Before anything else, we want to determine whether it is a thing or not a thing...
I would say SmartLX for this reason: his explanation actually has something to do with the definition of evidence.
Yours, on the other hand, is not a definition of evidence. It is a definition of inference. It actually takes as a given that evidence leading to "knowledge" has already been gathered. It provides no starting point but, instead, plunks one down in the middle of evidence that has already been accepted, examined and used to form proof. Honestly, what can it mean to "know" something other than to have had the thing proven by competent evidence?
[...]
Before anything else, we want to determine whether it is a thing or not a thing, and if a thing whether it is for the present all in the mind of man as a concept, or it is also a thing in objective reality, and very important, from the part of man in relation to the universe.
When the talk is about definition, it is about concepts, and from the definition as from a road map or a blueprint, the searcher can use it to go forth and locate the object represented by the concept and the word representing the concept, or fabricate the object.
Please don't regularly confuse and thus conflate the concept with the reality outside the concept, and thus always drum on the failure on your part to discern this subtlety, that is one most conspicuous and everlasting failure of atheists' mis-thinking and thus mis-knowing.
That is why a lot of discussions are into nowhere, because of this deficiency of positioning in the totality of existence.
However, there are thinkers(?) who already constrict their heart and mind to not go beyond what is called the material and/or physical universe, which for them is the totality of existence, that is a woeful and most catastrophic self-emasculation of the heart and mind, that is typical of atheists.
In re infinity, whether infinity is a genuine concept or a fake concept, for you it is genuine in mathematics, but for me it is a fake concept, period.
Now, in mathematics, mathematicians switch the concept of infinity from its etymological meaning to in effect render it no longer infinity but finity, that is the only way they can use the word in order to do their mathematical manipulations, so as for example to prove that the universe comes from nothing which everyone with intelligence understands to be no thing, how can you manipulate no thing -- that is another kind of switching that an unfettered mind can see right away, but the fettered mind, never.
Yrreg