Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

Kosher and halal killing are the same, which is a little ironic, but you're right, it's a horrible way to kill an animal.


As I understand it (and I have not seen these processes for myself, but I have colleagues who have), shechita is worse than halal, at least in theory. In that halal aims to decapitate the animal completely, while shechita just cuts the throat and leaves the backbone of the neck intact. The latter allows a significantly longer period of consciousness before the animal dies.

However, it may be that in practice there is little difference, because I imagine that actually succeeding in carrying out halal correctly must be very difficult indeed.

The only thing preventing humane shechita slaughter is the decree that using a captive bolt to stun the animal immediately before the shochet gets to work would constitute a "blemish", and so that would render the animal unacceptable.

Now consider. It is absolutely law that every bovine animal over a certain age (pretty young) is uniquely identified using an ear tag. That's just the first of a list of minor "mutilations" that farm animals routinely undergo. Every single bit of kosher beef has come from an animal that has had its ear pierced.

Somehow, the rules have been bent to allow that.

But they can't be bent to allow a captive bolt stun.

Do you wonder that I get off on a rant about this?

Rolfe.
 
I'd like to clear up some things about my original post....

First of all, I used to be a vegetarian, but I just couldn't stick to it well enough. The thing that bothered me most afterward was being treated like a failure for not keeping it up. I avoid meat when I can, but do eat it sometimes. When I go shopping, I look for free range chicken or eat veggie substitutes. I give myself credit for trying and just don't need others making me feel bad for not going "all the way".

I've been on both sides and have seen what it's like to be ridiculed by meat eaters and vegetarians.

Secondly, I certainly am not talking about *all* vegetarians. Not all vegetarians think they are morally superior to meat eaters. The "angry vegetarians" do exist. I used the veal example because I personally know vegetarians who get angry when meat eaters don't eat veal...that doesn't make sense to me because it seems like they'd be happy to at least see the veal industry taking a hit. Additionally, just yesterday someone made the comment to me "there is no justification for eating meat"

I'm specifically directing this thread to the angry vegans/vegetarians...so please don't think that I'm stereotyping all vegetarians...that's why in this line I was careful to use the word "some"...I DID NOT say "all":

"However, what bothers me are some vegetarian who behave as they though they are somehow morally superior to meat eaters."

Perhaps I wasn't clear enough...so I'm spelling it out...my post was intended to be directed specifically at angry vegetarians who are avoiding meat because of factory farming and who place judgement on meat eaters.
 
To rolfe: I made it one of my life choices to accept my background (jewish) as such because even though I was atheist all my life, I can't entirely run away from its trappings. I was influenced from it as I I it lived daily (religious orthodox), and, in some way, because my father spent his time slaughtering chickens I evolved from meat eating to "vegan" shortly after I left the family home. I am not defending shehita but it is still a much better method than what is used in most of the world, (may be not in Scottland or Switzerland). I have seen killings made by locals in various countries, and it ain't pretty as the saying goes. This said, I am not defending Judaism as with any religion, original meanings are lost and the actual practice becomes sacred and thus unchangeable. Judaism needs a slap in the face, I agree.
I think we mostly agree but we seem to express differently.
I have no problem with meat, after all, lots of animals kill prey always without too many niceties and I'd be an idiot to think that it has to be done differently. I am just saying that in this day and age, there are very valid reasons for being vegetarian and I feel that meat-eaters sometimes seem so content of being such that it leaves very little space for acceptance. I am always surprised by the condescending tone of comments made against this diet as if not doing so might threaten their share of the available flesh.
So in other words, eat your meat but please don't tell me how skinny, unhealthy, hypocritical, lazy and what else I am. None of those things are true. I process vegetable protein at amazing rates, I am never sick, I speak my mind aplenty(as you shall find out) and I work my ass off. Since my physiology is probably no different from any other, I have to assume that all vegetarians can be the same....unless they are hypocrites, or lazy, or sickly or even skinny. Independently from their being vegetarians.
Peace
 
I've never encountered one of these vegetarians who gets mad at meat-eaters, or tries to force their vegetarianism on others. And I've known kind of a lot of vegetarians and vegans. I'm beginning to wonder if this type of vegetarian is a myth that lives only in complaining posts on internet message boards.

There's at least one I know of who exists on this board. Though I would make a wild guess and assume he's not as bombastic and insulting to people in person.

I'm a vegetarian because I think it's healthier than eating meat.

As far as I'm concerned other people can eat whatever they want.

Pretty much my point of view, sans the vegetarian part. :)
 
There's at least one I know of who exists on this board. Though I would make a wild guess and assume he's not as bombastic and insulting to people in person.
He's like that in every thread, though, if you're referring to who I'm thinking of.

If a poster like Jerome the Gnome started arguing for vegetarianism, would the above described REALLY put him as much different than he was in any other topic?

Pretty much my point of view, sans the vegetarian part. :)

Wha?

"I'm a because I think it's healthier than eating meat." doesn't make any sense. :boggled:
 
Har har har.

I think eating meat is plenty healthy (though not as much meat as is generally suggested... I think Atkins was a crackpot). Other than that, though, I don't generally have a problem with whatever people want to eat.
 
I do not eat mammals.

It is not arbitrary.

I have problems digesting the meat of mammals, thus I don't eat it.

I also don't drink/use milk (tastes bad, can't digest it) but I can eat yogurt & aged cheese, and eggs, and I do eat them.

I also eat fish & fowl (white meat only - have problems with dark meat).

When I tell people I don't eat beef, many of them automatically assume I must be a conscience-based vegetarian and begin criticizing my choices. I have been criticized by meat-eaters a lot more than I've heard meat-eaters criticized by vegetarians.

I don't have any problem with being gaunt, thin, or unhealthy, by the way. In fact, I got a lot healthier after I eliminated the things that disrupted my digestive system completely.

I don't care what other people eat and will happily cook someone a steak if he/she wants it. However, I think some vegs have good, well-thought-out reasons for being vegetarians other than digestive reasons (economic, environmental, etc.). I also note that when I was sixteen I worked for a summer on a farm and I didn't have any digestive problems eating the pork from the pigs we raised and slaughtered there (a few free-range porkers, also fed our scraps, goat milk, leftover eggs, etc.).

When I told someone once that I didn't eat beef or pork, he aksed, "What do you eat?".

My answer: "Everything else."
 
1) Vegetarians, in general, quite frankly, don't look all that healthy. It's actually difficult to get the complete protein a body needs without eating meat, which is why y'all look so skinny and guant. Flexitarians strike me as people who want to be vegetarian (for emotional/ideological reasons) but realise that if they adhere to it strictly, they will eventually be only slightly better off than your average Ethiopian.

Allow me to pile on. I'm 6'1", 200 lbs. (yeah yeah metric. Look it up). Solid amound of muscle mass and a sub 12 second 100 meter time at age 28. No problem with growing muscle mass at all and I have a few pounds of fat I could stand to lose.

The notion that it's difficult to get protein on a vegetarian diet is laughable. For the traditional defination there's milk, eggs and cheese and for everyone including vegans there's rice, beans, soy and it's variants, lentils, seeds, nuts, tempeh, etc.
 
Being from Dairy county I'm going have to stick up for it.

The idea that dairy cows are worse off than beef (at least in New Zealand) is a load of tripe. Dairy cows have to be well treated and happy to produce milk. If they aren't happy or are mistreated they stop producing, or at least their yields drop. The idea they live shorter lives is also incorrect. In New Zealand some farms are actually moving towards fully automated milking which means that the cows can turn up at the shed and travel through it when they want to without humans needing to be there, and they do. If you have even been in a shed during milking you'd see them standing there chewing their cud, something a stressed unhappy animal wouldn't do. The simple fact of the matter is that the happier and less stressed out a cow is, the better the quality and the more milk it will produce. As such most Dairy Farmers spend a lot of time and money making sure that dairy cows are very well treated because in the end doing that increases their revenues and profit.
 
However, I do think that vegetarians who refuse to eat meat because of concerns about "killing animals for food" while being apparently quite happy to consume milk and cheese and so on, haven't really taken the trouble to understand the issues.

As a self-satisfied, smug vegan, I wholeheartedly agree. :D
 
Well personally I don't get the whole "Won't eat milk or cheese" part of "Won't kill animals." No animals are killed to produce milk and as I noted above, even stressing them out is bad for production and avoided like the plauge by most farmers (true there are bad ones, but there are bad examples everywhere and a bad dairy farmer doesn't stay in business long cause his cows go dry.) Even eggs, while I get the no battery hen eggs, free range eggs that aren't fertilised aren't killing anything because the egg is non-viable and there is no distress on the hens either. So what are the ethical problems here? Hoenestly, getting wool is more distressing to sheep than milk from cows.
 
I'm specifically directing this thread to the angry vegans/vegetarians...so please don't think that I'm stereotyping all vegetarians...that's why in this line I was careful to use the word "some"...I DID NOT say "all":

"However, what bothers me are some vegetarian who behave as they though they are somehow morally superior to meat eaters."
Sure, but you preceded this sentence with "vegetarians are lazy." I don't think you should be surprised that a pragmatically competent vegetarian might read that and think, "Hey, I'm being called lazy."

Perhaps I wasn't clear enough...so I'm spelling it out...my post was intended to be directed specifically at angry vegetarians who are avoiding meat because of factory farming and who place judgement on meat eaters.
The problem here, and the reason that I'm objecting, is that you're over-identifying the sermonizing vegetarians by setting up a false dichotomy between veganism as a personal choice and veganism as a moral obligation, between the judgmental vegetarian and the vegetarian who has nothing to say about what we ought to do as rational creatures. I'm trying to identify the space in between--veganism as a moral good, better than unreflective habit, but not necessarily required (trivially, someone who eats vegetables and roadkill is possibly doing more good than the vegan, but I'm not going to do that).

Anyway, this thread is a good record of how these perceptions of moralistic vegans are an inversion of reality, where people tend to get immediately defensive simply knowing that a vegan, a vegetarian, or even (apparently) someone who doesn't eat beef or pork is around.
 
Well personally I don't get the whole "Won't eat milk or cheese" part of "Won't kill animals." No animals are killed to produce milk

Dairy cows have to be regularly pregnant to ensure lactation. What do you think happens to the calves they birth?
 
Dairy cows have to be regularly pregnant to ensure lactation. What do you think happens to the calves they birth?

Regulary prenant equals once a year, if they were "in the wild" they'd likely face the same situations.

As to the calves it depends on the farm. Females are generaly raised as new milking stock or sold to other farmers wanting milking cows. Males face a different future, the lucky ones are raised as breeding bulls, while the others are sold. Whether that is to other farms as beefers or something else, or the works depends entirely on the demand for them.

Either way they aren't killed "to produce milk". If there wasn't a demand for them from the works they'd be raised as beef or whatever anyway.
 
To rolfe: [....]So in other words, eat your meat but please don't tell me how skinny, unhealthy, hypocritical, lazy and what else I am. None of those things are true. I process vegetable protein at amazing rates, I am never sick, I speak my mind aplenty(as you shall find out) and I work my ass off. Since my physiology is probably no different from any other, I have to assume that all vegetarians can be the same....unless they are hypocrites, or lazy, or sickly or even skinny. Independently from their being vegetarians.
Peace


Excuse me.

Perhaps you didn't mean that the way it came out, but please point to any place where I criticised your lifestyle, health or morals in any way. I did not, in fact.

I "had a go" at a post of yours where you praised shechita slaughter for its humane qualities. As you may have gathered, that is a hot-button topic with me.

I noticed even at the time, even before I said a word, that you readily acknowledged that the ritual should be revised to make it more humane. In this we agree perfectly. (Indeed, as I understand it, this is already the case in some countries where, faced with the choice of eating "kosher" meat which has been pre-stunned before ritual slaughter, and vegetarianism, the Jewish communities have discovered that maybe the pre-stunning isn't such a blemish after all.)

You also remark that you don't eat meat, kosher or otherwise. So again, I have no quarrel with you.

I was "having a go" at ritual slaughter. You just happened to be the one who brought it up. As you neither defend ritual slaughter without pre-stunning, nor eat the meat, I rather fail to see where I seem to have offended you.

Please reserve your ire for those who actually have declared that vegetarians are weedy, unhealthy, hypocritical or whatever. Which I have not.

And I will reserve my ire for those who refuse to allow pre-stunning of livestock at slaughter, and who eat the resulting product willingly. And of course for those who are obstructing moves to have such meat labelled when it enters the normal food retail system. None of which applies to you, and I don't recall saying it did.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
As I understand it (and I have not seen these processes for myself, but I have colleagues who have), shechita is worse than halal, at least in theory. In that halal aims to decapitate the animal completely, while shechita just cuts the throat and leaves the backbone of the neck intact.

Our halal slaughtermen must be doing it wrong then, because no decapitation was done on the many halal slaughtered beasts I've seen. It ain't pretty, and I agree, there is a period of consciousness while bleeding to death.

Being from Dairy county I'm going have to stick up for it.

The idea that dairy cows are worse off than beef (at least in New Zealand) is a load of tripe.

Have you spent much time on farms? That's a really naive position.

And did you have to mention tripe???

Dairy cows have to be well treated and happy to produce milk. If they aren't happy or are mistreated they stop producing, or at least their yields drop. The idea they live shorter lives is also incorrect.

You're right that an unhappy cow will produce less, but happiness for a cow is more a matter of grass to chew than anything else, and while cruelty isn't all that common, there's a hell of a lot more of it on dairy farms than beef. And dairy cows do have shorter lives than if they were left to their own devices. If some evidence isn't posted to reflect that, I'll track some down myself, because it's been well documented.

In general, you're partly right, because the cows are the farmer's livelihood and therefore aren't generally mistreated, but they aren't necessarily handled with kid gloves, either.

Out of 1000+ milkings, I don't think I've ever seen one where at least one cow wasn't punched in the tits. (not by me, I hasten to add)

I suspect dairy products would be a lot less popular if more people spent time in a milking shed. Even in an automated shed, the cows need to be rounded up and taken to milking. If left alone, they'd arrive for their morning milk at the afternoon time. They're not stupid, but they sure are slow!
 
Regulary prenant equals once a year, if they were "in the wild" they'd likely face the same situations.

As to the calves it depends on the farm. Females are generaly raised as new milking stock or sold to other farmers wanting milking cows. Males face a different future, the lucky ones are raised as breeding bulls, while the others are sold. Whether that is to other farms as beefers or something else, or the works depends entirely on the demand for them.

Either way they aren't killed "to produce milk". If there wasn't a demand for them from the works they'd be raised as beef or whatever anyway.

Exactly. Which is why, because I have numerous issues with killing animals for food, I eschew dairy too. When you said "No animals are killed to produce milk",you were wrong - the death of animals is a fundamental part of the milk production process unless we're talking husbandry where male calves are raised as pets to die of old age.
 
Last edited:
Being from Dairy county I'm going have to stick up for it.

The idea that dairy cows are worse off than beef (at least in New Zealand) is a load of tripe. Dairy cows have to be well treated and happy to produce milk. If they aren't happy or are mistreated they stop producing, or at least their yields drop. The idea they live shorter lives is also incorrect. In New Zealand some farms are actually moving towards fully automated milking which means that the cows can turn up at the shed and travel through it when they want to without humans needing to be there, and they do. If you have even been in a shed during milking you'd see them standing there chewing their cud, something a stressed unhappy animal wouldn't do. The simple fact of the matter is that the happier and less stressed out a cow is, the better the quality and the more milk it will produce. As such most Dairy Farmers spend a lot of time and money making sure that dairy cows are very well treated because in the end doing that increases their revenues and profit.


I'd dearly love to see your statistics for cattle longevity in your beef and dairy industries. What you are claiming seems very improbable to me. As I said, suckler cows regularly live into their late teens, which seems to be about par for the course for the species. I suspect a "pet" cow, mollycoddled and not permanently pregnant and/or lactating might even manage a bit more.

You have dairy cows that live that long? How? Please, please, tell us the secret.

Now I agree that dairy cows are generally quite content and well treated. I think I actually said that. However, what I meant by stress was not what you perhaps assumed. I meant, mainly, metabolic stress. You want a list of the metabolic diseases dairy cows get at the drop of a hat? Hypocalcaemia, ketosis and rumenal acidosis is just for starters. Dairy farming is one constant battle to avoid these things.

The reason is of course that producing 30 litres of milk a day is pushing the bovine metabolism to its limit. These girls are the Lance Armstrongs of their field. They have to be finely tuned "just so" to pull it off. Any little hiccup and it's off the rails into one metabolic nightmare or another. Which is why BST is such a bad idea. It's the bridge too far. It's the bloody haystack that broke the camel's back.

They are also far more prone than sucklers to infections and fertility problems. Mastitis alone is the cause of a high proportion of dairy cows being culled every year. Add all that up, and you get an average lifespan less than half the suckler cow's. I'd be positively fascinated to see any statistics for a country that has managed to buck this trend. And even more fascinated to figure out why our dairy farmers are not beating a path to its door.

Oh yes, and there is one very real stress the suckler cow is obviously spared. The removal of her calf as a newborn. Dairy cows do feel this keenly, although they seem to forget within two or three days.

Then there is the matter of the calves themselves. Yes, some farmers do simply shoot the bull calves at birth. Most don't, and raise the bull calves as second-rate beef. And of course the heifer calves are kept, and lovingly hand-reared as the next generation of milkers. The problem is that no artificial rearing system can compete with Mum. Calf health, vigour and yes, happiness, are all better in the suckler herd.

I'm not dissing your Dairy County. I accept that most dairy farms provide acceptable welfare standards, and that for the most part the cows are content and well-treated. If I didn't, I wouldn't be consuming the amount of milk and cheese that I do.

But you can't turn a blind eye to the metabolic disease incidence, the mastitis, the culling rates and the calf rearing difficulties that dairying inevitably suffers from.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom