Hokulele
Deleterious Slab of Damnation
"Anything man knows,"
Anything I know,
"leading him to know another thing."
may very well be wrong.
That's what you really mean, you just don't know that yet.
"Anything man knows,"
"leading him to know another thing."
Makes you wonder, doesn't it? We have to remember yrreG's control issues. He has to make other people say his words. Kinda creepy.
yrreG, here are fewer words: gods are made up. Even yours.
What do you say now? Do you get my drift?
this is why RLBaty reminded me so much of Gerry. Both seem to compose a script that they think their exchange will follow, then they waste most of the thread trying to force people to follow the script.
You say:
.
Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.
And I say:
Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.
Now, to reduce the number of words you use and still retain the thought you want to communicate, instead of saying:
"Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument,"
You say:
"Anything man knows,"
And instead of:
"which makes the claim more likely to be true,"
You say:
leading him to know another thing.
So, what do you say now?
Can you or can you not say what you want to say in fewer words and simpler ones and in a more encapsulating way: the depth and height and breadth of what is the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe?
We, you and I, if I may submit, want to see things in the most deep, most high, and most wide perspectives of evidence (as of everything else), namely, in its fundamental concept for man in relation to the universe.
Hope you get my drift.
Yrreg
Not quick or alert in perception, feeling, or intellect; not sensitive or observant; dull.
To control or play upon by artful, unfair, or insidious means especially to one's own advantage.
This is a despicable method of constructing an argument. Sadly it appears to be common practice among the most fervently faithful Christians.
For example, in the examination and exposition on man's nose, to be truly, completely, and exhaustively involved, you must delve into your nose ...
tl;drYrreg
Now, we come to the thing called evidence.
Yrreg
Put this thought into your head:
The fundamental concept of a thing for man in relation to the universe.
So, everytime you want to truly and completely and exhaustively examine a thing, anything, everything, start from that line above, here reproduced as follows:
The fundamental concept of a thing for man in relation to the universe.
For example, in the examination and exposition on man's nose, to be truly, completely, and exhaustively involved, you must delve into your nose as a human being, consider it in its most crucially important aspect in your estimation and also in regard to its place in the universe.
That brings in to your intelligent awareness another question more pre-basic than the question of your nose in its fundamental concept for you and in relation to the universe.
The question namely of being, again in its fundamental concept for you in relation to the universe.
If you think to the deepest depth, to the highest height, and to the widest breadth reachable by your intelligence, you will come to the thought that a being can be existing in objective reality even if you were not around, then in regard to your conscious awareness, it can be a concept in your mind, so that insofar as you are a human being with consciousness and intelligence, the universe is composed of two kinds of being, objectively existing things outside man's mind and concepts in man's mind.
So, first question in your inquisition and exposition of man's nose, is the nose an objectively existing thing or a concept or both, namely, both in the sense that it exists in objective reality even if man were not around, and also it exists as a concept in man's mind corresponding to the objective reality of man's nose.
Next, what does the nose mean to man and to the universe where man has his residence in?
At this point atheists will say that it is meaningless, which is a favorite term of Bertrand Russell, that is essentially a cop-out strategy with him when he does not want to go into something, that is not in accordance in the longer terms with his lifestyle.
Find the meaning for you of the nose in your face, and its meaning in regard to the universe of the nose being a part of the universe.
Study it the nose both in its objective existence and also in its conceptual presence in your mind.
See? that is the way to do a stint of genuinely personal thinking on the nose, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.
Now, we come to the thing called evidence.
Proceed as per routines described above, and you will come to the deepest, highest, and widest perspectives of evidence, namely, in its fundamental concept to man in relation to the universe.
And verbalize your finding in a few simple clear words which anyone even a child in nursery daycare center understands:
Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.
Yrreg
[*Snipped irrelevant rambling.*]
Now, we come to the thing called evidence.
[*Snipped more irrelevant rambling.*]
So, when I have already come to their fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, I will use it to prove that God as the maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in man's mind.
I think it demonstrates what most of us have known since our earliest interactions with Pachomius, yrreg, oslove, or whatever might be his nickname du jour. There is a fundamental flaw in his ability to construct an honest argument or engage in an honest discussion. Rather than even recognize that SmartLX is refining the definition of evidence and proof, attempting to move the conversation forward, yrreg blatantly and dishonestly changes the meaning of SmartLX's comment. This is a despicable method of constructing an argument. Sadly it appears to be common practice among the most fervently faithful Christians.
The word "now" doesn't mean what you think it means.
Was this a lie?
It's certainly gibberish.
That's an understatement. Gerry loves to jibber jabber and once he makes a phrase he likes, such as; "rote regurgitation of rancid slogans" I can sense the arrogance and further expanding ego. Typical Gerry.
is the nose an objectively existing thing or a concept or both, namely, both in the sense that it exists in objective reality even if man were not around
Proceed as per routines described above, and you will come to the deepest, highest, and widest perspectives of evidence, namely, in its fundamental concept to man in relation to the universe. And verbalize your finding in a few simple clear words which anyone even a child in nursery daycare center understands: Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.
You say:
Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.
And I say:
Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.
Now, to reduce the number of words you use and still retain the thought you want to communicate, instead of saying:
"Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument,"
You say:
"Anything man knows,"
And instead of:
"which makes the claim more likely to be true,"
You say:
leading him to know another thing.
So, what do you say now?
Yrreg
"Man" doesn't have to know something for it to be evidence. That's why criminal investigators talk about finding evidence: before the investigation, there's evidence nobody knows about yet.
Nor does evidence necessarily lead "man" to know anything. It might only lead someone to think something is more likely than before. Also, it might only reinforce something of which people are already aware, without them knowing anything new besides the evidence itself.
Asking for an atheist definition of evidence was a respectable thing to do, but you've essentially ignored its meaning in order to shoehorn in your own definition and launch into your prepared spiel based on that. Furthermore, your definition of evidence has very quickly become a rote regurgitation of a rancid slogan.
After all that, you're just leading into what looks like being either the transcendental or the ontological argument for God. These good people have already heard both, dude.
Anyway folks, sorry for the poor form earlier. To atone, I shall sacrifice some of my anonymity: I'm Alex and I live in Brisbane. G'day.