Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Gerry, this post is nothing but stupidly worded Preaching - I'm not a mod, but surely there are better places to preach than here? No one here - not a single thinking person I can see - wants to read anymore of your preaching, gurdjiefian-worded nonsense posts :(

One does get a little weary of reading total bollocks.
 
God is immense but not infinite, although Christian thinkers wax with tremendous awe using the word and fake or pseudo concept of infinite to describe God.


So, theoretically, something could be bigger than God? And something could be bigger than that? And that? And ... where does it end?

When you die, the time you spend in God's grace isn't infinite? How much time is it? Is it an hour and a half? A trillion years? And what happens when it ends?

Also, how many discrete points are there between the 1" and 2" mark on a ruler?

How many numbers are there total?

If you are an utterly abysmal person and you die, how long do you spend in hell?

How much physical force can God exert? How much can he withstand?

You earlier said that christians have a broader view of the universe than materialists, but now you're saying that the multiverse does not exist. Which is it? What space does God occupy? Is it material in this universe or is it on some alternate plane that you just said doesn't exist?

Will any of this really make you feel any better about yourself?
 
Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​



Okay, obviously the circular nature of this escapes you, so let's try a different tack:

What in this universe is "not God Himself"?
 
Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​
Ohhhh... I get it now. By repeating the same circular definition of God for the (i think) 6th time on this thread, you have finally made it clear that God is God because God=God and made all but God therefore God. Praise the Maker! (whom I assume is the God you refer to, still ambiguous though).
 
We should stop applying infinity to God even the Christian God.

You should stop and actually interact with people here. Seriously, we really are people that are not the least bit inferior to you. No matter how hard you try, it's a fact you can't ignore. Deal with it.
 
God is immense but not infinite, although Christian thinkers wax with tremendous awe using the word and fake or pseudo concept of infinite to describe God.

But you're always telling us that we should look to Christian thinkers to guidance?
 
I would say SmartLX for this reason: his explanation actually has something to do with the definition of evidence.

Yours, on the other hand, is not a definition of evidence. It is a definition of inference. It actually takes as a given that evidence leading to "knowledge" has already been gathered. It provides no starting point but, instead, plunks one down in the middle of evidence that has already been accepted, examined and used to form proof.


As I said, turtles all the way down.
 
We should stop applying infinity to God even the Christian God.

Here is again, so get that into your heads if not your brains, erh, minds, get that into your minds, my fundamental concept of God for Christians in relation to the universe:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​


That is why I am limiting God to the Big Bang universe, you can have Him in the multiple whatever parallel or M whatever universe(s).


God is immense but not infinite, although Christian thinkers wax with tremendous awe using the word and fake or pseudo concept of infinite to describe God.

The immensity of God is more than adequate to justify Him to be maker of everything that is not God Himself in the yes! Big Bang universe.


Yrreg

Your utterly bumpkinous presumptuality continuously astonishes me in a not very amused but head shaking way.

Your stand condemned by the lack of understanding of your own words - you are choosing a limited definition to conform to your preconceptions and intellectual limitations, yet at the same time hand-wave the incredible immensity of god. Do you not see the contradiction? You have made god big enough for your predetermined route of argument, but not too big such that your argument fails.

Also, what's with the conflating of the concepts of immensity and competency? Having a size or goodness does not confer capability or competency. Even if god were huge, but not too huge (having learned a thing or two from reading Goldilocks and the Three bears no doubt), you have presented NO CASE WHATSOEVER for not only any action being performed, but also no evidence of aany skerrick of competency or capability to create, influence or change anything, nor a desire to perform any such activity.

Your definition is a hollow chocolate bunny of a god rolling around an imaginary basket, 4 months after easter.

I rest my case.
 
Ohhhh... I get it now. By repeating the same circular definition of God for the (i think) 6th time on this thread, you have finally made it clear that God is God because God=God and made all but God therefore God. Praise the Maker! (whom I assume is the God you refer to, still ambiguous though).

You're a fast learner. Wait until you start decoding DOC!

(And welcome, but you already knew that...)
 
So how about it, yrreg? Are you going to actually prove that your god exists in objective reality, or was this just another bunch of meaningless words?...

So, when I have already come to their fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, I will use it to prove that God as the maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in man's mind.
 
Here are my comments on the five examples of evidence from SmartLX.

SmartLX said:
1. - A man's unique dental imprint on a woman's arm would be evidence that he bit her.
2. - Markers appearing in the middle of the second pair of human chromosomes, which normally only appear on the ends of chromosomes, are evidence that our (ape) ancestors had one more chromosome pair at one stage, and two of them later fused together.
3. - A man's amputated arm growing back seconds after he bathed in the shrine at Lourdes would be evidence for the shrine?s advertised healing properties.
4. - A prophecy in the Bible which predicted the day and time of three 21st century earthquakes, which then actually happened, would be evidence that its author had some prior knowledge.
5a. - An increase in the number of Christians worldwide which coincided with a similar decrease in the number of atheists would be evidence that non-believers were converting to Christianity in large numbers.
5b1. (The reality is that Christianity today mostly increases through reproduction or,
5b2. in some populations unaccustomed to missionaries, at the expense of more established religions.)

See, http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7301546#post7301546.



1. - A man's unique dental imprint on a woman's arm would be evidence that he bit her.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the similarity thing between the dental marks on a woman's arm, and the thing to know (TTKw) is the identity thing of the man biting her.


2. - Markers appearing in the middle of the second pair of human chromosomes, which normally only appear on the ends of chromosomes, are evidence that our (ape) ancestors had one more chromosome pair at one stage, and two of them later fused together.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the markers thing appearing etc., and the thing to know (TTKw) is common ancestry of mankind as of apes.


3. - A man's amputated arm growing back seconds after he bathed in the shrine at Lourdes would be evidence for the shrine's advertised healing properties.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly an amputated arm, and the thing to know (TTKw) is the cause by bathing in a shrine.


4. - A prophecy in the Bible which predicted the day and time of three 21st century earthquakes, which then actually happened, would be evidence that its author had some prior knowledge.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly an author's prediction of etc., and the thing to know (TTKw) is his prior knowledge.


5a. - An increase in the number of Christians worldwide which coincided with a similar decrease in the number of atheists would be evidence that non-believers were converting to Christianity in large numbers.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the fluctuations of Christians census and atheists census, and the thing to know (TTKw) is inverse correlation of Christians census and atheists census.


5b1. The reality is that Christianity today mostly increases through reproduction.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the increase of Christians census, and the thing to know (TTKw) is reproduction as the factor of increase in Christians census.


5b2. in some populations unaccustomed to missionaries, at the expense of more established religions.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the increase of Christians census, and the thing to know (TTKw) is conversion from other religions as the factor of increase in Christians census.



So, you have got to first know what you want evidence to target on (TTKw), and then you seek the evidence (TKn) that targets on the thing (TTKw).



Now, I love to read some (just five, then) peers-reviewed accounts of TKns and TTKws outside the realms of essentially literary fiction.




Yrreg
 
1. - A man's unique dental imprint on a woman's arm would be evidence that he bit her.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the similarity thing between the dental marks on a woman's arm, and the thing to know (TTKw) is the identity thing of the man biting her.


2. - Markers appearing in the middle of the second pair of human chromosomes, which normally only appear on the ends of chromosomes, are evidence that our (ape) ancestors had one more chromosome pair at one stage, and two of them later fused together.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the markers thing appearing etc., and the thing to know (TTKw) is common ancestry of mankind as of apes.


3. - A man's amputated arm growing back seconds after he bathed in the shrine at Lourdes would be evidence for the shrine's advertised healing properties.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly an amputated arm, and the thing to know (TTKw) is the cause by bathing in a shrine.


4. - A prophecy in the Bible which predicted the day and time of three 21st century earthquakes, which then actually happened, would be evidence that its author had some prior knowledge.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly an author's prediction of etc., and the thing to know (TTKw) is his prior knowledge.


5a. - An increase in the number of Christians worldwide which coincided with a similar decrease in the number of atheists would be evidence that non-believers were converting to Christianity in large numbers.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the fluctuations of Christians census and atheists census, and the thing to know (TTKw) is inverse correlation of Christians census and atheists census.


5b1. The reality is that Christianity today mostly increases through reproduction.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the increase of Christians census, and the thing to know (TTKw) is reproduction as the factor of increase in Christians census.


5b2. in some populations unaccustomed to missionaries, at the expense of more established religions.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the increase of Christians census, and the thing to know (TTKw) is conversion from other religions as the factor of increase in Christians census.



So, you have got to first know what you want evidence to target on (TTKw), and then you seek the evidence (TKn) that targets on the thing (TTKw).



Now, I love to read some (just five, then) peers-reviewed accounts of TKns and TTKws outside the realms of essentially literary fiction.




Yrreg
What a load of *****. Are you feeling alright? Off the medication again? No amputated arm has ever grown back because god decided it would,what on Earth are you wittering on about? We already knew that there is no god to perform miracles. What did you study,the blindingly obvious?
 
Last edited:
1. [...]​


The parts that weren't gibberish were nonsense.

Do you intend to get around to bringing in your alleged evidence that "God Himself exists in objective reality" as you said you would here?

So, when I have already come to their fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, I will use it to prove that God as the maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in man's mind.


Or was that a lie?
 
... outside the realms of essentially literary fiction.
Darn, I was going to quote the Bible!

I'll wait for some new posts and I'll peer-review them as we are here among peers.

You couldn't even define evidence; please, don't try to define peer-reviewed.

Tell me also how do you know that god didn't committed suicide yesterday?
 
Just trying to reinforce his version.

No need to over-analyse yrreg's last one, folks, he's simply tried to fit each of my examples of evidence into his definition of it.

It doesn't work, mainly because on most or all counts "the thing to know (TTKw)", or the claim supported by the evidence, isn't absolutely known as a result. It's merely thought to be more likely.

I can see why he apparently gets frustrated, bails and restarts elsewhere as if the previous exchange never happened. He's got a complete ontological argument all queued up on his clipboard and ready to paste, but he won't go past the first part until we've all accepted it exactly as written, probably because he can't confidently customise the rest of it on the fly. Unfortunately the first part is crap, and there's nothing he can do about it but look for another audience who won't notice.

Written discussions and arguments online allow one to organise one's thoughts, and to properly analyse the writings of others. (That's why I run Ask the Atheist.) yrreg does neither. He's just here for a chance to spread the Word, and isn't worried that he has no idea how to make it stick.
 
I was going to quote the part of yyreg's latest post that made sense and had relevance, but I ended up with nothing but QUOTE tags.

By the Noodly Appendages of the Flying Spaghetti Monster (may IT rest in sauce), what were you trying to say in that collection of words? Your responses to quoted text did not appear to relate.
 
1. - A man's unique dental imprint on a woman's arm would be evidence that he bit her.​

The thing known (TKn) is precisely and concisely and clearly the similarity thing between the dental marks on a woman's arm, and the thing to know (TTKw) is the identity thing of the man biting her.


But knowing about the dental marks doesn't lead to any knowledge about whether anyone bit the woman. It only leads to a slightly greater likelihood that a certain person may have bitten her.

You've left no room for countervailing evidence such as:

1. Dental imprints, especially partial, may not be unique. They are a good way of zeroing in on one person after a search has already been significantly narrowed, but they are useless for identification when the person is entirely unknown.

2. Just three weeks before, the suspect had an entire cast of his teeth made for a prosthetic for a movie in which he was to star. He quarreled with the cinematographer, who wanted him fired from the movie. The woman bitten was an intern on the set who had been romantically linked to the cinematographer.

3. The placement of the bite marks on the woman's left arm indicates that the suspect would have had to have been curled up in the woman's lap, and bringing her arm up to his mouth at the level of her chest. This is the same positioning as marks that would have been made had the right-handed woman used a cast of the man's teeth to "bite" her own left arm.


Nothing in your formulation allows facts to add and subtract from the likelihood of an event until it is "proven" to whatever level of satisfaction might be required by the mind. The proof necessary to be fired from a movie is probably much, much lower than the proof necessary to be convicted of a crime.

For that matter, nothing in your formulation allows "facts" to be wrong. SmartLX's "fact" about dental imprints, while I'm sure well-intentioned, was wrong.

Nothing in your formulation allows for anything to be disproven by later evidence.

SmartLX already made this observation about your post. "Evidence" does not correlate with "knowledge" and "proof" is not the same as "new knowledge."

You are wrong.
 
Last edited:
But knowing about the dental marks don't lead to any knowledge about whether anyone bit the woman. It only leads to a slightly greater likelihood that a certain person may have bitten her.

You've left no room for countervailing evidence such as:

1. Dental imprints, especially partial, may not be unique. They are a good way of zeroing in on one person after a search has already been significantly narrowed, but they are useless for identification when the person is entirely unknown.

2. Just three weeks before, the suspect had an entire cast of his teeth made for a prosthetic for a movie in which he was to star. He quarreled with the cinematographer, who wanted him fired from the movie. The woman bitten was an intern on the set who had been romantically linked to the cinematographer.

3. The placement of the bite marks on the woman's left arm indicates that the suspect would have had to have been curled up in the woman's lap, and bringing her arm up to his mouth at the level of her chest. This is the same positioning as marks that would have been made had the right-handed woman used a cast of the man's teeth to "bite" her own left arm.


Nothing in your formulation allows facts to add and subtract from the likelihood of an event until it is "proven" to whatever level of satisfaction might be required by the mind. The proof necessary to be fired from a movie is probably much, much lower than the proof necessary to be convicted of a crime.

For that matter, nothing in your formulation allows "facts" to be wrong. SmartLX's "fact" about dental imprints, while I'm sure well-intentioned, was wrong.

Nothing in your formulation allows for anything to be disproven by later evidence.

SmartLX already made this observation about your post. "Evidence" does not correlate with "knowledge" and "proof" is not the same as "new knowledge."

You are wrong.

yes - that's what I meant in the post above... :o
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom