Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

Words in the original documents are equivalent to the memories and information that makes a copy exactly the same as the original. The medium(ie. paper/body) has changed. Practically the essence(words/memories etc) are the same but I still like the original.

I don't think you're using "exact copy" to really mean "exact." You're emphasizing that it's primarily about containing the same information, as if typing the Declaration of Independence on a disk is an "exact copy" because it contains the same information.

But that's nowhere near an exact copy. An exact copy would need to contain the very same molecules as the original. Therefore, there can never be an exact copy of the Declaration of Independence, even in a Star Trek world, because its molecules are already in use.

The only way we can even consider an exact copy of a living thing is that its molecules are already changing, so it's less defined by its exact molecules.
 
Last edited:
INW was. Nick

The instinctual response is an aspect of your perspective. The logical appraisal another one. Perspective is not created solely by emotions. There are thoughts. There is analysis going on in the background.

Nick


Of course there are other aspects to a perspective, but the meaning of any perspective comes from the emotions and motivations -- they are the sources of value. So, my perspective is largely a result of my emotional life. So, from my perspective, I will lose everything. Even though I know logically that there is no "I" there in the first place.
 
Of course there are other aspects to a perspective, but the meaning of any perspective comes from the emotions and motivations -- they are the sources of value. So, my perspective is largely a result of my emotional life. So, from my perspective, I will lose everything. Even though I know logically that there is no "I" there in the first place.

That depends on the strength of your rationale against the strength of your logic. It appears similarly reckless to jump out of an aeroplane yet many thousands of parachuters do it nonetheless. Rationally they understand that the parachute will stop them from being splatted on the ground. Of course you can witness parachuting third hand without having to jump, which makes it easier, but nevertheless the same principle can apply.

What you are essentially saying, if I understand you correctly, is that we are all inevitable victims of instinctual responses and that there's nothing logic or understanding can do about this.

Nick
 
Last edited:
That depends on the strength of your rationale against the strength of your logic. It appears similarly reckless to jump out of an aeroplane yet many thousands of parachuters do it nonetheless. Rationally they understand that the parachute will stop them from being splatted on the ground. Of course you can witness parachuting third hand without having to jump, which makes it easier, but nevertheless the same principle can apply.

What you are essentially saying, if I understand you correctly, is that we are all inevitable victims of instinctual responses and that there's nothing logic or understanding can do about this.

Nick



No, no, that is not what I am saying.

What I am giving is a rationale for why people do think the way they do -- why they feel that there is something wrong with the whole transporter thing. The reason is that they instinctually feel that their death is something that they want to avoid. Logically speaking, there is nothing rational in that fear because the same pattern is going to be recreated 'over there'. But the feeling of wanting to avoid death is so strong that it is nearly impossible to shake the feeling that there is something wrong with the whole scenario.

We can certainly mitigate the fear by knowing that nothing is really lost from an outside perspective, but there is always going to be that little niggling issue of "Oops, I'm going to die". That is why Asimov had the robot develop a sense of humor when he was exposed to this dilemma -- he knew the person he was transporting was going to die, which he was strictly forbidden to allow to happen, but that same person would be recreated 'over there', so ultimately all was well.

The problem arises because of subjective perspective and the whole issue of valuation. Human values do not exist independent of people. My values, your values, everything that is actually important to you or I exists in the bundle of emotions that constitute what we call "us". Technically, when the transporter eradicates that bundle of emotions in 'me', "I" will cease to exist. "I" can learn not to be bothered by this by the simple act of being transported many times and seeing that "I" am recreated the same each time. But one of the problems is that I can only have one perspective and the new "me" that is re-created on the other end can never be 100% sure that I am the same as the person who was transported in the first place. I would need to place some faith in the process.

So, technically speaking, the thing that is lost is the local expression of values that constitutes a large part of "who I am" despite the fact that an identical set of the same values will appear over there. That new person 'over there' will be identical to me for all intents and purposes, but it still won't be me because "I" cannot feel what "that other I" feels, even if it is exactly the same thing.
 
No, no, that is not what I am saying.

What I am giving is a rationale for why people do think the way they do -- why they feel that there is something wrong with the whole transporter thing.

Well, I think it's clear that both of us, plus at least a few other posters, understand why people are afraid. It's entirely natural to be afraid. But that to me is not the point. The point for me is to really, on a personal level, examine one's own psyche for what is actually going on - how the mind attempts to rationalise its instinctive fear. The reasons it throws up. Because though doing this we can ourselves become more aware and overcome prejudice. Remember, no one is actually being teletransported. It is simply a thought experiment.

I find it healthy to be able to really put myself mentally in the teleporter pod. The switch is going to flick, this body will die and another at a remote location will take its place. Now, there is fear. What's it actually about on a personal level? What attempts at logic does my mind come up with to rationalise its position? Fascinating to see.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Sadly yes. I had hair then :(

Personally, if I imagine myself the copy and look back, it doesn't seem to me that Nick227#1 was a better or more exciting human being in any way. We are one and we do our thing.

Rationally, I know that there is no persisting self anyway, so the Nick227 that completes this post is many versions on from the one that started it anyhow.

Nick
 
So, if you now imagine yourself to be the copy, and you look back... do you consider yourself in some way inferior to the original?

Nick

We've had this discussion before. If the original is not destroyed in the teleport, then you have two yous. You are not the copy and the copy isn't you, and you're not experiencing both lives. When the original dies, you die. Your copy is an entirely different entity.
 
Personally, if I imagine myself the copy and look back, it doesn't seem to me that Nick227#1 was a better or more exciting human being in any way. We are one and we do our thing.

That's thing. You imagine yourself the copy but you are two different objects with distinct "minds". In a teleporter, You cease to exist.
 
Well, I think it's clear that both of us, plus at least a few other posters, understand why people are afraid. It's entirely natural to be afraid. But that to me is not the point. The point for me is to really, on a personal level, examine one's own psyche for what is actually going on - how the mind attempts to rationalise its instinctive fear. The reasons it throws up. Because though doing this we can ourselves become more aware and overcome prejudice. Remember, no one is actually being teletransported. It is simply a thought experiment.

I find it healthy to be able to really put myself mentally in the teleporter pod. The switch is going to flick, this body will die and another at a remote location will take its place. Now, there is fear. What's it actually about on a personal level? What attempts at logic does my mind come up with to rationalise its position? Fascinating to see.

Nick



Well, that's why even though I know there is an issue with it, I would still go ahead with all the weird scenarios that we propose if they were possible. I would get in the teleporter. I would have my brain patterns copied. Even though the subjective bit is a problem.

I know that there is no 'me' as an integrated self to begin with, but this isn't an issue about my reasoning ability. The fear of death is a purely emotional enterprise -- and that is just a description of the way things are.

The thing we have to watch out for always is that some people want to make more of an issue about the subjective 'experiencer' than is warranted and turn it into a separate 'thing' about which science cannot comment. That is simply wrong.
 
The thing we have to watch out for always is that some people want to make more of an issue about the subjective 'experiencer' than is warranted and turn it into a separate 'thing' about which science cannot comment. That is simply wrong.

Agreed.

Nick
 
You are not the copy and the copy isn't you, and you're not experiencing both lives. When the original dies, you die. Your copy is an entirely different entity.

"You" is a process. And no one is actually "experiencing" anyway. This is materialism.

There is, in actuality, no self that experiences. There merely appears to be. And this appearance can be perfectly replicated. What you have written is asserting dualism.

Nick
 
Last edited:
"You" is a process. And no one is actually "experiencing" anyway. This is materialism.
Man, you seem to love to assert what materialism says. Why is that?
But yup, "you" is a process but your second point is complete and utter garbage, nothing more than a semantic shift.
"You" are "experiencing".
There is, in actuality, no self that experiences. There merely appears to be.
Nope. The "self" is the process. This "self" experiences.
And this appearance can be perfectly replicated.
Yup. So?
The original is still lost.
The copy is not the original no matter how you keep twisting and changing your multiple points.
What you have written is asserting dualism.
No. You may want to recheck your logical train derail.
 
Man, you seem to love to assert what materialism says. Why is that?
But yup, "you" is a process but your second point is complete and utter garbage, nothing more than a semantic shift.
"You" are "experiencing".

"You" and "experience" are both processes that emerge from ancilliary brain processing. In simple sensory consciousness there is no "you" and there is no "experiencing." There is just sensory information. The mind categorizes it into "You" and "not you" as part of its function but this is not innate to sensory consciousness. If you just sit down and watch internally you can see it happening constantly. The mind creates from sensory reality a story about a "me" that is "experiencing." It has been programmed through evolution to do this. But it is just a story.

Nope. The "self" is the process. This "self" experiences.

Both emerge simultaneously from ancilliary processing. The mind constructs a me, presumably as a means to try and create a functional coherence from the vast mass of differing brain organs that comprise the brain. It creates a story about a "me" - a me that is doing things, a me that is experiencing. But this is just a means it has evolved to try and create integrity. And in most matters the difference between the story and the reality do not matter. But in hypothetical situations such as the Teleporter the separation can be seen.

Nick
 
Last edited:
"You" is a process. And no one is actually "experiencing" anyway. This is materialism.

There is, in actuality, no self that experiences. There merely appears to be. And this appearance can be perfectly replicated. What you have written is asserting dualism.

It has nothing to do with dualism. I'm not claiming that there is a soul or some nonsensical thing other than the molecules that are being copied.

But don't forget that one of the parameters of each of those molecules is location. The copy is a different animal from the original. He'll act the same, think the same and appear the same to everybody else, including himself and me, but he won't be me, still.

Why ?

Perhaps, this time, someone can answer this:

If you copy someone but keep the original, will the original feel and experience what the copy feels and experiences ? I assume you'll say "no". If no, then if the original ceases to be, his experiencing stops. Sure, the copy carries on, so to everybody else all is the same. But the original is gone, and has stopped experiencing. If I'm the original, I don't want that to happen: the knowledge that an exact copy of me will endure is no comfort for oblivion.

So far NO ONE has ever adressed that.
 
"You" and "experience" are both processes that emerge from ancilliary brain processing. In simple sensory consciousness there is no "you" and there is no "experiencing." There is just sensory information. The mind categorizes it into "You" and "not you" as part of its function but this is not innate to sensory consciousness. If you just sit down and watch internally you can see it happening constantly. The mind creates from sensory reality a story about a "me" that is "experiencing." It has been programmed through evolution to do this. But it is just a story.



Both emerge simultaneously from ancilliary processing. The mind constructs a me, presumably as a means to try and create a functional coherence from the vast mass of differing brain organs that comprise the brain. It creates a story about a "me" - a me that is doing things, a me that is experiencing. But this is just a means it has evolved to try and create integrity. And in most matters the difference between the story and the reality do not matter. But in hypothetical situations such as the Teleporter the separation can be seen.

Nick



Yes, but meaning only emerges through the story; and what matters evolutionarily is the survival of the individual since the genes can't do it on their own. They reporduce by means of reproducing the entire individual. Hence the strong feeling of not wanting to die and the equally strong feeling that we are all integrated selves.

The fact that this is just a story doesn't help anyone except in terms of thinking about what is going on in the brain.

Life decisions are not made at the level of individual neurons or neural systems. Life decisions concern the individual.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom