Regulary prenant equals once a year, if they were "in the wild" they'd likely face the same situations.
As to the calves it depends on the farm. Females are generaly raised as new milking stock or sold to other farmers wanting milking cows. Males face a different future, the lucky ones are raised as breeding bulls, while the others are sold. Whether that is to other farms as beefers or something else, or the works depends entirely on the demand for them.
Either way they aren't killed "to produce milk". If there wasn't a demand for them from the works they'd be raised as beef or whatever anyway.
I think this is being fairly shredded, but I'll weigh in anyway.
Problems pretty much specific to dairy farming.
- Calves. Whether bull or heifer, they aren't going to be reared by Mum. Which means that they aren't as well raised as suckler calves whatever happens.
- Cows. Metabolic stresses and production disease (such as mastitis and infertility) mean that the culling rate for dairy cows is high. This is why the life span is so much shorter than a suckler cow's.
Nobody would breed a Friesian Holstein for meat. The bull calves may well go for meat rather than being shot at birth, but they're still just surplus produce, an essential by-product of getting the cow into lactation. And the end of it is, they die. So score one for an animal that has to die so that milk can be produced.
And I just reiterate the culling rate in dairy cows, and the improbability of ever meeting a dairy cow older than about seven or eight at the outside. When the natural lifespan of even a productive non-dairy cow is maybe 18 years. So score another for an animal that is going to die prematurely so that milk can be produced.
I repeat, I don't think dairy farming, as practised by experienced, competent and caring farmers, is unacceptable. I don't like the taking away of the calves, but as I said, the cows do seem to forget after a couple of days. I don't like the potential for metabolic and production disease, but so long as a good stockman can confine it to "potential", then the system works. I don't like the short lifespan of the dairy cow, but so long as she's reasonably content during that lifespan then I think it's acceptable. I don't like the less healthy calf rearing methods, but again, if the calves are well cared for by a caring stockman (or better, woman), then it's not that bad a system.
Now some may say that I'm being too lenient on the dairy industry, and that this level of exploitation of the cow is too much. And I would say that is a valid point of view.
What I'm really trying to highlight, however, is the much longer and healthier life and higher welfare standards enjoyed by the average suckler cow. And how irrational it thus is to declare that one doesn't eat meat on ethical grounds but one is quite happy to consume dairy products.
Death is as big a part of dairy farming as of beef, and it's not just death one has to think about either.
Rolfe.