Islam's war on freedom

Evidence?
See below:

They weren't being prevented from talking about the violations, they just couldn't say "And the backwards, anti-intellectual, religion with the name synonymous to submission, Islam is behind it all, because Islam is evil like that."
They can discuss abuses but they have to pretend it just happens in a vacuum. We need to do that for America. No fair linking America to extraordinary rendition or Abu Ghraib because it would hurt American sensibilities. Not all Americans are for rendition or torture.

It's still not washing. Your example proves my point. Thank you.

Which is more conducive to honor killings, Islam or western culture? Why don't clerics stand up against honor killings and stoning?

BTW, have you even watched Submission or read Infidel? Do you think Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a simply propagating lies? You have to really push to separate Islam from the abuses. It's real. Women really are beaten and raped by their husbands and it's true that Islam does little to nothing to stop it and in fact does more to further it.
 
Last edited:
Your initial claim isn't actualy true. Asside from tribal traditions there is a fair bit of secular politics in the islamic world.

I heard quite the opposite. Most Muslim I've heard claim their religion and politics are the same.

Well which ones would you like to stop?

Public hangings and stoning for no good reasons like adultery and homosexuality for starters.
 
I'm not sure what you mean now; establishing a 'large indiginious scientific base', or modernizing the umma (as in infrastructure)?
As for the the latter, religion would play a huge role. Imagine the US being Islamic - how Iraq would probably not have as much of a fit as they do.

Nope. Religion appears to have little to do with investment in infrastructure. Compare Hati and the Dominican Republic.


Saudi arabia has spent a fortune on infrastructure (where the bin lardens get their money from). Heh it's been said that you could be away from Riyadh for the summer and not be able to find your way around when you got back the build rate was so fast. Simular has happned in Dubai. In neither case has it manged to kickstart a significant amount of indigenous scientific progress.

Lybia has a collection of infrastructure projects. Doesn't appear to have worked out too well.
 
Nope. Religion appears to have little to do with investment in infrastructure. Compare Hati and the Dominican Republic.

Apparently it's not clear enough, so let me clarify: I am mainly pointing at the acceptence of infrastructural work done by 'unbelievers' etc. That kind of thing. ;)
One example that comes to mind is the inability of Israelis to do work on the sewage system of the Palestinians because they'd get lynched for being Jewish - or not.
 
Last edited:
I heard quite the opposite. Most Muslim I've heard claim their religion and politics are the same.

Where does protesting over food prices fit into islamic theology?

In the west there is a complication that the islamic community tends to have only a limited amount of religion in common so insted tend towards uniteing under the the banner of politics.

Public hangings and stoning for no good reasons like adultery and homosexuality for starters.

Fairly trivail to get around. See how judaism does it.

But in any case death for such activities is becomeing less common and where it still exists tends to be driven by tribal traditions.

Of course we have simular issues in christian zimbabwe (although in that case the laws date back to that highly westernised country the uk) and Jamaica. The law doesn't object to homosexuality in russia but I would advise against going on a gay pride march there.
 
See below:

They can discuss abuses but they have to pretend it just happens in a vacuum. We need to do that for America. No fair linking America to extraordinary rendition or Abu Ghraib because it would hurt American sensibilities. Not all Americans are for rendition or torture.

I assume you are referring to the government of the United States of America, which, as you previously admitted, is different than a religion.

Furthermore, the whole point of the UN is to deal with governments, not religions.

It's still not washing. Your example proves my point. Thank you.

And you are still prefer childish attacks to intellectual discussions. Your example proves my point. Thank you.

Which is more conducive to honor killings, Islam or western culture? Why don't clerics stand up against honor killings and stoning?

BTW, have you even watched Submission or read Infidel? Do you think Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a simply propagating lies? You have to really push to separate Islam from the abuses. It's real. Women really are beaten and raped by their husbands and it's true that Islam does little to nothing to stop it and in fact does more to further it.

Yes, yes, you don't like Islam. That has nothing to do with your main assertion, that the UN had banned criticism of human rights violations committed by Muslims.
 
Apparently it's not clear enough, so let me clarify: I am mainly pointing at the acceptence of infrastructural work done by 'unbelievers' etc. That kind of thing. ;)

Can you show any actual evidence of this being the case in the last few decades? Faisal had some resistance back in the 60s but Muhammad employed unbelievers on the occasion so Faisal was able to argue around it.

One example that comes to mind is the inability of Israelis to do work on the sewage system of the Palestinians because they'd get lynched for being Jewish - or not.

That is not a situation that can be generalised across the islamic world.
 
Which means eventually they can not criticise a or the source (the when it comes to Muslims) for - as an example - FGM in countries like Egypt, Sudan etc.

Jolly good!

Ah, so you think it is the government's domain to attack the source of crime, e.g. hate ideologies do you?

We can make a Comrade out of you yet :D !
 
I assume you are referring to the government of the United States of America, which, as you previously admitted, is different than a religion.
Yes, and?

Furthermore, the whole point of the UN is to deal with governments, not religions.
Please to look up the definition of theocracy.

Yes, yes, you don't like Islam. That has nothing to do with your main assertion, that the UN had banned criticism of human rights violations committed by Muslims.
?

We've agreed what the facts of this issue are. Trying to cause controversy where there is none isn't going to advance the discussion. At the end of the day the UN has banned criticism of Islam during debates at the HRC. Given that a number of nations are theocratic and Muslim that effectively ends discussion of human rights abuses carried out by Islamic nations.
 
BTW, have you even watched Submission or read Infidel? Do you think Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a simply propagating lies? You have to really push to separate Islam from the abuses. It's real. Women really are beaten and raped by their husbands and it's true that Islam does little to nothing to stop it and in fact does more to further it.

I'd like to note the evasion of this point. The abuses are actually well documented and the down playing of them is rather disappointing.
 
But in any case death for such activities is becomeing less common and where it still exists tends to be driven by tribal traditions.
Do you have any evidence of this?

ETA: I really have a problem with this kind of downplaying of the problems in Islamic nations. The oppression is real. The mistreatment of women is real. The Islamic religion is not conducive to freedom and Independence of women. Yes, many of the problems are endemic to the tribal life but Islam is conducive to those cultures. No one has explained how or why Islam is counter to these abuses. On the other hand there is good reason why Islam furthers them in its views of infidels and women.

I don't want to end Islam. I want to end the abuses and not excuse Islams complicity.
 
Last edited:
Adulterous mother will face death by stoning

An Islamic court in Nigeria yesterday confirmed a sentence of death by stoning handed down to a divorced woman for having a child out of wedlock.

To cries of "God is great" from the public gallery, the court ruled that the execution for adultery would be carried out after Amina Lawal, 30, weans her eight-month-old daughter, Wasila, probably in two years' time.
Sharia. Not to be critisized in the HRC.
 
Teenage Mother Sentenced To 180 Lashes For Childbearing

"Bariya Ibrahim Magazu was convicted of zina (fornication) in September 2000, by the Shariah Court of Zamfara State, in northern Nigeria (enacted in June 2000) for being pregnant without being married. (Editor's Note: Zamfara State of Northern Nigeria, recently adopted Muslim/Sharia Law as State law.)
Not to be criticized in the HRC. To criticize Sharia Law is forbidden. But we are supposed to pretend that this has nothing to do with Islam. Right.
 
ETA: I really have a problem with this kind of downplaying of the problems in Islamic nations. The oppression is real. The mistreatment of women is real. The Islamic religion is not conducive to freedom and Independence of women. Yes, many of the problems are endemic to the tribal life but Islam is conducive to those cultures. No one has explained how or why Islam is counter to these abuses. On the other hand there is good reason why Islam furthers them in its views of infidels and women.

I don't want to end Islam. I want to end the abuses and not excuse Islams complicity.

There are backwards, repressive Christian nations too, but Christianity as a whole is not responsible for that, and attacking Christianity in general will not solve all those nation's problems.

There are also Christians who are perfectly decent to women and each other, and attacking Christianity in general will not endear you to them or garner their support.

Exactly the same facts are true of Islam.

Attacking "Islam" as opposed to attacking specific, evil groups, cultural values or practises is sloppy thinking and counterproductive to boot.

Specifying exactly which sects or people you are condemning is not as easy and fun as spewing generalised, ill-researched hatred but too bad, as a human being with a brain you owe it to yourself to do the legwork required in order to direct your moral outrage to proper targets and only proper targets.
 
Child sexual abuse in Bahrain as permited by Sharia Law but having nothing to do with Islam.

 
There are backwards, repressive Christian nations too, but Christianity as a whole is not responsible for that, and attacking Christianity in general will not solve all those nation's problems.

There are also Christians who are perfectly decent to women and each other, and attacking Christianity in general will not endear you to them or garner their support.

Exactly the same facts are true of Islam.

Attacking "Islam" as opposed to attacking specific, evil groups, cultural values or practises is sloppy thinking and counterproductive to boot.

Specifying exactly which sects or people you are condemning is not as easy and fun as spewing generalised, ill-researched hatred but too bad, as a human being with a brain you owe it to yourself to do the legwork required in order to direct your moral outrage to proper targets and only proper targets.
But I do criticize and attack Christianity and for good reason. Spend some time in the R&P forums. I criticize Christianity frequently. Some Christians have me on ignore for pointing out that the god of the Bible condoned stoning women for adultery and killing of children. I quote passages proving that almost daily at times. I'm equitable in my denunciation of religion I assure you.

The problem Kevin is that there is gross abuse carried out in the name of Islam at this very moment. And it's not just in the name of Islam it is condoned and encouraged by the religion. Further, many nations are theocratically Islamic and it is specifically the oppression by the religious clerics and their influence of the governments that cause so many problems.

Banning the criticism of Islam is the worst possible move and antithetical to the purpose of the UN.

Martin Luther protested the Catholic church and that led to a reformation. We need to do something to end the oppression of the Islamic church.

I understand your point but the problems are so widespread and so entrenched at this point the best strategy, IMO, is to point out the abuses and not give religion a free pass simply because it is a religion.
 
There are backwards, repressive Christian nations too, but Christianity as a whole is not responsible for that, and attacking Christianity in general will not solve all those nation's problems.

There are also Christians who are perfectly decent to women and each other, and attacking Christianity in general will not endear you to them or garner their support.

Exactly the same facts are true of Islam.

Attacking "Islam" as opposed to attacking specific, evil groups, cultural values or practises is sloppy thinking and counterproductive to boot.

Specifying exactly which sects or people you are condemning is not as easy and fun as spewing generalised, ill-researched hatred but too bad, as a human being with a brain you owe it to yourself to do the legwork required in order to direct your moral outrage to proper targets and only proper targets.

Who said anything about attacking?

The point here is that nothing is immune to criticism. Everything should be debated, and Islam doesn't have a free pass because a few people might get offended.

That is all.
 
Who said anything about attacking?

The point here is that nothing is immune to criticism. Everything should be debated, and Islam doesn't have a free pass because a few people might get offended.

That is all.
Actually that is a good point. It is about criticising and not attacking.
 
Yes, and?

Please to look up the definition of theocracy.

?

Your reasoning and logic is overwhelming.

We've agreed what the facts of this issue are.

What? No, we obviously haven't, unless you suddenly conceded that UN HRC can indeed critique human rights violations committed by Muslims in debate.

Trying to cause controversy where there is none isn't going to advance the discussion.

Hm, yes, I'VE been the OVERdramatic one in THIS discussion :rolleyes: .



At the end of the day the UN has banned criticism of Islam during debates at the HRC. Given that a number of nations are theocratic and Muslim that effectively ends discussion of human rights abuses carried out by Islamic nations.

Sorry, but that is still the same assertion that you've restated again and again without evidence. Your leap from a government actions being based on a religion meaning that the religion must be debated is wrong.

As I said before, and you ignored before, in an assault trial, do you debate heterosexism in the Church? Ideological motives are rather irrelevant.

And I believe you are straying back to your crappy source source in saying that they can't critique anything done by Sharia law. I wonder if that incredibly biased and inflammatory article may have jumped to reactionary conclusions :rolleyes: .
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom