Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

I don't believe that there is any ethical difference between killing an elephant or cutting my lawn.

You'd be arrested in any civilized society, then, since they have laws against animal abuse.

Don't really need to say much more than that.

Nice to see someone actually honest about the issue. Well, I can say your viewpoint isn't particularly arbitrary, but it's certainly backwards.
 
Last edited:
I'm a vegetarian and therefor this thread caught my I.
I find it funny how people react to vegetarianism, because there are many different point of views regarding this topic.

My opinion is that it is unnecessary to kill animals just to eat them. It is pretty much pointless seeing the conditions they go through to be slaughtered. Also, why would you eat it? There is a lot of food apart from meat that can be eaten, enough to live happily and healthily.Being a vegetarian only means you have a slight shortage of protein. The other thing you must keep in mind is that eating meat isn't particularly healthy. So in a way, meat is only eaten these days because people like it, just like any other sweets.

Ofcourse you could argue that there are so many other things in life that cause suffering, (???Drilling oil???) but does that mean it's okay to support eating meat. No I think it's quite the opposite. Just by saying there is a lot of suffering in the world and therefor it is okay to eat meat, I think is a strange arguement.

Now, as I said before it all comes down to a matter of opinion, and I respect it if you do eat meat. But it's a choice. do you think it's worth killing an animal just for a bit of meat on the side of your plate, which could be replaced and is completely unnecessary apart from the fact that one may find it tasty? or not?
I think not.
 
You'd be arrested in any civilized society, then, since they have laws against animal abuse.

Who mentioned abuse? The point was killing.

Not to mention that I specifically asked for moral diffrences - legal ones are irrelevant.

Don't really need to say much more than that.

To protect your assertion that there was a difference between killing animals and plants?

Yes.
 
I'm not a vegan, but I'm not convinced by this point.
You might be able to make an argument that free-range meat involves less animal death than grain harvest, but people still need grains, fruit and vegetables as well as meat for a healthy diet. To show that it would be ethically better to include meat in the diet you would have to show that this reduces the quantity of other foods consumed by a sufficient amount to reduce animal deaths by a greater number than the total number of animals slaughtered to provide the meat. And not everyone has access to free-range meat.
In the case of grain-fed meat the animals are killed to produce the grain first, then the grain is fed to more animals that are then slaughtered to produce the meat. In terms of reducing total animal deaths it would be better to eat the grain directly.

Indeed. IN the case of someone eating free-range meat (cows, pigs, chickens) they are acknowledging the death of "one" extra animal. It would be interesting exerise to see if someone who does eat free-range animals in addition to hand-raised vegetables/grains/fruits would actually cause less animal deaths. My main questions was whether those who adhere to a vegetarian diet realize that animals die none-the-less for their diet. Are they raising their own vegetables? Probably not. Someone who eats factory farmed vegetables and fruits and grains from exotic places may very well be contributing to far more animal deaths than someone who eats meat and veggies bought from supermarkets.

So one who is smug about their veg*n diet consisting of factory farmed veggies, exported fruits and grains/nuts could very well be contirbuting to far more animal deaths than the average joe.

Question is - where does your food come from and how is it produced? Until you know that answer, please don't assume that your diet is better than the average joes.
 
I agree that animals shouldn't be made to suffer needlessly. However, it seems kind of arbitrary to conclude that by not eating meat, one is leading a moral life.

The troublesome problem with your argument is that it's a straw man. Instead of reducing animal suffering we can make the same claim about torture. Just because I do not torture (human beings), it is wrong to conclude that I am leading a moral life.

Debaroo
Indeed. IN the case of someone eating free-range meat (cows, pigs, chickens) they are acknowledging the death of "one" extra animal. It would be interesting exerise to see if someone who does eat free-range animals in addition to hand-raised vegetables/grains/fruits would actually cause less animal deaths. My main questions was whether those who adhere to a vegetarian diet realize that animals die none-the-less for their diet. Are they raising their own vegetables? Probably not. Someone who eats factory farmed vegetables and fruits and grains from exotic places may very well be contributing to far more animal deaths than someone who eats meat and veggies bought from supermarkets.

Such distinctions have been made numerous times in previous threads. The main problem with this argument as I generally see it advanced on message boards, and the above rendition illustrates the point, is that's not interested in serious moral claims. Instead it's a cynical attempt at shutting down more relevant issue of reducing suffering by alleging vegans are smug hypocrites.

So one who is smug about their veg*n diet consisting of factory farmed veggies, exported fruits and grains/nuts could very well be contirbuting to far more animal deaths than the average joe.

This comment and the final line in the sentence above indicates you're more interested in weak rhetoric rather than rigorous arguments. At the beginning you talked about "free-range" animals but by the end you're talking about food purchased from supermarkets and average-joes, even saying vegans "could very well be contributing to far more animal deaths." But the meat purchased from supermarkets, the meat consumed by your "average joe" is more likely grain-fed, and it takes many pounds of grain to produce a single pound of beef.

Now, suppose I do grow the vast majority of what I eat. Does that mean I can go back to assuming I have a morally superior diet?

-----------------------
The Atheist:
I don't believe that there is any ethical difference between killing an elephant or cutting my lawn.

What is the "ethical difference," if any, between killing an elephant and killing a baby?
 
My opinion is that it is unnecessary to kill animals just to eat them.
I can't help but wonder what your shoes and belts (etc) are made of.......

Also, why would you eat it?
1 - unsurpassed source of protein
2 - tastes so damn good

I have also heard from ex-vegetarians that they had less energy or "fire" than they did when also eating meat, but couldn't say...


The other thing you must keep in mind is that eating meat isn't particularly healthy.
Sorry, that is patently false.

Now, as I said before it all comes down to a matter of opinion, and I respect it if you do eat meat. But it's a choice. do you think it's worth killing an animal just for a bit of meat on the side of your plate, which could be replaced and is completely unnecessary apart from the fact that one may find it tasty? or not?
I think not.
Thanks, yes I do, and think again. Who are you do decide where the morality line is drawn in this regard?
 
In the U.s., the majority of carnivores are far removed from the action behind the scene.
I guess that's a good thing, or there'd be even more vegans, destroying the earth with their self-righteous delusions.

Forget the moral issue; its hopeless.
Consider the technology:

What do we eat when we set off in space ships to colonize other planets?
Do we bring cattle along?

The 'taste' of meat can be replicated, but some people enjoy the real thing.
Our food production systems favor meat. I see it as out-dated technology.
 
What do we eat when we set off in space ships to colonize other planets?
Do we bring cattle along?
Too big. Seafood. Maybe a few pigs too :)

Anyway, who cares? We'll blow ourselves up long before that technology arrives.
 
Just for kicks, can you please explain to me the difference between the two. I don't believe that there is any ethical difference between killing an elephant or cutting my lawn. Plenty of human constructs to say why, but you seem to have found an answer.

Away you go, then.

Here's a non-human-construct answer, then: when you kill the elephant you kill an individual organism. When you cut your lawn you remove parts of the above-surface portions of an organism. In one case, you prevent further contributions to the population's gene pool by the individual you interfere with, whereas in the other case the individual(s, unless you have a very small lawn mower) may still contribute its genetic material to the local (or regional)gene pool.
 
Sense of empathy never comes into it; wonder if that theory's been blasted.

So killing a dog or a cat is no different than mowing the grass?

What about chopping an animal's limbs off, then? Same thing, right? After all, you don't destroy the grass; you chop off the blades, which will grow back.

Ergo, this statement:

The Atheist said:
Who mentioned abuse? The point was killing.

Shows such a profound ignorance in basic biology, that I don't think that any further conversation will lead anywhere.
 
Last edited:
Here's a non-human-construct answer, then: when you kill the elephant you kill an individual organism. When you cut your lawn you remove parts of the above-surface portions of an organism. In one case, you prevent further contributions to the population's gene pool by the individual you interfere with, whereas in the other case the individual(s, unless you have a very small lawn mower) may still contribute its genetic material to the local (or regional)gene pool.

Which is a cute way of valuing the elephant's DNA, which would be a human construct. Animals die anyway.

Sense of empathy never comes into it; wonder if that theory's been blasted.

If you're trying to make a point, you failed.

Are you claiming some hard-wired thing which gives us empathy with other animals/mammals/ whatevers?

So killing a dog or a cat is no different than mowing the grass?

Not without using human constructs, as far as I'm aware, no. (Especially dogs - I'd rather shoot a dog than mow a lawn any day.)

What about chopping an animal's limbs off, then? Same thing, right? After all, you don't destroy the grass; you chop off the blades, which will grow back.

Hey, it's your argument that there's a difference, so feel free...

Shows such a profound ignorance in basic biology, that I don't think that any further conversation will lead anywhere.

Yeah, much better to just post some blather like that than back up your assertion. What on earth does biology have to do with it? I've admitted that there are physical differences between plants and animals, but I also said, "So what?"

Thus far, you've said exactly nothing in defence of your assertion that some kind of hard-wired morality says otherwise. (At least I think that's what you're claiming, although it's impossible to tell since you won't post on the subject.)
 
The Atheist said:
(Especially dogs - I'd rather shoot a dog than mow a lawn any day.)

Well, you can't explain to a sociopath what empathy is.

No use discussing the issue with you, then.
 
Which is a cute way of valuing the elephant's DNA, which would be a human construct. Animals die anyway.

Not at all. Regardless of if any value is placed on the DNA of the grass, the elephant (1), both, or neither, the fact remains that there is a difference betwen removing an organism from a gene pool and merely temporarily prevent it from participating in it. I see no values in this statement; if you see any, please point them out for me.

EDIT: Values do creep in, of course, if you set one action as less desirable than the other. You will notice that I did no such thing, but merely pointed out that there is a difference. In a more human reference frame it is the difference between stopping your teenage son from having sex by gluing a condom to the relevant parts, and killing him. For many teenage boys, one might be as desirable as the other. That doesn't make the actions identical, though.

---
(1) I walked next to one today on my way from the bookshop!!!!!
 
Last edited:
To be honest, every time I think of "vegetarian" or "vegan" or "peta" I think of [link lamentably removed, please see original post] and I just laugh.

Not sure I see the comedy value, but humor is a subjective thing. [smile]

I couldn't help wondering just how much she'd had to drink before recording that. She sounded WASTED.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom