Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

I would like to have an original Action Comics number 1 and not a replica.

Me too. I don't want to be replaced by a replica. I don't like it one bit.
If I suddenly teleported outside of a tank of water with my perfect replica trapped within it, I would have an urge to let it die. Or I would shoot it with a gun and leave it on a pile of hats.
 
Last edited:
For sure there's a desire not to die. It's scary. But materialist logic dictates that the fear is invalid, because nothing is lost if you are replaced by the copy. Can you state what you believe would be lost?
The original.
 
Rest assured, neither would your replica!

But can you state just what you believe is being lost in this scenario that causes you to object to it?

Nick

I think that's your problem. I don't claim my desires are based in accuracy and logic. I am not an android or a green blooded hobgoblin.
 
I think that's your problem. I don't claim my desires are based in accuracy and logic. I am not an android or a green blooded hobgoblin.
It seems like Nick is attempting to argue that to have an emotional response that is illogical somehow invalidates the whole "materialistic logic", nevermind that entire premise is illogical.
 
It seems like Nick is attempting to argue that to have an emotional response that is illogical somehow invalidates the whole "materialistic logic", nevermind that entire premise is illogical.
I agree. It seems like this to me(the we-us-collective-I that is halfcentaur)as well.
 
Me too. I don't want to be replaced by a replica. I don't like it one bit.
If I suddenly teleported outside of a tank of water with my perfect replica trapped within it, I would have an urge to let it die. Or I would shoot it with a gun and leave it on a pile of hats.
"The Prestige" Conundrum? I actually brought that up in a similar argument here...about 6months ago I think.
 
Yessir. I liked that movie. I've been meaning to go see Inception.
Not that I am using the movie as a frame of reference to make a point, just musing on the similarities. I don't think anyone is actually arguing that the desire to not be replaced is founded in materialistic logic.
 
Yessir. I liked that movie. I've been meaning to go see Inception.
Not that I am using the movie as a frame of reference to make a point, just musing on the similarities. I don't think anyone is actually arguing that the desire to not be replaced is founded in materialistic logic.
I love Inception.
It was more action oriented than I thought. Great espionage thriller.
The whole dream and memory thing is not exactly original in the world of sci-fi but they did it pretty well and I loved the ambiguous ending(no spoilers).
If you like the Matrix, Inception is really good.

[\end derail]
 
I would consider the disparity between logic and feeling here essentially paradoxical. For it doesn't seem to me, on a feeling level, that it would "make it better" to have an identical copy of me take my place at the moment of death. Yet, materialist logic dictates that in such a scenario no one has been lost. Understanding self as non-persisting is IMO paradoxical for most people.

Nick


Ok. I wouldn't call that a paradox, though.

It doesn't make it better on a strictly feeling level to have a copy made. But I can create a new set of feelings based on what I know to be logically true -- that I am not losing a self.

I think there are simply certain situations in which feeling tends to trump logic. While I logically know that there is no integrated self lost in the process, that knowledge can only mitigate but not eliminate the extremely strong emotion I would have -- being killed.
 
Rest assured, neither would your replica!

But can you state just what you believe is being lost in this scenario that causes you to object to it?

Nick



I can. This local bundle of emotions that has one big one -- the desire not to be killed. Without that emotion, and emotions are always local affairs, the group of genes that help cook what we call "us" would not survive as easily. There is a very good evolutionary argument why I have the feeling of not wanting to die. Knowing in some sense that there is no "I" there doesn't help one bit. The feeling is very real and no amount of logic is going to make it go away.
 
I can. This local bundle of emotions that has one big one -- the desire not to be killed. Without that emotion, and emotions are always local affairs, the group of genes that help cook what we call "us" would not survive as easily. There is a very good evolutionary argument why I have the feeling of not wanting to die. Knowing in some sense that there is no "I" there doesn't help one bit. The feeling is very real and no amount of logic is going to make it go away.
Quite true. We have developed over the eons to protect this bundle of organs right here, not those over there, even if we know there's no difference in the part of our organs that computes such things. Green blooded hobgoblins and androids are free from such boundaries, at least the green blooded hobgoblins train themselves to be. In that sense, I am also striving for a similar freedom, but I would be dishonest were I to claim I've found it.

*And for those who think I am speaking gibberish, just as i was eluding to the movie "the Prestige" for dealing with the concept of our emotional response to perfect replicas, I am also eluding to Doctor Leonard McCoy and his distaste for the transporter pad for the same emotional dilemma, and his distaste for green blooded hobgoblins named Spock.
 
Last edited:
I think that's your problem. I don't claim my desires are based in accuracy and logic. I am not an android or a green blooded hobgoblin.

Actually, it is frequently asserted these days that desires and emotions are anything but illogical. IIRC Cummins called them the "executors of evolutionary logic."

But anyway I'm not asking you to account for your emotions, I'm asking you what you believe is being lost.

Nick
 
I can. This local bundle of emotions that has one big one -- the desire not to be killed. Without that emotion, and emotions are always local affairs, the group of genes that help cook what we call "us" would not survive as easily. There is a very good evolutionary argument why I have the feeling of not wanting to die. Knowing in some sense that there is no "I" there doesn't help one bit. The feeling is very real and no amount of logic is going to make it go away.

I am not asking this and I am not disputing that the emotions are real or that they have developed through evolutionary logic for good reason. I'm asking you what you personally believe is being lost.

You can continue to justify instinctual behaviour, but this is avoiding the question.

Nick
 
I am not asking this and I am not disputing that the emotions are real or that they have developed through evolutionary logic for good reason. I'm asking you what you personally believe is being lost.

You can continue to justify instinctual behaviour, but this is avoiding the question.

Nick


If the question is "what is lost?", then the answer is "not much of anything". Technically the local emotions are lost, but the same emotional responses are going to appear 'over there'.

But I still don't see where there is a paradox. The reason why we act as though something is lost is not based in logic but in instinctual emotional responses.


ETA:

You know, I think I should rephrase that, because it is a framing issue.

From the universe's perspective, or the perspective of anyone outside of 'me', nothing is lost.

From 'my' perspective, everything is lost.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom