Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

I've never encountered one of these vegetarians who gets mad at meat-eaters, or tries to force their vegetarianism on others. And I've known kind of a lot of vegetarians and vegans. I'm beginning to wonder if this type of vegetarian is a myth that lives only in complaining posts on internet message boards.
They're definitely not mythical. PETA consists primarily of these types; and I've encountered more than a few myself.
 
They're definitely not mythical. PETA consists primarily of these types; and I've encountered more than a few myself.

****ing PETA. They've pretty much ruined any possible chance of a rational debate with most people about vegetarianism/veganism, or cutting down in the general eating of meat at all.

Recently was on a message board. People were responding to learning that a webcomic artist, who took one of his frequent hiatus' for a day or so (he updates daily), and explained that he was eating a pseudo-turkey made out of tofu (tofurkey) and tofu-based chocolate pie of some sort.

In response was pretty much mockery (Note: To be fair, people mocked him for almost anything and everything on that forum, so this isn't exactly out of place...). "So he's vegetarian? I'll just keep up my murder".

Furthermore, people complained about the webcomic artist "rubbing it into their face" that he was a vegetarian, even though his little blurb wasn't much different than someone bragging about cooking a turkey with certain sides, which I've seen in other comic strips and wouldn't have been out of place at all.

Pretty much, the point is, if anyone decides to go vegetarian and mentions it, there is always someone that escalates the debate to one of "You're forcing yourself on me!" and "You think meat is murder!"

Furthermore, in any conversation of vegetarianism (look through this forum as well), there is almost always someone, if not several people, who brags about eating meat, their steak, how juicy it is, how they'll eat three for every one you eat, etc. When met with that kind of ridicule and in-your-face bragging, it's pretty easy to see the situation polarized. Part of the problem is, they keep assuming that all vegans and vegetarians are PETA-like asshats that show a very similar kind of arrogance.

Bleh. As far as I'm concerned, both sides need a hit upside the head with a clue bat. PETA doubly so, for multiple reasons that almost everyone here knows already.
 
Last edited:
I could honestly care less whether someone decides to stop eating delicious animals or not, but vegitarian arguments are just rediculous.

I won't get into the science of nutricion for the sake of brevity, but there is no evidence that a vegitarian lifestyle has ANY health benefits.

For the purpose of this post I think it's more interesting to deal with the more conceptual claims made by the cud-chewers, namely that eating meat is wrong because it causes suffering in animals.

As someone who has grown up near free-range ranching and who has Iowa farmers for relatives, I laugh hysterically everytime some black-turtleneck clad anemic tells me that milking cows is akin to torture. Certainly feed-lots and massive industrial farms are a blight upon our culture, but I would love for someone to articulate how a free-range grown animal that is humanely slaughtered has suffered.

The NATURAL course of events is for that animal to become injured, diseased, or painfully old then ripped to shreds by predators. Working to maintain a safe, healthy flock then killing the animals in a painless slaughter is a REVOLUTIONARY improvement over nature. It is the most humane way to deal with animals.
 
<snip>

Working to maintain a safe, healthy flock then killing the animals in a painless slaughter is a REVOLUTIONARY improvement over nature. It is the most humane way to deal with animals.

But a really inefficient way to provide food for humans.:)
 
I could honestly care less whether someone decides to stop eating delicious animals or not, but vegitarian arguments are just rediculous.

I won't get into the science of nutricion for the sake of brevity, but there is no evidence that a vegitarian lifestyle has ANY health benefits.

There's also no evidence that it's deleterious to heath either, and there certainly is evidence linking high levels of meat consumption to increased morbidity.

So what's your point?

Ethically, logically and environmentally, veg[etaria]nism strikes me as the most rational dietary choice. There are other threads where I explain, at length, why I believe that to be the case, and back it up with citations.
 
Tranewreck said:
For the purpose of this post I think it's more interesting to deal with the more conceptual claims made by the cud-chewers, namely that eating meat is wrong because it causes suffering in animals.

The irony is, if a vegetarian used a slur to refer to people that ate meat, he'd be considered one of the arrogant pushy vegetarians mentioned above.

I guess it's only okay to hurl insults when you're on the "right team"?
 
It isn't clear to me that it's actually been proven that a vegetarian diet is actually healthier...however...I do take issue with claims that vegetarians are "unhealthy" or "skinny" or "pale". Interestly enough, most of the vegetarians I know are actually a tad bit overweight (but very health concscience none the less...exercising and so forth) and I think my african-american vegetarian friend would take issue with being referred to as "pale". ;)

It is certainly common for meat eaters to brag about how delicious their meat is when they find themselves in the presence of a vegetarian. My family did it to me all the time when I wasn't eating meat...and that's indeed rude as well.
 
Anyone who thinks vegetarians are "weak" or "frail" should go to a "Weird Al" concert.

I don't get the insults either. Who cares what other people eat? This is like the people so obsessed with who other people are having sex with. It's quite silly. It doesn't harm me at all for someone to eat vegetarian... why would I care?

I do eat meat. I live on a farm, I raise my own. I far prefer to do this. My land won't grow crops, so using the goats to harvest the weeds and sticks (which I can not eat) and turning it into cabrito (which I can eat) is what works out best for my very marginal land. For me, I prefer to eat meat that I know for a fact has come from healthy happy animals who have not been fed any strange things. I know the animals did not suffer, I know the meat was handled properly and so on.

But even though I eat meat, and spend most of my time carefully raising it, I have never felt the need to insult someone due to their diet.
 
1) Vegetarians, in general, quite frankly, don't look all that healthy. It's actually difficult to get the complete protein a body needs without eating meat, which is why y'all look so skinny and guant. Flexitarians strike me as people who want to be vegetarian (for emotional/ideological reasons) but realise that if they adhere to it strictly, they will eventually be only slightly better off than your average Ethiopian.

I am largely vegetarian at home, but have been traveling between various bird banding stations in Japan and Australia for the last few months. During these travels, I have not pressed my preference, mainly out of convenience. Had I done so, it would have meant having to buy and prepare food on my own, instead of simply partaking in the communally prepared stuff. In Japan --- so my vegan friend who lived there for three years informs me --- it would also have been much much harder, as they generally put bonito powder or other animal-based stuff in more or less everything. When I come home, I will return to my non-meat-eating ways.

Thus, perhaps I would fall under what was called "flexitarian" before, in that I accept that I can eat meat when circumstances call for it, but prefer not to when I have a choice. Exactly which the circumstances that call for me eating meat are, is basically a matter of laziness.

As to the healthy aspect: my vegan friend has been vegan for about ten years, through which he has remained an elite sportsman in orienteering. Of course he eats pills to get what he cannot get (at least not in sufficient amounts) from vegetables, but he looks quite healthy to me. Well, he's also emo, and thus looks a bit unhealthy due to that, but...

As to the thread title question, I feel I must reply as the systematist I am:
Vegetarianism is arbitrary if the vegetarian also eats mushrooms, as she is then eating a paraphyletic group of organisms. And paraphyly is a no-no.
 
So does this mean that a person that doesn't believe in beating your dog or cat, should also believe in not chopping mushrooms, to avoid being arbitrary?
 
And the angel of the lord came unto me, snatching me up from my place of slumber. And took me on high, and higher still until we moved to the spaces betwixt the air itself. And he brought me into a vast farmlands of our own midwest. And as we descended, cries of impending doom rose from the soil. One thousand, nay a million voices full of fear. And terror possesed me then. And I begged, "Angel of the Lord, what are these tortured screams?" And the angel said unto me, "These are the cries of the carrots, the cries of the carrots! You see, Reverend Maynard, tomorrow is harvest day and to them it is the holocaust." And I sprang from my slumber drenched in sweat like the tears of one million terrified brothers and roared, "Hear me now, I have seen the light! They have a consciousness, they have a life, they have a soul! Damn you! Let the rabbits wear glasses! Save our brothers!"

Life feeds on life feeds on life feeds on life feeds on........
 
Life feeds on life feeds on life feeds on life feeds on........

Yes, I will have the carrots.. because I must eat. You will eat the rabbit... because you want to eat the rabbit. In any case we both do what is necessary to keep rabbit populations in check. So it all works out in the end. :)
 
Last edited:
I could honestly care less whether someone decides to stop eating delicious animals or not, but vegitarian arguments are just rediculous..

Then ignore them.

I won't get into the science of nutricion for the sake of brevity, but there is no evidence that a vegitarian lifestyle has ANY health benefits.

Hum...how categorical. The sake of brevity would have been fine, even with a couple of study links
Of course I can't use my own data because as we all know one case study does not evidence make (anecdotal).... Science, be damned.

For the purpose of this post I think it's more interesting to deal with the more conceptual claims made by the cud-chewers, namely that eating meat is wrong because it causes suffering in animals.

As a cud chewer who has watched the process from close up, I can say with certainty that before you actually eat the meat, the animal has to be disposessed of its most precious asset, its life. Well.. as long as it spends its short life happy and well fed.....

As someone who has grown up near free-range ranching and who has Iowa farmers for relatives, I laugh hysterically everytime some black-turtleneck clad anemic tells me that milking cows is akin to torture. Certainly feed-lots and massive industrial farms are a blight upon our culture, but I would love for someone to articulate how a free-range grown animal that is humanely slaughtered has suffered.

There we go again with free range vacation style farms....It suffered because it's dead and can no longer enjoy your loving attention and its carefree hoping-around of a life.

The NATURAL course of events is for that animal to become injured, diseased, or painfully old then ripped to shreds by predators. Working to maintain a safe, healthy flock then killing the animals in a painless slaughter is a REVOLUTIONARY improvement over nature. It is the most humane way to deal with animals.
Oh my god....such blasphemy...You are uttering the unthinkable.
Let's see... what would you choose ?? Freedom and the possibility of falling prey to some evil mountain lion or live in a prison where your benevolent guard will provide food and shelter ( and may be some lovin:D) ?.... Oh right, you don't have to.
You eat the animals because you wish to do so, not to ensure their well-being. That's simple and fair enough. I chose not to eat either them or their secretions, and that is simple and fair enough.

PS If your turtle-neck clad anemic visitor decides to show up again, please advise him in buying a more manly, butch looking sweat shirt... may be he'll have beer with you.. milk ? Nahhh.
 
So does this mean that a person that doesn't believe in beating your dog or cat, should also believe in not chopping mushrooms, to avoid being arbitrary?

Yes. Paraphyly should be stomped out wherever possible. All dishes that contain meat and vegetables should also contain mushrooms and other suitable organisms. Every family that owns two different kind of pets should be forced to also adopt animals in groups between these, so that their total ownership distribution becomes monophyletic. Expressions like "it's raining cats and dogs" should be modified to reflect this as well. I am not entirely sure what that would mean, but to be on the safe side, all families of Carnivora should be included: "It's raining cats and dogs, and also ferrets, linsangs, hyenas, seal, one or two pandas, a bear, some civets (plus the palm civet), skunks, raccoons, mongooses, sea lions, walruses, enaliarctids, hemicyonids, barbourofelids, percrocutids, nimravids, stenoplesticids, and, last but certainly not least, a fossa." Obviously, some kind of abbreviation would be handy.
 
Last edited:
I'm afraid I don't agree, and I find it hard to understand where you're coming from, Kotatsu.
 
Pretty much, the point is, if anyone decides to go vegetarian and mentions it, there is always someone that escalates the debate to one of "You're forcing yourself on me!" and "You think meat is murder!"
Yeah, that's annoying. I've been subjected to far more of that sort of anti-vegetarianism ridicule than I have been to militant vegans (because i'm not vegan, nor an "ethical" vegetarian, I still get treated like the enemy).
 
If I were a vegan, I'd be afraid of mentioning so to most people. Who can deal with that kind of argument, anyways?
 
Having been involved with two long threads on animal rights in recent months I'll just say that I think many, and perhaps most, vegans and vegetarians are not arbitrary.
 
Yes. Paraphyly should be stomped out wherever possible. All dishes that contain meat and vegetables should also contain mushrooms and other suitable organisms. Every family that owns two different kind of pets should be forced to also adopt animals in groups between these, so that their total ownership distribution becomes monophyletic. Expressions like "it's raining cats and dogs" should be modified to reflect this as well. I am not entirely sure what that would mean, but to be on the safe side, all families of Carnivora should be included: "It's raining cats and dogs, and also ferrets, linsangs, hyenas, seal, one or two pandas, a bear, some civets (plus the palm civet), skunks, raccoons, mongooses, sea lions, walruses, enaliarctids, hemicyonids, barbourofelids, percrocutids, nimravids, stenoplesticids, and, last but certainly not least, a fossa." Obviously, some kind of abbreviation would be handy.

;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom