Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

No need to over-analyse yrreg's last one, folks, he's simply tried to fit each of my examples of evidence into his definition of it.

It doesn't work, mainly because on most or all counts "the thing to know (TTKw)", or the claim supported by the evidence, isn't absolutely known as a result. It's merely thought to be more likely.

I can see why he apparently gets frustrated, bails and restarts elsewhere as if the previous exchange never happened. He's got a complete ontological argument all queued up on his clipboard and ready to paste, but he won't go past the first part until we've all accepted it exactly as written, probably because he can't confidently customise the rest of it on the fly. Unfortunately the first part is crap, and there's nothing he can do about it but look for another audience who won't notice.

Written discussions and arguments online allow one to organise one's thoughts, and to properly analyse the writings of others. (That's why I run Ask the Atheist.) yrreg does neither. He's just here for a chance to spread the Word, and isn't worried that he has no idea how to make it stick.


You beat me to the obvious.

I've only ever seen Yrreg present one argument for god's existence: re-definition of the word "god".

For all his many threads, it all leads back to the same point. Accept some arbitrary (and flawed) definition of God, then 'pure, intelligent, straightforward, etc etc thinking will lead you to the conclusion that penises noses animals roses etc things exist, and therefore god.

He invariably get frustrated, starts insulting people, gets suspended, and comes back sometime much later so that if can be on his own terms and not the forums, and begins anew. By re-defining god.

Or, as I put it in his previous thread: Congratulations yrreg, "god" now means a chemical reaction (specifically, the combustion of gasoline).
 
Everything was created in the Big Bang so how could a god exist outside of it? Yrreg is on a loser here.
 
Wait, really?

For all his many threads, it all leads back to the same point. Accept some arbitrary (and flawed) definition of God, then 'pure, intelligent, straightforward, etc etc thinking will lead you to the conclusion that penises noses animals roses etc things exist, and therefore god.

So his argument is that we'll realise his assertion is correct if we think about it? That's not even making an argument, it's telling us to make it for him!
 
So his argument is that we'll realise his assertion is correct if we think about it? That's not even making an argument, it's telling us to make it for him!

Welcome to the world of yrreG.

He won't be able to help himself. There aren't too many seven year old children posting on this forum so nobody falls for his naive attempts at subtlety. Apparently, seven year olds are the only people who he can indoctrinate. That means he will get frustrated again and start breaching the MA. That means he will get suspended again and put on probation again so we won't see him for another seven months (six months plus another month because it has to be his idea to return). He knows better than to post while he is on probation. He can't help himself.

yrreG, what did you think of the proof that your god doesn't exist?

Everything that exists began to exist.
God never began to exist.
God doesn't exist.
 
How many times?

Sorry Gee, but that link doesn't link to anything much.

So what lap, or iteration, is this? How many times has he been suspended since he started in November 2005?
 
Last edited:
Sorry Gee, but that link doesn't link to anything much.

So what lap, or iteration, is this? How many times has he been suspended since he started in November 2005?


Frequently, he doesn't get suspended. He just ... goes away. This can be for a month, a season or a year. Then, quite suddenly, there's a new thread and he's back. He almost never posts in a thread he didn't start.

Off and on, he's been attempting to make some sort of argument proving the existence of God. However, for a long time all of his threads were long diatribes against Buddhism. For some reason that nobody has ever figured out, Buddhism deeply offends him. He spent years arguing that Buddhists don't have any morals at all because they believe in reincarnation ... or something ... it was never particularly clear.

At least part of the reason, I've speculated, is his culture. Gerry's in the Philippines. It's almost the only place on earth where Catholicism is the dominant religion with Buddhism second. Everything for Gerry has to be very black and white, and he can't understand how those around him tolerate the existence of a different way of thought.

Gerry's avatar, by the way, was custom-made by him after he was criticized for making some very negative statements about all Buddhists everywhere. For a while, he pretended to actually want to discuss what was and wasn't hate speech, but since he has no ability to empathize with anyone, that was a complete disaster.

You, SmartLX, though, have shown yourself in a very few posts to be a careful, curious, and engaging guy. I hope you enjoy the whole forum. Sticking to a Yrreg thread will suck you dry.
 
Sorry Gee, but that link doesn't link to anything much.

So what lap, or iteration, is this? How many times has he been suspended since he started in November 2005?

I count five times.

The last was September 2010 and he didn't post again until June 2011, about nine months.
He had three in quick succession before that in July and August 2009. I suspect he got a three month probation after the third because he didn't post again after that until December 2009.

All speculation, I'm not sure if they even use 3 month suspensions. Maybe some mod or admin will enlighten us on our way to AAH.
 
Thanks.

You, SmartLX, though, have shown yourself in a very few posts to be a careful, curious, and engaging guy. I hope you enjoy the whole forum. Sticking to a Yrreg thread will suck you dry.

Ta for that LL. I don't plan to limit myself to this thread, I just want to see it through as long as yrreg is trying to use what I wrote for him. I followed him back here, after all. The chew-toy thing goes both ways.

I wonder if he puts his complete lack of meaningful engagement or communication down to his ESL? What if, to him, writing apologetic in English is like a man barking at dogs to bring them to the fence?
 

So, you have got to first know what you want evidence to target on (TTKw), and then you seek the evidence (TKn) that targets on the thing (TTKw).

​


So....your evidence (Yet to be presented) of God in the big bang universe is what?​
 
No need to over-analyse yrreg's last one, folks, he's simply tried to fit each of my examples of evidence into his definition of it.

It doesn't work, mainly because on most or all counts "the thing to know (TTKw)", or the claim supported by the evidence, isn't absolutely known as a result. It's merely thought to be more likely.

I can see why he apparently gets frustrated, bails and restarts elsewhere as if the previous exchange never happened. He's got a complete ontological argument all queued up on his clipboard and ready to paste, but he won't go past the first part until we've all accepted it exactly as written, probably because he can't confidently customise the rest of it on the fly. Unfortunately the first part is crap, and there's nothing he can do about it but look for another audience who won't notice.

Written discussions and arguments online allow one to organise one's thoughts, and to properly analyse the writings of others. (That's why I run Ask the Atheist.) yrreg does neither. He's just here for a chance to spread the Word, and isn't worried that he has no idea how to make it stick.
I'm afraid you are too much rational and sound for forums.randi.org. I mean, you are pretty right but you are thinking structurally and you use common sense to organize what you want to say, both rare qualities in these fora. Plans, purpose, common sense, rationality, hierarchical thinking, all of it places you as an outsider here.

What you have said could have been spot on in a discussion with a hundred of posts at most, but discussions involving yrreg reach thousands of posts, and he and those who posts in his threads -including you and me- have gathered more than ten thousand posts about the same thing within the same structure you have described ... superficially. First of all, believe me, when you reach thousands of posts and you are in the same place, it's all just about power, as power underlies the actions of everyone who creates/clones a god and dresses it with qualities, and concerns about power are behind who they try to dispel those creations. Yrreg needs everybody to agree not much because he wouldn't know what to say later -believe me, he'd hardly be able to tell the difference- but because he want us to yield. On the side of the rainbow of non-yrregs in these kind of threads, besides the occasional rational purposeful guys, a game of cat and mouse is taking place.

So reason has been displaced here by glitches of rationalism, and intelligence displaced by witticism, all in a repetitive fashion with partial victories and infinite levels to reach, pretty much in the obsessive way video games promote. And as in every human interchange the reason of it is everyone believing that what they get is more valuable that what they give: you need two people who think the opposite and, voilà! a transaction is made. For that reason threads like this exist, and it all boils to a lot of people shooting at 2D 16-colour images of yrreg and giggling when those images burst into 2D 16-colour flames, being yrreg indeed the owner of the arcade.

Reason and instinctive behaviour are present here the same way they are present in New Year resolutions like those of quit smoking and lose those thirty extra pounds at last by means of eating healthy home-made food and practising some martial art new to us.

I'm here to practise my English. What's your excuse?
 
I'm afraid you are too much rational and sound for forums.randi.org. I mean, you are pretty right but you are thinking structurally and you use common sense to organize what you want to say, both rare qualities in these fora. Plans, purpose, common sense, rationality, hierarchical thinking, all of it places you as an outsider here.

What you have said could have been spot on in a discussion with a hundred of posts at most, but discussions involving yrreg reach thousands of posts, and he and those who posts in his threads -including you and me- have gathered more than ten thousand posts about the same thing within the same structure you have described ... superficially. First of all, believe me, when you reach thousands of posts and you are in the same place, it's all just about power, as power underlies the actions of everyone who creates/clones a god and dresses it with qualities, and concerns about power are behind who they try to dispel those creations. Yrreg needs everybody to agree not much because he wouldn't know what to say later -believe me, he'd hardly be able to tell the difference- but because he want us to yield. On the side of the rainbow of non-yrregs in these kind of threads, besides the occasional rational purposeful guys, a game of cat and mouse is taking place.

So reason has been displaced here by glitches of rationalism, and intelligence displaced by witticism, all in a repetitive fashion with partial victories and infinite levels to reach, pretty much in the obsessive way video games promote. And as in every human interchange the reason of it is everyone believing that what they get is more valuable that what they give: you need two people who think the opposite and, voilà! a transaction is made. For that reason threads like this exist, and it all boils to a lot of people shooting at 2D 16-colour images of yrreg and giggling when those images burst into 2D 16-colour flames, being yrreg indeed the owner of the arcade.

Reason and instinctive behaviour are present here the same way they are present in New Year resolutions like those of quit smoking and lose those thirty extra pounds at last by means of eating healthy home-made food and practising some martial art new to us.

I'm here to practise my English. What's your excuse?

I think that Yrreg likes the attention.
 
I think that Yrreg likes the attention.

Indeed, attention is part of power. Attention and attraction. That's why so many people try to seduce and are devoted to taking care of the skin and fur bag that interfaces them with the rest of the universe, to the absolute neglect of the bag's content.

A testimony of yrreg being some sort of a Christian just driven by the idea of power is his pseudo avatar image: "Resident Buddhist Critic Studying Hate Speech", sort of a conceptual oxymoron waiting for someone to unriddle it. I know little about religions and their gods and beliefs, but I imagine Buddhism as a religion and philosophy in the antipodes of power, as I'd rather imagine it as renunciation, restraint, and meekness, that I can easily imagine as qualities being looked with a cheeky grin by the yrreg-likes.

Yrreg plays the kid here, but don't kid yourselves; like the joke of the smuggler riding a bicycle, he knows what he's doing. And as a ratio to his IQ and mastery in logic and the English language, his getting a yield higher than anyone who is trying to show how wrong he is.
 
I am terribly disappointed with SmartLX, let me see if aleC is different.

[...]

First of all, believe me, when you reach thousands of posts and you are in the same place, it's all just about power...


[...]

Now, I love to read some (just five, then) peers-reviewed accounts of TKns and TTKws outside the realms of essentially literary fiction.


Well, are you... ever going to just produce some five examples of evidence in terms of TKns and TTKws, etc. from peers-reviewed accounts (see above my quote)

Knowledge is anything that can be put in concepts in the mind of man, originally in his memory, then with the invention of writing in all kinds of media like stones and woods and skins at the beginning, and now in the internet, is stored for retrieval as usefulness dictates in the heart of man.​



Anyway, if you cannot or will not produce any examples of evidence from peers-reviewed accounts in terms of TKns and TTKws, then give me more of your literary fictions.

At least from such literary fictions I can fashion some ideas of what for you atheists is evidence in terms of TKns (things known) and TTKws (things to know)

Several breaches of rule 0 removed.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Cuddles


Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, are you atheists who screech on evidence ever going to just produce some five examples of evidence in terms of TKns and TTKws, etc. from peers-reviewed accounts (see above my quote), or you are going to continuously wallow in rote regurgitations of rancid slogans, for fear of getting further in the search for knowledge?

<snip>


No.

You've already been given the answers and examples you requested. They didn't fit with your pre-planned script, so now you're trying to make us re-word what was said so that it follows your game.

Not gonna happen.

You're fiddle is out of tune, your jig is poorly played, and we will not dance to your music.
 
Here come the frustration and insults. This is the stage where Gerry is perturbed by the fact that he can't make people follow his script to his big "Aha! Gotcha!!!" climax.
 
rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.




Yrreg

Is that your new catch phrase? It's not a very good one,you need something more snappy. Asking you for proof of the god you believe in is not sloganizing. Be a brave Christian and show us some evidence.
 
Here come the frustration and insults. This is the stage where Gerry is perturbed by the fact that he can't make people follow his script to his big "Aha! Gotcha!!!" climax.

Poor Yrreg,he will never get his Gotcha! moment.
 
Well, are you atheists who screech on evidence ever going to just produce some five examples of evidence in terms of TKns and TTKws, etc. from peers-reviewed accounts (see above my quote), or you are going to continuously wallow in rote regurgitations of rancid slogans, for fear of getting further in the search for knowledge?

Where can I find a brave atheist?

Not among this batch or rote regurgitators here, it appears most conspicuously.


Here is something for you to engage your brain cells with:

Knowledge is anything that can be put in concepts in the mind of man, originally in his memory, then with the invention of writing in all kinds of media like stones and woods and skins at the beginning, and now in the internet, is stored for retrieval as usefulness dictates in the heart of man.​

So, if your knowledge is just rancid slogans from your constipated belly, that ain't no knowledge but a lot of swill which you wallow in, albeit feeling so smart but knowing nothing at all peculiar to the essence of what is called wisdom among the ancients.

You guys have no anchorings whatsoever in the immensity of the totality of existence.


Anyway, if you cannot or will not produce any examples of evidence from peers-reviewed accounts in terms of TKns and TTKws, then give me more of your literary fictions.

At least from such literary fictions I can fashion some ideas of what for you atheists is evidence in terms of TKns (things known) and TTKws (things to know), better than nothing, which woefully is the status quo of your mind.



Dear gentle readers here, you do notice when atheists are required to do some real thinking they resort as from cue to rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.




Yrreg
You asked for others to define evidence and provide examples, which they did. Your own invented constructs and misunderstandings are irrelevant to that request and that discussion. If you want to present your own definitions, you should be honest and do so, instead of corrupting what others say.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom