theprestige
Penultimate Amazing
NVM
Why so binary? Is everyone either a democrat or republican? If you don't like partisanship perhaps you shouldn't characterize everyone as a partisan. Just sayin.As usual, the discussion is strictly along partisan lines. Of course, that's easier than other such discussions because this is obviously a "Republican" play and not an individual one.
Thanks for further proving that it isn't a treaty. Whatever deal Obama negotiates could in fact be undone by the next President. And if the American people are so stupid as to put a Republican in the White House in 2016, it probably will be.
PS: **** Congress. It is a dysfunctional joke. Thanks, of course, to Republicans.
There is a reason its approval ratings are in the teens
I'm sorry, you lost me here. How does this prove it's not a treaty since Congress makes treaties and Congress is the only one who can remove the sanctions?
If Congress is the one who makes and removes sanctions, how can this undo anything Obama does as it was Congress is the body who does it?
How does this prove Congress is dysfunctional?
What happened to the goalpost in that Congress has no role in this process?
What does the approval ranking of Congress have to do with their role in the process?
It isn't that complicated. Congress is the only one that can permanently remove the sanctions by repealing the sanctions bills. But the President isn't trying to permanently remove them. He is trying to use power that Congress gave him to temporarily lift sanctions. The lifting could be reversed by the next President or even by him.
Congress, specifically Republicans in Congress, can go screw themselves. They have done nothing since 2010 (though they have tried to repeal Obamacare 56 times). I don't give a crap what they think. And neither does the President. The fact of the matter is that they cannot force their will upon the President, the country, or the world without either the President agreeing or a bunch of Democrats turning on the President. All Republicans can do is cry about not getting their way. I actually expect to see a lot of that in the next two years. Should be pretty funny.
![]()
So Congress has a role now?
The President is trying to renegotiate the sanctions. A power he does not have. The only 2 reasons I can think to even be having these talks are either to compel Iran into capitulating to the terms of the sanctions or to change them. Both of which require Congressional action. He is there to accomplish something. To take an actions about the sanctions and the Iranian nuclear programs. It's not a social visit. And it's not to give a 90 day reprieve. It's to cut a long lasting deal and solve this decades old issue with Iran.
The President is looking for a long term solution. A 90 day solution is a massive waste of time and I guess I think more of the President than you do as I would never suggest he was working so hard to accomplish something so mundane.
Also, no, the next President could not reverse the removal of sanctions because sanctions can only be imposed by Congress just as they can only be lifted by Congress. According to the Times link I posted, the President can only ease the sanctions for 90 days.
As far as the ACA goes, or your opinions of Congress, or whatever, this doesn't change the fact that what they President is trying to do is to go around Congress. You started this thread because you thought Congress was subverting the process. Should I expect one about how the President is trying to subvert the sanctions? I'm guessing the outrage only flows in one direction.
Not only, as we have shown, is the federal power over external affairs in origin and essential character different from that over internal affairs, but participation in the exercise of the power is significantly limited. In this vast external realm, with its important, complicated, delicate and manifold problems, the President alone has the power to speak or listen as a representative of the nation. He makes treaties with the advice and consent of the Senate; but he alone negotiates. Into the field of negotiation the Senate cannot intrude; and Congress itself is powerless to invade it. As Marshall said in his great argument of March 7, 1800, in the House of Representatives, "The President is the sole organ of the nation in its external relations, and its sole representative with foreign nations." The Senate Committee on Foreign Relations at a very early day in our history (February 15, 1816), reported to the Senate, among other things, as follows:
"The President is the constitutional representative of the United States with regard to foreign nations. He manages our concerns with foreign nations and must necessarily be most competent to determine when, how, and upon what subjects negotiation may be urged with the greatest prospect of success. For his conduct he is responsible to the Constitution. The committee consider this responsibility the surest pledge for the faithful discharge of his duty. They think the interference of the Senate in the direction of foreign negotiations calculated to diminish that responsibility and thereby to impair the best security for the national safety. The nature of transactions with foreign nations, moreover, requires caution and unity of design, and their success frequently depends on secrecy and dispatch."
It is important to bear in mind that we are here dealing not alone with an authority vested in the President by an exertion of legislative power, but with such an authority plus the very delicate, plenary and exclusive power of the President as the sole organ of the federal government in the field of international relations — a power which does not require as a basis for its exercise an act of Congress, but which, of course, like every other governmental power, must be exercised in subordination to the applicable provisions of the Constitution. It is quite apparent that if, in the maintenance of our international relations, embarrassment — perhaps serious embarrassment — is to be avoided and success for our aims achieved, congressional legislation which is to be made effective through negotiation and inquiry within the international field must often accord to the President a degree of discretion and freedom from statutory restriction which would not be admissible were domestic affairs alone involved. Moreover, he, not Congress, has the better opportunity of knowing the conditions which prevail in foreign countries, and especially is this true in time of war. He has his confidential sources of information. He has his agents in the form of diplomatic, consular and other officials. Secrecy in respect of information gathered by them may be highly necessary, and the premature disclosure of it productive of harmful results. Indeed, so clearly is this true that the first President refused to accede to a request to lay before the House of Representatives the instructions, correspondence and documents relating to the negotiation of the Jay Treaty — a refusal the wisdom of which was recognized by the House itself and has never since been doubted. In his reply to the request, President Washington said:
"The nature of foreign negotiations requires caution, and their success must often depend on secrecy; and even when brought to a conclusion a full disclosure of all the measures, demands, or eventual concessions which may have been proposed or contemplated would be extremely impolitic; for this might have a pernicious influence on future negotiations, or produce immediate inconveniences, perhaps danger and mischief, in relation to other powers. The necessity of such caution and secrecy was one cogent reason for vesting the power of making treaties in the President, with the advice and consent of the Senate, the principle on which that body was formed confining it to a small number of members. To admit, then, a right in the House of Representatives to demand and to have as a matter of course all the papers respecting a negotiation with a foreign power would be to establish a dangerous precedent."
...
When the President is to be authorized by legislation to act in respect of a matter intended to affect a situation in foreign territory, the legislator properly bears in mind the important consideration that the form of the President's action — or, indeed, whether he shall act at all — may well depend, among other things, upon the nature of the confidential information which he has or may thereafter receive, or upon the effect which his action may have upon our foreign relations. This consideration, in connection with what we have already said on the subject, discloses the unwisdom of requiring Congress in this field of governmental power to lay down narrowly definite standards by which the President is to be governed.
...
Practically every volume of the United States Statutes contains one or more acts or joint resolutions of Congress authorizing action by the President in respect of subjects affecting foreign relations, which either leave the exercise of the power to his unrestricted judgment, or provide a standard far more general than that which has always been considered requisite with regard to domestic affairs. Many, though not all, of these acts are designated in the footnote.[2]
...It is enough to summarize by saying that, both upon principle and in accordance with precedent, we conclude there is sufficient warrant for the broad discretion vested in the President to determine whether the enforcement of the statute will have a beneficial effect upon the reestablishment of peace in the affected countries; whether he shall make proclamation to bring the resolution into operation; whether and when the resolution shall cease to operate and to make proclamation accordingly; and to prescribe limitations and exceptions to which the enforcement of the resolution shall be subject.
[2] Thus, the President has been broadly "authorized" to suspend embargo acts passed by Congress, "if in his judgment the public interest should require it" or if, "in the judgment of the President," there has been such suspension of hostilities abroad as may render commerce of the United States sufficiently safe....
Congress has also passed acts for the enforcement of treaties or conventions, to be effective only upon proclamation of the President. Some of them may be noted which "authorize" the President to make proclamation when he shall be "satisfied" or shall receive "satisfactory evidence" that the other nation has complied....
But as I already said, Obama is not negotiating a treaty with Iran. It will almost certainly be an executive agreement where he agrees to waive sanctions if they agree to his terms. It isn't a treaty because he has the power to waive sanctions with his own authority as the President. Similarly it is not a subversion of Congress’s power for him to do this because
He can't waive the sanctions without Congress which was covered in the NY Times link. He can't create new terms without the advice and consent of the Senate which was covered in your highlight. He can't unilaterally do what you are suggesting.
The President may waive the application of sanctions...if the President determines that such a waiver is in the national interest of the United States.
So it looks like (and I may be a cynic here) that "the opposition party is convening a special session of Congress so that a foreign leader, on the floor of our national legislature, can rebuke the foreign policy of our president."
Looks like it.
Nah, gotta be something else.
Why can't it be exactly what it looks like to you?
Why can't it be exactly what it looks like to you?
Pretty sure he was being sarcastic...
I get your sarcasm, but I think I'm still missing your point. We already know that the Republicans invited Netanyahu to speak against Obama's policy before Congress. As far as I can tell, all you're doing is restating the OP in Opposite Day Language. Did I miss some novel insight you were providing? Was there some argument in this thread you were trying to refute?Because Republicans would never do something like that.
In 1995, Netanyahu wrote that Iran would have a nuclear weapon in “three to five years,” and, in 1996, speaking before a joint session of Congress, he warned that the deadline for Iran acquiring a nuclear weapon was “getting extremely close.”
Bibi has even less credibility than I thought. He's literally been saying the same crap for 20 years.
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/cafe/netanyahu-speech-red-meat-for-iran-hawks-dealbreaker-for-democrats
At press time, Netanyahu was asking if he might have a few more minutes for an abbreviated version of his PowerPoint on the troubling unanswered questions that still surrounded Benghazi.