Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

I am waiting for SmartLX to return and for us to cooperate toward a systematic exposition of evidence.

The man does employ his intelligence to do personal genuine productive thinking and also he can use better verbalization of his thoughts.




Now, let these thoughts be in you all atheists here because it the keeping in your mind is profitable to you toward personal intelligent productive thinking.

In the matter of evidence the questor of evidence must already have an idea of what it is he wants to look for evidence to substantiate in any way possible, i.e. the existence of the object in need of substantiation by evidence.

Phew!? Too heavy for you guys accustomed to only rote regurgitation of rancid slogans?

Exercise in thinking in a personal manner:

The object you are looking for evidence to substantiate the existence of can already be existing but you want to find out whether in a specified location of the time space milieu of the universe* it can and is also found.

What about evidence to the existence of a concept in your mind?

You can string concepts/words together in your mind but that is no evidence that the strung-up assembly in your mind exists as a genuine concept.

An example of a non-genuine concept to my thinking is the concept socalled of infinity.

Think about that.

But the concept fundamental at that of God in the Christian faith in relation to the universe* as the:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself,​

that is a genuine concept in the mind of a conscious intelligent human being.

Think about that, and get the habit of genuine thinking, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

Think about that, namely, what is the fundamental concept of a genuine concept existing in the mind of man in relation to the universe, as opposed to a fake concept.



Yrreg

*Universe for atheists and atheist scientists is delimited to the material or physical universe, but for Christians it is deeper, higher, and broader, it includes realms beyond the material and/or the physical.

But that is okay, I can keep to the material and/or physical universe when I finally come to prove the existence of God from the concurred among mankind on if ever fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.
​

Um, I don't know if I need to point this out for you, but if that particular part in bold is all you've got, well you've just validated the Flying Spaghetti Monster, Allah, Vishnu, Ba'al, the Pantheon...well the list just goes on. And can you believe your God isn't even first in line.



Oh, this is evidence only if evidence can be declared by fiat. And it can't so...you're wrong. Again.

This is referred to as the "ARGUMENT FROM PETULANCE"
(1) GOD EXISTS! HE DOES.. HE DOES HE DOES HE DOES HE DOES stamps feet*
(2) Therefore, God exists.
 
Last edited:
Put this thought into your head:

The fundamental concept of a thing for man in relation to the universe.​

So, everytime you want to truly and completely and exhaustively examine a thing, anything, everything, start from that line above, here reproduced as follows:

The fundamental concept of a thing for man in relation to the universe.​

For example, in the examination and exposition on man's nose, to be truly, completely, and exhaustively involved, you must delve into your nose as a human being, consider it in its most crucially important aspect in your estimation and also in regard to its place in the universe.

That brings in to your intelligent awareness another question more pre-basic than the question of your nose in its fundamental concept for you and in relation to the universe.

The question namely of being, again in its fundamental concept for you in relation to the universe.

If you think to the deepest depth, to the highest height, and to the widest breadth reachable by your intelligence, you will come to the thought that a being can be existing in objective reality even if you were not around, then in regard to your conscious awareness, it can be a concept in your mind, so that insofar as you are a human being with consciousness and intelligence, the universe is composed of two kinds of being, objectively existing things outside man's mind and concepts in man's mind.

So, first question in your inquisition and exposition of man's nose, is the nose an objectively existing thing or a concept or both, namely, both in the sense that it exists in objective reality even if man were not around, and also it exists as a concept in man's mind corresponding to the objective reality of man's nose.

Next, what does the nose mean to man and to the universe where man has his residence in?

At this point atheists will say that it is meaningless, which is a favorite term of Bertrand Russell, that is essentially a cop-out strategy with him when he does not want to go into something, that is not in accordance in the longer terms with his lifestyle.


Find the meaning for you of the nose in your face, and its meaning in regard to the universe of the nose being a part of the universe.

Study it the nose both in its objective existence and also in its conceptual presence in your mind.

See? that is the way to do a stint of genuinely personal thinking on the nose, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.


Now, we come to the thing called evidence.

Proceed as per routines described above, and you will come to the deepest, highest, and widest perspectives of evidence, namely, in its fundamental concept to man in relation to the universe.

And verbalize your finding in a few simple clear words which anyone even a child in nursery daycare center understands:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​



Yrreg

Gerry, this is truly hilarious stuff - are you sure you're not a budding Comic, practicing you're latest skit on us here? I say - very, very funny!! Try it in front of a crowd, see how they respond.

It's either that, or gerry has been reading far too much Gurdjieff - and trying to imitate his style used in that obnoxious book 'Beezebubs Tales to His Grandson'. Anyone who wants to see hundreds of pages of writing just like gerry , check out that book (but check your mind at the door first).

:)
 
Yep, ontological.

It's like the ontological argument in extreme slow motion, so slow that he didn't check to see my reply before he posted.

It seems like the best he can do from here is redefine evidence such that there is "evidence" for God, but in so doing define "evidence" so broadly that there can be "evidence" for something which doesn't exist. And he's dropped "proof" altogether.
 
What about evidence to the existence of a concept in your mind?

All your concepts come from what you have been taught or read (Including the Apostles creed). The very thing you fail to prove in all of your threads: The evidence of an existence of a concept in your mind. This is what makes you incapable of engaging on a personable level.
 
Last edited:
I just took a peek at Yrreg's dictionary.

Evidence,noun-bovine waste product.
 
I am waiting for SmartLX to return and for us to cooperate toward a systematic exposition of evidence.

The man does employ his intelligence to do personal genuine productive thinking and also he can use better verbalization of his thoughts.




Now, let these thoughts be in you all atheists here because it the keeping in your mind is profitable to you toward personal intelligent productive thinking.

In the matter of evidence the questor of evidence must already have an idea of what it is he wants to look for evidence to substantiate in any way possible, i.e. the existence of the object in need of substantiation by evidence.

Phew!? Too heavy for you guys accustomed to only rote regurgitation of rancid slogans?

Exercise in thinking in a personal manner:

The object you are looking for evidence to substantiate the existence of can already be existing but you want to find out whether in a specified location of the time space milieu of the universe* it can and is also found.

What about evidence to the existence of a concept in your mind?

You can string concepts/words together in your mind but that is no evidence that the strung-up assembly in your mind exists as a genuine concept.

An example of a non-genuine concept to my thinking is the concept socalled of infinity.

Think about that.

But the concept fundamental at that of God in the Christian faith in relation to the universe* as the:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself,​

that is a genuine concept in the mind of a conscious intelligent human being.

Think about that, and get the habit of genuine thinking, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.

Think about that, namely, what is the fundamental concept of a genuine concept existing in the mind of man in relation to the universe, as opposed to a fake concept.



Yrreg

*Universe for atheists and atheist scientists is delimited to the material or physical universe, but for Christians it is deeper, higher, and broader, it includes realms beyond the material and/or the physical.

But that is okay, I can keep to the material and/or physical universe when I finally come to prove the existence of God from the concurred among mankind on if ever fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.
​

So-called concept of infinity? We can add maths to the long list of subjects that you know nothing about. The rest of your post is pure Yrreg comedy gold. Keep 'em coming.
 
Last edited:
As Yogi Berra -who probably held a chair in Gerry's alma mater- once said: "This is déjà vu all over again". The only difference are the arguments from Acme that the coyote -theistus rabidus- is using.

One day people will understand once and for all that yrregular thinking is based in a "discovery" over which yrregular thinkers have come across by divine inspiration while they were removing fluff from their navels. If you want to know what the "discovery" is, you must agree upon the terms proposed: you agree there's a god behind this big-bang-big-crunch state of affairs and they'll award you by sharing their "discovery". Playing the rational person only will keep you apart from the "discovery".

If you take a being whose behaviour shows a positive theotaxia, contesting that by means of real reason won't make the taxia evolve into intelligence.

I rather prefer...

beep, beep!
 
So-called concept of infinity? We can add maths to the long list of subjects that you know nothing about.


Can infinity be observed? I mean, I look at a ruler and I know that between 1" and 2" inches are an infinite number of points. And I'm looking at the ruler; I can see all the space between 1 and 2. But am I actually observing infinity?

Infinity also doesn't appear testable, because the test would never end. If I asked a computer to spit out the digits of Pi, it would never be done. So, I couldn't call infinity proven by that method.

It is provable as a concept in math. It is necessarily true if our other math conditions are true. However, it's still not observed, just inferred.

I would say that infinity is a pure concept, existing nowhere but in human thought. That is not changed by the fact that it is consistent with all observable evidence shows it is likely true (so likely that we can just accept it to be true).

Or perhaps you were responding to the "so-called" part of Gerry's statement. If so, please accept my apologies for trying to discuss something of consequence in a Yrreg thread.
 
...snip...

Or perhaps you were responding to the "so-called" part of Gerry's statement. If so, please accept my apologies for trying to discuss something of consequence in a Yrreg thread.
If there's something of consequence in a yrreg thread I want it caught and shot! :p
 
Can infinity be observed? I mean, I look at a ruler and I know that between 1" and 2" inches are an infinite number of points. And I'm looking at the ruler; I can see all the space between 1 and 2. But am I actually observing infinity?

Infinity also doesn't appear testable, because the test would never end. If I asked a computer to spit out the digits of Pi, it would never be done. So, I couldn't call infinity proven by that method.

It is provable as a concept in math. It is necessarily true if our other math conditions are true. However, it's still not observed, just inferred.

I would say that infinity is a pure concept, existing nowhere but in human thought. That is not changed by the fact that it is consistent with all observable evidence shows it is likely true (so likely that we can just accept it to be true).

Or perhaps you were responding to the "so-called" part of Gerry's statement. If so, please accept my apologies for trying to discuss something of consequence in a Yrreg thread.

I object to the so-called. The noise you can hear in the background is Cantor spinning in his grave.
 
*Universe for atheists and atheist scientists is delimited to the material or physical universe, but for Christians it is deeper, higher, and broader, it includes realms beyond the material and/or the physical.


Humble.



It's like the ontological argument in extreme slow motion, so slow that he didn't check to see my reply before he posted.

It seems like the best he can do from here is redefine evidence such that there is "evidence" for God, but in so doing define "evidence" so broadly that there can be "evidence" for something which doesn't exist. And he's dropped "proof" altogether.


4 posts in, and you've already got yrreg figured. Stick around, enjoy the show. Pop into an Edge or a DOC thread. They're good fun too.

Personally, though, my favourite "yrreg's proof for god" has to be Hokulele's* penis. Both are equally extant.


*Sorry for reminding you about that episode, Hok.
 
Yrregular thinking is highly entertaining. Are you going to post some evidence soon Yrreg?
 
Yrreg you may want to check the bottom of the previous page as SmartLX did respond to your previous post. Also, you may want to avoid rewriting other people's well-thought-out responses to match your own, when you've been told that your own definition of evidence is vague and completely meaningless. Just a tip.

Btw, welcome to the forum, SmartLX. I hope Yrreg responds to your examples of evidence and proof. They seem to be above his nursery school comfort level, so it may not happen. :)

Also, this:

*Universe for atheists and atheist scientists is delimited to the material or physical universe, but for Christians it is deeper, higher, and broader, it includes realms beyond the material and/or the physical.
Yes, many Christians seem to be perpetually standing deeper in a broad, high pile of steaming B.S., but somehow it brings them comfort that physical reality can't. "Our navel gazings mean something that you evil atheists just don't understand because you won't open your eyes to the evidence......" Good observation though, that many Christians don't feel fulfilled unless they believe that they're pawns in a supernatural battle of good and evil. Why bother yourself with real life in the here and now when there's all this cool stuff happening that nobody can see?
 
Yrregular thinking is highly entertaining. Are you going to post some evidence soon Yrreg?
He will continue to post with the characteristic slow stride he acquired once he discovered there's a superior power here -moderators- that can got him struck banned.

I'm sure his epistemological reassurance is the idea of being there, at the end of the dark tunnel where the blinding glare is, to greet us "I told you so" with a sanctimonious grin. That's the hard evidence every believer has; the problem is that they can't produce it now legally. To them, the rest of the debate is immaterial. "Yo do not comprehend" as it used to say another pain in the occiput, now banned.

Because, what the heck is logic to people who could overcome the natural rejection and pain sparked off in humans by a cadaver and turn it into a comforting feeling when that corpse is nailed to a pair of logs? And they keep telling advertising and graphic design are modern inventions!

These yrregular threads advance with a pace set by their yrregulars. Mr Y says A and a lot of people contest that. The thread evolves, loses momentum and becomes stagnated. Mr Y reappears with a new post just to let the wheel revolve once again. I wonder, who is the people doing well according to human basic standards? Who is the fly bouncing off the window glass, over and over,by thinking it's air?
 
Put this thought into your head:

The fundamental concept of a thing for man in relation to the universe.​

So, everytime you want to truly and completely and exhaustively examine a thing, anything, everything, start from that line above, here reproduced as follows:

The fundamental concept of a thing for man in relation to the universe.​

For example, in the examination and exposition on man's nose, to be truly, completely, and exhaustively involved, you must delve into your nose as a human being, consider it in its most crucially important aspect in your estimation and also in regard to its place in the universe.

That brings in to your intelligent awareness another question more pre-basic than the question of your nose in its fundamental concept for you and in relation to the universe.

The question namely of being, again in its fundamental concept for you in relation to the universe.

If you think to the deepest depth, to the highest height, and to the widest breadth reachable by your intelligence, you will come to the thought that a being can be existing in objective reality even if you were not around, then in regard to your conscious awareness, it can be a concept in your mind, so that insofar as you are a human being with consciousness and intelligence, the universe is composed of two kinds of being, objectively existing things outside man's mind and concepts in man's mind.

So, first question in your inquisition and exposition of man's nose, is the nose an objectively existing thing or a concept or both, namely, both in the sense that it exists in objective reality even if man were not around, and also it exists as a concept in man's mind corresponding to the objective reality of man's nose.

Next, what does the nose mean to man and to the universe where man has his residence in?

At this point atheists will say that it is meaningless, which is a favorite term of Bertrand Russell, that is essentially a cop-out strategy with him when he does not want to go into something, that is not in accordance in the longer terms with his lifestyle.


Find the meaning for you of the nose in your face, and its meaning in regard to the universe of the nose being a part of the universe.

Study it the nose both in its objective existence and also in its conceptual presence in your mind.

See? that is the way to do a stint of genuinely personal thinking on the nose, instead of rote regurgitation of rancid slogans.


Now, we come to the thing called evidence.

Proceed as per routines described above, and you will come to the deepest, highest, and widest perspectives of evidence, namely, in its fundamental concept to man in relation to the universe.

And verbalize your finding in a few simple clear words which anyone even a child in nursery daycare center understands:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​



Yrreg

So picking my nose is the way to enlightenment? 'Snot the way I heard it.
 
Can infinity be observed? I mean, I look at a ruler and I know that between 1" and 2" inches are an infinite number of points. And I'm looking at the ruler; I can see all the space between 1 and 2. But am I actually observing infinity?

Infinity also doesn't appear testable, because the test would never end. If I asked a computer to spit out the digits of Pi, it would never be done. So, I couldn't call infinity proven by that method.

It is provable as a concept in math. It is necessarily true if our other math conditions are true. However, it's still not observed, just inferred.

I would say that infinity is a pure concept, existing nowhere but in human thought. That is not changed by the fact that it is consistent with all observable evidence shows it is likely true (so likely that we can just accept it to be true).

Or perhaps you were responding to the "so-called" part of Gerry's statement. If so, please accept my apologies for trying to discuss something of consequence in a Yrreg thread.

Infinity is as real as the square root of -1.
 
Let us now examine two texts on the matter of evidence.

Let us now examine two texts on the matter of evidence.

Yrreg said:
Cf. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7293344&postcount=454

Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

And here is my example of the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe,

the nose in man's face.​

That is just one example representing one kind of evidence but it illustrates perfectly the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe as:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​

Explanation: Man knows the existence of his nose and what he does with it. wherefore it leads him to know about breathing in a living thing that has also what appears to be a nose in its face.

Nose is an existing thing, an object thing; breathing is an existing thing, a process thing.


Man knowing his nose leads him to know breathing in another living thing.

Simple.


Lesson: Anything at all that exists in objective reality or in man's mind as a concept can be a piece of evidence leading him to know another thing.

Okay?


My purpose now is to find out whether atheists can think their way into the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and give one example with explanation on the how and why of their concept of evidence.

Honestly, so far I have not found any exposition on evidence from atheists that is worth the bandwidth it is written on.

And atheists are the most vociferous about evidence in the issue of God or no God.


So, when I have already come to their fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, I will use it to prove that God as the maker of everything that is not God Himself exists in objective reality outside the realm of concepts in man's mind.
.
.​
SmartLX said:
Cf. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7296128#post7296128

In my concept, evidence and proof are indeed connected, but here’s the difference between them:

Evidence for a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim more likely to be true.

Proof of a claim is an object, event or argument which makes the claim certain to be true.

Therefore proof is the ultimate evidence, but evidence is not necessarily proof.

Here are five examples of evidence that would at least make me re-evaluate the probability of a claim:

- A man’s unique dental imprint on a woman’s arm would be evidence that he bit her.
- Markers appearing in the middle of the second pair of human chromosomes, which normally only appear on the ends of chromosomes, are evidence that our (ape) ancestors had one more chromosome pair at one stage, and two of them later fused together.
- A man’s amputated arm growing back seconds after he bathed in the shrine at Lourdes would be evidence for the shrine’s advertised healing properties.
- A prophecy in the Bible which predicted the day and time of three 21st century earthquakes, which then actually happened, would be evidence that its author had some prior knowledge.
- An increase in the number of Christians worldwide which coincided with a similar decrease in the number of atheists would be evidence that non-believers were converting to Christianity in large numbers. (The reality is that Christianity today mostly increases through reproduction or, in some populations unaccustomed to missionaries, at the expense of more established religions.)​

Proof is a lot harder to come by. As absolutes, proofs may only exist in pure mathematics, and even then they rely on axioms which are questioned by some philosophers. Each of the following five examples, however, would be good enough for me in its own context that I would unreservedly accept the given claim:

- Seeing a gaping wound in my leg after an accident, but not feeling any pain after several hours, would be proof that I had lost the feeling in that leg. (The wait would be necessary to make sure I wasn’t simply in shock.)
- If a positive integer is divided by every positive integer between 1 and itself (non-inclusive) and none of the results are integers, that proves the integer is a prime number.
- As JBS Haldane famously said, the discovery of fossilised rabbits from the Precambrian era would prove that there was a serious flaw in the theory of evolution, given that rabbits are thought to have evolved well after the Cambrian era.
- If when we first arrived on Saturn’s moon Titan we found that a stick figure ten kilometres tall had been burnt into the surface by a laser, it would prove that intelligent life had been there before us.
- If there’s an afterlife, its existence is proved to everyone after they die through their own continued existence. (Of course, this is no help to the living.)​
.
.​
Now, read both texts carefully, thoughtfully, and try to find out what each author is heading toward in regard to the fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.

Which text is concerned with the deepest, highest, and widest fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe.

What we must always labor to achieve in knowledge is to come to the deepest, highest, and widest perspectives of a subject of knowledge, like for our present concern, evidence.

Otherwise we are always missing the whole picture and stymieing ourselves in a constricted spot of the totality of existence.

And that is bad for any presumably intelligent human being possessed of conscious reason, bad because it does not add to his fullness of worth as a human being.

But atheists don't have any concern with the worth of man, that is the constricted heart and mind of atheists.



Yrreg
 
Let us now examine two texts on the matter of evidence.
Here is my fundamental concept of evidence for man in relation to the universe:

Anything man knows leading him to know another thing.​


There is a problem with this definition. It leads to those pesky turtles...
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
:turtle:
...all the way down.

.
.
.
.​


By the way, what is it with these random full-stops in the right hand margin?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom