Islam's war on freedom

I've read Diamond's Guns Germs and Steel and I don't remember any of this.

You should. The fagility of the fertile cresent is certianly covered. Being on the reciveing end of invadeing armies isn't but is well documented history. The mongols distroyed much.

I do remember about the dissolution of schools and the burning of books

Heh catholic spain did all that to south america.

and one of the greatest libraries ever.

Questionable. Then of course there is the suggestion that Theodosius I had something to with it. While invadeing muslims may have finished off the library the record of them doing so is weak and if they did it is likely the library would have been much reduced by that point.
 
You should. The fagility of the fertile cresent is certianly covered. Being on the reciveing end of invadeing armies isn't but is well documented history.
I do remember the point that farming moved from the fertile crescent to other areas but not that that specifically lead to the downfall. I'm listening to a video now that discusses the fall and I will post it but I've got to reiterate that even if you are correct it does not at all excuse the lack of progress in recent times.
 
it does not at all excuse the lack of progress in recent times.

Not to mention many Middle Eastern / Arabic Muslims have large quantities of money at their disposal to do something else than building artificial holiday resort islands or places for skiing in the desert. ;)
 
Imam Hamid al-Ghazali 1058 - 1111.

He declares that mathmatics is the work of the devil and moved Islam into a period of anti-intelectualism that it hasn't recovered from since.

It's by Neil deGrasse Tyson and that is not his area of expertise so I need to do more research. I also note that he leaves out the mention of Hamid al-Ghazali in a later article so that is a red flag.

http://thesciencenetwork.org/BeyondBelief/watch/watch.php?Video=Session 2

It's about 30 minutes in.
 
BTW, assuming that deforestation and geography led to a decline and I'm not familiar with that, it does not excuse the lack of any significant progress in modern history nor does it explain the hostility many Muslims have toward science and progress.

Modern history hasn't been too kind. The ottomans managed to keep the europeans out but that was at the cost of a largely fossilised societly to keep them in power (Japan had simular issues but the ottomans were always a biot more open to progress). Much of the rest of the islamic world fell to european armies who had little interest in setting up their holdings as centers of scientific devolopment.

Science is expensive even more so when you have little to build on.

Other than the creationism issues there doesn't appear to be much of a hostility towards science in islam.

Why does catholic south america fail to produce as many new delevlopments as the west? They got rid of the spanish before islam got rid of europeans. They have at least some worthwhile land and population densities.
 
Not to mention many Middle Eastern / Arabic Muslims have large quantities of money at their disposal to do something else than building artificial holiday resort islands or places for skiing in the desert. ;)
I know, that kills me. There doesn't seem to be an urgency to embrace intellectualism or enlightenment. If there is it's being hidden.

The greatest asset to human civilization is the human mind. Muslims, inherently, are no different from any other group of people.

BTW, Americans are falling in the race. I don't expect America to continue to be the leader in innovation and progress, due in part to our own superstition (see Intelligent Design).
 
Not to mention many Middle Eastern / Arabic Muslims have large quantities of money at their disposal to do something else than building artificial holiday resort islands or places for skiing in the desert. ;)

Okey suppose you wanted to develop a large indiginious scientific base. How would you do it?

The buildings of Dubai are an attempt to turn the place into a future income generator but it's not simple to do that by throwing money at the problem.
 
Last edited:
What? What the hell are you talking about?

Fact: Human rights abuses as they pertain specifically to Muslims and Sharia law can't be discussed in the Human Rights Council except by clerics.

Except that's not a fact, which I was clearly just talking about.

They can talk about the human rights violations committed by Muslims, and they can talk about the human rights violations committed by Muslim States.

What they can't critique is Islam, the faith, itself.

Think of it this way. When in a trial for assault, do you debate the merits of heterosexism in the Church?

No, that is not what the system is about.

The UN is a system for the cooperation of governments, and most of us think that government and religion should be separate. Why do you want an inter-governmental institution discussing faiths?

That's the crux of the thread. I honestly don't have a clue what you are rambling on about.

Could you join us in the discussion? If you have some other issue PM me and I'll see if I can't help you resolve it. But please try to be clear.

Maybe if you actually read everything I was writing, and tried to discuss things honestly, you wouldn't have such poor reading comprehension.
 
Imam Hamid al-Ghazali 1058 - 1111.

He declares that mathmatics is the work of the devil and moved Islam into a period of anti-intelectualism that it hasn't recovered from since.

It's by Neil deGrasse Tyson and that is not his area of expertise so I need to do more research. I also note that he leaves out the mention of Hamid al-Ghazali in a later article so that is a red flag.

http://thesciencenetwork.org/BeyondBelief/watch/watch.php?Video=Session 2

It's about 30 minutes in.

You might want to have a look at bid'a (Wikipedia I am afraid). I still have to get my head around the different categories and how to apply them, so don't ask me further on this for now. ;)
 
Okey suppose you wanted to develop a large indiginious scientific base. How would you do it?

Well with Islam it's pretty hard I'd say. ;)
What I was talking about is, well, just modernize the 'umma', you know? :)
 
They can talk about the human rights violations committed by Muslims...
Not if the abuse is a result of Islamic faith.

and they can talk about the human rights violations committed by Muslim States.
Not if talking about it is seen as a criticism of Islam.

What they can't critique is Islam, the faith, itself.
You mean they can't critique honor killings done in the name of Islam. They can't critique Sharia law.

It's not washing dude.
 
They can talk about the human rights violations committed by Muslims, and they can talk about the human rights violations committed by Muslim States.

What they can't critique is Islam, the faith, itself.

Which means eventually they can not criticise a or the source (the when it comes to Muslims) for - as an example - FGM in countries like Egypt, Sudan etc.

Jolly good!
 
Last edited:
Gurdur, since in the Muslim world politics and religion are the same, wouldn't this mean that we have a right to be especially critical of Islam, since it directly influences the policies of Islamic countries?

If we're not allowed to do that in UN humans Rights sessions, then how are we going to confront a country's abusive policies?
 
Imam Hamid al-Ghazali 1058 - 1111.

He declares that mathmatics is the work of the devil and moved Islam into a period of anti-intelectualism that it hasn't recovered from since.

The existance of Nasīr al-Dīn al-Tūsī in the 13th century suggests otherwise.

The date however collides with an increaseing amount of political instability which didn't help but development does continue. There exact reason why development halted is highly dissputed but I find the appearence of the Mongols on the scene about the time it happened to be somewhat suggestive.
 
Not if the abuse is a result of Islamic faith.

Not if talking about it is seen as a criticism of Islam.

You mean they can't critique honor killings done in the name of Islam. They can't critique Sharia law.

Evidence?

From my link:

On Monday Egypt, Pakistan and Iran angrily protested attempts by a humanist group to link Islam to human rights abuses such as female genital mutilation and so-called honour killing of women.

[Emphasis mine]

They weren't being prevented from talking about the violations, they just couldn't say "And the backwards, anti-intellectual, religion with the name synonymous to submission, Islam is behind it all, because Islam is evil like that."

It's not washing dude.

Repetition does not make something any less false, dude.
 
Last edited:
Gurdur, since in the Muslim world politics and religion are the same, wouldn't this mean that we have a right to be especially critical of Islam, since it directly influences the policies of Islamic countries?

Your initial claim isn't actualy true. Asside from tribal traditions there is a fair bit of secular politics in the islamic world.

If we're not allowed to do that in UN humans Rights sessions, then how are we going to confront a country's abusive policies?

Well which ones would you like to stop?
 
Religion unimportant. How would you do it anywhere?

I'm not sure what you mean now; establishing a 'large indiginious scientific base', or modernizing the umma (as in infrastructure)?
As for the the latter, religion would play a huge role. Imagine the US being Islamic - how Iraq would probably not have as much of a fit as they do.
 
Last edited:
I guess Buddha either got me on ignore or is ignoring what I am saying about the female genital mutilation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom