Islam's war on freedom

Not all of the links were biased (tasfir.com and altasfir.com aren't bad)

I have to say though, this one was pretty funny to see. You probably don't even know what you're looking at, do you? Ah well.
 
Last edited:
Even when I try to be gracious you have to throw it back. The height of civility, your posts are.
 
Bush and his Admin deserved to get criticized.
I live in a Democracy. Americans absolutely deserve to be criticized. As Americans we must accept responsibility. There can be no argument about that. Otherwise we are no better than (Godwin, sorry) other folks who declared that they were simply following orders.

...and when religion comes into play you have to be even more carefull and direct the critique very precise.
Nonsense. It is the religion that is, to very much degree, the problem. It requires submission to god and those who are his mouthpiece, Imams.

I think it is impossible for outstanders of said religion to change anything, it has to come from inside. and this is a long process.
Yeah, we've heard this before. During the civil rights movement. It's nonsense.
 
Saying things that are blatant lies, however, does. I'd love to know which mythical streets in London they meant.
I've no intention of coming to the defense of the 700 club but I would like to go on record as strongly disagreeing with you. In the end it is still ad hominem. Plenty of reason to be skeptical but one untruth does not make everything untrue (see Michael Moore's skillful editing).

Facts stand on their own.

I don't dismiss what they say, but I tend to hear a lot of confirmation bias in the information they use even in passing. And when it comes to a religious program making an assessment of another religion, well, let's just say I'm inclined to require a more reputable second opinion. ;)
No problem.

I think that people are going to be less receptive to listening when they feel threatened. It's not the extremists who I'm talking about, either.
I understand your first statement and I am inclined to agree, to a point. The second is vague so it's difficult to comment but I suspect I would very much disagree with that statement.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
I live in a Democracy. Americans absolutely deserve to be criticized. As Americans we must accept responsibility. There can be no argument about that. Otherwise we are no better than (Godwin, sorry) other folks who declared that they were simply following orders.

Nonsense. It is the religion that is, to very much degree, the problem. It requires submission to god and those who are his mouthpiece, Imams.

Yeah, we've heard this before. During the civil rights movement. It's nonsense.

because it is a religion you have to be carefull and place your critique very precise. sure you should be able to criticize it, but i think this has to be done carefully, This can be something very offending. Those people really belive in a superior beeing watching and judging us. And they belive what they do is needed to make that beeing happy or so.

and i do really belive that a religion cannot be reformed or changed from non belivers of that religion.
 
because it is a religion you have to be carefull and place your critique very precise.
Hell no.

Fairness and honesty might dictate it but not because it is religion. I think you're purpose here is to make an argument that is practical but I'm not that moved by it.

and i do really belive that a religion cannot be reformed or changed from non belivers of that religion.
I don't think I made any such assertion counter. That said, belivers can be influenced from the outside to make change.

See Mormons and polygamy for an excellent example. I have more if you need them.
 
I missed this one earlier.
I've no intention of coming to the defense of the 700 club but I would like to go on record as strongly disagreeing with you. In the end it is still ad hominem. Plenty of reason to be skeptical but one untruth does not make everything untrue (see Michael Moore's skillful editing).

Facts stand on their own.

Indeed, the facts stand on their own, but the presentations often do not. The implications in the presentation of that video do not necessarily reflect the reality of what the facts indicate. Moore's skillful editing is a good example of that.

I have no reason to disbelieve that there are religious fundamentalists in Britain who have committed to circumstances that led to the deaths of even their own family members. That wouldn't be a situation unheard of in many countries (the US included). What I reject is the implication that it's the Muslim faith that is the source of the problem, because the facts (which stand on their own) indicate that this is not only a phenomenon within Islam. The locations, the political implications, and in some cases the extremity may differ between different groups, but that's normally less a matter of the religion itself and more to do with the social make-up of the originating incident. We don't see stonings, beheadings, or other horrible acts against people by their own support structure in the US because of a different social environment (which I'm in favor of encouraging the spread of). That doesn't mean horrible things don't happen for similar reasons anyway here in the States, it means enough people got tired of it to put a stop to its institutional presence.

I'm not trying to argue "X does it too" here, I'm trying to point out that the source of the problem when examining the facts seems to be different than the hyperbole within videos like that one by the 700 Club (among other things).
 
The problem we have--and which you do not apparently see--is that within Western Culture, such religous conflicts are the Exception, and unusual enough to raise outrage and/or action, while within the Islam, they tend to be the rule, and raise the "they should have know better" vilification of the victim...
 
the Islam

Islamophobe!

I'm not trying to argue "X does it too" here, I'm trying to point out that the source of the problem when examining the facts seems to be different than the hyperbole within videos like that one by the 700 Club (among other things).

Care to define 'the problem'?

Saying things that are blatant lies, however, does. I'd love to know which mythical streets in London they meant.

What exactly do they say? I must have missed it; or is it on their webpage (which I have not had a look at)?
 
Care to define 'the problem'?

Fundamentalism. It's less a "the problem" and more "the source" of multiple problems.

What exactly do they say? I must have missed it; or is it on their webpage (which I have not had a look at)?

The video on the first page says there are streets in London where non-Muslims can't go for fear of attack. Honestly the whole video plays with implying some sort of infestation-- not unlike what I've seen said of hispanics in the US-- by Muslims in the UK. The comment that there are streets in London where a non-Muslim wouldn't go actually made me laugh at the sincerity behind the narrator's voice. I've been to cities where there are streets a majority of people would want to avoid for their safety, but to this day I have never seen a city street that was so daunting because of people of a certain religion populating it. I'd be very curious to see it for myself.
 
The problem we have--and which you do not apparently see--is that within Western Culture, such religous conflicts are the Exception, and unusual enough to raise outrage and/or action, while within the Islam, they tend to be the rule, and raise the "they should have know better" vilification of the victim...

Do you mean the Islamic world or the Middle Eastern world or the Arab world? You see, if we're going to start pointing out examples of 'the exception' and 'the rule' in this case, I think it's a good idea to not mix those things up.

I find the comments in this thread an interesting comparison to the vegan dating thread. Apparently self-righteousness is okay sometimes and not okay other times.
 
Fundamentalism. It's less a "the problem" and more "the source" of multiple problems.

Does not compute! You said "What I reject is the implication that it's the Muslim faith that is the source of the problem". Maybe you want to rephrase that or get to the problem(s)?

The video on the first page says there are streets in London where non-Muslims can't go for fear of attack.

The one in #5 embedded by cyclone, right? I must have missed that assertion in the video (if it is in there at all), but there are indeed cases of this. It's probably exaggerated to a certain extend, especially the 'attack on sight' stuff, but it's not made up. We have our own cases of whole areas like that here in Germany now.
 
Does not compute! You said "What I reject is the implication that it's the Muslim faith that is the source of the problem". Maybe you want to rephrase that or get to the problem(s)?

Nope, you just parsed it poorly. The problem, obviously, is violence and human rights violations. The source of the problem, however, I am proposing is fundamentalism of any sort, not just of the Muslim sort. That clear it up for you?

The one in #5 embedded by cyclone, right? I must have missed that assertion in the video (if it is in there at all), but there are indeed cases of this. It's probably exaggerated to a certain extend, especially the 'attack on sight' stuff, but it's not made up. We have our own cases of whole areas like that here in Germany now.

If it's there at all? Do you seriously need me to give you the counter time on the video so you can check yourself? What an odd thing to be incredulous about when you can simply go watch for yourself.

Yes, it is made up. There might be places people are too afraid to go, but give me any location in either London or Germany that you think is not safe for a non-Muslim to walk because they are non-Muslim, and please give me the address because I'll be sure to add it to my list of places to see when I take a vacation in the area. I'm sure there are places where crime may make it dangerous, but religion? Seriously, you're going to need to back up a claim like that with a little more than "trust me" assurance.
 
The problem, obviously, is violence and human rights violations. The source of the problem, however, I am proposing is fundamentalism of any sort, not just of the Muslim sort.

The case is pretty clear to me when you got a Muslim family of which the father kills his daughter with the help of his uncle because she's not Muslim enough. As seen in the video, as seen in Germany just a week ago, as another young woman was killed; as seen all over the western world done by Muslims acting out their faith while disregarding the law - why heed it anyway, if it's man-made and not by 'Allah'?

What you are proposing is all fine and dandy, but you might want to look above and see what the thread's title is.


It's always strange to me when we, you, talk about Islam and Muslims and how it's only the fundamentalists, or radicals that pose a problem.

Isn't it scary enough to have the need of 'moderates' or a 'moderate Islam' just to not have Muslims whipping and stoning daughters and sons because they're lewd?
Isn't it scary enough to have the need of 'moderates' or a 'moderate Islam' just to not have Muslims beheading other Muslims or non-Muslims for leaving Islam or not joining it or living as a 2nd class citizen while being subdued?
Isn't it scary enough to have the need of 'moderates' or a 'moderate Islam' just to not have Muslims throw homosexuals from 'the highest place' just because they're homosexuals?
Isn't it scary enough to have the need of 'moderates' or a 'moderate Islam' just to not have people cutting off limbs or crucifying others?

Is there such a difference between the two biggest denominations, Sunni Islam and Shia Islam? Sunnis chop off limbs, behead people, call for the genocide of Jews to bring about 'the day of judgement' - Shias do the same and openly even more, like hanging homosexuals from cranes.

What makes a Muslim a moderate, GrenMe? Can and does a 'moderate' just discard the barbaric things he does not like about Islam? Doesn't that make him or her an apostate; to discard - if only parts of - 'the unwritten word of Allah'?
Does 'the moderate' just not act on what is commanded as much as the fundamental one does; ignore commandments?

Does 'the moderate' not still believe in this horse crap and further the radicals', the fundamentalists' cause?

What is 'radical Islam' and what is 'moderate Islam'?
Which sect did Muhammad belong to? Which sect did the 'rightly guided caliphs' adhere to?

Is 'moderate Islam' to discard parts of the 'true religion' or to distort parts?
Isn't Islam really the problem then? And isn't it even a bigger problem then to be unable to freely criticise the laws, the sharia that stems from this barbaric 'religion' over at an institution having 'human rights' in the title?

Inquiring minds wish to know, GrenMe.

If it's there at all? Do you seriously need me to give you the counter time on the video so you can check yourself?

Since you are proposing this, yes, why not.

What an odd thing to be incredulous about when you can simply go watch for yourself.

What's odd here is that it seems to have eluded me, although I have a pretty good attention span and was focused on it and the main reason to even watch it in the first place was because of these streets.

Yes, it is made up. There might be places people are too afraid to go, but give me any location in either London or Germany that you think is not safe for a non-Muslim to walk because they are non-Muslim, and please give me the address because I'll be sure to add it to my list of places to see when I take a vacation in the area. I'm sure there are places where crime may make it dangerous, but religion? Seriously, you're going to need to back up a claim like that with a little more than "trust me" assurance.

Not even that would help, since you already said 'it's made up'. But maybe you'd do good to watch 'Dispatches - Undercover Mosque' and 'Dispatches - Undercover Mosque: The Return' and think about what effect the footage you see can have on an area with a high density of Muslim people or those exclusively living there.
 
Fundamentalism. It's less a "the problem" and more "the source" of multiple problems.



The video on the first page says there are streets in London where non-Muslims can't go for fear of attack. Honestly the whole video plays with implying some sort of infestation-- not unlike what I've seen said of hispanics in the US-- by Muslims in the UK. The comment that there are streets in London where a non-Muslim wouldn't go actually made me laugh at the sincerity behind the narrator's voice. I've been to cities where there are streets a majority of people would want to avoid for their safety, but to this day I have never seen a city street that was so daunting because of people of a certain religion populating it. I'd be very curious to see it for myself.

As a whitey I had to run after wandering into a street in Washington but that is off topic and nothing to do with religion. Try looking at Belfast in Northern Ireland. I think it fits your criteria.
 
I should have stayed disengaged with you previously, mrbaracuda, especially after you PM-ed me all pissed off. You're obviously not looking for discussion on the matter, you're looking for affirmation.
 
Nope, you just parsed it poorly. The problem, obviously, is violence and human rights violations. The source of the problem, however, I am proposing is fundamentalism of any sort, not just of the Muslim sort. That clear it up for you?



If it's there at all? Do you seriously need me to give you the counter time on the video so you can check yourself? What an odd thing to be incredulous about when you can simply go watch for yourself.

Yes, it is made up. There might be places people are too afraid to go, but give me any location in either London or Germany that you think is not safe for a non-Muslim to walk because they are non-Muslim, and please give me the address because I'll be sure to add it to my list of places to see when I take a vacation in the area. I'm sure there are places where crime may make it dangerous, but religion? Seriously, you're going to need to back up a claim like that with a little more than "trust me" assurance.

Sigh...
"There are none so blind..."
 
I should have stayed disengaged with you previously, mrbaracuda, especially after you PM-ed me all pissed off.

I was and am not pissed off. There is no reason to be.
If you thought I was, maybe there's something wrong on your end? :p

you're looking for affirmation.

Of reality on your part maybe. But, as it seems, one cannot expect such a thing from you.

You're obviously not looking for discussion on the matter

Yes I am. It's you who shies away from discussion all the time, not me.
Inquiring minds are disappointed, GreNME.

Image1.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom