John Boehner tries ruin US - Iran nuclear talks

Tony Stark

Philosopher
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
9,626
John Boehner tries to ruin US - Iran nuclear talks

House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) appeared to have pulled off a masterful political victory against the Obama administration Wednesday when he revealed that he had invited Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to address Congress on the dangers of the administration's negotiations with Iran.

Coming a day after President Barack Obama threatened to veto new Iran-related sanctions legislation that he said could harm the negotiations, Boehner's move looked like a smart way to reinforce support for such bills -- a priority for the Republican-led Congress -- by showing that the U.S.'s top ally in the region supported them.

Then things started to fall apart.

Secretary of State John Kerry, fresh off his fumbling on the issue of French solidarity, pulled off a diplomatic bank shot by using a different part of the Israeli government against Boehner. Asked about the invitation at a press conference with European Union foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini, Kerry diplomatically said Netanyahu was welcome in the U.S. any time -- and proceeded to both steal Boehner's thunder and turn news coverage in a different direction.

"In Israel, one of the top intelligence –- one of the top intelligence personnel within the Israeli intelligence field –- I won’t name names, but this person was asked directly by a congressional delegation that visited there over the weekend what the effect of sanctions would be. And this person answered that it would be like throwing a grenade into the process," Kerry said. "So we’re asking people to be responsible here, and then let’s have a good, responsible debate about what the best way to proceed is."

Kerry's comment altered the conversation, making it about whether Republicans want to torpedo nuclear talks with Iran. The Obama administration describes the negotiations as the only way to ensure that Iran cannot gain a nuclear weapon to threaten the very country Boehner says the administration is failing: Israel. Kerry's message: It's Republicans, and the Democrats who support them on new sanctions, who would fail Israel by antagonizing Iran and destroying the chance of a peaceful resolution to the years-long controversy over Tehran's nuclear program.


http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/01/22/kerry-israel-boehner-_n_6527826.html

The American people elected President Obama to makes these decision. John Boehner's opinion is irrelevant.

I'm not sure how they thought this would play out anyway. The Iranians back out of talks because Netanyahu? Then what happens, we impose sanctions? What happens when that fails? We invade the middle east yet again? Please tell me that isn't the end game.
 
Last edited:
Wait until John Boehner hears about this lawless violation of the separation of powers. He would sue in a heartbeat over this.
 
The American people elected President Obama to makes these decision. John Boehner's opinion is irrelevant.

I'm not sure how they thought this would play out anyway. The Iranians back out of talks because Netanyahu? Then what happens, we impose sanctions? What happens when that fails? We invade the middle east yet again? Please tell me that isn't the end game.

"In Israel, one of the top intelligence –- one of the top intelligence personnel within the Israeli intelligence field –- I won’t name names, but this person was asked directly by a congressional delegation that visited there over the weekend what the effect of sanctions would be. And this person answered that it would be like throwing a grenade into the process," Kerry said.

That's quite a witty metaphor. I can see why Kerry thought it was worth making up repeating.

And to answer your question, the end game is we impose sanctions until the Iranian government can't bear the pressure anymore. Things were going along pretty well until Obama released the pressure at the first sign of Iranian distress. Now, with oil below $50 per barrel, sanctions will work even better. But Obama, being enamored with his unique personal narrative, as well as the sound of his own voice, doesn't think such mundane concepts like leverage are important in a negotiation.
 
Wow!

I am really surprised that Netanyahu is so willing to be one of Boehner's lackies.

Yes, how humiliating to be invited to address a joint session of Congress. How can Netanyahu even look at himself in the mirror for accepting?
 
Wow!

I am really surprised that Netanyahu is so willing to be one of Boehner's lackies.

Netanyahu's willing to do whatever it takes to help Netanyahu.

Right now, he sees that as cozying up to the Republicans.
 
When is that? Is that going to work like with North Korea and Cuba?

A couple of years perhaps. It was already working but Obama let Iran off the hook. Iran isn't even remotely like North Korea, nor is it like Cuba (which is a small island nation that has been subsidized by like-minded benefactors from abroad). Iran is not even like any Arab country. Iran is a relatively educated, modern, and demographically young society, which just happens to be run by a theocratic oligarchy. But that oligarchy's days are numbered. Do you remember what happened in June 2009? There is a lot of dry tinder there, and the mullahs know it.
 
A couple of years perhaps. It was already working but Obama let Iran off the hook. Iran isn't even remotely like North Korea, nor is it like Cuba (which is a small island nation that has been subsidized by like-minded benefactors from abroad). Iran is not even like any Arab country. Iran is a relatively educated, modern, and demographically young society, which just happens to be run by a theocratic oligarchy. But that oligarchy's days are numbered. Do you remember what happened in June 2009? There is a lot of dry tinder there, and the mullahs know it.

But won't sanctions make it easier for the mullahs to blame the US for everything and anything?
 
"In Israel, one of the top intelligence –- one of the top intelligence personnel within the Israeli intelligence field –- I won’t name names, but this person was asked directly by a congressional delegation that visited there over the weekend what the effect of sanctions would be. And this person answered that it would be like throwing a grenade into the process," Kerry said.

That's quite a witty metaphor. I can see why Kerry thought it was worth making up repeating.

And to answer your question, the end game is we impose sanctions until the Iranian government can't bear the pressure anymore. Things were going along pretty well until Obama released the pressure at the first sign of Iranian distress. Now, with oil below $50 per barrel, sanctions will work even better. But Obama, being enamored with his unique personal narrative, as well as the sound of his own voice, doesn't think such mundane concepts like leverage are important in a negotiation.

Since there were increasing sanctions since 1979 and that Obama finally brought them to the table by easing sanctions as the talks progressed, maybe he knows what he's doing. Maybe he doesn't have enough leverage to make them come back the table if the United States proves it doesn't negotiate in good faith.

Either way, John Boehner nor anybody else in Congress makes foreign policy. It doesn't matter if how poorly they believe the President is handling it.
 
The Republican faithful love Israel. Because the sooner it erupts into flaming conflict, the sooner the End Times will happen. Actual Jews, many of them can do without. Boehner's just playing to the base.

(My Opinion. YMMV)
 
Wow!

I am really surprised that Netanyahu is so willing to be one of Boehner's lackies.

I don't want to lapse into Zionist Conspiracy territory, but it's equally (if not far more) likely that Boehner is so willing to be one Netanyahu's stooges. Bibi tried this end-run once before with a different variation and got shut down with, of course, the ODS sufferers leading the complaints.

Actually, let's say it's mutual lackie-stooge-ship. They're each in this thinking they're going to get a big win. Netanyahu thinks he'll get cozied up to Congress who will give him what he wants and Boehner(or the GOP brass to be more accurate) thinks he'll further separate the Dems from their large base of traditional Jewish supporters and embarrass Obama as a great side benefit.
 
Yes, how humiliating to be invited to address a joint session of Congress. How can Netanyahu even look at himself in the mirror for accepting?
Possibly because he is often a flaming *******. Unfortunate but true. Of course it does not remotely change the fact that those who claim the Israelis committed war crimes in the recent fooferall clearly have not the slightest knowledge of the words and meaning of the actual rules of warfare. And I have gotten bored of posting them on here . They are free to continue being incompetent in that area.:mad::rolleyes::mad::rolleyes::mad::rolleyes::jaw-dropp
 
The Republican faithful love Israel. Because the sooner it erupts into flaming conflict, the sooner the End Times will happen. Actual Jews, many of them can do without. Boehner's just playing to the base.

(My Opinion. YMMV)

You are quite correct - this has been in general (functional/intelligent) knowledge since the early 80s and at least one normal religious person wrote a book on the fundies that covered many things including that. I would happily give the title but it was many years back and I only read the excerpted part that was mostly about the Jewish thing.
 
Bibi might be making big mistake in his partnership with Boehner.
A great many foreign poltical leaders have tried to dabble in American Domestic Politics....it has never turned out well for them.
 
I can name three examples of Congress legitimately making foreign policy, in accord with their Constitutional responsibilities, right now.

Maybe somethings that would only become policy if the President decided to sign it. Furthermore, I wasn't talking about Congress collectively.
 
Here will be another 40+ minute speech by a leader of Israel asking for the U.S. to take care of Israel's problems again just like Netanyahu did in '96 when the Clean Break policy was enacted.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom