Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

Welcome to the board, deavman!

You said "sometimes to the point of violence" -- I'm curious... how violently were you treated?

Well, it was mostly verbal and eventually turned to physical taunts because of my terrible habit of not missing an occasion to respond (verbally). It was along time ago and I am now a litlle less sensitive to idiotic comments.
 
Last edited:
Well, I said "almost",
I must say, gently, that that is not so, although perhaps you were thinking that that word. :o

You stated:
I have born, suffered sometimes to the point of violence,

But yes, I was about to say "almost" in response, when I looked back saw the "sometimes"; I was thinking you meant "almost" anyways, though.

it was mostly verbal and eventually turned to physical taunts because of my terrible habit of not missing an occasion to respond (verbally). It was along time ago and I am now a litlle less sensitive to idiotic comments.

Ah, well, some people will fight over anything really... especially when the subject of their abuse fights back, verbally or physically.
 
I have three comments:

1) Vegetarians, in general, quite frankly, don't look all that healthy. It's actually difficult to get the complete protein a body needs without eating meat, which is why y'all look so skinny and guant. Flexitarians strike me as people who want to be vegetarian (for emotional/ideological reasons) but realise that if they adhere to it strictly, they will eventually be only slightly better off than your average Ethiopian..

Well since you have met all the vegetarians of the world, I can't really convince you otherwise......or may be I can..Since I can't post links yet I'll try to redirect you to a site where Vegan athletes converse of many issues concerning them : (veganbodybuildingDOTcom/?page=bios) I do appear there as a powerlifter, the issue of bodybuilding being moot to me.

2) How long is the intestinal tract of a typical carnivore? How long is it in herbivores? Omnivores? And how long is it in Homo Sapiens? Q.E.D..

"Lonewulf" answered that one beautifully

3) "Koshering" meat is barbaric and cruel. If you're going to kill something, at least be quick and painless about it.

As the son of a former jewish ritual slaughterer I find myself on the fence...Indeed I feel that ritual slaughtering should be revised in order to reflect the possibility of a more "humane" way. Yet this very method was formulated to avoid unnecessary pain to the animal. Indeed making sure that the knife used would be free of any nicks and other irregularities is paramount to declaring the meat kosher(I remember my father spending entire nights sharpening his knives with a soft stone to ensure "painless" cuts). In addition before the slaughter the animal must be checked and found free of sicknesses, injuries or other blemishes thus establishing a modicum of proof for decent treatment. I think that if you beat, tortured or otherwise abuse animals during their short stay in their cage/stable/shed, it would definitely show on their external appearance
 
Last edited:
I must say, gently, that that is not so, although perhaps you were thinking that that word. :o

You stated:

But yes, I was about to say "almost" in response, when I looked back saw the "sometimes"; I was thinking you meant "almost" anyways, though.



Ah, well, some people will fight over anything really... especially when the subject of their abuse fights back, verbally or physically.

You are correct on all points...Sometimes my keyboard refuses to convey my thought properly.. :-)
 
As the son of a former jewish ritual slaughterer I find myself on the fence...Indeed I feel that ritual slaughtering should be revised in order to reflect the possibility of a more "humane" way. Yet this very method was formulated to avoid unnecessary pain to the animal. Indeed making sure that the knife used would be free of any nicks and other irregularities is paramount to declaring the meat kosher(I remember my father spending entire nights sharpening his knives with a soft stone to ensure "painless" cuts). In addition before the slaughter the animal must be checked and found free of sicknesses, injuries or other blemishes thus establishing a modicum of proof for decent treatment. I think that if you beat, tortured or otherwise abuse animals during their short stay in their cage/stable/shed, it would definitely show on their external appearance


I'm sorry, I'm going to have a go here.

Yes, it's perfectly possible that shechita slaughter was originally formulated to be as painless as possible, and also with the object of bleeding the carcass out as much as possible.

About 4,000 years ago.

Funnily enough, we know more now than we knew then.

We know about the circulation through the spinal vessels that can keep an animal conscious while it's bleeding out with its throat cut. We know that however sharp a knife, there's no such thing as a painless cut. We know how to kill an animal instantly and painlessly, and this isn't it.

We also know that the shechita method is not at all efficient in bleeding out the carcass. It may seem that way, because the meat is a different colour, but that has to do with the fact that the blood is oxygenated (because the animal is still breathing while it is bleeding out), as opposed to the dark, deoxygenated blood in a pre-stunned animal.

Large numbers of Jewish vet students have visited the slaughterhouse as part of their training, seen what goes on with a knowledgeable and educated mind, and gone home to have storming rows with their parents. These animals die in agony.

All that is required is to permit the stunning of the animal with a captive bolt immediately before the shechita ritual takes place. However, the rabbis oppose this because of the rule that says meat from a "blemished" animal cannot be kosher. And they class the captive bolt use as a blemish. (I'm not sure how come it's OK to eat meat from castrated males or dehorned cattle and so on, but there you go.)

And the thing that really riles me about all this is that I am quite probably eating meat from animals abused in this way without knowing it or having any choice in this matter. Kosher meat does not use all the carcass. So guess what? The bits that aren't used for the kosher trade go into the normal meat retail trade. And if anything isn't quite right about a particular slaughter instance, nicked knife or something, then the rabbi will reject the entire carcass - which, you guessed it, goes into the normal retail meat trade. Unlabelled.

It seems that kosher meat would be unacceptably expensive if such unrequired surplus couldn't be sold off in this way. Personally, I would very much welcome the opportunity to boycott any meat killed without pre-stunning (and that includes halal as well). I have a sneaky feeling that if this were possible, we might see a lot of such boycotting, and a big change in the economics of kosher meat production.

Too many political vested interests though.

</rant>

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
It's incredibly easy for a person to avoid eating animals farmed under cruel conditions. Eat NZ beef and lamb; they grow out in lovely, grassy paddocks, free to roam wherever they want. No hormonal growth drugs, no factory farms, no feeding stalls, they grow at natural rates until they are carted off in nicely air-conditioned trucks until they arrive at the meat works and are whacked instantly to death with an electric pole-axe.

Humane to a fault.


Can I just stick my oar in here to promote Scotch beef and lamb on the same grounds? I see this stuff being produced every day. The animals have a lovely life. I have no problem eating the delicious end-product.

In fact, the arguments against the consumption of dairy products are a lot stronger, because dairy farming is by its very nature a lot more intensive and puts the cows under a lot more stress. Beef suckler cows often live into their late teens, having a calf every year, and raising that calf themselves up to a natural weaning age. Dairy cows seldom live half that long, they lose their calves as neonates, and the calves themselves are less happy and healthy in the artificial rearing systems, compared to the suckled beef calves.

Now I have to say I'm very fond of dairy products, and I still believe that the average dairy farm does a decent job and the cows are nevertheless reasonably content and not abused. However, I do think that vegetarians who refuse to eat meat because of concerns about "killing animals for food" while being apparently quite happy to consume milk and cheese and so on, haven't really taken the trouble to understand the issues.

Rolfe.
 
I'm a vegetarian because I think it's healthier than eating meat.

As far as I'm concerned other people can eat whatever they want.
 
I'm a vegetarian because I think it's healthier than eating meat.

As far as I'm concerned other people can eat whatever they want.
Thank you for your sanity. :)

The question from the OP was "is your decision arbitrary" and I am still mulling over that, while I consider the wit and wisdom of Denis Leary:

Eating meat is an instinct {to an omnivore}, not eating meat is a choice.​

Whence the choice?

DR
 
So, why can't we just say that vegetarianism is a personal choice and one of many ways that one can do their part to help animals....not a moral imperative that everyone must follow.
Because I don't think it's true--I would neither say that vegetarianism (or more specifically veganism) is a personal choice nor a moral obligation. I'd probably just say that it's a good way of dealing with a number of different problems of public consequence. I don't think there's a magic bullet argument against raising animals for food, and I don't think I'm Moral (angelic choir) for having made the decision to eat a vegan diet. I do think we ought to do something about the treatment of animals in factory farms, especially here in the US, but as others have pointed out there are strategies that don't involve refraining from eating meat. These can be environmentally counterproductive, and I'm too lazy to deal with determining which animals have been treated fairly in a country with no credible certification process. But someone who eats less meat, who makes a good faith effort to eat animals that have been treated well during their lives...she has a compelling response to arguments built around the problem of animal suffering.

I'd also point out that the podcast you're referring to is run-off from the previous week's interview with Peter Singer, where he discussed the moral questions that he presumably considers to be more important. I don't think vegetarians can be so sweepingly accused of misplacing their priorities.
 
Last edited:
I'd also point out that the podcast you're referring to is run-off from the previous week's interview with Peter Singer, where he discussed the moral questions that he presumably considers to be more important. I don't think vegetarians can be so sweepingly accused of misplacing their priorities.

Why not? I mean, people that declare themselves this or that usually only focus on it, right? I mean, it's not like they ever have a life or do anything else... right? :D
 
I'm sorry, I'm going to have a go here.

Yes, it's perfectly possible that shechita slaughter was originally formulated to be as painless as possible, and also with the object of bleeding the carcass out as much as possible.

About 4,000 years ago.

Funnily enough, we know more now than we knew then.

We know about the circulation through the spinal vessels that can keep an animal conscious while it's bleeding out with its throat cut. We know that however sharp a knife, there's no such thing as a painless cut. We know how to kill an animal instantly and painlessly, and this isn't it.

We also know that the shechita method is not at all efficient in bleeding out the carcass. It may seem that way, because the meat is a different colour, but that has to do with the fact that the blood is oxygenated (because the animal is still breathing while it is bleeding out), as opposed to the dark, deoxygenated blood in a pre-stunned animal.

Large numbers of Jewish vet students have visited the slaughterhouse as part of their training, seen what goes on with a knowledgeable and educated mind, and gone home to have storming rows with their parents. These animals die in agony.

All that is required is to permit the stunning of the animal with a captive bolt immediately before the shechita ritual takes place. However, the rabbis oppose this because of the rule that says meat from a "blemished" animal cannot be kosher. And they class the captive bolt use as a blemish. (I'm not sure how come it's OK to eat meat from castrated males or dehorned cattle and so on, but there you go.)

And the thing that really riles me about all this is that I am quite probably eating meat from animals abused in this way without knowing it or having any choice in this matter. Kosher meat does not use all the carcass. So guess what? The bits that aren't used for the kosher trade go into the normal meat retail trade. And if anything isn't quite right about a particular slaughter instance, nicked knife or something, then the rabbi will reject the entire carcass - which, you guessed it, goes into the normal retail meat trade. Unlabelled.

It seems that kosher meat would be unacceptably expensive if such unrequired surplus couldn't be sold off in this way. Personally, I would very much welcome the opportunity to boycott any meat killed without pre-stunning (and that includes halal as well). I have a sneaky feeling that if this were possible, we might see a lot of such boycotting, and a big change in the economics of kosher meat production.
Too many political vested interests though.
Rolfe.

I do agree with the above but I was making a point: with today's treatment of animals in factory farms, the "unblemished" requirement for kosher meat makes it more likely that workers will try harder to keep the animal healthier. This said I won't eat meat, kosher or otherwise & for the same reasons I won't have dairy, I don't drive a car(I used to), I recycle organic trash through composting... I try, but it's not perfect. You seem to choose to attack those life choices by focusing on its imperfections. I am an atheist but culturally I remain Jewish as I am a product of Judaism with its faults and hopefully with its positive traits.
You claim that bad treatment as a reason for avoiding meat is moot because you have those wonderful little sheep farms in Australia and/or Scotland...Hum, guess what, tranhumance won't get them close enough to most countries in the world..how about the middle east? Oh well you got me, indeed boatloads of Australian sheep do arrive here after weeks of tribulation without proper care and atrocious methods of unloading. You live in paradise-land while the rest of the world regards animals as nothing more than tools or food that happens to be mobile. You have never seen mistreatment until you get to see little arab kids torturing puppies under the benevolent eyes of their parents. You have chosen to ignore the true story behind those lovely free-range farms as eventually millions of animals will be shipped to countries where the issue of wellfare will be laughed at...loudly.
As much as I realize that the world will not stop eating meat, I still think that every litttle bit of influence I have on the world around me makes it more worthwhile ans thus bareable.

Now I have to say I'm very fond of dairy products, and I still believe that the average dairy farm does a decent job and the cows are nevertheless reasonably content and not abused. However, I do think that vegetarians who refuse to eat meat because of concerns about "killing animals for food" while being apparently quite happy to consume milk and cheese and so on, haven't really taken the trouble to understand the issues.


"Vegetarians" that eat milk and/or eggs are just fooling themselves as you have correctly mentionned.


I did not mean to start a fight, though I felt that the animosity expressed against vegetarians here unfortunately transcends the rational thinking process that usually rules on this site.

P.S. Meat is not murder
 
I have three comments:

1) Vegetarians, in general, quite frankly, don't look all that healthy. It's actually difficult to get the complete protein a body needs without eating meat, which is why y'all look so skinny and guant.

I give you a giant belly laugh from my giant vegetarian belly. You know what foods are vegetarian (according to the usual sense of the word, i.e., allowing eggs and dairy)?
Pie*, Cake, Cookies, Chocolate, Pizza with vegetable toppings or no toppings, Refried Beans*, Cheese, Potato Chips, French Fries*, Donuts*, Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, Macaroni and Cheese, Potatoes, Ice cream...

After three years of vegetarianism, I am anything but skinny or gaunt. And I have no problem getting the protein I need from non-meat sources.





* When made without lard, beef fat, etc.
 
"Vegetarians" that eat milk and/or eggs are just fooling themselves as you have correctly mentionned.

This is only true if those vegetarians are vegetarians because of the way farm animals are treated. (ETA: This may have been what you meant. The context was clear in the comment to which you were responding, but was left out of your comment. I'm sorry if I misread.) I could argue that vegetarians who eat wheat are "fooling themselves" because they don't realize how many animals are killed during a wheat harvest (lots). But that only holds water if they are vegetarians because they don't want animals to die in the production of their food.

(ETA: food for thought)

There are a lot of different reasons for not wanting to eat dead animals, and some of them are compatible with eggs and milk, and some are not.
 
Last edited:
I've encountered more self-righteousness from meat-eaters than vegetarians.

twinkie eaters are the only humble ones.
 
I've encountered more self-righteousness from meat-eaters than vegetarians.
Reminds me of a comic strip that I found hilarious, for opposite reasons than the artist meant... where people go into a restaurant that specifically caters to vegetarians, to make fun of and mock the vegetarians. I'm paraphrasing at this point...

Then they turned around and said, "It's fun to mock people that are holier-than-thou and wrong-headed!", or something similar. EDIT: Probably was contentious and ignorant or something similar... either, vocabulary that more or less fits.

Either way... the irony is so hilarious, and it was obviously not a parody or a satire (in my eyes). But it's okay to mock vegetarians/vegans and tell them that they're "wrong" and flaunt meat eating in their faces, say that you'll eat three animals for every animal they don't eat, and tell them that they're responsible for the deaths of some children thanks to parents that didn't educate themselves.

And I've seen a lot of the above here on the JREF forum (the latter from CFLarsen).

But it's *perfectly okay*, because X number of vegetarians/vegans are arrogant and holier-than-thou, so reciprocating that attitude towards vegetarians/vegans in general is fine.

twinkie eaters are the only humble ones.

Word! :o
 
Last edited:
I do agree with the above but I was making a point: with today's treatment of animals in factory farms, the "unblemished" requirement for kosher meat makes it more likely that workers will try harder to keep the animal healthier.


I still wonder whether these oft-vilified "factory farms" really are as common even in the USA as anti-meat people seem to think. I remember Dictator Cheney dementing on about the evils of factory farming, and then realising that where he lived (Switzerland) that was something that really didn't happen at all. How prevalent are such welfare-poor systems in the USA compared to what I would see as ordinary standard extensive grazing management? This in the country of ranches, no less? I'd honestly like to know.

You seem to choose to attack those life choices by focusing on its imperfections. I am an atheist but culturally I remain Jewish as I am a product of Judaism with its faults and hopefully with its positive traits.


I was attacking nothing except inhumane slaughter, and the mindset that refuses to adapt its thinking even very slightly to reduce/minimise the cruelty involved. If you see that as an attack on "life choices", then that's your privilege.

You claim that bad treatment as a reason for avoiding meat is moot because you have those wonderful little sheep farms in Australia and/or Scotland...


I think if you describe sheep farms in Australia and New Zealand as "little", you'd better get ready to duck. Scotland is a much smaller country of course, but still, the sheer size of the actual enterprises is far from small.

Oh well you got me, indeed boatloads of Australian sheep do arrive here after weeks of tribulation without proper care and atrocious methods of unloading.


Now that is indeed a very fair point. Inhumane transport is another very big issue. However, what's wrong with transhipping chilled carcasses? I agree that all ain't well so far as reaching that ideal is concerned, and the preference of many countries for having their meat slaughtered locally is another big issue. However, for those who live in places where humanely reared and slaughtered meat is available, and that includes foreign-raised meat transported as carcasses, then my point (which was essentially just reiterating what The Atheist said) stands.

You live in paradise-land while the rest of the world regards animals as nothing more than tools or food that happens to be mobile. You have never seen mistreatment until you get to see little arab kids torturing puppies under the benevolent eyes of their parents. You have chosen to ignore the true story behind those lovely free-range farms as eventually millions of animals will be shipped to countries where the issue of wellfare will be laughed at...loudly.
As much as I realize that the world will not stop eating meat, I still think that every litttle bit of influence I have on the world around me makes it more worthwhile ans thus bareable.


I agree, much more still needs to be done in respect of insisting on the shipping of carcasses. And you're right, there is a great deal of lamb going from Scotland to Arab countries.

However, I still don't see how me stopping eating the meat I have available which was reared and slaughtered humanely will help in that effort. Might even simply divert more of the locally-produced animals to the Arab market. Much better to campaign to end live exports.

Aiming for a world free of farm animals seems to me to be a very difficult and probably an undesirable goal. Aiming to maximise welfare and minimise suffering might just have a chance. And that includes choosing to eat humanely reared and slaughtered produce. I'm still to be convinced that such produce is not available in the USA.

Rolfe.
 
3) "Koshering" meat is barbaric and cruel. If you're going to kill something, at least be quick and painless about it.

This is a point which escapes many, but then again, I doubt that most people have ever spent any time inside an abbatoir.

Kosher and halal killing are the same, which is a little ironic, but you're right, it's a horrible way to kill an animal.

Always amuses me how the same people who only eat kosher/halal would cry cruelty at seeing a Korean prepare dog in the traditional manner of beating it before death to "oxygenate" the meat.

Can I just stick my oar in here to promote Scotch beef and lamb on the same grounds? I see this stuff being produced every day. The animals have a lovely life. I have no problem eating the delicious end-product.

Yes indeed. There are other places where the same applies, but not Australia, where the cruel bastards force cows to live in deserts.

Now I have to say I'm very fond of dairy products, and I still believe that the average dairy farm does a decent job and the cows are nevertheless reasonably content and not abused. However, I do think that vegetarians who refuse to eat meat because of concerns about "killing animals for food" while being apparently quite happy to consume milk and cheese and so on, haven't really taken the trouble to understand the issues.

Rolfe.

Excellent point.
 
Rolfe said:
Aiming for a world free of farm animals seems to me to be a very difficult and probably an undesirable goal.
Depends. If we keep up with the animals we have today, and then continue to reproduce them to keep up with the demands of a rising population, their contributions to global warming would be greater than they are currently; and their contributions, as it is, are around 15% of man-made greenhouse gasses, thanks in no small part to treated manure and methane/nitrous oxide production of the animal itself.

Of course, people continually write off this data as "unbelievable" and use Argument from Incredulity. I don't really care myself. It's the truth, just as much as global warming is. And I choose to attempt to lower my overall meat intake for just that reason.
 
Last edited:
I just like animals. In most of the ways that would count as legal.

And of course I earn my crust by looking after the health and welfare of domesticated animals. Now there's a vested interest if you like.

I really wouldn't care to see farm animals reduced to penny-numbers in conservation parks for many many reasons.

Rolfe.
 
I like animals and humans, combined. The environment affects both.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom