John Boehner tries ruin US - Iran nuclear talks

Both of your points are quite wrong.

First, there was one time that US State Department declared Iran to be inviolation of the NPT. That that was in 2005, and it has not done so since.

And since the US State Department does not have the authority to officially represent the USA, and since that pronouncement is ten years old, therefore one can hardly say now that "official position of the United States is that Iran is in violation of the NPT".

Gee, does Hillary Clinton saying it while Secretary of State in 2010 not count (emphasis added)?

If Iran is coming to say, "We're willing to abide by the non-proliferation treaty," that would be very welcome news. I have a feeling that's not what they're coming to do. I think they're coming to try to divert attention and confuse the issue. And there is no confusion. They have violated the terms of the NPT, they have been held under all kinds of restrictions and obligations that they have not complied with by the IAEA, the International Atomic Energy Agency, by the U.N. Security Council. So we're not going to permit Iran to try to change the, the story from their failure to comply and in any way upset the efforts we are in the midst of, which is to get the international community to adopt a strong Security Council resolution that further isolates them and imposes consequences for their behavior.



Second, it was the CIA who claimed that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003. Therefore, one cannot say that "the claim that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003 is utterly baseless and ridiculous".

It was an utterly bogus, disingenuous, politically-driven, and baseless claim. First of all, do you really think the CIA could say with confidence that Iran wasn't working toward a nuclear weapon? It's like proving a negative. Second, all of the evidence since then proves the original CIA report false. Iran has made tremendous progress towards a nuclear weapon, as reported by DNI Clapper to the Senate Intelligence Committee in 2014. To wit:

Tehran has made technical progress in a number of areas - including uranium enrichment, nuclear reactors, and ballistic missiles - from which it could draw if it wished to build missile-deliverable nuclear weapons.

The claims that you and Tony parrot are extremely disingenuous. There are only two difficulties in making a uranium bomb: (1) enriching uranium to 90% or so, of which enriching to 20% is 95% of the work; and (2) having a missile powerful enough to deliver the heavy payload that a uranium bomb represents. Actually designing a uranium bomb is utterly trivial. I could probably do it myself.

Iran has made tremendous progress in both those areas. The fact that it might not have started machining the pieces for an actual bomb is of zero importance. It could be done in a few days, and a practical bomb could be assembled within a week, provided that the other elements (which our intelligence agencies concede that Iran has progressing on) are in place.
 
Last edited:
And yet pointing out a double standard remains a legitimate form of rebuttal. I stand by my arguments. If people objecting to the idea is a valid basis for criticizing Netanyahu's actions, then it's a valid basis for criticizing Obama's actions. And if it's appropriate to suggest that Netanyahu's actions may be motivated by personal ambition, then it is appropriate to suggest that Obama's actions have the same motivation.

Note that I am not attempting to rebut Tony Stark's argument because he is doing the same thing he criticizes in others, or because Obama is doing the same thing he criticizes in Netanyahu. Rather, I am observing that once again Tony Stark is singling out one instance of a thing as wrong, while ignoring or dismissing other instances that don't serve his partisan bias. I'm not appealing to tu quoque, I'm pointing out special pleading.

If Tony Stark wants us to accept that the Netanyahu case has special significance, then I would like him to present an internally-consistent argument that applies the same reasoning to similar cases on the other side of the partisan divide, showing that they are not similarly significant for reasons other than partisan bias.

Exactly.
 
Gee, does Hillary Clinton saying it while Secretary of State in 2010 not count (emphasis added)?

She said "have" not "is". So you have no point.

It was an utterly bogus, disingenuous, politically-driven, and baseless claim. First of all, do you really think the CIA could say with confidence that Iran wasn't working toward a nuclear weapon? It's like proving a negative. Second, all of the evidence since then proves the original CIA report false. Iran has made tremendous progress towards a nuclear weapon, as reported by DNI Clapper to the Senate Intelligence Committee in 2014. To wit:



The claims that you and Tony parrot are extremely disingenuous. There are only two difficulties in making a uranium bomb: (1) enriching uranium to 90% or so, of which enriching to 20% is 95% of the work; and (2) having a missile powerful enough to deliver the heavy payload that a uranium bomb represents. Actually designing a uranium is utterly trivial. I could probably do it myself.

Iran has made tremendous progress in both those areas. The fact that it might not have started machining the pieces for an actual bomb is of zero importance. It could be done in a few days, and a practical bomb could be assembled within a week, provided that the other elements (which our intelligence agencies concede that Iran has progressing on) are in place.


They are legally allowed to enrich uranium and build reactors under the NPT.

Again, you have no point.
 
Gee, does Hillary Clinton saying it while Secretary of State in 2010 not count (emphasis added)?

Read your own citations.

Clinton was speaking what Iran had done in the the past, not about what Iran was doing at that the time she gave the interview.

It was an utterly bogus, disingenuous, politically-driven, and baseless claim. First of all, do you really think the CIA could say with confidence that Iran wasn't working toward a nuclear weapon? It's like proving a negative. Second, all of the evidence since then proves the original CIA report false. Iran has made tremendous progress towards a nuclear weapon, as reported by DNI Clapper to the Senate Intelligence Committee in 2014. To wit:

Read your own citations.

Clapper was speaking what Iran as doing in the past as opposed to what is going on now.

The claims that you and Tony parrot are extremely disingenuous. There are only two difficulties in making a uranium bomb: (1) enriching uranium to 90% or so, of which enriching to 20% is 95% of the work; and (2) having a missile powerful enough to deliver the heavy payload that a uranium bomb represents. Actually designing a uranium bomb is utterly trivial. I could probably do it myself.

Iran has made tremendous progress in both those areas. The fact that it might not have started machining the pieces for an actual bomb is of zero importance. It could be done in a few days, and a practical bomb could be assembled within a week, provided that the other elements (which our intelligence agencies concede that Iran has progressing on) are in place.

Well, if it so easy to make a nuclear bomb, then go ahead and make one.

If you did such a thing, then I (and quite a few other people) would take your ravings more seriously.
 
She said "have" not "is". So you have no point.

LOL. I don't think Hillary has the same problem that her husband does with being hyper-technical about tense.

That is not true. That is not true. I did not ask anyone to tell anything other than the truth. There is no improper relationship. And I intend to cooperate with this inquiry. But that is not true.



Your specious argument brought back some good memories. So, thanks for that.

They are legally allowed to enrich uranium and build reactors under the NPT.

Tony, you should tell the IAEA straight away. All of this scrutiny and negotiating with Iran has obviously been just a big misunderstanding.
 
LOL. I don't think Hillary has the same problem that her husband does with being hyper-technical about tense.





Your specious argument brought back some good memories. So, thanks for that.

There is a difference between past and present tense. She was referring to past behavior. Clear by her choice of words.

You're wrong. The end.

Tony, you should tell the IAEA straight away. All of this scrutiny and negotiating with Iran has obviously been just a big misunderstanding.

The IAEA knows that Iran is allowed to enrich uranium and build reactors. No need for me to tell them.
 
It isn't special pleading because the President in fact shapes United States foreign policy not the Speaker of the House and the Prime Minister of Israel.

I'm pretty sure the Prime Minister of Israel is not constrained to silence on the subject of US foreign policy.

And the President's authority in this domain is not absolute, nor is his power entirely without checks and balances. In a democracy, the unity and support of the legislature, and of the people they represent, actually matters to the success of the President's goals. If the President's foreign policy is in jeopardy not only because of dissent among the leaders of allied nations, but also within his own legislature, it's not because the dissenters are overstepping their bounds (they're not, and you insisting that they are won't make it so), but because he has failed to pursue a policy that is secure it its support from those quarters. He has either failed to get the necessary support, or he has failed to identify and pursue a policy that would be supported.

The President has great powers, it is true, but one of the powers he does not have is to impose his singular and unpopular vision upon the nation without opposition.
 
And several other groups, including the government of Israel, think that Obama's policy towards Iran is a bad idea. So what?

People in Bibi's own party..who are skeptical about Obama's approach to Iran... are criticising him for what looks like taking sides in US Partisan Politics. The policy of Israel has been, in lobbying in the US,to have a strictly non partisan approach;they don't care if you are a Democrat or a Republcan, Liberal or Conservative, if you support Israel you are considered a friend. Now Bibi is flushing that down the toilets. There are better methods of opposing a US policy they don't like.
THere is a long history of foreign leaders who have tried to dabble in US Partisan politics. They always burn their fingers.
 
Does this just apply to Republicans undermining a Democrat? Or does it also apply the other way? Do you consider Pelosi a criminal for her trip to Syria in 2007?

---------------------------
http://www.cnn.com/2007/POLITICS/04/04/carter.pelosi/

Bush on Tuesday called the trip "counterproductive" and said it would send mixed signals.

"Photo opportunities and/or meetings with President Assad lead the Assad government to believe they're part of the mainstream of the international community, when, in fact, they're a state sponsor of terror," he said at a news conference in the White House's Rose Garden.

Carter, however, said there was "no threat" that the Democratic speaker's visit would dilute the United States' ability to speak to Syria with one voice.
----------------------------

Who cares what Bush has to say?

George W. Bush was the absolute worst President that we have ever had.

He is stupid, he is idiotic, and he is a liar.

He tortured hundreds, killed hundreds of thousands, and could not be bothered to end his vacation a bit early when Hurricane Katrina hit.
 
People in Bibi's own party..who are skeptical about Obama's approach to Iran... are criticising him for what looks like taking sides in US Partisan Politics. The policy of Israel has been, in lobbying in the US,to have a strictly non partisan approach;they don't care if you are a Democrat or a Republcan, Liberal or Conservative, if you support Israel you are considered a friend. Now Bibi is flushing that down the toilets. There are better methods of opposing a US policy they don't like.
THere is a long history of foreign leaders who have tried to dabble in US Partisan politics. They always burn their fingers.

Those are good points. What I am trying to discern in Tony's argument, is whether he is saying that Netanyahu should desist because people oppose him, or he is saying that Netanyahu should desist because the people who oppose him have good reasons for him to desist.

If it's the former, then it looks like a glaringly partisan double standard, since Tony's argument insists that Obama should persevere in spite of people also opposing him. If it's the latter, then Tony should bolster his argument by examining the reasons for opposing Netanyahu, rather than repeatedly insisting that Netanyahu's actions are somehow illegitimate.

As for the opposition to Obama, Tony's argument ignores any consideration of the merits of the policy itself, and instead depends entirely on asserting that opposition to the president is simply not allowed. On that point, I think we're at an impasse.
 
Who cares what Bush has to say?

George W. Bush was the absolute worst President that we have ever had.

He is stupid, he is idiotic, and he is a liar.

He tortured hundreds, killed hundreds of thousands, and could not be bothered to end his vacation a bit early when Hurricane Katrina hit.

Thank you for illustrating my point about partisanship.
 
Those are good points. What I am trying to discern in Tony's argument, is whether he is saying that Netanyahu should desist because people oppose him, or he is saying that Netanyahu should desist because the people who oppose him have good reasons for him to desist.

If it's the former, then it looks like a glaringly partisan double standard, since Tony's argument insists that Obama should persevere in spite of people also opposing him. If it's the latter, then Tony should bolster his argument by examining the reasons for opposing Netanyahu, rather than repeatedly insisting that Netanyahu's actions are somehow illegitimate.

As for the opposition to Obama, Tony's argument ignores any consideration of the merits of the policy itself, and instead depends entirely on asserting that opposition to the president is simply not allowed. On that point, I think we're at an impasse.

He should desist because it is completely outrageous and stupid for the leader of a foreign who closest ally is the United States to conspire with Republicans (or Democrats it that was actually the case) to undermine the President of the United States. At least if he cares about the support of the United States. No matter how much Bibi may wish it were different, Obama is the President of the United States. And it is with Obama that he (or his successor) must work with regards to Iran for the next two years (and probably Hillary Clinton after that).

If Bibi disagrees with Obama, he can tell Obama/Kerry/US ambassador to Israel. If he fails to be convincing, tough ****.

Thank you for illustrating my point about partisanship.

Bush was in fact a terrible President not to mention war criminal. It is Republicans that are the hyper partisans if they cant admit that.
 
Congress has no power to negotiate with foreign countries.

They can enact sanctions/embargoes. But President Obama already said he would veto those. And I doubt that Republicans are going to be able to pick off 13 Democratic Senators needed overturn it unless talks fail.

They could also declare war. If it turns out that Republicans are that crazy, Obama, he better damn well veto their declaration.



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_agreement

What is deal that the President can make that isn't going to include some sort of trade or lack of trade or an reductions in sanctions? Which is exactly in the wheelhouse of Congress. And just because the President calls it an executive agreement doesn't mean it is one. If Congress is the one creating embargoes and sanctions, as you have pointed out, shouldn't the removal of the same be done by the same body? Because that is what this talk is all about. The removing of those sanctions for dismantling. Some might even call that to be part of that whole "regulate commerce with foreign nations" thing since it's largely a trade.

But I asked you why it wasn't a treaty. An answer I'm still waiting on.
 
What is deal that the President can make that isn't going to include some sort of trade or lack of trade or an reductions in sanctions? Which is exactly in the wheelhouse of Congress. And just because the President calls it an executive agreement doesn't mean it is one. If Congress is the one creating embargoes and sanctions, as you have pointed out, shouldn't the removal of the same be done by the same body? Because that is what this talk is all about. The removing of those sanctions for dismantling. Some might even call that to be part of that whole "regulate commerce with foreign nations" thing since it's largely a trade.

But I asked you why it wasn't a treaty. An answer I'm still waiting on.

Congress gave the President the power to lift sanctions.

SEC. 8. TERMINATION OF SANCTIONS.

(a) IRAN- The requirement under section 5(a) to impose sanctions shall no longer have force or effect with respect to Iran if the President determines and certifies to the appropriate congressional committees that Iran--
(1) has ceased its efforts to design, develop, manufacture, or acquire--
(A) a nuclear explosive device or related materials and technology;
(B) chemical and biological weapons; and
(C) ballistic missiles and ballistic missile launch technology; and
(2) has been removed from the list of countries the governments of which have been determined, for purposes of section 6(j) of the Export Administration Act of 1979, to have repeatedly provided support for acts of international terrorism.

http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c104:1:./temp/~c104gzzlwx:e16724:
 
To anybody who thinks that Bibi is even remotely credible: He's not. He told Congress back in 2002 that there was "no question" that Iraq was developing nuclear weapons. This of course turned out to be a lie.

 
Congress gave the President the power to lift sanctions.



http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/F?c104:1:./temp/~c104gzzlwx:e16724:

Did you miss the part about certifying to congressional committees? Congress has a role. Congress has to accept the certification. And I would doubt that you would agree that Iran has met every condition put forth in your link.

Also, lift is not the same as renegotiate. To lift the sanctions all of the components would have to have been met. It was all or nothing. That isn't what the President is trying to do. He is trying to find a path to it, but that would be require a change to the current deal. Hence the problem and question I put to you.

How is the President, in trying to cut a new deal with Iran, not creating a treaty?
 
Did you miss the part about certifying to congressional committees? Congress has a role. Congress has to accept the certification. And I would doubt that you would agree that Iran has met every condition put forth in your link.

It says nothing about Congress accepting anything. You just made that up.

Also, lift is not the same as renegotiate. To lift the sanctions all of the components would have to have been met. It was all or nothing. That isn't what the President is trying to do. He is trying to find a path to it, but that would be require a change to the current deal. Hence the problem and question I put to you.

How is the President, in trying to cut a new deal with Iran, not creating a treaty?

He's not trying to renegotiate any treaty with then. He's trying to make sure they follow the NPT. And if they are, he will drop sanctions. Something Congress empowered him to do at his discretion.

You have nothing.
 
It says nothing about Congress accepting anything. You just made that up.



He's not trying to renegotiate any treaty with then. He's trying to make sure they follow the NPT. And if they are, he will drop sanctions. Something Congress empowered him to do at his discretion.

You have nothing.

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/20/u...-an-iran-deal-that-could-avoid-congress-.html


NY Times said:
“But Mr. Obama cannot permanently terminate those sanctions. Only Congress can take that step. And even if Democrats held on to the Senate next month, Mr. Obama’s advisers have concluded they would probably lose such a vote,” The Times wrote.

And the efforts of a President intentionally designed to sidestep the Congress should bother you no matter which team is holding which seat.
 
Last edited:
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/20/u...-an-iran-deal-that-could-avoid-congress-.html




And the efforts of a President intentionally designed to sidestep the Congress should bother you no matter which team is holding which seat.

Thanks for further proving that it isn't a treaty. Whatever deal Obama negotiates could in fact be undone by the next President. And if the American people are so stupid as to put a Republican in the White House in 2016, it probably will be.

PS: **** Congress. It is a dysfunctional joke. Thanks, of course, to Republicans.

There is a reason its approval ratings are in the teens
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom