Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

I don't really know how to respond to this. I don't think it addresses any of the things I said but I'm not sure. I recognize the words as English words but they're not put together in a way that makes sense in the English language. It's as if his keyboard vomited. Could somebody possibly translate that drivel into actual English and tell me if he was actually responding to my post that he quoted?

It will take a better man than I to translate that farrago of nonsense into English.
 
God conceptually made everything that is not God Himself out of His thoughts.

So, in concepts, he wills to create with his thought as the material and when He does not want to create He stops thinking about the thoughts which go to make the universe and everything in it.
Say this out loud and ask yourself if it sounds as stupid to you as it does to me. He closed his eyes really really hard and he wished it. Then when he wanted to stop making so much stuff, he opened his eyes.
So, in concepts, there was a point in the realm of existence when God had not created the universe and He was all alone, the whole realm of existence was He Himself.
Where did all this happen? Where did your god come from, and where did he get the physical materials to make the universe? I know you adamantly ignore questions which ask where your god came from, but I'd really like to know if you ever give it any thought, or if you just think it's all magical and not worth considering.

When God wills to not think about me and you, we will stop existing, or when he wills to stop thinking about us staying alive, we die.
This is childish thinking. I find it sad.

I already said that God as maker of the universe does not require faith.
Yes it does. You are positing a magical being that has properties much more complex than the universe, and saying that he magically poofed into existence out of ??? and was able to think physical things into existence. How does that not require a huge leap of faith?

But it is the teaching of Christianism that God's existence as the maker of everything that is not God Himself can be known and is known by reason.
The teaching is incorrect. It's a way for smug Christians to put themselves above non-Christians, because they've got the words in their magical little book that tell them that the proof for their god is so obvious that only a fool would deny it. And then the book doesn't provide any actual proof. "It's written on every man's heart." B.S. pure and simple. The evidence is not obvious and atheists don't have god-shaped holes in their heart. It's not about atheists not hearing or not seeing what seems so obvious to you. And all along, no evidence is presented. It wasn't presented to you, and you haven't presented any here.
 
I don't really know how to respond to this. I don't think it addresses any of the things I said but I'm not sure. I recognize the words as English words but they're not put together in a way that makes sense in the English language. It's as if his keyboard vomited. Could somebody possibly translate that drivel into actual English and tell me if he was actually responding to my post that he quoted?


I'll try. I took 6 credits in borderline personality Filipino narcisists at Queens College

You asked:


Isn't faith believing in something without any evidence? ... Aren't those who try to show evidence of God contradicting themselves by trying to prove their faith when they don't actually have any?


Gerry answered:


Well, you do have a limited acquaintance with the Christian God. I see you're familiar with the Christian concept of God.

He is fundamentally in relation to the universe maker of everything that is not God Himself. That concept is, at its heart, that God created the entire universe. Everything else flows from that.


The existence of God as in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, namely, maker of everything that is not God Himself, according to the Christian faith is accessible to human reason.The concept of God as creator is able to be logically deduced through pure reason./COLOR]

In the beginning God made heaven and earth. Gen. 1:1.

I believe in God... maker of heaven and earth. Apostles' Creed line one.
​
These Bible verses are evidence that God as creator is a central concept in Christianity.

That God made heaven and earth is in the Bible and in the Apostles Creed, but insofar as maker of heaven and earth is concerned which is the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith, and up to that point:

Christians don't need faith nor revelation to know that God, for it is the doctrine of Christianism that that God can be and is known by and to human reason. Despite the fact that we could turn to the Bible to supply all the proof we need that God created the universe, we don't have to. We can arrive at the same conclusion through pure reason.

Of course Christians also know God by faith and from revelation, but still man with his reason can and does know the existence of God in His fundamental relation to the universe as maker of everything that is not God Himself. Of course, faith and revelation are ways that some Christians might know God, but such a God is proven necessarily true by the application of pure reason.

​

You don't know that?

Please read up on reason and faith in Christianism from the established authorities of the Christian faith, not please not from atheists and non-Christians or ex-Christians.A literature review of christian theologians will support my statements.



Yrreg I sign my name funny, but it's not a joke. It's evidence that I feel that my ego is not fully integrated. Thus, I am driven to seek constant reassurance about my intelligence and beliefs.



It's simple, really. I can teach you by correspondence and you'll be speaking Gerry in no time.
 
Hey Gerry, ever heard of the Dark Ages?

That's where you're living right now, but in the midst of the era of technology and knowledge. Kinda sad, ain't it?
 
To make the thread simpler.

So, please don't bring in the matter of God being this or that, just keep to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, which is that He is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Yrreg

Not simple enough... please establish first which god you are talking about:

1 Catholicism
1.1 Catholic Church
1.2 Other churches
2 Orthodoxy
3 Protestantism
3.1 Pre-Lutheran Protestants
3.2 Lutheranism
3.3 Anglicanism
3.4 Reformed Churches
3.5 Presbyterianism
3.6 Congregationalist Churches
3.7 Anabaptists
3.8 Brethren
3.9 Methodists
3.10 Pietists and Holiness Churches
3.11 Baptists
3.12 Apostolic Churches – Irvingites
3.13 Pentecostalism
3.14 Charismatics
3.15 African Initiated Churches
3.16 United and uniting churches
3.17 Religious Society of Friends (Quakers)
3.18 Stone-Campbell Restoration Movement
3.19 Southcottites
3.20 Millerites and comparable groups
3.21 British-Israelism
3.22 Miscellaneous/Other
3.23 Christian Revival Church
4 Latter Day Saints
4.1 "Original" denomination
4.2 "Prairie Saint" denominations
4.3 Rocky Mountains denominations
4.4 Other denominations
5 Oriental Orthodoxy
6 Assyrian Church
7 Nontrinitarian groups
7.1 Oneness Pentecostalism
7.2 Unitarianism and Universalism
7.3 Bible Student groups
7.4 Swedenborgianism
7.5 Other non-Trinitarians
8 Messianic Judaism
9 Jewish Christians
10 Esoteric Christianity
11 New Thought
12 Syncretistic religions incorporating elements of Christianity

And that is just the more general classification. To keep solutions simple, please provide undeniable evidence that your particular flavor of Christian god is the "right one" and all the others are wrong. The we can discuss if this remaining God exists. (Which of course would mean nothing because we are only artificially ignoring all the non christian gods)
 
Genesis and Apostles' Creed are testimonies to reason's conclusion to the concept...

Yrreg, you can't on the one hand insist that we are discussing only god (maker of everything not god) who is the Xian god, from Genesis and the Apostles creed, while at the same time telling us we can't discuss the bible or Xianity.

It's hypocritical.

YOU brought Christianity and the bible and the creed into this. We are fully justified in asking you to justify the leap from "maker of everything" to the Xian god.


Genesis and Apostles' Creed in the present context are ancient plain human testimonies in written record to reason's conclusion to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, namely, that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Just orientate yourselves to concepts.

Keep in mind that I am not into arguing the existence of God, just into the informative drive to inculcate in atheists that the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Keep to the concept, prescind from going into existence.


And I am still waiting for people to present examples for evidence as for proof, people who gave some definitions of evidence and proof.

So that in the later thread on the existence of God I can guide myself on what is evidence and proof, as illustrated by examples from atheists who do claim to know what is evidence and what is proof in relation to the existence of things.



Yrreg
 
Well, you do have a limited acquaintance with the Christian God.

He is fundamentally in relation to the universe maker of everything that is not God Himself.

The existence of God as in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, namely, maker of everything that is not God Himself, according to the Christian faith is accessible to human reason.

In the beginning God made heaven and earth. Gen. 1:1.

I believe in God... maker of heaven and earth. Apostles' Creed line one.
​

That God made heaven and earth is in the Bible and in the Apostles Creed, but insofar as maker of heaven and earth is concerned which is the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith, and up to that point:

Christians don't need faith nor revelation to know that God, for it is the doctrine of Christianism that that God can be and is known by and to human reason.

Of course Christians also know God by faith and from revelation, but still man with his reason can and does know the existence of God in His fundamental relation to the universe as maker of everything that is not God Himself.

​

You don't know that?

Please read up on reason and faith in Christianism from the established authorities of the Christian faith, not please not from atheists and non-Christians or ex-Christians.



Yrreg


If you think this expresses the "fundamental concept" of the Christian God, then you have and extraordinarily limited acquaintance with the Christian God.
 
I already said that God as maker of the universe does not require faith.


Use the search function and look for Apostles' Creed, Gen. 1:1.


I looked at the text of the Apostle's Creed, but I stopped as soon as it contradicted your claim. This is how far I got: "Credo..."
 
Do you remember I used to tell you people about the Latin phrases "sensu aienti" and "sensu neganti"?*

"Sensu aienti" means in affirmation of but not implying any negation of anything not mentioned in one's words.

"Sensu neganti" means denying what is not mentioned.
What is this? The fallacy of misunderstood Latin phrases? It just means "in the sense of affirming / negating". It's telling that the only other online reference to these phrases is by a poster named "yrger" on a christian forum. Is that you? :rolleyes:

And I don't see the relevance to the discussion. You set out to prove the existence of God, you prove it. There is no such "sense" to try to affix to statements.

*Correct me if I am mistaken, as the Romans or Latin speaking academics say: Salva meliori sententia.​
I doubt any Latin speaking academics would say that. The grammar seems just wrong. What do you mean? You better make no typos if you copy Latin phrases you don't understand.
 
Atheists do not have to prove the non existence of any god or gods,that would be a long job,the list of gods that mankind has invented is a long one. Atheists do not have to do anything,you are the one making the claim. Would you like non believers to prove the non existence of Santa Claus,The Tooth Fairy,Zeus and Jupiter while we're at it?

Which reminds of the quip: atheists and Christians are very much alike. Atheists just disbelieve in one more god than Christians. :p

Yrreg, if you're really bent on the logical fallacy that atheists should have to prove the non-existence of YHWH, then why don't you lead by example and start to prove the non-existence of Zeus, Jupiter, Thor and Odin, just to name a couple? :rolleyes:
 
Credo means I believe for people who have to believe.

Originally Posted by yrreg
I already said that God as maker of the universe does not require faith.


Use the search function and look for Apostles' Creed, Gen. 1:1.​
I looked at the text of the Apostle's Creed, but I stopped as soon as it contradicted your claim. This is how far I got: "Credo..."


Credo means I believe for people who have to believe, not because their reason cannot come to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, namely, as maker of everything that is not God Himself.

But because they don't have the leisure to reason it out.


The Credo line is used here not to show that the fundamental concept of God etc. is a matter of faith, but to tell atheists that the fundamental concept of God etc. is known to Christians as maker of everything that is not God Himself.


I notice very glaringly that atheists do not distinguish between the realm of concepts and the realm of objective reality.

So they always lapse into the objective existence outside concepts, as they claim of course to know objective existence even though they are not necessarily genuinely in touch with true reality, when concepts are the gist of the discourse.


That makes discussion almost impossible with them.


Okay, keep this in your mind:

The fundamental concept of God [notice that word, concept] in relation to the universe in the Christian faith or for Christians that is, is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Concepts are very important, when you speak you are using concepts, unless you want to have to drag every piece of reality with you and show it to your party of conversation, in which case no need for you to learn to talk.


So, get used to dwell in concepts, otherwise it is so impossible to communicate efficiently with you people.




Yrreg
 
Credo means I believe for people who have to believe, not because their reason cannot come to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, namely, as maker of everything that is not God Himself.

But because they don't have the leisure to reason it out.


The Credo line is used here not to show that the fundamental concept of God etc. is a matter of faith, but to tell atheists that the fundamental concept of God etc. is known to Christians as maker of everything that is not God Himself.


If it was intended to show that faith is not required here, it would not start "I believe..."

The Apostles' Creed is a statement of faith. It cannot support your claim that belief in God does not require faith.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg, nobody denies that there is a concept of God in Christianity, and that that concept includes God as the creator of the universe.

But having a concept of God does not mean that God exists. And it doesn't mean that believing in God does not require faith.
 
Credo means I believe for people who have to believe, not because their reason cannot come to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, namely, as maker of everything that is not God Himself.

But because they don't have the leisure to reason it out.


The Credo line is used here not to show that the fundamental concept of God etc. is a matter of faith, but to tell atheists that the fundamental concept of God etc. is known to Christians as maker of everything that is not God Himself.


I notice very glaringly that atheists do not distinguish between the realm of concepts and the realm of objective reality.

So they always lapse into the objective existence outside concepts, as they claim of course to know objective existence even though they are not necessarily genuinely in touch with true reality, when concepts are the gist of the discourse.


That makes discussion almost impossible with them.


Okay, keep this in your mind:

The fundamental concept of God [notice that word, concept] in relation to the universe in the Christian faith or for Christians that is, is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Concepts are very important, when you speak you are using concepts, unless you want to have to drag every piece of reality with you and show it to your party of conversation, in which case no need for you to learn to talk.


So, get used to dwell in concepts, otherwise it is so impossible to communicate efficiently with you people.



Hi Yrreg,
I agree with you on the concept issue when dealing with atheists.

I am also a deist, I am enjoying this thread and look forward to pitching in at some point.:)
 
Well I am glad for us both that you know the fundamental concept in relation to the universe in the Christian faith is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

In the meantime you can read the works of atheists who seek to prove the non-existence of God, to find out whether they do have in regard to the Christian God, the fundamental concept of God etc.

Then also whether they do delimit the universe where God is the maker etc., to the Big Bang universe where man resides in, so that their reasoning to the non-existence of that God has bearing to a concrete universe.



Yrreg

Yes and how could you tell a created univserse from an uncreated universe?


There would be no penis in an uncreated universe.
 
Hi Yrreg,
I agree with you on the concept issue when dealing with atheists.

I am also a deist, I am enjoying this thread and look forward to pitching in at some point.:)
I take it that you will be presenting cast iron evidence of the existence of a god? That is the first step.
 
Credo means I believe for people who have to believe, not because their reason cannot come to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, namely, as maker of everything that is not God Himself.

But because they don't have the leisure to reason it out.


The Credo line is used here not to show that the fundamental concept of God etc. is a matter of faith, but to tell atheists that the fundamental concept of God etc. is known to Christians as maker of everything that is not God Himself.


I notice very glaringly that atheists do not distinguish between the realm of concepts and the realm of objective reality.

So they always lapse into the objective existence outside concepts, as they claim of course to know objective existence even though they are not necessarily genuinely in touch with true reality, when concepts are the gist of the discourse.


That makes discussion almost impossible with them.


Okay, keep this in your mind:

The fundamental concept of God [notice that word, concept] in relation to the universe in the Christian faith or for Christians that is, is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Concepts are very important, when you speak you are using concepts, unless you want to have to drag every piece of reality with you and show it to your party of conversation, in which case no need for you to learn to talk.


So, get used to dwell in concepts, otherwise it is so impossible to communicate efficiently with you people.




Yrreg

What is 'true reality'? Hint,it won't be found in the bible. Amazing that you know how every atheist in the world thinks. I take the above post to mean that you don't like answering awkward questions. Communicate with me by presenting your evidence for the existence of your god,and tell me why Odin does not exist.
 
Last edited:
Credo means I believe for people who have to believe, not because their reason cannot come to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, namely, as maker of everything that is not God Himself.

But because they don't have the leisure to reason it out.
:rolleyes: Oh, thanks for explaining that. I was under the impression that a lot of Christians just believe what their parents and other authority figures taught them to believe. I had no idea that they were all so busy that they didn't have the leisure time for reasoning.


The Credo line is used here not to show that the fundamental concept of God etc. is a matter of faith, but to tell atheists that the fundamental concept of God etc. is known to Christians as maker of everything that is not God Himself.
Plus a whole lot of other stuff. If you are just going by the fundamental first lines, then the Jewish God and many other gods are also creators of the universe. I can accept that "creator of the universe" is a fundamental part of the Christian concept of god, but it's not the most important part, and that concept does not distinguish the christian god from many other gods.

I notice very glaringly that atheists do not distinguish between the realm of concepts and the realm of objective reality.
You're not looking very hard. You need to open your eyes, or turn on the lights. :) I fully understand concepts such as love, peace, imaginary numbers, etc. But if you're talking about what you call "leisure to reason" which is really just a way to think that your navel-gazing musings are somehow smarter and more intellectual than those of atheists, then you're very wrong. I do plenty of navel-gazing. For instance, I can spend hours trying to figure out why grown, educated people think that invisible magic men listen to their prayers and need to know what kind of sex their neighbors are having. I have some ideas....but you probably wouldn't like them.


So they always lapse into the objective existence outside concepts, as they claim of course to know objective existence even though they are not necessarily genuinely in touch with true reality, when concepts are the gist of the discourse.
There you go again. Asserting that the results of your particular brand of navel-gazing are somehow part of true reality. If your god exists within this universe, you should be able to produce some sort of evidence.*

That makes discussion almost impossible with them.
Translation: Waah waah. I talk and talk and they don't agree with me. Yet I don't listen to anything they say.


So, get used to dwell in concepts, otherwise it is so impossible to communicate efficiently with you people.
We are talking concepts. Certainly no god is a part of objective reality. We all get the concept. If you want to claim a god is the "maker of everything in the universe except himself" then that's fine. But if you want to talk specifically about a Christian god being the maker of the universe, then you need to understand that it involves many many concepts besides that. First show evidence that any thing made the universe, and then show evidence that it was a god-being, then show evidence that it was your specific god-being.


* You asked for examples of evidence. Here's an easy one. I'm the last one to leave for work in the morning. I come home, and my husband's car is there. I walk in, and see a mayonnaise-encrusted knife in the sink and breadcrumbs on the counter. The dog and his leash are nowhere to be found. That to me is evidence that my husband came home from work, made a sandwich and then took the dog for a walk. If he comes home with a tired, happy dog and says, "Oh hey, I was hungry so I ate a quick sandwich, but we can still have dinner together." that's even further evidence that he ate a sandwich then took the dog for a walk. It's not proof. Maybe he made the sandwich for a girlfriend or a homeless person. Maybe he sprinkled breadcrumbs on the counter and stuck a knife in the mayonnaise jar just for kicks. If I want hard proof, I could go to the surveillance tapes that I have installed all over my house and neighborhood. Even then it could be an imposter. Maybe you can see that proof is very hard to find outside of mathematics. Evidence should be much easier for you to present.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom