As the son of a former jewish ritual slaughterer I find myself on the fence...Indeed I feel that ritual slaughtering should be revised in order to reflect the possibility of a more "humane" way. Yet this very method was formulated to avoid unnecessary pain to the animal. Indeed making sure that the knife used would be free of any nicks and other irregularities is paramount to declaring the meat kosher(I remember my father spending entire nights sharpening his knives with a soft stone to ensure "painless" cuts). In addition before the slaughter the animal must be checked and found free of sicknesses, injuries or other blemishes thus establishing a modicum of proof for decent treatment. I think that if you beat, tortured or otherwise abuse animals during their short stay in their cage/stable/shed, it would definitely show on their external appearance
I'm sorry, I'm going to have a go here.
Yes, it's perfectly possible that shechita slaughter was originally formulated to be as painless as possible, and also with the object of bleeding the carcass out as much as possible.
About 4,000 years ago.
Funnily enough, we know more now than we knew then.
We know about the circulation through the spinal vessels that can keep an animal conscious while it's bleeding out with its throat cut. We know that however sharp a knife, there's no such thing as a painless cut. We know how to kill an animal instantly and painlessly, and this isn't it.
We also know that the shechita method is not at all efficient in bleeding out the carcass. It may seem that way, because the meat is a different colour, but that has to do with the fact that the blood is oxygenated (because the animal is still breathing while it is bleeding out), as opposed to the dark, deoxygenated blood in a pre-stunned animal.
Large numbers of Jewish vet students have visited the slaughterhouse as part of their training, seen what goes on with a knowledgeable and educated mind, and gone home to have storming rows with their parents. These animals die in agony.
All that is required is to permit the stunning of the animal with a captive bolt immediately before the shechita ritual takes place. However, the rabbis oppose this because of the rule that says meat from a "blemished" animal cannot be kosher. And they class the captive bolt use as a blemish. (I'm not sure how come it's OK to eat meat from castrated males or dehorned cattle and so on, but there you go.)
And the thing that really riles me about all this is that I am quite probably eating meat from animals abused in this way without knowing it or having any choice in this matter. Kosher meat does not use all the carcass. So guess what? The bits that aren't used for the kosher trade go into the normal meat retail trade. And if anything isn't quite right about a particular slaughter instance, nicked knife or something, then the rabbi will reject the entire carcass - which, you guessed it, goes into the normal retail meat trade. Unlabelled.
It seems that kosher meat would be unacceptably expensive if such unrequired surplus couldn't be sold off in this way. Personally, I would very much welcome the opportunity to boycott any meat killed without pre-stunning (and that includes halal as well). I have a sneaky feeling that if this were possible, we might see a lot of such boycotting, and a big change in the economics of kosher meat production.
Too many political vested interests though.
</rant>
Rolfe.