Islam's war on freedom

The UN is moving in the wrong direction.

I agree. What can be done about it without resorting to paranoid and fanatical right-wing talking points and conspiracy theories about the UN?

Disclaimer: I'm not implying you're engaging in said behaviors.
 
I agree. What can be done about it without resorting to paranoid and fanatical right-wing talking points and conspiracy theories about the UN?

Disclaimer: I'm not implying you're engaging in said behaviors.
No, I understand completly. The dynamics are difficult I agree. But I encourage anyone who is intelectually honest to look carefully at the facts. And please note that Pat Condell is not a fanatical right-winger.
 
The point of the thread is the UN policy to forbid criticism of Islam and Sharia law for human rights abuses.

Can you imagine a UN policy policy that excluded America from any human rights criticism? I don't want anyone excluded from criticism. America deserves any and all shame for its abuses at Abu Ghraib and for extraordinary rendition.

The UN is moving in the wrong direction.

Well, the only article I could find on that matter that wasn't as trashy as the one linked to was this one:

Linky.

Which obviously implies something different.

It isn't saying that whatever people do in the name of Islam cannot be criticized, but that the actions should be criticized and the Human Rights Council should avoid religious debates.

If you can find a better link, please do so. Most searches just turn up copies of the article you linked.
 
I've noticed that most defenders of Islam engage in this same non-sequitor. Condemning and being critical of religion does not follow that one is condemning all people who claim or are coerced into believing the religion.

Why can't/won't you separate the human from the religion?

Because people make the religion. For every different person, there is a different type of Islam, just like for every Christian, there is a different Christianity.

I have yet to meet this independent entity called "Islam".
 
Well, the only article I could find on that matter that wasn't as trashy as the one linked to was this one:

Linky.
I'm glad you like that link. I'm glad you provided that link.

From your link.

GENEVA: Muslim countries have won a battle to prevent Islam from being criticised during debates by the UN Human Rights Council. Religions deserve special protection because any debate about faith is bound to be “very complex, very sensitive and very intense”, council President Doru-Romulus Costea said Wednesday.

Ok, let me make this perfectly clear. That is pure and unadulterated BS. Now, was there anything about my analysis that you don't understand? I don't mean to be rude but religion does NOT deserve special protection and the notion that faith is beyond criticism because it is complex and sensitive is spurious nonsense not worthy of consideration and debate.

So, we don't need any other links. We can use yours just fine.
 
Because people make the religion. For every different person, there is a different type of Islam, just like for every Christian, there is a different Christianity.

I have yet to meet this independent entity called "Islam".
Yes, and by this logic it would be wrong to criticize any group including America. A nation made up of 50 states and 300 million people of disparate ideologies, theologies and philosophies. I'll grant that Americans are democratic and therefore can elect their leaders but in the end isn't that the problem of Islam? There is no Democracy. It's tyrannical and theocratic. Clerics propagate fear and hatred without any accountability.

When a significant majority of Islamic clerics and Muslims reject Sharia law and call for basic human rights I will gladly stop criticizing Islam. Until then it's quite appropriate.

Religion should be critisiced.
 
Because people make the religion. For every different person, there is a different type of Islam, just like for every Christian, there is a different Christianity.

I have yet to meet this independent entity called "Islam".

Do yourself a favour and watch the 2nd part:



And then meet Tantawi, the guy who issued a fatwa (in case you don't know: a legal opinion based on Islamic sources) on how genital mutilation is perfectly fine in accordance with sharia and even recommended, if you like. The very fatwa 90% of Egyptian women, like the old guy said, suffer from today.

And then come back with your silly argument.
 
That will never happen. :mad:
I don't know if it is impossible but I do believe it will be near impossible.

Islam has never had a reformation and there are no dynamics that would cause one to think it will. The religion is specifically anti-intellectual and anti-enlightenment. Unlike Judaism it frowns on debate and dissent. Islam literally means submission. A Muslim can be put to death for questioning or leaving the religion (see Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Salmon Rushdie).

Are there any analogs in Judeo-Christianity?

FTR, I criticize all religions.
 
It's specific to the council on human rights. You cannot criticise Islam or Sharia Law while speaking to the council.

It all started when the heroic David Littman, undaunted by malicious attempts to expel him from the UN, tried to deliver a speech on violence against women and what Islamic scholars can do to prevent it. The Egyptian representative interrupted repeatedly and challenged the council president. “Regardless of the result of the vote — I couldn’t care less if I will win or lose this vote — my point is that Islam will not be crucified in this council!”

The president gave in: “Statements should refrain from making judgments or evaluations of a particular religion. . . I can promise that at the next evaluation of a religious creed, law, or document, I will interrupt the speaker and we’ll go on to the next one.”

But was this made into official UN policy or just the independent decision of the President? It's better to be sure on this, as it seems to be an extraordinary ruling.
 
I'm glad you like that link. I'm glad you provided that link.

From your link.



Ok, let me make this perfectly clear. That is pure and unadulterated BS. Now, was there anything about my analysis that you don't understand? I don't mean to be rude but religion does NOT deserve special protection and the notion that faith is beyond criticism because it is complex and sensitive is spurious nonsense not worthy of consideration and debate.

So, we don't need any other links. We can use yours just fine.

Jesus, deflate thy ego oh superior one.

Yes, and by this logic it would be wrong to criticize any group including America. A nation made up of 50 states and 300 million people of disparate ideologies, theologies and philosophies. I'll grant that Americans are democratic and therefore can elect their leaders but in the end isn't that the problem of Islam?

Okay, so you bring up a counter example just to admit that it really isn't apt.

There is no Democracy. It's tyrannical and theocratic. Clerics propagate fear and hatred without any accountability.

When a significant majority of Islamic clerics and Muslims reject Sharia law and call for basic human rights I will gladly stop criticizing Islam. Until then it's quite appropriate.

Religion should be critisiced.

But do you think it is within the job of UN bureaucrats to criticize religion?

If you look at the link I love so much, it says that this only pertained to debates in the UN HRC, not banning criticizing religion everywhere.

How well do you think the UN would be able to do its job if they got into theological debates every time a Muslim nation abused human rights?
 
The hysteria is kinda interesting, as is the view that the UN is useless and a Bad Thing unless it behaves like the Waffen SS out there enforcing.
 
Jesus, deflate thy ego oh superior one.
:D Hell no!

Okay, so you bring up a counter example just to admit that it really isn't apt.
What?

But do you think it is within the job of UN bureaucrats to criticize religion?
?????

Hmmmmm... How to say this, ah HELL YES! (was that clear?). It's the effing Council on Human Rights for crying in the dark.

Are you getting this?

The council whose job it is, is to set policy to further human rights cannot do its job as it relates to Muslism because to do so would be insensitive to Islam.

If you look at the link I love so much, it says that this only pertained to debates in the UN HRC, not banning criticizing religion everywhere.
You kill me, you really do.

TB: HRC.
RF: HRC? Oh, it's only the HRC. What's the HRC? The Human Rights Commision. Oh, well, that's all. So what if the Human Rights Commision can't discuss the human rights of Muslims?

Sheesh!!! For crying in the dark Tsukas, get real. Are you being obtuse? Are you pulling my leg here?

How well do you think the UN would be able to do its job if they got into theological debates every time a Muslim nation abused human rights?

Well, as it is, they CAN'T DO IT ALL when it comes to Muslims now can they? No!

I gotta say it again, for crying in the dark.
 
Last edited:
I don't know if it is impossible but I do believe it will be near impossible.

It would be to abandon Islam.

Islam has never had a reformation

In the Christian sense, 'Wahabism' (which is pretty much Salafism by the way; hello Brits!) and I assume the stuff the Taliban and maybe even al-Qaeda are doing, teaching and following could be considered a reformation in the sense of going back to the core of Islam before sects came about.

Some are just more extreme and al-Qaeda puts a heavy emphasis on jihad. I've started reading 'the al-Qaeda reader and from what I have seen it should be very interesting.

Some here might also want to read this thread (again) starting from page 5 or 6 to understand me better.

and there are no dynamics that would cause one to think it will. The religion is specifically anti-intellectual and anti-enlightenment. Unlike Judaism it frowns on debate and dissent. Islam literally means submission. A Muslim can be put to death for questioning or leaving the religion (see Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Salmon Rushdie).

Even personal interpretation is pretty much forbidden. So this argument some here try to bring up is void when it comes to discussing Islam. Personally, I make it pretty clear when I stick to Sunni Islam which about 90% of Muslims adhere to. The differences between Shias and Sunnis are as far as I know very small. The Shias have the whole personal cult for Ali and other issues like the self-flagellation to suffer like him, as well as building mosques on top of graves to revere heroes etc. These differences do not affect sharia in the broad sense though and are trivial.

If your Muslim neighbour doesn't want to stone or throw homosexuals from high places, it's his own, human decision not based on Islamic core texts. It's like Catholics disregarding the Pope on contraceptions, only that it's about killing people for their sexuality.

Are there any analogs in Judeo-Christianity?

I think.. what's it called.. when you get thrown out of the church as a member is probably the worst that can happen to you.
 
Last edited:
The hysteria is kinda interesting, as is the view that the UN is useless and a Bad Thing unless it behaves like the Waffen SS out there enforcing.
Oh, I just love that argument. Nothing to see here folks. The UN is ineffective so it doesn't matter. Are you sure that is what you want to go with?
 
The hysteria is kinda interesting, as is the view that the UN is useless and a Bad Thing unless it behaves like the Waffen SS out there enforcing.

... I think.. what's it called.. when you get thrown out of the church as a member is probably the worst that can happen to you.


The total ignorance of history, let alone say the recent war in Serbia and round about, is also fascinating. Like watching pathology slides, really.
 
Oh, I just love that argument. Nothing to see here folks. The UN is ineffective so it doesn't matter. Are you sure that is what you want to go with?


Oh, I just love terminal dishonesty. Want to try again? :) You're not fooling anyone, you know, with that stupid bit of strawmanning; I'm deeply sorry if I prefer actual nuances to joining in your parade of bigotry, but hey, I prefer intelligence.

And yes, it's open bigotry, and bloody stupid bigotry at that. To equate Islam as a whole with what the articles were talking about is simply willfully ignorant; it gets even more hairy when mrbaracuda starts equating Islam with Al-Qaida. But hey; let me rain on your self-righteous crusade.
:)
 
The total ignorance of history, let alone say the recent war in Serbia and round about, is also fascinating. Like watching pathology slides, really.
So when was the last time someone was killed for heresy in the Christian church?

No one is denying history Gurdur. Go back and read the thread. Christianity had a reformation. As much as I loathe religion I have to face the fact that Christianity and Judaism has embraced western civilization and enlightenment to a significant degree greater than Islam.
 
TB: HRC.
RF: HRC? Oh, it's only the HRC. What's the HRC? The Human Rights Commision. Oh, well, that's all. So what if the Human Rights Commision can't discuss the human rights of Muslims?

Sheesh!!! For crying in the dark Tsukas, get real. Are you being obtuse? Are you pulling my leg here?

I think it's this relativism I am still trying to nail.
 
The total ignorance of history, let alone say the recent war in Serbia and round about, is also fascinating. Like watching pathology slides, really.

Oh, I suppose they can back their ethnic cleansings just fine by citing some of what Jesus said!

It's not my ignorance of history, but your ignorance of.. well, just about anything I have ever said on this matter.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom