John Boehner tries ruin US - Iran nuclear talks

Maybe somethings that would only become policy if the President decided to sign it. Furthermore, I wasn't talking about Congress collectively.

I don't think there's any meaningful distinction between an individual member of Congress acting in their official capacity, and Congress acting collectively. By Congress's own rules, which they have collectively established, Boehner has the authority to conduct hearings and invite testimony on any subject of interest to the Legislature.

As for the President having to sign off, that's a check and balance on the Constitutional power of Congress to make foreign policy--and one which Congress can override with a large enough majority. It's not really a demonstration of the President's exclusive authority to make foreign policy.

The fact is that the Iran Question is a contentious, controversial issue in American politics. There may be unity of purpose in Obama's mind, but there is certainly not unity of purpose among the American electorate, or among its elected representatives. It's absurd to think that just because Obama has resolved the division personally, he can dismiss or ignore the fact that Congress and the nation are still deeply divided on the issue. It's absurd to think that having ignored this division, he can insist on having his preferred policy towards Iran, without suffering the consequences of his unresolved conflict with Congress.

It's unfortunate that Obama spent most of his brief Congressional career campaigning for President, instead of learning how Congress works, and making the connections necessary to work it to his own ends. It's unfortunate that he's been so focused on achieving consensus with the government of Iran, that he's ignored the vital first step of getting consensus with his own government. It's unfortunate that he believes that whining in public about the lack of consensus after the fact should make up for his failure to go to Congress and get a consensus ahead of time. It's unfortunate, but to paraphrase a great man, you go with the President you have, not the President you wish to have or plan to have at a later time.
 
Last edited:
One thing to keep in mind is that 90% of Netanyahu's political cash comes from people in the United States.

Combine that with all the aid Washington sends Israel, and you realize that his career is inexorably tied to the political winds in Washington.

I don't think that's particularly meaningful. It's a ridiculously small amount of money regardless. Money just doesn't play that big a role in parliamentary elections in Israel, and Israelis themselves appear to be pretty stingy about making political donations. IIRC, it's typical for a Labor politician to get more than 50% of his money from US sources as well.
 
Wow! I am really surprised that Netanyahu is so willing to be one of Boehner's lackies.

As was stated in another thread, the Israeli leadership is concerned by the fact that among young American voters -- even and especially among young Jewish voters -- support for the Israeli government is declining. That the Israeli government is no longer seen as "the good guys" but just less bad than some of the region's other governments. This is a concern because the United States has always been among Israel's staunchest allies. However, conservative Republicans have emerged as the Israeli government's most steadfast supporters.

I think there's probably some quid-pro-quo in this, too. Netanyahu is facing an election in Israel in March and being invited to address the U.S. Congress will probably help him. Israeli political pundits see it as a way for Netanyahu to enhance his prestige with Israeli voters. At the same time it provides U.S. Republicansw ith a way to undermine support for and potentially discredit a Democratic President.
 
As usual, the discussion is strictly along partisan lines. Of course, that's easier than other such discussions because this is obviously a "Republican" play and not an individual one.

I'd like to know how the GOP supporters would have reacted in 1973 if the Democratic Senate and Democratic House had invited Nguyen to address a joint session and explain how Nixon's "secret strategy to end the war" was wrong and needed to be revised. How about 1987? Dems in charge in both bodies, they invite Daniel Ortega over to explain his side of the, er, "argument" and explain what the US Executive was really up to.

There would be cries for arrests for "Treason!!!"
 
That was a different era though. Congress could oppose a President's policies but they would never do anything to undermine the President. Not even a Republican Presidential candidate would do that.
[During the 1968 election campaign on] September 8, 1968...Billy Graham told [President Lyndon Johnson] that Mr. Nixon had high respect for the man he described as “the hardest working president in 140 years.” Nixon pledged to never embarrass the President and, if elected, to task him with important work and make sure Johnson got proper credit when Vietnam was settled. Johnson was very moved by this and asked the evangelist to repeat a few of the points, remarking, “If Mr. Nixon becomes the president, I will do all in my power to cooperate with him.” Nixon Foundation


When Old School politicians say that today's extreme partisanship is deplorable I'm sure they mean it.
 
Netanyahu's willing to do whatever it takes to help Netanyahu.

Right now, he sees that as cozying up to the Republicans.

Just like any US politician.

Remember the old saying, Nations have no friends, only interests.

The US and Israel are no exceptions to the rule.
 
Just like any US politician.

Remember the old saying, Nations have no friends, only interests.

The US and Israel are no exceptions to the rule.

But nations are complex things, and what may be in the interests of some individuals, may not be in the interests of other individuals, and what may be in the interests of one particular politician may not be in the interests of the nation as a whole.
 
But nations are complex things, and what may be in the interests of some individuals, may not be in the interests of other individuals, and what may be in the interests of one particular politician may not be in the interests of the nation as a whole.

Funny how this point never seems to come up in the context of Obama's preferred policy towards Iran.
 
As usual, the discussion is strictly along partisan lines. Of course, that's easier than other such discussions because this is obviously a "Republican" play and not an individual one.

I'd like to know how the GOP supporters would have reacted in 1973 if the Democratic Senate and Democratic House had invited Nguyen to address a joint session and explain how Nixon's "secret strategy to end the war" was wrong and needed to be revised. How about 1987? Dems in charge in both bodies, they invite Daniel Ortega over to explain his side of the, er, "argument" and explain what the US Executive was really up to.

There would be cries for arrests for "Treason!!!"

I'm not sure where you're getting this from, but there is strong bipartisan support for both Israel and Netanyahu in particular in both houses of Congress. Your analysis is completely off the mark.
 
I'm not sure where you're getting this from, but there is strong bipartisan support for both Israel and Netanyahu in particular in both houses of Congress. Your analysis is completely off the mark.

Uh, maybe because it wasn't an analysis. It was another an... word. Analogy. There were sitting members from both parties in both the Congresses I mentioned that held differing views from the White House. Does that change the fact that the right (who are the people supporting Boehner's "invitation") would have had collective coronaries if Tip invited either of the parties I mentioned to speak to a joint session?
 
Uh, maybe because it wasn't an analysis. It was another an... word. Analogy. There were sitting members from both parties in both the Congresses I mentioned that held differing views from the White House. Does that change the fact that the right (who are the people supporting Boehner's "invitation") would have had collective coronaries if Tip invited either of the parties I mentioned to speak to a joint session?

I think you're conflating the question of whether it's improper for members of Congress to take an active interest in the foreign policy of the nation, with the question of whether it's improper for one faction in Congress to get butthurt when another faction disagrees with them over policy and takes actions that are within their authority and responsibility, but are not helpful to the first faction's preferred policy.

My take is that neither is improper, but that it is dishonest to pretend that the two are the same.
 
Last edited:
I think you're conflating the question of whether it's improper for members of Congress to take an active interest in the foreign policy of the nation, with the question of whether it's improper for one faction in Congress to get butthurt when another faction disagrees with them over policy and takes actions that are within their authority and responsibility, but are not helpful to the first faction's preferred policy.

My take is that neither is improper, but that it is dishonest to pretend that the two are the same.

No, I'm pointing out the partisan hypocrisy of the present day political map of the USA. Next week it'll be something the Dems do, but you can be pretty certain that no one in '73 or '87 would have dreamed of inviting Nguyen or Ortega to come explain to the Congress why the POTUS was wrong. And you can be equally assured that the loudest noises would've been heard from the GOP, as this would've been critical of "their guy" not the "other team's guy".

There. Now I've worded it more forcefully (although I don't feel that strongly about it and did so for purposes of clarification), so maybe the hypothetical is clearer. (And yes, it's a hypothetical. It's "IMHO".)
 
What is different is that Isreali attempts to influence American Policy have, to date, been very "bi partisan". They sought influence in both parties, and were careful to avoid getting caught up in US partisan politics.
Bibi has thrown that out the window,and decided to dabble in partisan politics. There is long list of Foreign Leaders who have tried that,and it has not ended well for them.
 
I have a wait and see attitude toward the Iran Nuclear talks. What see what the final deal looks like. Then I will decide to support it or not.
You have the ideologues on both sides:those who will blindly oppose any deal, and those who will blindly support any deal. Me, I perfer the facts before deciding.
I don't like the GOP blind obstructionism on this issue,but I reserve the right not to support the deal if I think we are being taken for a ride by the Iraninas.
For me,there have to be strict inspections and monitoring. And before normalizing relataions with Iran I would insist that Iran stop funding groups like Hezbollah.
 
James Baker: Boehner's invite to Netanyahu a significant breach of protocol

Foreign policy is best done when there is "at least cooperation" between the executive branch and congress according to Baker. Baker says in this interview that he thinks Netanyahu's acceptance of an invitation to speak before our congress without the approval of the President could backfire and lose him his election.

Former Secretary of State James Baker says he can't remember the last time a foreign leader was invited to address Congress without the president being informed beforehand.

Bohener seems to think he is in the executive branch in charge of foreign policy I suppose.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom