Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

Exactly. Which is why, because I have numerous issues with killing animals for food, I eschew dairy too. When you said "No animals are killed to produce milk",you were wrong - the death of animals is a fundamental part of the milk production process unless we're talking husbandry where male calves are raised as pets to die of old age.

But it's not fundamental, because that would say that the Dairy industry couldn't exist without it. The fact is that is can, yes it's have to change, but if the demand from the works wasn't there for bobby calves, then the end result is that bobby's would be treated in a different manner. While the demand is there then the bobbys are supplied to meet the demand. If the world changes so that tomorrow there was no demand for bobbies buy the works, then they'd be sold to become steers and beef cattle (or pets or by pseuo-farmers.) The reason that isn't done is because there is still a demand for them, blaming the dairy industry for supplying that demand is unfair.
 
Our halal slaughtermen must be doing it wrong then, because no decapitation was done on the many halal slaughtered beasts I've seen. It ain't pretty, and I agree, there is a period of consciousness while bleeding to death.


I may very well be wrong. As I said, I haven't personally witnessed the procedure. I have merely listened to many of my colleagues who have, and the niceties tend to be slightly lost in the tirade of impotent fury that gets unleashed against "ritual slaughter" in general. The published papers I've read were all considering shechita alone.

My impression of the differencies was from a meat inspection lecture in about 1975. I was under the impression that halal wasn't quite so inhumane as shechita, but I may have mis-remembered the details.

Rolfe.
 
Speaking as a vegetarian, the diet is absolutely arbitrary; except in cases like mine where it's due to an allergy/sensitivity.

Few things annoy me more than self-righteous, fanatical vegans.
 
Mashed potatoes is murder!!! (So eat your own feces only, PETA bots!!)
That won't work. Feces are full of tiny dead animals (like E.coli), aren't they? :boggled: What are you going to suggest next? Making fur coats out of dead bacteria husks, you murderer? How many trillions of spirochetes had to give their lives to make that curly trim on your parka?!!?!

I've known several vegetarians, all with different stories. One just didn't like meat. One thinks it's healthier, and admitted to me that she sometimes misses those Burger King chicken sandwiches. One is against eating animals, although she doesn't lecture anybody about it. One was raised in India and has never eaten "anything with a face," and just doesn't plan to start. He does point out that he could have eaten something made with meat and not known it - how would he know, with nothing to compare it to?

People who honestly and knowingly support PETA and groups like the ALF tend to consider non-human animals as more important than humans, higher beings with their rights being denied. So killing humans, or at least risking killing humans (say by arson) to save some lab animals makes total sense to them, and avoiding use of any animal products, even honey.
Some very confused people take this to idiotic, dangerous extremes, like women being unwilling to breastfeed their babies because somehow that's exploiting...herself, I guess, and it means feeding the baby an animal product. It is often very sad when that happens, because these people don't turn to formula, and babies do not thrive on wheatgrass and almond milk. :(
 
Regulary prenant equals once a year, if they were "in the wild" they'd likely face the same situations.

As to the calves it depends on the farm. Females are generaly raised as new milking stock or sold to other farmers wanting milking cows. Males face a different future, the lucky ones are raised as breeding bulls, while the others are sold. Whether that is to other farms as beefers or something else, or the works depends entirely on the demand for them.

Either way they aren't killed "to produce milk". If there wasn't a demand for them from the works they'd be raised as beef or whatever anyway.


I think this is being fairly shredded, but I'll weigh in anyway.

Problems pretty much specific to dairy farming.
  • Calves. Whether bull or heifer, they aren't going to be reared by Mum. Which means that they aren't as well raised as suckler calves whatever happens.
  • Cows. Metabolic stresses and production disease (such as mastitis and infertility) mean that the culling rate for dairy cows is high. This is why the life span is so much shorter than a suckler cow's.
Nobody would breed a Friesian Holstein for meat. The bull calves may well go for meat rather than being shot at birth, but they're still just surplus produce, an essential by-product of getting the cow into lactation. And the end of it is, they die. So score one for an animal that has to die so that milk can be produced.

And I just reiterate the culling rate in dairy cows, and the improbability of ever meeting a dairy cow older than about seven or eight at the outside. When the natural lifespan of even a productive non-dairy cow is maybe 18 years. So score another for an animal that is going to die prematurely so that milk can be produced.

I repeat, I don't think dairy farming, as practised by experienced, competent and caring farmers, is unacceptable. I don't like the taking away of the calves, but as I said, the cows do seem to forget after a couple of days. I don't like the potential for metabolic and production disease, but so long as a good stockman can confine it to "potential", then the system works. I don't like the short lifespan of the dairy cow, but so long as she's reasonably content during that lifespan then I think it's acceptable. I don't like the less healthy calf rearing methods, but again, if the calves are well cared for by a caring stockman (or better, woman), then it's not that bad a system.

Now some may say that I'm being too lenient on the dairy industry, and that this level of exploitation of the cow is too much. And I would say that is a valid point of view.

What I'm really trying to highlight, however, is the much longer and healthier life and higher welfare standards enjoyed by the average suckler cow. And how irrational it thus is to declare that one doesn't eat meat on ethical grounds but one is quite happy to consume dairy products.

Death is as big a part of dairy farming as of beef, and it's not just death one has to think about either.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
But it's not fundamental, because that would say that the Dairy industry couldn't exist without it. The fact is that is can, yes it's have to change, but if the demand from the works wasn't there for bobby calves, then the end result is that bobby's would be treated in a different manner. While the demand is there then the bobbys are supplied to meet the demand. If the world changes so that tomorrow there was no demand for bobbies buy the works, then they'd be sold to become steers and beef cattle (or pets or by pseuo-farmers.) The reason that isn't done is because there is still a demand for them, blaming the dairy industry for supplying that demand is unfair.

What you say is trivially true, of course, which is why I don't have a moral or fundamentalist objection to dairy, and think small-holding dairy cows aren't necessarily a bad thing. That said, when we're talking about the dairy industry, I stand by my claim - the production of milk necessarily involves the death (and as Rolfe explains, the suffering) of cows.
 
I noticed even at the time, even before I said a word, that you readily acknowledged that the ritual should be revised to make it more humane. In this we agree perfectly. (Indeed, as I understand it, this is already the case in some countries where, faced with the choice of eating "kosher" meat which has been pre-stunned before ritual slaughter, and vegetarianism, the Jewish communities have discovered that maybe the pre-stunning isn't such a blemish after all.)

It's important to keep in mind that the Jewish community is not monolithic, and there are many different "levels" of kashrut, depending on the particular sect. Many of them do allow for stunning and similar humane slaughter techniques. The mention you made earlier about only certain parts of the meat being usable is also a bit incorrect, as that only applies to very strict Orthodox and Haredi requirements, known informally as "glatt kosher", and is due to the difficulty of ensuring the removal of the sciatic nerve tissue and major blood vessels from the hindquarters. This meat is considered perfectly acceptable to many Conservative and Reform Rabbis; some of whom will also accept stunning as part of the slaughter. Many Reform and more liberal sects, eg. Reconstructionists, actively discard much of the kashrut as excessively hair-splitting, and no longer necessary due to modern hygiene practices and better understanding of the science of food preparation.
 
Sure, but you preceded this sentence with "vegetarians are lazy." I don't think you should be surprised that a pragmatically competent vegetarian might read that and think, "Hey, I'm being called lazy."


The problem here, and the reason that I'm objecting, is that you're over-identifying the sermonizing vegetarians by setting up a false dichotomy between veganism as a personal choice and veganism as a moral obligation, between the judgmental vegetarian and the vegetarian who has nothing to say about what we ought to do as rational creatures. I'm trying to identify the space in between--veganism as a moral good, better than unreflective habit, but not necessarily required (trivially, someone who eats vegetables and roadkill is possibly doing more good than the vegan, but I'm not going to do that).

Anyway, this thread is a good record of how these perceptions of moralistic vegans are an inversion of reality, where people tend to get immediately defensive simply knowing that a vegan, a vegetarian, or even (apparently) someone who doesn't eat beef or pork is around.

Perhaps lazy was too strong a word...I will apologize for that...though I don't believe I setup a false dichotomy. My point was that there are a myriad of things that we can do to ease suffering in the world and dietary changes are one of the simplest. Picking a dietary change is somewhat arbitrary given the multitude of other things that one could do to help.

There really isn't anything wrong with drawing arbitrary lines...some people draw the line at eating animals...some draw the line at eating "intelligent" animals...some draw the line at eating red meat...some people don't worry about animals at all and focus all their time and attention on educating children...some on feeding the poor and many on a combination of these an many other "good deeds". To me, it doesn't really matter. As a matter of fact, its too overwhelming for anyone to focus their time and attention on all moral matters. No one can help everyone or everything. So, it seems reasonable to me to think that everyone *should* help out in different ways.

The thing I find bothersome is when die hard vegans don't recognize the contributions of others because the contribution doesn't fit into the die hard vegans world view. If you eat meat, you're a bad person....doesn't matter if you are doing other things to help the world.

I'm certain the perception of moralistic vegans are an inversion of reality...and the perception exists for a reason. Its easy to be a victim of confirmation bias when die hard vegans are sooo public. I saw a "meat is murder" sign posted on an overpass on the way to work...I'm not kidding. We aren't making up stories here...these things really happen and they shouldn't.

This is similar to complaints lodged against Christians. Not all Christians are die hard fundamentalists who are out proselytizing, judging everyone, protesting abortion clinics...etc. Most Christians are not extreme wackos. Does that mean we shouldn't discuss the fact that there are Christians who behave in a deplorable manner?

Just because a behavior is only exhibited by a small percentage of a population, it doesn't make that behavior acceptable.
 
It's important to keep in mind that the Jewish community is not monolithic, and there are many different "levels" of kashrut, depending on the particular sect. Many of them do allow for stunning and similar humane slaughter techniques. The mention you made earlier about only certain parts of the meat being usable is also a bit incorrect, as that only applies to very strict Orthodox and Haredi requirements, known informally as "glatt kosher", and is due to the difficulty of ensuring the removal of the sciatic nerve tissue and major blood vessels from the hindquarters. This meat is considered perfectly acceptable to many Conservative and Reform Rabbis; some of whom will also accept stunning as part of the slaughter. Many Reform and more liberal sects, eg. Reconstructionists, actively discard much of the kashrut as excessively hair-splitting, and no longer necessary due to modern hygiene practices and better understanding of the science of food preparation.


Fair enough. What I would say is, if the cap doesn't fit, then don't wear it.

I have to say that I've never heard of pre-stunning being allowed with ritual slaughter in this country. I personally would have no problem at all with ritual slaughter if pre-stunning were carried out, but so far as I know that isn't happening.

I mention the hindquarter meat merely to illustrate the problem of non-pre-stunned meat entering the normal retail chain. Along with meat from the animals the rabbi rejected as having been improperly killed. I don't know how much of this there is, but it happens and it's not negligible.

If pre-stunning were employed, I would have no problem at all eating the "unsuitable" meat myself. However, I have a bit issue with non-pre-stunned meat entering the normal retail chain unlabelled. Without labelling, how can I avoid it? And unless I and others can do this, how can we make our disapproval of the process known, and hit the system where it will be noticed?

How else to encourage these enlightened rabbis you refer to, and encourage other rabbis to become similarly enlightened?

Rolfe.
 
Excuse me.

Perhaps you didn't mean that the way it came out, but please point to any place where I criticised your lifestyle, health or morals in any way. I did not, in fact..................
. None of which applies to you, and I don't recall saying it did.

Rolfe.
The first part of my comment(about shehita) was as stated, a response to you, the second part was directed at the post describing vegetarians in certain terms. I am not used to forums that well yet and I can definitely see the misunderstanding.As for shehita, I was just commenting on someone who brought it up(Uh..uh don't look at me): see below:
osmosis said:
I have three comments:

1) Vegetarians, in general, quite frankly, don't look all that healthy. It's actually difficult to get the complete protein a body needs without eating meat, which is why y'all look so skinny and guant. Flexitarians strike me as people who want to be vegetarian (for emotional/ideological reasons) but realise that if they adhere to it strictly, they will eventually be only slightly better off than your average Ethiopian.

2) How long is the intestinal tract of a typical carnivore? How long is it in herbivores? Omnivores? And how long is it in Homo Sapiens? Q.E.D.

3) "Koshering" meat is barbaric and cruel. If you're going to kill something, at least be quick and painless about it.

Koshering meat(he meant Shehita) is said to be barbaric and cruel and I reflected that the intent of the method was just the opposite.Nothing more. Available means of killing have evolved since but yet I thought I had to add my two cents. You jumped on the bandwagon and the rest is history....
Compared to hacking to death, throwing against a wall, schoking with a rope, drowning, stoning, shooting and waiting for it to die all available in a non-NZ country not near you, it is still the better choice. The best being not eating any.
 
Well Vegetarians seem to have no problems with the factory farming and mass slaughter of plants, so I'd say yes.

Of course the argument is that "Plants don't feel pain etc" however we can't know that for sure since while they don't have nervous systems like we do, they do seem to react to damage. Take the acacia for example. This tree can detect when a giffae is eating it's leaves and so will increase the tanins in them to make them inedible. It also will release a chemical into the air to warn the nearby plants of the issue, resulting in them also increasing their tanins without being eaten. This seems to be a very basic form of reaction to damage and comminications. Perhaps just because they aren't like us it doesn't mean they don't have their own systems that result in awareness of the world about them and if so, should we not be treating them with the same respect as animals?

So laws against torturing ones pets must be equallay arbitrary, since there are no equivalent laws against pruning shrubs?
 
Being from the TX/OK corridor, I eat a crap-ton of meat. Anyone who's lived in this neck of the woods, or in Memphis or South Carolina or Kansas City knows a little something of the pastime/religion known as the barbecue. I'm not talking about the general term of grilling a food item over coals, that is grilling and be done with it. BBQ is the low and slow method of cooking over an offset and tasty wood fire. This kind of cooking is ideal for certain cuts of meat that don't do so well with other methods, like the brisket for example.

I usually have about 10 or 12 BBQ's every summer. It's a huge social event over at my place and a fantastic good time. Recently though, friends have been bringing vegetarian/vegan acquaintances by. If they were mortified at the burning of dead beasts, they were kind enough to keep it to themselves, although I was a little embarassed that they didn't have anything to eat outside of bread, coleslaw, and beans.

Now, I really like a challenge - and I'd like to put it to those of you that strictly eat vegetables. I'm looking for vegetarian recipes that can stand up to the extended low-temperature high smoke environment of my double pig smoker without just turning into absolute mush. All the vegetarians/vegans commented that the smoky stuff smelled great, they just couldn't eat it. I'd like to find some sort of vegetable that's a reasonably good meat analogue that could be up to the task. Any ideas?
 
What about a vegetarian kabob?

Take the kabob, and stick on pineapple slices and whatever else that's tasty that you can stick onto it. (I once experimented with cherries; was good, but they kept falling off... who knew that would happen?! IOW, we're sometimes stupid :P ) Those can get mighty tasty. Here's one recipe I found: http://www.thatsmyhome.com/bbqpit/vegetable-kebabs.htm

The quickest thing I can tell you is to just use google. A quick google search led me here: http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Marinated-Barbequed-Vegetables/MoreRecipesLikeThis.aspx

This one's MUCH better: http://www.thatsmyhome.com/bbqpit/barbecued-vegetable-recipes.htm

Looks good to me!

Another alternative might be to just have some vegetables and fruits available outside of the barbecue pit itself. Bring some fruit salad or the like as well the coleslaw.

Man, you're making me hungry...

Hey, if you're in Texas or ever come around Texas, maybe we can have a barbecue sometime. :D
 
Last edited:
Har har har.

I think eating meat is plenty healthy (though not as much meat as is generally suggested... I think Atkins was a crackpot). Other than that, though, I don't generally have a problem with whatever people want to eat.
I just want to make plain, in case I wasn't before (probably should have thrown in a winking smiley), I was just kidding around. :)

Personally, I won't come down to your doorstep or insult you for what you eat, nor would I judge based on it. Although I am all for promoting social awareness of the issues (and find it distasteful how quickly people discard real environmental concerns because they find it incredulous without looking at the data).

I'm of a mixed mind on the case of animal welfare in general.
 
morality is always a can of worms.

One of the morality angles of eschewing meat is that our domestic lifestock are generally enslaved and perverted. The expansion of their niche often implies a shrinking niche for naturaly occurring herbivores and their predators.

I'm vegetarian, for lots of reasons; none worth defending. One of the things that worries me about vegetarianism is that it would allow too many people if it caught on.
I think we have plenty of people already.
 
Hey Rolfe, what's the average life expectancy of a calf born on a dairy farm, vs one born as a suckler?

In either industry, most cows would have value for their production, and live longer.

In both industries, most bulls end up on the table in what, two years?

And a side track: A friend that owns a share in a cattle herd in Wyoming believes that it is illegal to sell cow meat for human consumption. But I recall from 30 years ago when I worked at McDonald's (hamburger, not the e-i-e-i-o farm) that Micky's meat was a specific blend of steer, bull, and cow. My guess is that old breeding cows are probably lower quality meat, probably fit for hamburger, not Porterhouses. But "illegal"?I don't think so...
 
Fair enough. What I would say is, if the cap doesn't fit, then don't wear it.

I have to say that I've never heard of pre-stunning being allowed with ritual slaughter in this country. I personally would have no problem at all with ritual slaughter if pre-stunning were carried out, but so far as I know that isn't happening.
Part of the problem is that the majority of the kashrut slaughterhouses cater to the Orthodox regulations, because that provides the largest market (if it's good enough for them, it's good enough for everyone else). However, it really depends on the particular organization. Some certification organizations have been known to include products that would not pass Orthodox kashrut, but are acceptable to most other sects. There are 5 national agencies, and over 50 state agencies, as well as 7 Canadian, 5 Australian, 2 New Zealand, and 4 UK agencies; all represented by different distinctive heschers represented on the end products. That's not including the numerous other heschers on imports -- Israel itself has 4 different agencies. On top of that, some of them offer multiple degrees of certification. You'd have to research a specific agency directly to find out more about their particular requirements. Here's a good source for most of them: http://www.kashrut.com/agencies/. I haven't done any research on specific agencies, and depend mostly on what I have been told by Jewish friends.
If pre-stunning were employed, I would have no problem at all eating the "unsuitable" meat myself. However, I have a bit issue with non-pre-stunned meat entering the normal retail chain unlabelled. Without labelling, how can I avoid it? And unless I and others can do this, how can we make our disapproval of the process known, and hit the system where it will be noticed?

How else to encourage these enlightened rabbis you refer to, and encourage other rabbis to become similarly enlightened?
To be honest, I don't think it will make the slightest bit of difference until there's actual legislation prohibiting non-stunned slaughter, or the importation of such. Orthodox Jewish sects pride themselves on their seperatism.

If such legislation was enacted, I believe that much of the Orthodox is likely to modify the kashrut to reflect necessity; but Haredi sects will probably drop meat altogether. Together, they're probably a big enough market and political segment to prevent any such legislation being enacted.
 
I've never encountered one of these vegetarians who gets mad at meat-eaters, or tries to force their vegetarianism on others. And I've known kind of a lot of vegetarians and vegans. I'm beginning to wonder if this type of vegetarian is a myth that lives only in complaining posts on internet message boards.

Oh, I can assure you, from personal experience, they are not.
In fact at least one is a regular poster here. And I think a lot of the old timers here know who I am talking about.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom