sunmaster14
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2014
- Messages
- 10,017
Both of your points are quite wrong.
First, there was one time that US State Department declared Iran to be inviolation of the NPT. That that was in 2005, and it has not done so since.
And since the US State Department does not have the authority to officially represent the USA, and since that pronouncement is ten years old, therefore one can hardly say now that "official position of the United States is that Iran is in violation of the NPT".
Gee, does Hillary Clinton saying it while Secretary of State in 2010 not count (emphasis added)?
If Iran is coming to say, "We're willing to abide by the non-proliferation treaty," that would be very welcome news. I have a feeling that's not what they're coming to do. I think they're coming to try to divert attention and confuse the issue. And there is no confusion. They have violated the terms of the NPT, they have been held under all kinds of restrictions and obligations that they have not complied with by the IAEA, the International Atomic Energy Agency, by the U.N. Security Council. So we're not going to permit Iran to try to change the, the story from their failure to comply and in any way upset the efforts we are in the midst of, which is to get the international community to adopt a strong Security Council resolution that further isolates them and imposes consequences for their behavior.
Second, it was the CIA who claimed that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003. Therefore, one cannot say that "the claim that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003 is utterly baseless and ridiculous".
It was an utterly bogus, disingenuous, politically-driven, and baseless claim. First of all, do you really think the CIA could say with confidence that Iran wasn't working toward a nuclear weapon? It's like proving a negative. Second, all of the evidence since then proves the original CIA report false. Iran has made tremendous progress towards a nuclear weapon, as reported by DNI Clapper to the Senate Intelligence Committee in 2014. To wit:
Tehran has made technical progress in a number of areas - including uranium enrichment, nuclear reactors, and ballistic missiles - from which it could draw if it wished to build missile-deliverable nuclear weapons.
The claims that you and Tony parrot are extremely disingenuous. There are only two difficulties in making a uranium bomb: (1) enriching uranium to 90% or so, of which enriching to 20% is 95% of the work; and (2) having a missile powerful enough to deliver the heavy payload that a uranium bomb represents. Actually designing a uranium bomb is utterly trivial. I could probably do it myself.
Iran has made tremendous progress in both those areas. The fact that it might not have started machining the pieces for an actual bomb is of zero importance. It could be done in a few days, and a practical bomb could be assembled within a week, provided that the other elements (which our intelligence agencies concede that Iran has progressing on) are in place.
Last edited: