That depends on the strength of your rationale against the strength of your logic. It appears similarly reckless to jump out of an aeroplane yet many thousands of parachuters do it nonetheless. Rationally they understand that the parachute will stop them from being splatted on the ground. Of course you can witness parachuting third hand without having to jump, which makes it easier, but nevertheless the same principle can apply.
What you are essentially saying, if I understand you correctly, is that we are all inevitable victims of instinctual responses and that there's nothing logic or understanding can do about this.
Nick
No, no, that is not what I am saying.
What I am giving is a rationale for why people do think the way they do -- why they feel that there is something wrong with the whole transporter thing. The reason is that they instinctually feel that their death is something that they want to avoid. Logically speaking, there is nothing rational in that fear because the same pattern is going to be recreated 'over there'. But the feeling of wanting to avoid death is so strong that it is nearly impossible to shake the feeling that there is something wrong with the whole scenario.
We can certainly mitigate the fear by knowing that nothing is really lost from an outside perspective, but there is always going to be that little niggling issue of "Oops, I'm going to die". That is why Asimov had the robot develop a sense of humor when he was exposed to this dilemma -- he knew the person he was transporting was going to die, which he was strictly forbidden to allow to happen, but that same person would be recreated 'over there', so ultimately all was well.
The problem arises because of subjective perspective and the whole issue of valuation. Human values do not exist independent of people. My values, your values, everything that is actually important to you or I exists in the bundle of emotions that constitute what we call "us". Technically, when the transporter eradicates that bundle of emotions in 'me', "I" will cease to exist. "I" can learn not to be bothered by this by the simple act of being transported many times and seeing that "I" am recreated the same each time. But one of the problems is that I can only have one perspective and the new "me" that is re-created on the other end can never be 100% sure that I am the same as the person who was transported in the first place. I would need to place some faith in the process.
So, technically speaking, the thing that is lost is the local expression of values that constitutes a large part of "who I am" despite the fact that an identical set of the same values will appear over there. That new person 'over there' will be identical to me for all intents and purposes, but it still won't be me because "I" cannot feel what "that other I" feels, even if it is exactly the same thing.