Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

From 'my' perspective, everything is lost.

From your perspective nothing is lost (unless you simply follow your instinctual response).

If you look at it logically, from the materialist standpoint, then nothing is lost regardless of who's perspective it is.

Nick
 
Last edited:
I wonder if the fact that it's a thought experiment with no possible way for it to actually happen at present, is what causes the emotional reaction?

We tell somebody they're going to "die" in the experiment, yet we're using the word "die" in a way that may or may not actually mean "die." Also, since we have no technology to duplicate something exactly down to the atomic level, we have no word for that process. A "copy" means "almost but not quite the same."

And then we get into the more confusing issue (no pun intended) that a comic book actually does contain the same molecules for its whole existence, but a living thing doesn't. So exactly copying and destroying a comic book (you can't, even in theory) and copying and then killing a person (can you?) actually mean two different things, yet we don't really have words to describe the difference.

So the way the question is worded, we're told that we're going to "die" even though the word was never meant for this situation, and then we're told we'll be "copied" even though the word was never meant for that situation either.

When one says an exact copy of a person, does that mean literally the same molecules, as would be required for an exact copy of a comic book? That would be impossible, since they're already being used at the moment of death or by the comic book that will be destroyed.

Or does that mean the exact same type of molecules reassembled in the same way? That's not precisely an exact copy, and wouldn't be exact enough for the comic book, but we might consider it close enough for anything living, since living things are always rearranging molecules anyway.
 
Last edited:
Do you have a belief either way? Which side would you take?

I tend to veer towards Objective reality existing.
The idea of no objective reality leads to solipsism. Solipsism can be tested empirically, or at least, pragmatically:


MRC_Hans' practical test of Solipsism . (tm)
Disclaimer: This experiment might not only bruise your ego, but also your body, so you undertake it entirely at your own risk. I will not be held responsible for any consequences, including, but not limited to, loss of pride, peace of mind, teeth, etc.

1) Find a busy city street.

2) Wait for large aggressive looking male to walk by (generally, the more tattoos, the better).

3) Walk up behind said large aggressive looking male and direct a solid kick at the lower, rear portion of his body.

4) When he turns, tell him: "That was because you mother is so ugly".

5) Observe.

You will soon have tangible evidence for the following:

a) You exist physically.

b) At least one other entity exists physically.

c) You and that other entity are in communication, both abstractly and physically.

d) The other entity probably has a mother.

You may conclude that all your observations are, after all, part of an illusion, but the experience should convince you that you had better treat the illusion as reality .

Good luck!

Hans :D
 
The copy will feel the same. So where's the problem?
So? It's not the original.

So do you think a copy of the Declaration of Independence is the same as the original? It's just words, right? I know it doesn't matter but the original still has emotional significance.
 
These are the sorts of concepts that kept me awake at night as a young halfcentaur on the grassy fields with my stallion of a father dismissing it as nonsense.

As for what is being lost, I would say my emotional involvement would be lost, though perhaps if my double were to know of the details behind it's creation and situation it would feel a corresponding emotional response itself, pity, horror, relief at being the successive doppelganger. But not until the moment we were separate and I was gone and it learned of the exact mechanics. Until that point, having my emotions, it would share the horror of my realization, if in fact I was aware of what was about to happen and had no power to stop the copy and termination.

*
If you look at it logically, from the materialist standpoint, then nothing is lost regardless of who's perspective it is.

Nick

Was someone positing something to the contrary? I was under the implication that the only position of objection to this stance came from exactly outside the position of the purely materialist standpoint. So all we're being called out on is not being purely materialist observers.

*edit* I've been editing to keep from double posting, perhaps I should just post again when I feel I've something to add immediately after posting at the rate things go.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if the fact that it's a thought experiment with no possible way for it to actually happen at present, is what causes the emotional reaction?

We tell somebody they're going to "die" in the experiment, yet we're using the word "die" in a way that may or may not actually mean "die." Also, since we have no technology to duplicate something exactly down to the atomic level, we have no word for that process. A "copy" means "almost but not quite the same."

And then we get into the more confusing issue (no pun intended) that a comic book actually does contain the same molecules for its whole existence, but a living thing doesn't. So exactly copying and destroying a comic book (you can't, even in theory) and copying and then killing a person (can you?) actually mean two different things, yet we don't really have words to describe the difference.

So the way the question is worded, we're told that we're going to "die" even though the word was never meant for this situation, and then we're told we'll be "copied" even though the word was never meant for that situation either.

When one says an exact copy of a person, does that mean literally the same molecules, as would be required for an exact copy of a comic book? That would be impossible, since they're already being used at the moment of death or by the comic book that will be destroyed.

Or does that mean the exact same type of molecules reassembled in the same way? That's not precisely an exact copy, and wouldn't be exact enough for the comic book, but we might consider it close enough for anything living, since living things are always rearranging molecules anyway.
So let's say you were in the Star Trek universe.
The teleporter essentially vaporized the original, copies the information down and reassembles an exact copy in the other teleporter pad.

Practically-nothing has changed. The copy and the original is the exact same thing. Emotionally(at present), I don't like being vaporized despite knowing that another copy will be made. Maybe that hypothetical me could get used to the concept of being vaporized and remade via the teleporter.
 
So? It's not the original.

So do you think a copy of the Declaration of Independence is the same as the original? It's just words, right? I know it doesn't matter but the original still has emotional significance.

We can get attached to things for sure. But I do feel that discussing inanimate objects here is substantially different from examining human beings. Your body is anyway renewing itself on various differing levels all the time. Yet I'm willing to bet that you don't spend your days bereaving the loss of each cell that falls away to be replaced.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Practically-nothing has changed. The copy and the original is the exact same thing. Emotionally(at present), I don't like being vaporized despite knowing that another copy will be made. Maybe that hypothetical me could get used to the concept of being vaporized and remade via the teleporter.

Materialist reasoning has the possibility to overwhelm the instinctual response. If you can see clearly, through applying rationality, that there can be no experiencing self (at least not one that persists) then you teleport in peace.

Nick
 
We can get attached to things for sure. But I do feel that discussing inanimate objects here is substantially different from examining human beings. Your body is anyway completely renewing itself on various differing levels all the time. Yet I'm willing to bet that you don't spend your days bereaving the loss of each cell that falls away to be replaced.
No. I consider it the same thing.

Words in the original documents are equivalent to the memories and information that makes a copy exactly the same as the original. The medium(ie. paper/body) has changed. Practically the essence(words/memories etc) are the same but I still like the original.

There is nothing rational about it. Some people look at Einsteins shoes or Washington's pen with awe. Its a damn shoe and pen. Who cares? For some strange reason we do.

We're not arguing about anything at this point. You seem to have this strange concept that an irrational emotional attachment to the "original" is somehow paradoxical to "materialist logic". Uh...yuh, that's what people have stated. There is nothing logical about it but there is nothing paradoxical about it either.
 
We can get attached to things for sure. But I do feel that discussing inanimate objects here is substantially different from examining human beings. Your body is anyway completely renewing itself on various differing levels all the time. Yet I'm willing to bet that you don't spend your days bereaving the loss of each cell that falls away to be replaced.

Nick

Or the fact that at any given moment your elementary particles are exchanging places with other particles, making you a at all times a fluctuation of copies.
At first I found it spooky and unsettling, now I find it fascinating, one of those things I derive amazement from that make life intriguing.
 
Materialist reasoning has the possibility to overwhelm the instinctual response. If you can see clearly, through applying rationality, that there can be no experiencing self (at least not one that persists) then you teleport in peace.

Nick

Which is what happens every time you watch Star Trek and someone willfully uses the transporter pad.
 
No. I consider it the same thing.

Words in the original documents are equivalent to the memories and information that makes a copy exactly the same as the original. The medium(ie. paper/body) has changed. Practically the essence(words/memories etc) are the same but I still like the original.

Yes. But in the case of a human body the cells are anyway in a state of constant change.

Anyway, how about you imagine that you are now the copy, looking back... would you consider the original paximp to have been superior?

Nick
 
Last edited:
Yes. But in the case of a human body the cells are anyway in a state of constant change.

Anyway, how about you consider that you are now the copy, looking back... would you consider the original paximp to have been superior?
Ahhhh, but do you notice the continuum?
The past "me" has a direct gradual connection to the current "me". Bits of "me" are slowly replaced over time.

A teleported "me" has every molecule replaced at a single moment.

Like I said, practically no difference. Emotionally, I still like the original.
 
Ahhhh, but do you notice the continuum?
The past "me" has a direct gradual connection to the current "me". Bits of "me" are slowly replaced over time.

A teleported "me" has every molecule replaced at a single moment.

Like I said, practically no difference. Emotionally, I still like the original.

So, if you now imagine yourself to be the copy, and you look back... do you consider yourself in some way inferior to the original?

Nick
 
So, if you now imagine yourself to be the copy, and you look back... do you consider yourself in some way inferior to the original?

Nick

I never thought about it like that. Hehe. Thank you for the novel approach.
 
From your perspective nothing is lost (unless you simply follow your instinctual response).

If you look at it logically, from the materialist standpoint, then nothing is lost regardless of who's perspective it is.

Nick

The instinctual response is my perspective. Perspective is based in value; otherwise the word 'perspective' is meaningless. Value derives from emotion. Logic is something we use to solve problems, it is not a perspective.
 
The instinctual response is my perspective. Perspective is based in value; otherwise the word 'perspective' is meaningless. Value derives from emotion. Logic is something we use to solve problems, it is not a perspective.

The instinctual response is an aspect of your perspective. The logical appraisal another one. Perspective is not created solely by emotions. There are thoughts. There is analysis going on in the background.

Nick
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom