Islam's war on freedom

So when was the last time someone was killed for heresy in the Christian church?


Do you know many were killed only for being Muslims, Bosnia, by Serbs and Croats? Very recently? Hmmmm? Or you just choose to ignore such inconvenient facts?

No one is denying history Gurdur.


Bollocks, bollocks, bolllocks. Pull the other leg, it's got bells on. THe ignorance of history you've assumed like a cloak, or mrbaracuda simply shows, is massive and dishonest. You two are talking about Islam as if it was a monoloithic entity, and as if it was somehow a special given, a terrorist force in an essentialist way. The both of you need to come up with some honest arguments.

But hey, like I say, let me rain on your self-righteous parade. :)

As much as I loathe religion I have to face the fact that Christianity and Judaism has embraced western civilization and enlightenment to a significant degree greater than Islam.


Times were when it was otherwise, and no doubt it will be otherwise again. Go talk to the (Christian) Lord's Army in Uganda, learn something for once.
 
it gets even more hairy when mrbaracuda starts equating Islam with Al-Qaida. But hey; let me rain on your self-righteous crusade.
:)

Where am I equating them?
What else is going basically back to what Islam looked like and was lived in 630 AD+ than a reformation?

You do know why al-Qaeda has such a 'fan base', don't you?
Here's a hint: Sound, on Islamic texts based reasoning.
 
!

:D Hell no!

What?

?????

Hmmmmm... How to say this, ah HELL YES! (was that clear?). It's the effing Council on Human Rights for crying in the dark.

Are you getting this?

The council whose job it is, is to set policy to further human rights cannot do its job as it relates to Muslism because to do so would be insensitive to Islam.

You kill me, you really do.

TB: HRC.
RF: HRC? Oh, it's only the HRC. What's the HRC? The Human Rights Commision. Oh, well, that's all. So what if the Human Rights Commision can't discuss the human rights of Muslims?

Sheesh!!! For crying in the dark Tsukas, get real. Are you being obtuse? Are you pulling my leg here?



Well, as it is, they CAN'T DO IT ALL when it comes to Muslims now can they? No!

I gotta say it again, for crying in the dark.

OMG SPAZ!!!!!!1111

And WHAT kind of nick name is Tsukas? That has got to be the WORST butchering I've seen yet!!!!

@#$@!@#$@!@%T^

Ahem, now that that is out of the way, I think you didn't really read everything I wrote.

Tsukas said:
It isn't saying that whatever people do in the name of Islam cannot be criticized, but that the actions should be criticized and the Human Rights Council should avoid religious debates.

Also, from the article:

The ruling will not affect findings by the council’s experts, just its chamber debates.

...

The council’s resolutions carry no legal weight but are intended to throw a spotlight on governments that abuse their citizens.

[Emphasis mine]

If I shouted some, would that help me make my point?
 
To equate Islam as a whole...
Dealt with. Sorry but this is a bankrupt argument. Islam fosters Sharia law and other homophobic and anti-human rights theology. You can deny that until you are blue in the face but no one who is intellectually honest is going to agree with you.
 
Oh, and Gurdur, that's YOUR strawman, not mine. Dude, at least figure that one out.



Dude, grow up. Seen enough in this thread and others to know just what the POV's are. Be honest enough to admit it.
 
The ruling will not affect findings by the council’s experts, just its chamber debates.

Ok.... please to explain how they are going to come to a finding about something that THEY CAN'T DEBATE?

Are you serious?

Hey, let's try a little experiment. We will have a finding on this subject but you can't debate it.

Are you getting this now?
 
Dealt with. Sorry but this is a bankrupt argument. Islam fosters Sharia law and other homophobic and anti-human rights theology. You can deny that until you are blue in the face but no one who is intellectually honest is going to agree with you.


Such "invincible ignorance" is deeply funny. The only thing bankrupt is your bigotry.

Try this for size: there are many different strands in Islam, just like Christianity; nor is Sharia Islam-wide codified nor accepted nor implemented.

Regardless of your rantings, Muslims actually do form very different communities and polities.
 
Do you know many were killed only for being Muslims, Bosnia, by Serbs and Croats? Very recently? Hmmmm? Or you just choose to ignore such inconvenient facts?

How many have been killed today in the name of Islam? Hmmmm?
We could do this all day. How about you open a thread about that? Hmmmm?

If that makes you happy. Until then, I advise you to read the thread's title again.

You two are talking about Islam as if it was a monoloithic entity, and as if it was somehow a special given, a terrorist force in an essentialist way. The both of you need to come up with some honest arguments.

No, you just need to stop with the strawmen crap.

Times were when it was otherwise, and no doubt it will be otherwise again. Go talk to the (Christian) Lord's Army in Uganda, learn something for once.

How much of their stuff do they base on what Jesus did and said etc.?


It's quite funny to observe this behaviour in a thread called 'Islam's war on freedom'. Well, not really funny, but you get the idea of what I am saying.
 
Regardless of your rantings, Muslims actually do form very different communities and polities.

None of which anyone can criticize now, according to the UN, even if one of them may indeed be dead wrong and abusive towards mankind.
 
Dude, grow up. Seen enough in this thread and others to know just what the POV's are. Be honest enough to admit it.
You haven't a clue what my POV is, be honest about that.

I'm for human rights. All humans including Muslims.

Don't pretend to know my motivations or thoughts. You are clueless on this one I assure you. I've posted more than everyone on this forum save 3 people. If I were racist or anything like that you could dredge up a hell of a lot of posts to prove it.
 
Where am I equating them?

Post 34.


You do know why al-Qaeda has such a 'fan base', don't you?
Here's a hint: Sound, on Islamic texts based reasoning.


Oh, the hysteria. You do know that the Al-Qaida fanbase among Muslims is bloody small, don't you? Didn't someone recently put you right at length on that? Oh, that's right, he did; but for your own reasons you want to keep on equating Islam and Al-Qaida, explicitly and/or implicitly. Not an honest stance of yours by any means.

God, I love these rant threads where it is demanded of the rest of us that we join in the Ten-Minute Hate Session of the day; they're funny, as well as being utterly impotent. Rant on, however.
 
Such "invincible ignorance" is deeply funny. The only thing bankrupt is your bigotry.
How is criticizing human rights abuses bigotry?

Try this for size: there are many different strands in Islam, just like Christianity; nor is Sharia Islam-wide codified nor accepted nor implemented.
I never said anything differently.

Regardless of your rantings, Muslims actually do form very different communities and polities.
Entirely irrelevant to my point.
 
You haven't a clue what my POV is, be honest about that.


You off-planet again? I've known you for a couple of years and more on JREF. You do post enough to show things.

I'm for human rights. All humans including Muslims.


Congrats. :)

Don't pretend to know my motivations or thoughts. You are clueless on this one I assure you. I've posted more than everyone on this forum save 3 people. If I were racist or anything like that you could dredge up a hell of a lot of posts to prove it.


Stop being hysterical, and stop being foolish. See above.
 
Gurdur, what do you think of the UN singling out "Islam" as being de facto protected from criticism. Isn't this a kind of segregation?

Isn't this the topic of the thread?
 
How is criticizing human rights abuses bigotry?


Another deeply dishonest attempt of yours. Pose much? The bigotry lies in assuming that Islam is a monolithic whole, that Sharia is universally consistant or accepted by all Muslims, and that Islam has a special, essentialist terrorist or anti-freedom nature not paralled by other religions.

Entirely irrelevant to my point.


You need to try making a point worthwhile making.
 
The bigotry lies in assuming that Islam is a monolithic whole, that Sharia is universally consistant or accepted by all Muslims, and that Islam has a special, essentialist terrorist or anti-freedom nature not paralled by other religions.
And I did this where?

I won't hold my breath. BTW, you are in breach of the rules. This isn't about me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom