John Boehner tries ruin US - Iran nuclear talks

Article 1, Section 8 of the constitution.

To regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes;

Any talk with a foreign nation. be it an embargo or support, is commerce and thus a role for Congress, or a declaration of war which is also a specific power for Congress. Of course, we haven't exactly followed the declaration of war thing too closely in about a forever, but to pretend that Congress has no input into foreign affairs is a total misreading on the constitution.

Congress has no power to negotiate with foreign countries.

They can enact sanctions/embargoes. But President Obama already said he would veto those. And I doubt that Republicans are going to be able to pick off 13 Democratic Senators needed overturn it unless talks fail.

They could also declare war. If it turns out that Republicans are that crazy, Obama, he better damn well veto their declaration.

Also, how is this deal the President is trying to make not a treaty?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_agreement
 
Congress has no power to negotiate with foreign countries.

They can enact sanctions/embargoes. But President Obama already said he would veto those. And I doubt that Republicans are going to be able to pick off 13 Democratic Senators needed overturn it unless talks fail.

They could also declare war. If it turns out that Republicans are that crazy, Obama, he better damn well veto their declaration.



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_agreement

Obama would unilaterally be allowing Iran to violate the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty. Surely, making a deal to allow the violation of a formal treaty would amount to making a new treaty, no? Otherwise, there would be quite the loophole.
 
T

(1) Tony's implication that this is a criminal act on Boehner's part is ridiculous. It's arguably unconstitutional, but that is a political act, not a crime. It is almost certain that there is no practical legal remedy for such a "breach" beyond a little bit of name-calling. The federal courts would surely decline to get involved.

I cited a law showing how it could be criminal.

(2) Obama seems to be driven by personal animus for Netanyahu, and perhaps for Israel in general. As usual he treats our allies like crap and kowtows to our enemies. It is not surprising that Israel supporters are panicking about the kerfuffle. Though something as minor as that should have de minimis impact on the ties between strong allies, even Obama supporters understand how thin-skinned and petulant he is, and that it is entirely plausible he would undermine the security of an ally composed of 8MM people for no other reason than retaliation for personal insult.

Just because he isn't a war mongering piece of crap like his Republican predecessor doesn't mean he "kowtows to our enemies".

Bibi seems to think that he can pressure the United States into doing whatever he wants it to do. Well, he can't, at least not while Obama is the President of the United States. And if Bibi with his stunt with Boehner worsens relations with the President that will be Bibi's fault. And his problem since Israel depends on the United States and not the other way around.

And many Israelis seem to realize this. They know it is freaking retarded to make a move that will worsen relations with the United States for at least two years. And so Bibi may actually lose the upcoming Israeli elections.

(3) Arguably, if Obama cuts a deal with Iran, that's a treaty, and if he doesn't allow the Senate to vote on it, it would be unconstitutional.

And arguably, it will be a executive agreement, and Republican will be able to do nothing.
 
Obama would unilaterally be allowing Iran to violate the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty. Surely, making a deal to allow the violation of a formal treaty would amount to making a new treaty, no? Otherwise, there would be quite the loophole.

You know what the deal will be already? I hear there is a million dollars for the person who can prove he can see the future.
 
You know what the deal will be already? I hear there is a million dollars for the person who can prove he can see the future.

Predicting the future is not that hard in many cases. For example, I predict it will be cold tonight where I am. Also that it will snow. Also that the sun will rise tomorrow morning, and that it will still be cold, and that there will be lots more snow on the ground. Also, that Obama's "negotiations" with Iran will yield a deal where Iran gets a nuclear weapons capability but pretends that they don't, and we pretend to believe them.
 
Predicting the future is not that hard in many cases. For example, I predict it will be cold tonight where I am. Also that it will snow. Also that the sun will rise tomorrow morning, and that it will still be cold, and that there will be lots more snow on the ground. Also, that Obama's "negotiations" with Iran will yield a deal where Iran gets a nuclear weapons capability but pretends that they don't, and we pretend to believe them.

"And that, my liege, is how we know the world to be bannana shaped."
 
Predicting the future is not that hard in many cases. For example, I predict it will be cold tonight where I am. Also that it will snow. Also that the sun will rise tomorrow morning, and that it will still be cold, and that there will be lots more snow on the ground. Also, that Obama's "negotiations" with Iran will yield a deal where Iran gets a nuclear weapons capability but pretends that they don't, and we pretend to believe them.

Any country with a nuclear program, has the capacity, in time, to build nuclear weapons. But that doesn't mean they are in violation of the NPT. That requires that they are actually working towards building nuclear weapons. Something Iran has not done since 2003. The prediction that Obama would grant them a nuclear weapons program is baseless and ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
Despite the extensive criticism, Netanyahu has no intention of backing out of the speech, he told a group of visitors to his home Tuesday.​

And despite extensive criticism, Obama has no intention of backing off from his policy towards Iran. LOL jackass indeed.

Of course I think it's a fair point. And of course I think it applies to Obama. I don't necessarily think it should be made here, as it has been made many times elsewhere (and is readily obvious to anyone who thinks about it for a moment). I do, however, think it's worth noting that those who dismiss Netanyahu's opposition to Obama's Iran policy on such grounds never seem to apply the same criteria to judging that policy in the first place.

Why should we assume that Netanyahu's position is naked ambition, but Obama's is not?

That's odd, I could have sworn I've seen you dismiss tu quoque arguments as fallacies before...
 
Any country with a nuclear program, has the capacity, in time, to build nuclear weapons. But that doesn't mean they are in violation of the NPT. That requires that they are actually working towards building nuclear weapons. Something Iran has not done since 2003. The prediction that Obama would grant them a nuclear weapons program is baseless and ridiculous.

The official position of the United States is that Iran is in violation of the NPT. Also, the claim that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003 is utterly baseless and ridiculous.
 
ETA: And if it's a criminal act, Obama can always send US Marshals down to the Capitol, have Boehner clapped in irons, and bring him up on criminal charges in federal court. "Possibly criminal", my butt. Even Obama--constitutional scholar--knows that Congress is acting well within its authority.

I just saw this ETA. No, it does not follow that he would do that.

He has, unfortunately, let Republicans get away from much worse crimes that they have admitted to. Bush/Cheney have admitted to torturing people and there is zero doubt that this is a serious crime both internationally and in the United States.
 
The official position of the United States is that Iran is in violation of the NPT. Also, the claim that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003 is utterly baseless and ridiculous.

It isn't my contention that Iran hasn't tried to make nuclear weapons since 2003. That is the position of US intelligence agencies.

As U.S. and Israeli officials talk publicly about the prospect of a military strike against Iran's nuclear program, one fact is often overlooked: U.S. intelligence agencies don't believe Iran is actively trying to build an atomic bomb.

A highly classified U.S. intelligence assessment circulated to policymakers early last year largely affirms that view, originally made in 2007. Both reports, known as national intelligence estimates, conclude that Tehran halted efforts to develop and build a nuclear warhead in 2003.

The most recent report, which represents the consensus of 16 U.S. intelligence agencies, indicates that Iran is pursuing research that could put it in a position to build a weapon, but that it has not sought to do so.

Although Iran continues to enrich uranium at low levels, U.S. officials say they have not seen evidence that has caused them to significantly revise that judgment. Senior U.S. officials say Israel does not dispute the basic intelligence or analysis.

But Israel appears to have a lower threshold for action than Washington. It regards Iran as a threat to its existence and says it will not allow Iran to become capable of building and delivering a nuclear weapon. Some Israeli officials have raised the prospect of a military strike to stop Iran before it's too late.

http://articles.latimes.com/2012/feb/23/world/la-fg-iran-intel-20120224

Note that Iran has the legal right under the NPT to enrich uranium as long as they are not using it to make nuclear weapons.
 
They can disagree with him all they want, what is outrageous and as far as I can tell unprecedented is them conspiring to undermine him.

Outrageous and probably criminal:



http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/953

Does this just apply to Republicans undermining a Democrat? Or does it also apply the other way? Do you consider Pelosi a criminal for her trip to Syria in 2007?

---------------------------
http://www.cnn.com/2007/POLITICS/04/04/carter.pelosi/

Bush on Tuesday called the trip "counterproductive" and said it would send mixed signals.

"Photo opportunities and/or meetings with President Assad lead the Assad government to believe they're part of the mainstream of the international community, when, in fact, they're a state sponsor of terror," he said at a news conference in the White House's Rose Garden.

Carter, however, said there was "no threat" that the Democratic speaker's visit would dilute the United States' ability to speak to Syria with one voice.
----------------------------
 
The official position of the United States is that Iran is in violation of the NPT. Also, the claim that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003 is utterly baseless and ridiculous.

Both of your points are quite wrong.

First, there was one time that US State Department declared Iran to be inviolation of the NPT. That that was in 2005, and it has not done so since.

And since the US State Department does not have the authority to officially represent the USA, and since that pronouncement is ten years old, therefore one can hardly say now that "official position of the United States is that Iran is in violation of the NPT".

Second, it was the CIA who claimed that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003. Therefore, one cannot say that "the claim that Iran has not been working toward a nuclear weapon since 2003 is utterly baseless and ridiculous".
 
Does this just apply to Republicans undermining a Democrat? Or does it also apply the other way? Do you consider Pelosi a criminal for her trip to Syria in 2007?

---------------------------
http://www.cnn.com/2007/POLITICS/04/04/carter.pelosi/

Bush on Tuesday called the trip "counterproductive" and said it would send mixed signals.

"Photo opportunities and/or meetings with President Assad lead the Assad government to believe they're part of the mainstream of the international community, when, in fact, they're a state sponsor of terror," he said at a news conference in the White House's Rose Garden.

Carter, however, said there was "no threat" that the Democratic speaker's visit would dilute the United States' ability to speak to Syria with one voice.
----------------------------

Pelosi defended her visit, saying her talks with Al-Assad focused only on topics on which she and Bush agree.

"On the issues that we set before the president (of Syria)," she said, "there is no division among us or between our congressional delegation in Congress and the president of the United States." (Full story)

Huge difference.
 
That's odd, I could have sworn I've seen you dismiss tu quoque arguments as fallacies before...

And yet pointing out a double standard remains a legitimate form of rebuttal. I stand by my arguments. If people objecting to the idea is a valid basis for criticizing Netanyahu's actions, then it's a valid basis for criticizing Obama's actions. And if it's appropriate to suggest that Netanyahu's actions may be motivated by personal ambition, then it is appropriate to suggest that Obama's actions have the same motivation.

Note that I am not attempting to rebut Tony Stark's argument because he is doing the same thing he criticizes in others, or because Obama is doing the same thing he criticizes in Netanyahu. Rather, I am observing that once again Tony Stark is singling out one instance of a thing as wrong, while ignoring or dismissing other instances that don't serve his partisan bias. I'm not appealing to tu quoque, I'm pointing out special pleading.

If Tony Stark wants us to accept that the Netanyahu case has special significance, then I would like him to present an internally-consistent argument that applies the same reasoning to similar cases on the other side of the partisan divide, showing that they are not similarly significant for reasons other than partisan bias.
 
Last edited:
And yet pointing out a double standard remains a legitimate form of rebuttal. I stand by my arguments. If people objecting to the idea is a valid basis for criticizing Netanyahu's actions, then it's a valid basis for criticizing Obama's actions. And if it's appropriate to suggest that Netanyahu's actions may be motivated by personal ambition, then it is appropriate to suggest that Obama's actions have the same motivation.

Note that I am not attempting to rebut Tony Stark's argument because he is doing the same thing he criticizes in others, or because Obama is doing the same thing he criticizes in Netanyahu. Rather, I am observing that once again Tony Stark is singling out one instance of a thing as wrong, while ignoring or dismissing other instances that don't serve his partisan bias. I'm not appealing to tu quoque, I'm pointing out special pleading.

If Tony Stark wants us to accept that the Netanyahu case has special significance, then I would like him to present an internally-consistent argument that applies the same reasoning to similar cases on the other side of the partisan divide, showing that they are not similarly significant for reasons other than partisan bias.

It isn't special pleading because the President in fact shapes United States foreign policy not the Speaker of the House and the Prime Minister of Israel.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom