John Boehner tries ruin US - Iran nuclear talks

On that we agree.

I'm not sure who appointed the US or Israel final arbiters as to who can have nuclear programs or even nuclear weapons.

Until all parties are willing to put them aside, I think the whole thing is hypocritical.

But then again, most of us have never lived under an existential threat. Israel has, and does.

The Non-Proliferation Treaty (which was signed by Iran but not Israel) says that the parties which signed as non nuclear states (that would be every party that signed but the US, Russia, China, the UK, and France) have a right to civilian nuclear programs but not to nuclear weapons programs.

So far this treaty has proven 100% effective in preventing signatory states from acquiring nuclear weapons. The only ones that have since acquired nukes are those that haven't signed the treaty (Israel, Pakistan, and India) or signed the treaty then withdrew (North Korea).
 
Last edited:
So far this treaty has proven 100% effective in preventing signatory states from acquiring nuclear weapons. The only ones that have since acquired nukes are those that ... [snipped]... signed the treaty then withdrew (North Korea).

Pray explain how that shows the treaty as being 100% effective?
 
Pray explain how that shows the treaty as being 100% effective?

The treaty requires that civilian nuclear programs be monitored by the UN to prevent them from being used to develop nuclear weapons. Zero countries with UN monitoring have developed nuclear weapons. Zero.
 
The treaty requires that civilian nuclear programs be monitored by the UN to prevent them from being used to develop nuclear weapons. Zero countries with UN monitoring have developed nuclear weapons. Zero.

Except when they leave the treaty, taking the tech with them, and go nuclear.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom