linusrichard
Master Poster
- Joined
- Apr 17, 2007
- Messages
- 2,710
I like animals and humans, combined.
You have to send me some recipes!
I like animals and humans, combined.
Kosher and halal killing are the same, which is a little ironic, but you're right, it's a horrible way to kill an animal.
You have to send me some recipes!
I've never encountered one of these vegetarians who gets mad at meat-eaters, or tries to force their vegetarianism on others. And I've known kind of a lot of vegetarians and vegans. I'm beginning to wonder if this type of vegetarian is a myth that lives only in complaining posts on internet message boards.
I'm a vegetarian because I think it's healthier than eating meat.
As far as I'm concerned other people can eat whatever they want.
He's like that in every thread, though, if you're referring to who I'm thinking of.There's at least one I know of who exists on this board. Though I would make a wild guess and assume he's not as bombastic and insulting to people in person.
Pretty much my point of view, sans the vegetarian part.![]()

1) Vegetarians, in general, quite frankly, don't look all that healthy. It's actually difficult to get the complete protein a body needs without eating meat, which is why y'all look so skinny and guant. Flexitarians strike me as people who want to be vegetarian (for emotional/ideological reasons) but realise that if they adhere to it strictly, they will eventually be only slightly better off than your average Ethiopian.
However, I do think that vegetarians who refuse to eat meat because of concerns about "killing animals for food" while being apparently quite happy to consume milk and cheese and so on, haven't really taken the trouble to understand the issues.
Sure, but you preceded this sentence with "vegetarians are lazy." I don't think you should be surprised that a pragmatically competent vegetarian might read that and think, "Hey, I'm being called lazy."I'm specifically directing this thread to the angry vegans/vegetarians...so please don't think that I'm stereotyping all vegetarians...that's why in this line I was careful to use the word "some"...I DID NOT say "all":
"However, what bothers me are some vegetarian who behave as they though they are somehow morally superior to meat eaters."
The problem here, and the reason that I'm objecting, is that you're over-identifying the sermonizing vegetarians by setting up a false dichotomy between veganism as a personal choice and veganism as a moral obligation, between the judgmental vegetarian and the vegetarian who has nothing to say about what we ought to do as rational creatures. I'm trying to identify the space in between--veganism as a moral good, better than unreflective habit, but not necessarily required (trivially, someone who eats vegetables and roadkill is possibly doing more good than the vegan, but I'm not going to do that).Perhaps I wasn't clear enough...so I'm spelling it out...my post was intended to be directed specifically at angry vegetarians who are avoiding meat because of factory farming and who place judgement on meat eaters.
Well personally I don't get the whole "Won't eat milk or cheese" part of "Won't kill animals." No animals are killed to produce milk
Dairy cows have to be regularly pregnant to ensure lactation. What do you think happens to the calves they birth?
To rolfe: [....]So in other words, eat your meat but please don't tell me how skinny, unhealthy, hypocritical, lazy and what else I am. None of those things are true. I process vegetable protein at amazing rates, I am never sick, I speak my mind aplenty(as you shall find out) and I work my ass off. Since my physiology is probably no different from any other, I have to assume that all vegetarians can be the same....unless they are hypocrites, or lazy, or sickly or even skinny. Independently from their being vegetarians.
Peace
As I understand it (and I have not seen these processes for myself, but I have colleagues who have), shechita is worse than halal, at least in theory. In that halal aims to decapitate the animal completely, while shechita just cuts the throat and leaves the backbone of the neck intact.
Being from Dairy county I'm going have to stick up for it.
The idea that dairy cows are worse off than beef (at least in New Zealand) is a load of tripe.
Dairy cows have to be well treated and happy to produce milk. If they aren't happy or are mistreated they stop producing, or at least their yields drop. The idea they live shorter lives is also incorrect.
Regulary prenant equals once a year, if they were "in the wild" they'd likely face the same situations.
As to the calves it depends on the farm. Females are generaly raised as new milking stock or sold to other farmers wanting milking cows. Males face a different future, the lucky ones are raised as breeding bulls, while the others are sold. Whether that is to other farms as beefers or something else, or the works depends entirely on the demand for them.
Either way they aren't killed "to produce milk". If there wasn't a demand for them from the works they'd be raised as beef or whatever anyway.
Being from Dairy county I'm going have to stick up for it.
The idea that dairy cows are worse off than beef (at least in New Zealand) is a load of tripe. Dairy cows have to be well treated and happy to produce milk. If they aren't happy or are mistreated they stop producing, or at least their yields drop. The idea they live shorter lives is also incorrect. In New Zealand some farms are actually moving towards fully automated milking which means that the cows can turn up at the shed and travel through it when they want to without humans needing to be there, and they do. If you have even been in a shed during milking you'd see them standing there chewing their cud, something a stressed unhappy animal wouldn't do. The simple fact of the matter is that the happier and less stressed out a cow is, the better the quality and the more milk it will produce. As such most Dairy Farmers spend a lot of time and money making sure that dairy cows are very well treated because in the end doing that increases their revenues and profit.