John Boehner tries ruin US - Iran nuclear talks

John Boehner tries to ruin US - Iran nuclear talks

And they were going so well too.
 
Funny how this point never seems to come up in the context of Obama's preferred policy towards Iran.

If you think it is a fair point, then great. And if you think it is a fair point and that it applies to Obama then that's also great. And if nobody is making this point and you think it should be made then you are as much to blame for not making it as anyone else.
 
lol, jackass

Israeli consuls general in the United States have warned the Foreign Ministry to expect fierce negative reactions to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s planned March 3 speech to Congress, including from U.S. Jewish communities and Israel allies.

Despite the extensive criticism, Netanyahu has no intention of backing out of the speech, he told a group of visitors to his home Tuesday.

A senior Foreign Ministry official said the consuls general in San Francisco, Chicago, Atlanta, Boston, Los Angeles and Philadelphia have sent the ministry worried cables in the past two weeks about widespread dissatisfaction regarding Netanyahu’s speech.

They also expressed concern about the implications of the deepening crisis between Netanyahu and the Obama administration.

http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/.premium-1.640896
 
If you think it is a fair point, then great. And if you think it is a fair point and that it applies to Obama then that's also great. And if nobody is making this point and you think it should be made then you are as much to blame for not making it as anyone else.

Of course I think it's a fair point. And of course I think it applies to Obama. I don't necessarily think it should be made here, as it has been made many times elsewhere (and is readily obvious to anyone who thinks about it for a moment). I do, however, think it's worth noting that those who dismiss Netanyahu's opposition to Obama's Iran policy on such grounds never seem to apply the same criteria to judging that policy in the first place.

Why should we assume that Netanyahu's position is naked ambition, but Obama's is not?
 
Despite the extensive criticism, Netanyahu has no intention of backing out of the speech, he told a group of visitors to his home Tuesday.​

And despite extensive criticism, Obama has no intention of backing off from his policy towards Iran. LOL jackass indeed.

The President of the United States should back off from his foreign policy because the Speaker of the House and the leader of the foreign country are trying to undermine him?
 
The President of the United States should back off from his foreign policy because the Speaker of the House and the leader of the foreign country are trying to undermine him?

Unlike the Blessed Saint Ronald Reagan, RIP, PBUH, Hallowed Be Thy Name, etc., Barack Obama is no god-king, whose policies must go uncontested by mere mortals. He is but a man, and regardless of the office he holds, his ideas have only equal standing with the ideas of other men. He is no more entitled to Netanyahu's concession, than Netanyahu is entitled to his.

Appealing to the office of the President to legitimize the President's ideas is an appeal to authority, and a logical fallacy. It's also obviously stupid and wrong, unless you're prepared to defend every bad policy of every president ever, on the grounds that the nation's legislature and the leaders of other nations lack the standing to criticize him.

Reagan fires striking air traffic controllers and you don't like it? Tough noogies, he's the President. Iran-Contra? Suck it, bitches, President comin' through. Watergate? Legislature, swerve. Invade Iraq? Turn down for what!
 
Unlike the Blessed Saint Ronald Reagan, RIP, PBUH, Hallowed Be Thy Name, etc., Barack Obama is no god-king, whose policies must go uncontested by mere mortals. He is but a man, and regardless of the office he holds, his ideas have only equal standing with the ideas of other men. He is no more entitled to Netanyahu's concession, than Netanyahu is entitled to his.

Appealing to the office of the President to legitimize the President's ideas is an appeal to authority, and a logical fallacy. It's also obviously stupid and wrong, unless you're prepared to defend every bad policy of every president ever, on the grounds that the nation's legislature and the leaders of other nations lack the standing to criticize him.

Reagan fires striking air traffic controllers and you don't like it? Tough noogies, he's the President. Iran-Contra? Suck it, bitches, President comin' through. Watergate? Legislature, swerve. Invade Iraq? Turn down for what!

"While the Constitution does not explicitly say that all ability to conduct foreign policy is vested in the President, it is nonetheless given implicitly and by the fact that the executive, by its very nature, is empowered to conduct foreign affairs in a way that Congress cannot and should not."

-Supreme Court
 
"While the Constitution does not explicitly say that all ability to conduct foreign policy is vested in the President, it is nonetheless given implicitly and by the fact that the executive, by its very nature, is empowered to conduct foreign affairs in a way that Congress cannot and should not."

-Supreme Court

That is an excellent point, which I wholeheartedly agree with.

However, Barack Obama is still not entitled by the virtue of his office or the opinions of the Supreme Court, to the support of legislators and foreign leaders when they disagree with his policies. Nor is he entitled to their silence, if they would speak out against his policies. It's this sense of entitlement, which seems to form the whole of your argument, that I object to.
 
Last edited:
That is an excellent point, which I wholeheartedly agree with.

However, Barack Obama is still not entitled by the virtue of his office or the opinions of the Supreme Court, to the support of legislators and foreign leaders when they disagree with his policies. Nor is he entitled to their silence, if they would speak out against his policies. It's this sense of entitlement, which seems to form the whole of your argument, that I object to.

They can disagree with him all they want, what is outrageous and as far as I can tell unprecedented is them conspiring to undermine him.

Outrageous and probably criminal:

Any citizen of the United States, wherever he may be, who, without authority of the United States, directly or indirectly commences or carries on any correspondence or intercourse with any foreign government or any officer or agent thereof, with intent to influence the measures or conduct of any foreign government or of any officer or agent thereof, in relation to any disputes or controversies with the United States, or to defeat the measures of the United States, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both.

This section shall not abridge the right of a citizen to apply, himself or his agent, to any foreign government or the agents thereof for redress of any injury which he may have sustained from such government or any of its agents or subjects.

http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/953
 
Last edited:
They can disagree with him all they want, what is outrageous and as far as I can tell unprecedented is them conspiring to undermine him.

Outrageous and probably criminal:



http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/953

I'd say possibly criminal, not probably. Does the law apply to Congress acting in its official capacity? I bet it doesn't. I bet it only applies to private citizens acting as such.

Anyway, you keep using "undermining" like it's a magic spell that makes all your arguments for you. It doesn't. Characterize it however you like, the truth is that the leader of a democracy is only as stong as the consensus of the people he leads. If the nation is divided and the consensus is weak, then the president will be weak. If he wants to pursue a policy that depends on a strong consensus for its success, then he must get that consensus, or his policy will fail.

You can find all the different ways of saying "it's not fair!" and "shut up!" that you like, it doesn't change the fact that Obama has willfully placed himself between an untrustworthy negotiating partner on one side, and a legislature that doesn't trust his negotiations on the other. It doesn't change the fact that Obama has to deal with an unsupportive legislature and an unsupportive Israel today, regardless of how the constitutional question might be resolved tomorrow.
 
I'd say possibly criminal, not probably. Does the law apply to Congress acting in its official capacity? I bet it doesn't. I bet it only applies to private citizens acting as such.

Congress doesn't have an official capacity to negotiate with foreign governments.

Anyway, you keep using "undermining" like it's a magic spell that makes all your arguments for you. It doesn't. Characterize it however you like, the truth is that the leader of a democracy is only as stong as the consensus of the people he leads. If the nation is divided and the consensus is weak, then the president will be weak. If he wants to pursue a policy that depends on a strong consensus for its success, then he must get that consensus, or his policy will fail.

You can find all the different ways of saying "it's not fair!" and "shut up!" that you like, it doesn't change the fact that Obama has willfully placed himself between an untrustworthy negotiating partner on one side, and a legislature that doesn't trust his negotiations on the other. It doesn't change the fact that Obama has to deal with an unsupportive legislature and an unsupportive Israel today, regardless of how the constitutional question might be resolved tomorrow.

The President's capacity to conduct foreign affairs isn't dependent on the support of obstructionist pieces of crap in Congress. Though apparently they will try to insert themselves and undermine him anyway. This possibly criminal stunt is all they have though and the President is rightfully refusing to allow it to work.
 
Last edited:
Of course I think it's a fair point. And of course I think it applies to Obama. I don't necessarily think it should be made here, as it has been made many times elsewhere (and is readily obvious to anyone who thinks about it for a moment).

And yet that is quite different from what you said earlier.

Funny how this point never seems to come up in the context of Obama's preferred policy towards Iran.

I do, however, think it's worth noting that those who dismiss Netanyahu's opposition to Obama's Iran policy on such grounds never seem to apply the same criteria to judging that policy in the first place.

Why should we assume that Netanyahu's position is naked ambition, but Obama's is not?

I make no such assumptions, only that it should not be assumed that all actions by politicians are expressions of national interest as was suggested in the post that I was initially responding to:

BStrong said:
Just like any US politician.

Remember the old saying, Nations have no friends, only interests.

The US and Israel are no exceptions to the rule.
 
And yet that is quite different from what you said earlier.
Not really. Earlier I was commenting on the fact that it isn't discussed on this forum. Later I was referring to the fact that I've seen it discussed on other fora. That is totally not clear in my posts. I apologize for any confusion.

I make no such assumptions, only that it should not be assumed that all actions by politicians are expressions of national interest as was suggested in the post that I was initially responding to:

Fair enough. Would you say that your analysis is equally applicable to Obama's policy towards Iran, or do you intend it to be read only in the context of Netanyahu's decision to speak to Congress?
 
Congress doesn't have an official capacity to negotiate with foreign governments.
No, but they do have the official capacity to hear testimony on any subject they like, including the opinions of foreign officials on the course of US foreign policy.

The President's capacity to conduct foreign affairs isn't dependent on the support of obstructionist pieces of crap in Congress. Though apparently they will try to insert themselves and undermine him anyway. This possibly criminal stunt is all they have though and the President is rightfully refusing to allow it to work.
If the President's foreign policy does not need the support of a unified Congress, then by the same token the actions of a divided and dissenting Congress cannot obstruct that policy. If the President has the power to prevent the stunts of Congress from working, then those stunts cannot be said to undermine the President.

Make up your mind: Either Congress can undermine the President's policy by witholding their support and expressing their dissent, or they can't. Which is it?

ETA: And if it's a criminal act, Obama can always send US Marshals down to the Capitol, have Boehner clapped in irons, and bring him up on criminal charges in federal court. "Possibly criminal", my butt. Even Obama--constitutional scholar--knows that Congress is acting well within its authority.
 
Last edited:
No, but they do have the official capacity to hear testimony on any subject they like, including the opinions of foreign officials on the course of US foreign policy.

Not if the intention of this "testimony" is to undermine stated US policy.

If the President's foreign policy does not need the support of a unified Congress, then by the same token the actions of a divided and dissenting Congress cannot obstruct that policy. If the President has the power to prevent the stunts of Congress from working, then those stunts cannot be said to undermine the President.

Make up your mind: Either Congress can undermine the President's policy by witholding their support and expressing their dissent, or they can't. Which is it?

Just because the possibly criminal attempt to undermine the President will fail because the President is in fact not a spineless coward doesn't mean that it wasn't an attempt to undermine the President. Just means that Boehner and Netanyahu are also idiots.
 
Last edited:
Not really. Earlier I was commenting on the fact that it isn't discussed on this forum. Later I was referring to the fact that I've seen it discussed on other fora. That is totally not clear in my posts. I apologize for any confusion.

Thanks for clarifying. I think you could be right.

Fair enough. Would you say that your analysis is equally applicable to Obama's policy towards Iran, or do you intend it to be read only in the context of Netanyahu's decision to speak to Congress?

As it happens, I am not really sure what motivates either Obama or Netanyahu. My guess is that, as with most people, there is some mixture of principle and ego at work. I think Obama genuinely wants peace between the US and Iran, and I think Netanyahu genuinely wants security for Israel from Iran and furthermore, I think that both of them believe they are working in the interests of their respective countries.

However, I am less sure if that is the case with each member of Congress, not least because many of them do not have to put the national interest ahead of their constituents' interests or preferences, and because some of them are more susceptible to being leaned on, or even to corruption, or to finding favour within the party heirachy.

ETA: And of course, what the intentions are of each politician, and how they crunch the data they have, does not guarantee that they will make decisions that maximize their respective nations' interests even if they want to. Although I am sure that goes without saying, I thought I would put that here anyway.
 
Last edited:
Congress doesn't have an official capacity to negotiate with foreign governments.

Article 1, Section 8 of the constitution.

To regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes;

Any talk with a foreign nation. be it an embargo or support, is commerce and thus a role for Congress, or a declaration of war which is also a specific power for Congress. Of course, we haven't exactly followed the declaration of war thing too closely in about a forever, but to pretend that Congress has no input into foreign affairs is a total misreading on the constitution.

Also, how is this deal the President is trying to make not a treaty?
 
There was an interesting analysis in the Washington Post this weekend.

So we have two different narratives here. The Israeli narrative is that Boehner, on behalf of a bipartisan Congress (as the Israelis claim they sincerely believed), invited Netanyahu to address a joint session of Congress. Netanyahu had done so before under similar circumstances, without White House objection. The invitation had been conveyed informally to Netanyahu weeks before it was publicly announced, and the Israelis figured, based on what Boehner himself told them, that it was Boehner’s job to decide when and how inform the White House that a formal invitation was pending. Once Boehner did so, Netanyahu having heard no objection from the White House beyond concern that the invitation had breached diplomatic protocol (which would seem to be primarily Boehner’s sin), went ahead and accepted it.

The White House, by contrast, seems to think that Netanyahu is in league with the GOP (or in fact is, somehow, a Republican), that he tried to help defeat Obama in 2012 (apparently they believe that if Netanyahu had said the word to Sheldon Adelson, the latter wouldn’t have donated millions to Romney, which seems speculative to say the least, and more likely is fanciful), and that his choice of a former Republican American, Ron Dermer, to be ambassador to the U.S., showed disrespect for the Democratic president.

My thoughts:

(1) Tony's implication that this is a criminal act on Boehner's part is ridiculous. It's arguably unconstitutional, but that is a political act, not a crime. It is almost certain that there is no practical legal remedy for such a "breach" beyond a little bit of name-calling. The federal courts would surely decline to get involved.

(2) Obama seems to be driven by personal animus for Netanyahu, and perhaps for Israel in general. As usual he treats our allies like crap and kowtows to our enemies. It is not surprising that Israel supporters are panicking about the kerfuffle. Though something as minor as that should have de minimis impact on the ties between strong allies, even Obama supporters understand how thin-skinned and petulant he is, and that it is entirely plausible he would undermine the security of an ally composed of 8MM people for no other reason than retaliation for personal insult.

(3) Arguably, if Obama cuts a deal with Iran, that's a treaty, and if he doesn't allow the Senate to vote on it, it would be unconstitutional.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom