Islam's war on freedom

Gurdur, where is the evidence that Islam is pro-intellectualism? Where are the seats of learning? Who are the Islamic secular thinkers?

Does Islam mean submission?

Gurdur, I have the truth. I'm happy to sit here behind this monitor day and night on this issue for the mere fact that I do have the truth.

I don't claim that Muslims are inherently different from anyone else. I claim that the religion, by and large, causes great suffering and misery for its people. Not all of them. Many of them.

I claim that Islam is counter to freedom of thought and behavior. It is oppressive and intellectually stilting. Not always, but too damn often.
 
RandFan, get off it. Just deal with the facts, and deal with your conflation of Islam as a whole, will you, already? This other gunk of yours is deeply boring.
Gurdur,

One more time, this is not about me.

Please stick to the subject at hand.
 
Sure. Go read the Wikipedia article on Islam, as good a place to start as any, find out about Sufi'ism, Alawiteism, all the other variants, and learn something!
:)

Or you could actually read and comprehend what I am actually saying in the thread you were referring to. You know, stuff like

in Sunni Islam[...]

[...]Hanbali school
[...]Shafi'i school
[...]Maliki.
[...]Hanafi

[...]When some Sufis meditate to get closer to Allah or a dervish guy swirls about in a happy fashion, these things do not affect me. What affects me and you is what Muslims adhere to and for Sunnis, unless they belong to one of the fringe groups, that is for the vast majority one of the four schools. And those four schools agree for example on what I am saying about jihad.

Oh, what's that? Four movements alone in the orthodox Sunni branch and the mystical branch in one post? I'm sure I've mentioned the Shia branch of Islam as well as the Salafis. But yea, quite the monolithical view I constructed here.

Gurdur said:
Then read up on the history of say the years round 900 AD to 1200 AD, how the writings of the classical Greeks were brought over to the West, or say a little on the Arab regime in Spain (and the Reconquista), and learn some more!
:)

Oh, I see how it is. We should endure their **** AND be thankful!
Let me ask you, what did the Muslims exactly do with those resources in contrast to what us 'westerners' did with them?

Need links? Or can you find those for yourself?

Ah, you know, if all you got about Islam is from Wikipedia, I recommend reading a book some time.
 
Last edited:
Then read up on the history of say the years round 900 AD to 1200 AD, how the writings of the classical Greeks were brought over to the West, or say a little on the Arab regime in Spain (and the Reconquista), and learn some more!

Ok, and then what happened? No one disputes that the seat of intellect and progress was in Persia and other Islamic nations. That misses the point. Have you heard Neil Degrasse Tyson's lecture on fall of Islamic enlightenment? Do you really not know the history? Would you like a link?

Gurdur, what has happened since then?

That's the point you miss.
 
Would you take Revd Ian Paisley's version of christanity to be definative?

I don't even know the guy, yet alone what he has to say, nor have I ever claimed to be vested in Christian core texts and teachings, so even if I knew what he had to say, I could probably not comment on it in a sufficient way.
 
Footprints in the Sands of Science

...

The influence of these early Islamic contributions to science remains to this day. For example, so widely distributed was the Arabic translation of Ptolemy’s magnum opus on the geocentric universe, (originally written in Greek in a.d. 150), that even today, in all translations, the work is known by its Arabic title Almagest, or “The Greatest.”

...

The late Pakistani physicist Abdus Salam, the first Muslim ever to win the Nobel Prize, lamented:

There is no question [that] of all civilizations on this planet, science is the weakest in the lands of Islam. The dangers of this weakness cannot be overemphasized since honorable survival of a society depends directly on strength in science and technology in the conditions of the present age.

Gurdur, here's the question, why did the lands of Islam go from the greatest to the weakest? There's actually an answer. It might surprise you.
 
Gurdur, where is the evidence that Islam is pro-intellectualism?

Historic baghdad.

Where are the seats of learning?

These days? Alexandra to an extent Istanbul. Tehran to a degree. Where are the christian ones outside the US an europe?

Who are the Islamic secular thinkers?

Define your terms.

Does Islam mean submission?

Does the phrase "Happy are those who fear the lord" mean anything to you?

I don't claim that Muslims are inherently different from anyone else. I claim that the religion, by and large, causes great suffering and misery for its people. Not all of them. Many of them.

I claim that Islam is counter to freedom of thought and behavior. It is oppressive and intellectually stilting. Not always, but too damn often.

Not really. Look at where in the world islam is mostly based. The fertile cresent never really recovered from the collapse of agriculture due to deforestation. Those thay did arise got wacked by the mongols and later us. North africa suffered from being grabbed by europeans which is never good for your ability to develop independent learning. Centeral asia has tended to suffer from low populartion densities which are never great if you want centers of learning. Finaly pakistan suffered from British imperialism but it's urban areas are doing fairly well.

Or in other words geography is somewhat against Islam.
 
Not really. Look at where in the world islam is mostly based. The fertile cresent never really recovered from the collapse of agriculture due to deforestation. Those thay did arise got wacked by the mongols and later us. North africa suffered from being grabbed by europeans which is never good for your ability to develop independent learning. Centeral asia has tended to suffer from low populartion densities which are never great if you want centers of learning. Finaly pakistan suffered from British imperialism but it's urban areas are doing fairly well.

Or in other words geography is somewhat against Islam.
I've read Diamond's Guns Germs and Steel and I don't remember any of this. I do remember about the dissolution of schools and the burning of books and one of the greatest libraries ever. I'll get a link but I think you need to do the same.
 
Oh, I see how it is. We should endure their **** AND be thankful!
Let me ask you, what did the Muslims exactly do with those resources in contrast to what us 'westerners' did with them?

Much the same really. Went out and killed other people. We were rather better at it and got lucking in avoiding the mongols.


Ah, you know, if all you got about Islam is from Wikipedia, I recommend reading a book some time.

Since we are discussing the fate of civilisations guns germs and steel should probably be a higher prioritory.
 
What exactly did I ignore that was so important.

Non-responsive. I asked a direct question. How on earth is the HRC supposed to come to a decision about subjects they can't even debate?

:rolleyes:

So typical. Fine, run away.

Hold on, wait a minute, it's the HRC's job to make policy based on discussion and debate. If everything is known then why have a debate at all? To state that they can't discuss or debate the issues is nonsense and you know it.

I thought you were going to run away.

My God, your ability to be both combative and provide zero substance is a true tribute to pro-intellectualism.

Again:

Tsukas said:
It isn't saying that whatever people do in the name of Islam cannot be criticized, but that the actions should be criticized and the Human Rights Council should avoid religious debates.

Well, you see, human rights abuses are carried out by people and by governments, you know, the things that the UN was established to deal with. Those are free to be criticized. I don't think you need to have a debate about Eugenics to recognize the human rights violations in the Holocaust.

In other words, this claim:

RandFan said:
The facts are that this thread is about silencing criticism of Sharia law or human rights abuses carried out by Muslims.

Is, as you so eloquently put it, "pure and unadulterated BS".
 
Why does it matter?

Because Europe has multiple factors in it's favor. The homes of islam for the most part do not. So if you want to compare islam to other religions it has to be like to like.
 
BTW, assuming that deforestation and geography led to a decline and I'm not familiar with that, it does not excuse the lack of any significant progress in modern history nor does it explain the hostility many Muslims have toward science and progress.
 
My God, your ability to be both combative and provide zero substance is a true tribute to pro-intellectualism.

Again:

In other words, this claim:

Is, as you so eloquently put it, "pure and unadulterated BS".
What? What the hell are you talking about?

Fact: Human rights abuses as they pertain specifically to Muslims and Sharia law can't be discussed in the Human Rights Council except by clerics.

That's the crux of the thread. I honestly don't have a clue what you are rambling on about.

Could you join us in the discussion? If you have some other issue PM me and I'll see if I can't help you resolve it. But please try to be clear.
 
Last edited:
I'd like to comment on this: I am in no way hysterical. Maybe you'd wish me to be, but I am quite calm.
:D

I picture Marlon Brando in Apocalypse now.

The hysteria... the hysteria...

I guess if you don't have argument then fall back on rhetoric.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom