Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

.Now, read both texts carefully, thoughtfully, and try to find out what each author is heading toward in regard to the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.
Have you lost the thread of your own thoughts?

Why don't you summarize yourself. Take into account that magical toy factories in the North Pole are to be ruled out.
 
Which text is concerned with the deepest, highest, and widest fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.


I would say SmartLX for this reason: his explanation actually has something to do with the definition of evidence.

Yours, on the other hand, is not a definition of evidence. It is a definition of inference. It actually takes as a given that evidence leading to "knowledge" has already been gathered. It provides no starting point but, instead, plunks one down in the middle of evidence that has already been accepted, examined and used to form proof. Honestly, what can it mean to "know" something other than to have had the thing proven by competent evidence?

Since SmartLX's thoughts do not presuppose proof before looking for evidence, his definition is not circular. It is useful (although not entirely accurate, as I have already stated).

Your definition is useless ... unless you are trying to pretend that deductive reasoning is somehow sufficient to infer rules about the natural world. It isn't. You are wrong.
 
Last edited:
But atheists don't have any concern with the worth of man, that is the constricted heart and mind of atheists.



Yrreg

How did you work that one out? You have the most constricted mind that I have ever come across. I am an atheist and that means I do not believe in the existence of any god or gods. When will you get that into your skull? You know nothing about me,how do do you know that I don't have any concern for the worth of man? Stop being so presumptuous. On a scale of ten,how much concern do you have for the worth of man?
 
Before anything else, we want to determine whether it is a thing or not a thing...

I would say SmartLX for this reason: his explanation actually has something to do with the definition of evidence.

Yours, on the other hand, is not a definition of evidence. It is a definition of inference. It actually takes as a given that evidence leading to "knowledge" has already been gathered. It provides no starting point but, instead, plunks one down in the middle of evidence that has already been accepted, examined and used to form proof. Honestly, what can it mean to "know" something other than to have had the thing proven by competent evidence?

[...]


Before anything else, we want to determine whether it is a thing or not a thing, and if a thing whether it is for the present all in the mind of man as a concept, or it is also a thing in objective reality, and very important, from the part of man in relation to the universe.

When the talk is about definition, it is about concepts, and from the definition as from a road map or a blueprint, the searcher can use it to go forth and locate the object represented by the concept and the word representing the concept, or fabricate the object.

Please don't regularly confuse and thus conflate the concept with the reality outside the concept, and thus always drum on the failure on your part to discern this subtlety, that is one most conspicuous and everlasting failure of atheists' mis-thinking and thus mis-knowing.



That is why a lot of discussions are into nowhere, because of this deficiency of positioning in the totality of existence.



However, there are thinkers(?) who already constrict their heart and mind to not go beyond what is called the material and/or physical universe, which for them is the totality of existence, that is a woeful and most catastrophic self-emasculation of the heart and mind, that is typical of atheists.


In re infinity, whether infinity is a genuine concept or a fake concept, for you it is genuine in mathematics, but for me it is a fake concept, period.

Now, in mathematics, mathematicians switch the concept of infinity from its etymological meaning to in effect render it no longer infinity but finity, that is the only way they can use the word in order to do their mathematical manipulations, so as for example to prove that the universe comes from nothing which everyone with intelligence understands to be no thing, how can you manipulate no thing -- that is another kind of switching that an unfettered mind can see right away, but the fettered mind, never.



Yrreg
 
Let us now examine two texts on the matter of evidence.

I don't need to examine yours, because it's sooooo predictable. :rolleyes: You like to infer your argument in long winded posts using mangled English; You are in love with your writing self . You don't really care about anyone's request of evidence requirements if they don't mirror yours. In fact, to the point of changing Smart LX's words to manipulate the argument in your direction. The next qoute says everything about you Gerry....


But atheists don't have any concern with the worth of man, that is the constricted heart and mind of atheists.

You don't have any concern about us since we refuse to be manipulated.
 
In re infinity, whether infinity is a genuine concept or a fake concept, for you it is genuine in mathematics, but for me it is a fake concept, period.

Is God not infinitely powerful? Has God not always existed? Will you not spend eternity in Heaven, and us in Hell? Seems to me that your outlook needs infinity to be real more than ours does.
 
Before anything else, we want to determine whether it is a thing or not a thing, and if a thing whether it is for the present all in the mind of man as a concept, or it is also a thing in objective reality, and very important, from the part of man in relation to the universe.
What is this "it" you refer to? Is "it" supposed to be evidence? Please refrain from vague pronouns in your posts if you want people to actually understand what you're trying to say. If nothing else think of us lurkers who might be finding your posts difficult to follow.
thinkers(?)
And don't be so condescending, there are plenty of people who are actually thinking in this thread, regardless of whether or not you pay them any heed.
ETA: Sorry I think the quote I chose as an example of condescension may be taken out of context, but nevertheless, your tone in this thread has gotten progressively more condescending, and although I have a sneaking suspicion my request won't mean much, I'd ask that you tone it down a little, unless your ultimate goal is in fact to goad people into breaking the forum's rules.
 
Last edited:
Unless some evidence is forthcoming to support "God Himself exist[ing] in objective reality" as asserted here...

So, when I have already come to their fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, I will use it to prove that God as the maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in man's mind.


... it is reasonable to accept the comment as a lie.
 
And don't be so condescending, there are plenty of people who are actually thinking in this thread, regardless of whether or not you pay them any heed.
ETA: Sorry I think the quote I chose as an example of condescension may be taken out of context, but nevertheless, your tone in this thread has gotten progressively more condescending, and although I have a sneaking suspicion my request won't mean much, I'd ask that you tone it down a little, unless your ultimate goal is in fact to goad people into breaking the forum's rules.


Welcome.
And don't second-guess yourself. Yrreg is indeed condescending. It's one of his more endearing traits, and has gotten him spanked before. If you fancy some masochistic pursuits, look through some of his old threads.
 
Please don't regularly confuse and thus conflate the concept with the reality outside the concept, and thus always drum on the failure on your part to discern this subtlety, that is one most conspicuous and everlasting failure of atheists' mis-thinking and thus mis-knowing.


A) "mis-thinking" and "mis-knowing" are not words.
B) Your post starts with an undefined pronoun, making it impossible for anyone to determine what you're talking about.
C) You must miss your family. Do you understand at all why they left?
 
Before anything else, we want to determine whether it is a thing or not a thing, and if a thing whether it is for the present all in the mind of man as a concept, or it is also a thing in objective reality, and very important, from the part of man in relation to the universe.

When the talk is about definition, it is about concepts, and from the definition as from a road map or a blueprint, the searcher can use it to go forth and locate the object represented by the concept and the word representing the concept, or fabricate the object.

Please don't regularly confuse and thus conflate the concept with the reality outside the concept, and thus always drum on the failure on your part to discern this subtlety, that is one most conspicuous and everlasting failure of atheists' mis-thinking and thus mis-knowing.



That is why a lot of discussions are into nowhere, because of this deficiency of positioning in the totality of existence.



However, there are thinkers(?) who already constrict their heart and mind to not go beyond what is called the material and/or physical universe, which for them is the totality of existence, that is a woeful and most catastrophic self-emasculation of the heart and mind, that is typical of atheists.


In re infinity, whether infinity is a genuine concept or a fake concept, for you it is genuine in mathematics, but for me it is a fake concept, period.

Now, in mathematics, mathematicians switch the concept of infinity from its etymological meaning to in effect render it no longer infinity but finity, that is the only way they can use the word in order to do their mathematical manipulations, so as for example to prove that the universe comes from nothing which everyone with intelligence understands to be no thing, how can you manipulate no thing -- that is another kind of switching that an unfettered mind can see right away, but the fettered mind, never.



Yrreg

Would you please address our posts instead of answering with these incoherent word salads? I'll try again.


Originally Posted by yrreg
But atheists don't have any concern with the worth of man, that is the constricted heart and mind of atheists.



Me.
How did you work that one out? You have the most constricted mind that I have ever come across. I am an atheist and that means I do not believe in the existence of any god or gods. When will you get that into your skull? You know nothing about me,how do do you know that I don't have any concern for the worth of man? Stop being so presumptuous. On a scale of ten,how much concern do you have for the worth of man?

Be a man and answer instead of hiding behind the bible. Be a brave Christian soldier.
 
Last edited:
What is this "it" you refer to? Is "it" supposed to be evidence? Please refrain from vague pronouns in your posts if you want people to actually understand what you're trying to say. If nothing else think of us lurkers who might be finding your posts difficult to follow.
Welcome, Flea - yrreg is actually not interested in your doing anything with/about his posts except nodding and saying, in tones of uncontrollable awe, "Yes, of course!"

He doesn't want a conversation and he doesn't much care if anyone understands him as long as that person agrees with him.
 
Welcome, Flea - yrreg is actually not interested in your doing anything with/about his posts except nodding and saying, in tones of uncontrollable awe, "Yes, of course!"

He doesn't want a conversation and he doesn't much care if anyone understands him as long as that person agrees with him.

He'll have a long wait.
 
We should stop applying infinity to God even the Christian God.

Originally Posted by yrreg
In re infinity, whether infinity is a genuine concept or a fake concept, for you it is genuine in mathematics, but for me it is a fake concept, period.

​

Is God not infinitely powerful? Has God not always existed? Will you not spend eternity in Heaven, and us in Hell? Seems to me that your outlook needs infinity to be real more than ours does.


We should stop applying infinity to God even the Christian God.

Here is again, so get that into your heads if not your brains, erh, minds, get that into your minds, my fundamental concept of God for Christians in relation to the universe:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​


That is why I am limiting God to the Big Bang universe, you can have Him in the multiple whatever parallel or M whatever universe(s).


God is immense but not infinite, although Christian thinkers wax with tremendous awe using the word and fake or pseudo concept of infinite to describe God.

The immensity of God is more than adequate to justify Him to be maker of everything that is not God Himself in the yes! Big Bang universe.


Yrreg
 
He doesn't want a conversation and he doesn't much care if anyone understands him as long as that person agrees with him.


Actually, he doesn't want us to agree with him. His sees our disagree as evidence of his superiority. The more we dislike what he says, the better he feels about himself.

It's actually not uncommon. A person can only receive so much negative feedback before he snaps. The ego, in an attempt to comfort and protect itself, just decides that negative is positive.

With intense cognitive behavioral therapy over many years, this can be overcome. Basically, one needs to start behaving correctly even though it feels wrong. The positive response of others then helps the person continue to modify his behavior.

I should know. It worked with me.
 
We should stop applying infinity to God even the Christian God.

Here is again, so get that into your heads if not your brains, erh, minds, get that into your minds, my fundamental concept of God for Christians in relation to the universe:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​


That is why I am limiting God to the Big Bang universe, you can have Him in the multiple whatever parallel or M whatever universe(s).


God is immense but not infinite, although Christian thinkers wax with tremendous awe using the word and fake or pseudo concept of infinite to describe God.

The immensity of God is more than adequate to justify Him to be maker of everything that is not God Himself in the yes! Big Bang universe.


Yrreg

Gerry, this post is nothing but stupidly worded Preaching - I'm not a mod, but surely there are better places to preach than here? No one here - not a single thinking person I can see - wants to read anymore of your preaching, gurdjiefian-worded nonsense posts :(
 
We should stop applying infinity to God even the Christian God.

Here is again, so get that into your heads if not your brains, erh, minds, get that into your minds, my fundamental concept of God for Christians in relation to the universe:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​


That is why I am limiting God to the Big Bang universe, you can have Him in the multiple whatever parallel or M whatever universe(s).


God is immense but not infinite, although Christian thinkers wax with tremendous awe using the word and fake or pseudo concept of infinite to describe God.

The immensity of God is more than adequate to justify Him to be maker of everything that is not God Himself in the yes! Big Bang universe.


Yrreg

Where is your proof that this god exists and all the other gods do not? Are you a Hindu atheist?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom