situation is tainting your view?
Mainstream means jumping through hoops. It means not questioning the status quo. It means following the conventional path.
If Einstein had been conventional I think he would have "played the game".
He would have been a scholastic superstar destined for success.
Take Bill Gates. He was a college dropout. Is that the conventional path to success? Is that mainstream? I don't think so. Mainstream would mean positioning yourself for surefire success. The safe path someone interested in conventional success would take.
If Einstein had taken the conventional/mainstream path with his brilliance others would have seen his success coming.
Look at Einstein.. was he mainstream?
The script is the scientific method. And yes, we all follow it. Because no serious progress was made understanding the world around us until it was invented, and then masses of progress was made very quickly. We stick with it because it works.Considering you all follow the same script there must be something like that.
I never said Einstein couldn't be wrong. I am just saying I trust Einstein much more than the mainstream.
Am I the only one who has no idea what "mainstream" is being used to mean in this thread?
A cynic (not a skeptic) would observe that the thread is attempting to set up a big reveal along the lines of...
"I'm (allegedly) autistic and Einstein was (allegedly) autistic, so anything I say is amazing and I shouldn't have to explain myself, especially as you wouldn't understand it anyway. So, shut up and accept that what I say is true."
Just as well I'm not a cynic.
Why do you say that?
Because I know how to read.
Back in the day, if you had a mental disorder it was considered a disability. Now that Einstein has one it's all the rage. I suppose that's progress of a sort.
Was Einstein taking the mainstream path of a world class theoretical physicist?
Again.. this is a lawyerly debate. Technically he was mainstream.. but was he mainstream for a revolutionary theoretical physicist?
Show me proof that Einstein was on the conventional path of a world class theoretical physicists. Unless you do that you aren't refuting the point I was making. You are refuting the point you imagine I made.
Einstein was not an outsider or a maverick. He was a mainstream scientist doing mainstream work who was getting increasingly prestigious academic positions as he progressed.
As I have said I don't deny Einstein became mainstream. I just don't accept that that is how became successful.
Why can't Einstein using a more holistic approach than others of the time be considered non-mainstream?
Again, a revolutionary new chef isn't using food that others haven't. Like molecular gastronomy. But that doesn't mean it isn't outside the mainstream.
As I have said I don't deny Einstein became mainstream. I just don't accept that that is how became successful.