Islam's war on freedom

Gurdur, what do you think of the UN singling out "Islam" as being de facto protected from criticism. Isn't this a kind of segregation?

Isn't this the topic of the thread?
Gurdur doesn't want to deal with the topic. He would prefer to individualize the issue and he is off topic.
 
Gurdur, what do you think of the UN singling out "Islam" as being de facto protected from criticism. Isn't this a kind of segregation?


I'ld like to see a better news item which was more accurate on this than the OP. Tell me, do you believe all headlines? The headlines here are woefully emotional and non-informative. You going to pretend that the UN has singled out Islam, or protected it against criticism? Really? Do show me actual court cases then of the UN prosecuting offenders. Please do. The rank, nonfactual hysteria in this thread is stultifying.

Isn't this the topic of the thread?


Among with the subjects of just what is Islam, since a few have taken it upon themselves to pronounce on it.

Hey, don't blame me, I'm a skeptic. :)
 
How is criticizing human rights abuses bigotry?
BTW, I would like an answer. The facts are that this thread is about silencing criticism of Sharia law or human rights abuses carried out by Muslims.

The question deserves an answer.
 
Ok.... please to explain how they are going to come to a finding about something that THEY CAN'T DEBATE?

Are you serious?

Hey, let's try a little experiment. We will have a finding on this subject but you can't debate it.

Are you getting this now?

Well, obviously you missed or ignored the rest of my comments.

If that is your only defense, then it only shows how staggeringly ignorant you are about this issue. Do you even know how the HRC works, or the UN for that matter? What, did you just see a link that had the ebil Islam in it taking away free speech?

I won't debate children.
 
Last edited:
The headlines here are woefully emotional and non-informative.
If you were to find out that the OP is correct and criticism of Islam or Sharia is not allowed during debates would you concede that is wrong and antithetical to the goals of the HRC?
 
BTW, I would like an answer. The facts are that this thread is about silencing criticism of Sharia law or human rights abuses carried out by Muslims.

The question deserves an answer.

Well, you see, human rights abuses are carried out by people and by governments, you know, the things that the UN was established to deal with. Those are free to be criticized. I don't think you need to have a debate about Eugenics to recognize the human rights violations in the Holocaust.
 
Well, obviously you missed or ignored the rest of my comments.
What exactly did I ignore that was so important.

If that is your only defense, then it only shows how staggeringly ignorant you are about this issue. Do you even know how the HRC works, or the UN for that matter? What, did you just see a link that had the ebil Islam in it taking away free speech?
Non-responsive. I asked a direct question. How on earth is the HRC supposed to come to a decision about subjects they can't even debate?

I won't debate children.
:rolleyes:

So typical. Fine, run away.
 
Well, you see, human rights abuses are carried out by people and by governments, you know, the things that the UN was established to deal with. Those are free to be criticized. I don't think you need to have a debate about Eugenics to recognize the human rights violations in the Holocaust.
Hold on, wait a minute, it's the HRC's job to make policy based on discussion and debate. If everything is known then why have a debate at all? To state that they can't discuss or debate the issues is nonsense and you know it.

I thought you were going to run away.
 
And I did this where?

...."Perhaps we should rename the United Nations and call it the “Nations of Islam."
I don't know if it is impossible but I do believe it will be near impossible.

Islam has never had a reformation and there are no dynamics that would cause one to think it will. The religion is specifically anti-intellectual and anti-enlightenment. Unlike Judaism it frowns on debate and dissent. Islam literally means submission. A Muslim can be put to death for questioning or leaving the religion (see Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Salmon Rushdie).

Are there any analogs in Judeo-Christianity?
(deeply ignorant of history and simply wrong)

Gurdur doesn't want to deal with the topic. He would prefer to individualize the issue and he is off topic.


Yeah, yeah. Just deal with the facts, will you? Sorry if I upset you not marching in lockstep to the bigotry, but hey, this is a board for skeptics.

I won't hold my breath. BTW, you are in breach of the rules. This isn't about me.


And it's not about me either, so pot, kettle, and BTW, Report if you must, but you are no mod, so don't try that one. Jeeez. Wake up and deal.
 
Post 34.

Post #34 said:
RandFan said:
Islam has never had a reformation

In the Christian sense, 'Wahabism' (which is pretty much Salafism by the way; hello Brits!) and I assume the stuff the Taliban and maybe even al-Qaeda are doing, teaching and following could be considered a reformation in the sense of going back to the core of Islam before sects came about.

Okay, I've been there. Anything wrong with that? I don't see me saying 'Islam = al-Qaeda'. What I do see is, once again, you don't understanding what I am saying. Fun fact for you on Ayman al-Zawahiri, courtesy of Wikipedia:

Upbringing and education

Ayman al-Zawahiri was born to a prominent upper middle class family in Maadi, Egypt, a suburb of Cairo, and was reportedly a studious youth. His father, Mohammed Rabie al-Zawahiri, was a pharmacologist and a professor coming from a large family of doctors and scholars, while his mother, Umayma Azzam, came from a wealthy, politically active clan. He excelled in school, loved poetry, "hated violent sports" - which he thought were `inhumane` - and had a deep affection for his mother.[9]

His family was "religious but not overly pious,"[10] but Zawahiri became both quite pious and political, under the influence of his uncle Mahfouz Azzam, who had been a student and then lifelong follower of radical Islamist thinker Sayyid Qutb.

Qutb preached in his manifesto, Ma'alim fi al-Tariq (Milestones), that "the Muslim community has been extinct for a few centuries" having reverted to Jahiliyyah, "the state of ignorance of the guidance from God."[11] To restore Islam and free Muslims, "jahili society, jahili concepts, jahili traditions and jahili leadership," had to be eliminated,[12] and to do this a vanguard of true Muslims modeling itself after the original Muslims, the "companions" of Muhammad had to be developed. Like the companions, this vanguard would cut themselves off from the Jahiliyyah -- i.e., ignore the learning and culture of non-Muslim groups (Greeks, Romans, Persians, Christians or Jews) -- and separate themselves from their old non-Muslim friends and family. It would look to the Qur'an for orders to obey, not "learning and information" or solutions to problems.[13]
The implication of this idea for many, was that Muslim government officials, particularly those of Egypt, had become so corrupted they were no longer true Muslims. As apostates, they could be killed under Islamic law.

Read and understand.

You do know that the Al-Qaida fanbase among Muslims is bloody small, don't you? Didn't someone recently put you right at length on that? Oh, that's right, he did; but for your own reasons you want to keep on equating Islam and Al-Qaida, explicitly and/or implicitly.

If you are referring to my conversation with Upchurch, read it again and understand what the poll says. It does not say what you might wish it would say. Nor does it say much or anything on al-Qaeda anyway.

Not an honest stance of yours by any means.

The only dishonesty I see is coming from you here.
 
(deeply ignorant of history and simply wrong)
I'm sorry but a.) stating it is ignorant of history doesn't make it so and b.) It doesn't reveal what you claimed.

Yeah, yeah. Just deal with the facts, will you? Sorry if I upset you not marching in lockstep to the bigotry, but hey, this is a board for skeptics.
No one is asking you to march in lockstep.

And it's not about me either...
You are the one who started to focus on me so it's no pot calling kettle. I responded. End of story.

If you keep the focus on me I will report it.
 
I don't know if it is impossible but I do believe it will be near impossible.

Islam has never had a reformation and there are no dynamics that would cause one to think it will. The religion is specifically anti-intellectual and anti-enlightenment. Unlike Judaism it frowns on debate and dissent. Islam literally means submission. A Muslim can be put to death for questioning or leaving the religion (see Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Salmon Rushdie).

Are there any analogs in Judeo-Christianity?

FTR, I criticize all religions.
I stand by this. It's the truth. It's against the religion and not the adherents much like I was against Stalinism and not Soviet citizens. Like it is possible to be agaisnt the policies of America but not Americans.

I challenge you Gurdur to show how anything in this post is wrong.
 
Okay, I've been there. Anything wrong with that? I don't see me saying 'Islam = al-Qaeda'. What I do see is, once again, you don't understanding what I am saying.


Yeah, yeah, you equate Islam with terrorism and with AL-Qaida, funnily enough it's just the rest of us who do not get what you mean because we read your actual words. Dearie me.
:boggled:

I do like how you quote one single Muslim, though, as though it meant anything for Islam as a whole. How ridiculous do you want to get? You want to try pretending Jack Chick tracts represent Christianity as a whole?


If you are referring to my conversation with Upchurch


Yep. Rarely have I seen anyone so unwilling to learn and so given to prevarication as you in your long conversation with him. He was extremely patient with you. It's all there, evenif you chose ignoring it all.
 
I.... ou are the one who started to focus on me so it's no pot calling kettle. I responded. End of story.

If you keep the focus on me I will report it.

RandFan, get off it. Just deal with the facts, and deal with your conflation of Islam as a whole, will you, already? This other gunk of yours is deeply boring.
 
Okay, I've been there. Anything wrong with that? I don't see me saying 'Islam = al-Qaeda'. What I do see is, once again, you don't understanding what I am saying. Fun fact for you on Ayman al-Zawahiri, courtesy of Wikipedia:



Read and understand.

Would you take Revd Ian Paisley's version of christanity to be definative?
 
Great answer. Care to enlighten us? Otherwise I'd suggest you create a thread where you can, well, do whatever it is you are doing here!

Sure. Go read the Wikipedia article on Islam, as good a place to start as any, find out about Sufi'ism, Alawiteism, all the other variants, and learn something!
:)

Then read up on the history of say the years round 900 AD to 1200 AD, how the writings of the classical Greeks were brought over to the West, or say a little on the Arab regime in Spain (and the Reconquista), and learn some more!
:)

Need links? Or can you find those for yourself?
 
Yeah, yeah, you equate Islam with terrorism and with AL-Qaida, funnily enough it's just the rest of us who do not get what you mean because we read your actual words. Dearie me.
:boggled:

Clipboard01.jpg

I do like how you quote one single Muslim, though, as though it meant anything for Islam as a whole. How ridiculous do you want to get? You want to try pretending Jack Chick tracts represent Christianity as a whole?

Who? Oh and:


Yep. Rarely have I seen anyone so unwilling to learn and so given to prevarication as you in your long conversation with him. He was extremely patient with you. It's all there, evenif you chose ignoring it all.

And another one:


There is just no other way.
 
Last edited:
I'ld like to see a better news item which was more accurate on this than the OP. Tell me, do you believe all headlines? The headlines here are woefully emotional and non-informative. You going to pretend that the UN has singled out Islam, or protected it against criticism? Really? Do show me actual court cases then of the UN prosecuting offenders. Please do. The rank, nonfactual hysteria in this thread is stultifying.

Do you have anything to say about the OP or not?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom