Split Thread Mainstream vs. fringe science

SkepticalTheorist

Critical Thinker
Joined
May 18, 2017
Messages
418
Split from this thread.
Posted By: jsfisher


Hydrogen spectra and hydrogen plasma, as well as the hydrogen potential well, was something i studied, measured and was published at the lab i was. It is not where i ended but thus is where i started.

The fact you call it mainstream science rather than science, is very very revalatory btw.

Do you think cutting edge revolutionary science is done in the mainstream?

Look at Einstein.. was he mainstream? Who predicted Einstein would revolutionize theoretical physics? He was considered a failure from my understanding. This is a perfect example of how mainstream science is not cutting edge science.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Do you think cutting edge revolutionary science is done in the mainstream?

Look at Einstein.. was he mainstream? Who predicted Einstein would revolutionize theoretical physics? He was considered a failure from my understanding. This is a perfect example of how mainstream science is not cutting edge science.

Then your understanding is wrong.
Einstein was mainstream and while of course noone could predict it was him of the various scientists working to solve a known problem, he was not considered a failure.
People did of course challenge his theories, but he managed to prove them by letting others look at every detail of his theory (unlike Mills), by adapting his theory when criticism turned out to be right (unlike Mills) and by having a sound mathematical and experimental basis which combined to a predictive model (unlike Mills).

As I and many others have pointed out. Mills claims a problem where there is none, his mathematics are wrong on a level any grad student can spot, and if he were right any chemistry involving Hydrogen would simply not work. Which would mean we would not exist.

I'm sorry to burst your bubble, but the persecuted loner who is hounded by the evil mainstream scientists for overturning their theories while being right all along is a myth belonging to comic books and movies. There are literally no examples in actual science.
 
Do you think cutting edge revolutionary science is done in the mainstream?

Look at Einstein.. was he mainstream? Who predicted Einstein would revolutionize theoretical physics? He was considered a failure from my understanding. This is a perfect example of how mainstream science is not cutting edge science.

Yes he was mainstream science, used the way and avenue of the time to publish, and even proposed way to falsify his own hypothesis, and while he revolutionned physic, he was wrong on some points, and i contend that seeing at the way physic was evolving at the epoch, it was a question if time before somebody else was going this direction too.

There is simply no comparison between einstein and mills.

And for one einstein there are many hundreds of schrödinger, gibbs, pasteur, and so forth.
 
Correct me if I am wrong but are there people from Steorn involved with Brilliant Light Power? If not then it's stereotyping to lump them together, no? That's not scientific.
Mills gets lumped in with Steorn because their MO is exactly the same.

And the only reason you are able to post here is "mainstream" science.
 
Mills gets lumped in with Steorn because their MO is exactly the same.

And the only reason you are able to post here is "mainstream" science.

Actually I would disagree with that. No one has convinced me Einstein was a part of mainstream science when he made his discoveries which are most responsible for the technology we have today. If Einstein had forced himself to conform to mainstream science I highly highly doubt he would have ever achieved what he did. And that shows how flawed mainstream thinking is.

I feel the same about the Wright brothers as well. Immense paradigm shifts don't come from the mainstream from what I have seen.
 
Actually I would disagree with that. No one has convinced me Einstein was a part of mainstream science when he made his discoveries which are most responsible for the technology we have today. If Einstein had forced himself to conform to mainstream science I highly highly doubt he would have ever achieved what he did. And that shows how flawed mainstream thinking is.
You are simply wrong. Have you any clue how many scientists were working on the very same problem at the time?

I feel the same about the Wright brothers as well. Immense paradigm shifts don't come from the mainstream from what I have seen.
Wrong again. The Wright brothers shifted no paradigms. None. Try reading up on the history of flight. They were preceded by at least 100 years of previous work.

And I wonder why this argument is strangely familiar?
 
You are simply wrong. Have you any clue how many scientists were working on the very same problem at the time?

Then why was Einstein the one responsible for so many incredible discoveries at that time? If what you were saying was remotely true he shouldn't have been the lone super star of his era. Not only that.. but then you have mainstream science quickly move us away from Einstein and throw us back into the dark ages where we currently remain...

Wrong again. The Wright brothers shifted no paradigms. None. Try reading up on the history of flight. They were preceded by at least 100 years of previous work.

From what I read their biggest competition - who was part of mainstream science and was considered much more of a safe bet to achieve what the Wright brothers did - had a completely different approach - more of a brute force approach.

Also, didn't the Wright's almost single handedly develop aeronautical engineering techniques still used to this day?
 
Last edited:
You are simply wrong. Have you any clue how many scientists were working on the very same problem at the time?

Then why was Einstein the one responsible for so many incredible discoveries at that time? If what you were saying was remotely true he shouldn't have been the lone super star of his era. Not only that.. but then you have mainstream science quickly move us away from Einstein and throw us back into the dark ages where we currently remain...
That isn't right, it isn't even wrong. (See if you can figure out the irony there)

Einstein was one of many working on the problem. One of them had to be first to figure it out. It happened to be Einstein. If you can't figure out happenstance, I can't help you.

"Mainstream" science has not moved us away from Einstein. Whatever makes you think that? Are you claiming GPS doesn't exist?

From what I read their biggest competition - who was part of mainstream science and was considered much more of a safe bet to achieve what the Wright brothers did - had a completely different approach - more of a brute force approach.

Also, didn't the Wright's almost single handedly develop aeronautical engineering techniques still used to this day?
Nope. Their genius lay in creating a synthesis of ideas that worked.
 
Einstein was one of many working on the problem. One of them had to be first to figure it out. It happened to be Einstein. If you can't figure out happenstance, I can't help you.

I don't see Einstein's work as a logical step that others were certain to achieve in the same era. I think it could have taken decades to reach the understanding he had at that time. And I think it was because Einstein wasn't constrained by working in mainstream science that allowed him to see the big picture.

"Mainstream" science has not moved us away from Einstein. Whatever makes you think that? Are you claiming GPS doesn't exist?

I'm talking about quantum mechanics. From what I know he was considered out of touch with the mainstream quantum movement that he thought was going down the wrong path.
 
I don't see Einstein's work as a logical step that others were certain to achieve in the same era. I think it could have taken decades to reach the understanding he had at that time. And I think it was because Einstein wasn't constrained by working in mainstream science that allowed him to see the big picture.



I'm talking about quantum mechanics. From what I know he was considered out of touch with the mainstream quantum movement that he thought was going down the wrong path.
You remain wrong. You seem to believe that Einstein was incapable of error. He wasn't.
 
I'm talking about quantum mechanics. From what I know he was considered out of touch with the mainstream quantum movement that he thought was going down the wrong path.
In 1905 Albert Einstein interpreted Planck's quantum hypothesis realistically and used it to explain the photoelectric effect, in which shining light on certain materials can eject electrons from the material. He won the 1921 Nobel Prize in Physics for this work.

So exactly how would this be considered fringe or out of touch? :confused:

And how exactly does this prove Mills correct when it is Mills basically claiming Einstein's work in Quantum Mechanics fundamentally wrong?:confused:

And how exactly is Mills supposed to overturn Einsteins work in quantum mechanics thus falsifying the photoelectric effect...yet build a new power generator including solar panels?:boggled::boggled:

You are completely boxed in by your own ignorance.:boxedin: Seems the reason you buy the Emperor's new clothes scam is that you really are susceptible to the fear of appearing unfit or intelligent!
 
Last edited:
I never said Einstein couldn't be wrong. I am just saying I trust Einstein much more than the mainstream.



And the point you're missing is that Einstein is the mainstream. Relativity is one of the major building blocks of the modern understanding of physics, and as has been pointed out, his work was also fundamental to establishing the reality of the quantization of energy, upon which Quantum Mechanics was built.

You'd be hard pressed to find a physicist who was/is more mainstream than Einstein.
 
Why can't mainstream science succeed for the same reason? Look back all through history.. the mainstream has always been incompetent in hindsight. Why does anyone think our modern era would be any different?


Incompetency "in hindsight" infers some current, well, competency.


Why is modern mainstream science exempt from this?



Society has always advanced in spite of being completely backwards in their thinking. It seems to simply be trial and error that allows us to advance.

The Scientific method is "trial and error".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method

Mainstream science having a completely inaccurate model of the universe is just the most glaring error. All these bizarre theories from quantum mechanics that never produce any real working technology such as quantum teleportation seem to be examples of this as well. Yet the people here seem to ignore this kind of thing from what I have seen. It doesn't make sense to me.

"never produce any real working technology"? Just look around you, find anything with microchips in it? They were produced using quantum mechanics. Heck, if you got a NOR flash drive just erase some data on it and you are using quantum tunneling.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flash_memory#NOR_flash
 
I never said Einstein couldn't be wrong. I am just saying I trust Einstein much more than the mainstream.

Einstein IS what you call "mainstream". Your problem is that you have a term in search of a viable definition. GPS works BECAUSE of relativity, not in spite of it. And where did relativity come from?
 
Einstein IS what you call "mainstream". Your problem is that you have a term in search of a viable definition. GPS works BECAUSE of relativity, not in spite of it. And where did relativity come from?

I don't deny most of Einstein's work is mainstream now - outside of quantum mechanics.

But I think that era when Einstein went from outsider to superstar they were desperate for new ideas. Now it's the opposite.. everyone is trying to be like Einstein and come up with these ideas that seem to be as weird as Einstein's were early on... but they don't have the ability Einstein did so it's just fantasy. And they won't let any other ideas that conflict with theirs enter the discussion. Like a religion.
 
Last edited:
I don't deny most of Einstein's work is mainstream now - outside of quantum mechanics.

But I think that era when Einstein went from outsider to superstar they were desperate for new ideas. Now it's the opposite.. everyone is trying to be like Einstein and come up with these ideas that seem to be as weird as Einstein's were early on... but they don't have the ability Einstein did so it's just fantasy. And they won't let any other ideas that conflict with theirs enter the discussion. Like a religion.

It wasn't "most of Einstein's work" and see that's the problem. If "everyone is trying to be like Einstein and come up with these ideas that seem to be as weird as Einstein's" then they've got it all wrong. Einstein utilized and relied on the work of others both previous and current. Planck, De Broglie, Galileo and Maxwell just to name a few off the top of my head. Heck, it was even Minkowski not Einstein who first came up with the concept of space-time.
 
I don't deny most of Einstein's work is mainstream now - outside of quantum mechanics.

But I think that era when Einstein went from outsider to superstar they were desperate for new ideas. Now it's the opposite.. everyone is trying to be like Einstein and come up with these ideas that seem to be as weird as Einstein's were early on... but they don't have the ability Einstein did so it's just fantasy. And they won't let any other ideas that conflict with theirs enter the discussion. Like a religion.



And here you display your ignorance of the history of relativity. Einstein wasn't some maverick outsider who wasn't allowed to play with the "Cool Kids" of science. His work built on earlier work just like every other scientist's work has. Heck, he was so "mainstream" even at that time that there are people out there who claim he didn't really do much at all, and just copied other's work. I don't personally agree with that assessment, but the fact that an argument can even be made along those lines tells you how mainstream it was.
 
Because people like you exist, and in far greater numbers than actual working scientists. That is, people who, despite the vast evidence of the benefits of mainstream science they see all around them, still persist in some fantasy that mainstream science is "all wrong", or "misguided", or "arrogant", or any other pejorative they might use as as excuse for their lack of understanding.

Without people like us there would be no Einsteins Wright brothers.. do you really want a world like that?

Seriously, these people are everywhere. Christians who refuse to accept evolution, or the age of the Earth.

You seem to be stereotyping again.

Climate change deniers who refuse to accept that the Earth is heating up. Moon landing deniers who refuse to accept that spaceflight is possible. Vaccine deniers who refuse to accept that vaccines have vastly reduced the incidence of many infectious diseases. Any number of magical medical believers that refuse to accept that modern medicine works far better than mumbo-jumbo. Free energy believers who refuse to accept the first law of thermodynamics.

Those people sound like skeptics... funny you would have a problem with that being a skeptic. How can you know all those people are wrong?

Scientists have been trying for decades to try to explain to these people why they are wrong, and yet, these people persist in laughing off the scientists and spending their money on all this crap.

Again, I think it's very telling you lump all these people into one group. It's almost as if your brand of skepticism is a religion in itself...

The question isn't why Mills hasn't been stopped yet; the question is, are people like you ever going to listen? Because that's really the only thing that will ever stop him. The minority of people who are scientists just aren't powerful enough to do it on their own.

More stereotyping and condescension.. You assume you can't be wrong.. that people shouldn't even question the things you present.

It still doesn't explain how a scam could avoid being outed by people like yourself. The legal system must be completely broken to allow people to be bilked out of millions of dollars and no one can do anything about it. If the legal system can be so broken in modern society why can't the scientific establishment be just as broken? And that's the reality.. people know it's all broken. And you are blaming them for pointing out the elephant in the room.
 
And here you display your ignorance of the history of relativity. Einstein wasn't some maverick outsider who wasn't allowed to play with the "Cool Kids" of science. His work built on earlier work just like every other scientist's work has. Heck, he was so "mainstream" even at that time that there are people out there who claim he didn't really do much at all, and just copied other's work. I don't personally agree with that assessment, but the fact that an argument can even be made along those lines tells you how mainstream it was.

This seems to be a straw man argument... I don't claim Einstein had to completely invent science to revolutionize it.

The Wright brothers copied birds... they used elements that were all around them put together in new ways. That doesn't mean that they didn't make incredible contributions. Interestingly it was their process of invention in both cases that may have been so innovative. The Wrights with their wind tunnel experiments and Einstein with his thought experiments.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom