Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

Yes. Paraphyly should be stomped out wherever possible. All dishes that contain meat and vegetables should also contain mushrooms and other suitable organisms. Every family that owns two different kind of pets should be forced to also adopt animals in groups between these, so that their total ownership distribution becomes monophyletic. Expressions like "it's raining cats and dogs" should be modified to reflect this as well. I am not entirely sure what that would mean, but to be on the safe side, all families of Carnivora should be included: "It's raining cats and dogs, and also ferrets, linsangs, hyenas, seal, one or two pandas, a bear, some civets (plus the palm civet), skunks, raccoons, mongooses, sea lions, walruses, enaliarctids, hemicyonids, barbourofelids, percrocutids, nimravids, stenoplesticids, and, last but certainly not least, a fossa." Obviously, some kind of abbreviation would be handy.

I could have sworn that the post I responded to was far shorter and more ambiguous than this. Well, don't I feel the fool for taking you seriously.

I've been troll'd. :blush:
 
Quantity of food consumed is probably a larger health issue than what is consumed.
It may well be healthiest to be hungry all the time, but not malnourished. That's a difficult path to take, if you're around ample food.
 
I could have sworn that the post I responded to was far shorter and more ambiguous than this. Well, don't I feel the fool for taking you seriously.

I've been troll'd. :blush:

Fear not. I edited my post almost immediately to make my position clearer. In systematics and taxonomy we are taught that paraphyly (the name for a group that contains some, but not all, descendants of a common ancestor) is wrong (1). Therefore, by applying this principle to other areas of life than systematics and taxonomy, I seek to attract laughter through humourous exaggeration.

Also, I dislike most mushrooms. As the cat in Get Fuzzy says (here probably paraphrased): "The first person who found a mushroom and thought, 'Hey, I'll put that in my mouth and eat it', was a weirdo".

---
(1) Though there are certainly prominent taxonomists and systematists who argue against this, usually because the strict application of the no-paraphyly preference directly affects their pet organisms. Tarmo Timm is an excellent example of this in the wonderful world of Oligochaetology.
 
I just want to make plain, in case I wasn't before (probably should have thrown in a winking smiley), I was just kidding around. :)

Personally, I won't come down to your doorstep or insult you for what you eat, nor would I judge based on it. Although I am all for promoting social awareness of the issues (and find it distasteful how quickly people discard real environmental concerns because they find it incredulous without looking at the data).

I'm of a mixed mind on the case of animal welfare in general.

Naw, I knew you were joking. We have a degree of agreement on the matter anyway, so it's not like our opinions are far from each other. If you're ever up around D-town (when back in the country of TX), I'll buy you a beer while we make fun of each other's diets.

****ing PETA. They've pretty much ruined any possible chance of a rational debate with most people about vegetarianism/veganism, or cutting down in the general eating of meat at all.

Definitely agree there. Considering I know more people who are doing it (eating vegetarian) for health reasons than ethical reasons, I've found personally that PETA has created an extremely negative stigma around different diets.

Bleh. As far as I'm concerned, both sides need a hit upside the head with a clue bat. PETA doubly so, for multiple reasons that almost everyone here knows already.

I say we grab some clubs and go party. ;)

To echo what RandFan said, I also don't think the majority of the people who have altered their diets are doing so arbitrarily.
 
How much consideration do the vegetarians/vegans give to the animals that die for the production of their vegetables/fruits and grains?

Just wondering if that is factored into the dietary concerns and if so, would you kindly tell me what you (veg*n) do to minimize the animals deaths that make up your diet.

Thanks.
 
I love discussing dietary stuff, but I have to say, I think anyone following any particular diet can fall into the trap of being annoyingly evangelical about it. There seems to be a sort of purity that people can start seeking and it makes them get more and more extreme. I personally think it's healthy for me to control my carbs carefully, with my family history of diabetes and my own health problems. I don't think that everyone has to do it my way, but I will admit that down in my heart of hearts, I do think it would be better for most people to control their carb intake, especially processed carbs. I just know better than to think I should be going around converting anyone to that idea.

I've found some of the paleo-diet followers to be a really good example of this. The basic idea of eating like a caveman seems sensible enough. But when they get extreme, they start quarreling about historical records of what people ate thousands of years ago (as in, what was found in various coproliths from various sites), to try to prove that their personal idea of the ideal caveman diet is the correct one. If someone mentions the work of some illustrious anthropologist as a counterexample, they'll just say that some of these scientists let ego get in the way of the truth or something.
Weirdly, they seem to think that nobody ever ate wheat until we suddenly started planting it everywhere at the advent of agriculture, and that nobody consumed dairy until the same time. Then they use coconut products as handy dairy replacements, which doesn't make a lot of sense to me, at least if the person is of European ancestry. Anyway, I don't find them to be evangelical exactly, but they do tend to tell people that dairy is the source of all evil (or wheat), and that glutamate/MSG goes into your brain directly, and stuff like that.

I haven't met that many raw-fooders but I am finding some people who believe that we should consume more live enzymes - that is, more foods with their own enzymes intact - as not doing so will "deplete" us of our digestive enzymes. Why people think that a carrot enzyme is going to help us digest the carrot is beyond me.

Anyway, one of my favorite sites discusses that "purity" concept of dietary extremism: Beyond Veg.
 
How much consideration do the vegetarians/vegans give to the animals that die for the production of their vegetables/fruits and grains?

Just wondering if that is factored into the dietary concerns and if so, would you kindly tell me what you (veg*n) do to minimize the animals deaths that make up your diet.

Thanks.

I mentioned this earlier in the thread, with no response. I think it's interesting to think about - arguably, the best choice would be to eat steak or similar from an animal that fed itself exclusively by grazing. On the side, I'm not sure - you'd have to find out how things are harvested. Potatoes? Asparagus? Fruit? I can't imagine you could get any grains at all unless you were willing to pay a hefty price for it.

If you're a veg*n for other reasons (like me), it might not be something to worry about. But if you're one who says "I'm a veg*n because I like knowing no animal died to bring me my meal," then you're (almost certainly) fooling yourself.

Fun.
 
Well Vegetarians seem to have no problems with the factory farming and mass slaughter of plants, so I'd say yes.

Of course the argument is that "Plants don't feel pain etc" however we can't know that for sure since while they don't have nervous systems like we do, they do seem to react to damage. Take the acacia for example. This tree can detect when a giffae is eating it's leaves and so will increase the tanins in them to make them inedible. It also will release a chemical into the air to warn the nearby plants of the issue, resulting in them also increasing their tanins without being eaten. This seems to be a very basic form of reaction to damage and comminications. Perhaps just because they aren't like us it doesn't mean they don't have their own systems that result in awareness of the world about them and if so, should we not be treating them with the same respect as animals?

Bravo, exactly. We should all be eating soylent green or some chemically created "food."
 
A vegan diet certainly requires less land in agriculture than a more carnivorous diet, unless you're eating wild animals, in which case, you'd need more wild country than what could possibly sustain today's population.

It is also possible to concentrate the proteins in grasses; remove fiber, and make a nutritious food for human consumption. The main reason for animal husbandry still existing on earth is historical emotion based crappy technology.

A time will come when it will be seen as barbaric and silly, I hope. It will be the next big abolition. Free mammals, complete with adequate habitat.

Its awkward now. But we really don't need to eat animals to be healthy. It might sink in; it might not. But the fact of the matter is that we don't need to eat mammals.
 
I mentioned this earlier in the thread, with no response. I think it's interesting to think about - arguably, the best choice would be to eat steak or similar from an animal that fed itself exclusively by grazing. On the side, I'm not sure - you'd have to find out how things are harvested. Potatoes? Asparagus? Fruit? I can't imagine you could get any grains at all unless you were willing to pay a hefty price for it.

If you're a veg*n for other reasons (like me), it might not be something to worry about. But if you're one who says "I'm a veg*n because I like knowing no animal died to bring me my meal," then you're (almost certainly) fooling yourself.

Fun.




Thank you. I believe that is the first honest answer I've seen yet from some one who claims to be a veg*n and still understands that what they eat involves death to animals.
 
Here's how I look at it, and it's a view I have no real interest in debating or supporting, but just sharing.

If *I* was offered the choice between 1) never existing; 2) existing to the age of 35, and then being slaughtered for food, I would choose 2. And, for the record, I'm now 42 or something, so I would already be dead under #2. I would not choose 2 only under extreme conditions of hardship - the PETA videos of chicken cages (which I doubt represents normal conditions, but do not know for sure). Just about all the meat we eat lived only because it was destined for food and thus faced the same choice of never existing, or an early demise for food.

Now, I would make the choice to exist and be eaten, and I'm a conscious being, with awareness. that's a higher standard than, say, a cow or chicken. Thus I extrapolate that it is okay to make the same choice for them, since they won't be aware of an abbreviated life, let alone mull on it.

Of course this is a hypothetical - I have not been presented with the choice, and things like this can be hard to predict - I acknowledge that the decision I make sitting on my couch is different than the one I might make if forced. (but of course how can you make the choice if you don't exist yet, it's a hypothetical that can never be tested).

In any case, I am comfortable eating meat that was once a well cared for animal, for it lived a life it otherwise would not have lived. I drive by cattle every day here in CO; it's hard to tell, but they look pretty content and well taken care of. Seems like a decent enough life.

I can understand people drawing different conclusions, but giving animals a chance at life seems like a good, not a bad to me.
 
The old, "You draw a border here!!111 THAT IS SO ARBITRARY!111 Plants are just like animals in every way!!11111oneoneone"

Sigh.

No wonder some vegans feel superior, when this is the "logic" of some of those on the other side.

Sad.
 
How much consideration do the vegetarians/vegans give to the animals that die for the production of their vegetables/fruits and grains?

Just wondering if that is factored into the dietary concerns and if so, would you kindly tell me what you (veg*n) do to minimize the animals deaths that make up your diet.

Thanks.

I'm not a vegan, but I'm not convinced by this point.
You might be able to make an argument that free-range meat involves less animal death than grain harvest, but people still need grains, fruit and vegetables as well as meat for a healthy diet. To show that it would be ethically better to include meat in the diet you would have to show that this reduces the quantity of other foods consumed by a sufficient amount to reduce animal deaths by a greater number than the total number of animals slaughtered to provide the meat. And not everyone has access to free-range meat.
In the case of grain-fed meat the animals are killed to produce the grain first, then the grain is fed to more animals that are then slaughtered to produce the meat. In terms of reducing total animal deaths it would be better to eat the grain directly.
 
I'm not a vegan, but I'm not convinced by this point.
You might be able to make an argument that free-range meat involves less animal death than grain harvest, but people still need grains, fruit and vegetables as well as meat for a healthy diet. To show that it would be ethically better to include meat in the diet you would have to show that this reduces the quantity of other foods consumed by a sufficient amount to reduce animal deaths by a greater number than the total number of animals slaughtered to provide the meat. And not everyone has access to free-range meat.
In the case of grain-fed meat the animals are killed to produce the grain first, then the grain is fed to more animals that are then slaughtered to produce the meat. In terms of reducing total animal deaths it would be better to eat the grain directly.
Yeah, but they're Arguing by Maddox, who claims that "according to you [asshats]", we need to go ALL THE WAY!!1111oneone

Ergo, you should support meat eating in general, because if you're drawing a border, you should get rid of it and go the other extreme.

Or else it's arbitrary and not logical, see?
 
I don't especially care what people chose to eat, but i must object to the notion of plant eating being equivilant to animal eating. In the case of fruits and nuts and most grains, the plant is allowed to carry on its life cycle and we eat the seed.

The plant needn't be confined, because it doesn't want to move. When you eat corn, the plant is already done growing and has died. Same with potatoes; tomatoes. Fresh greens might be a different matter, yet still utterly different than animal husbandry.
 
I don't especially care what people chose to eat, but i must object to the notion of plant eating being equivilant to animal eating. In the case of fruits and nuts and most grains, the plant is allowed to carry on its life cycle and we eat the seed.
So if we whacked off part of an animal and allowed it to continue living, it'd be OK? :cool:


The plant needn't be confined, because it doesn't want to move.
So? Confinement of animals (beyond reason ie give them plenty of room) isn't mandatory. So if we give them more room, it's OK?

When you eat corn, the plant is already done growing and has died. Same with potatoes; tomatoes.
? No, the plant (and the "food") are very much alive.
 
It's amazing, the people who can't see the difference between a plant and a cow.

Where do they come from? What kind of education do they receive? :boggled:
 
I've found some of the paleo-diet followers to be a really good example of this. The basic idea of eating like a caveman seems sensible enough.

Um it does? How so? What makes these people think cavemen lived long, healthy lives? Do they also go out in packs to hunt elephant with sharpened sticks? Lacking mastodon that is.
 
It's amazing, the people who can't see the difference between a plant and a cow.

Just for kicks, can you please explain to me the difference between the two. I don't believe that there is any ethical difference between killing an elephant or cutting my lawn. Plenty of human constructs to say why, but you seem to have found an answer.

Away you go, then.

Where do they come from? What kind of education do they receive? :boggled:

Ultimately, both plants & animals come from replicating, single-celled organisms, and in particular, cows are educated in the cowshed with the aid of an alkathene pipe while trees are usually educated by DNA. To expand: cows learn it's milking time by being bitten by a dog or whacked with a plastic pipe, trees learn it's time to shed their leaves in winter by the encoding of their DNA.

Someone will correct me if I'm wrong, but I think all that's pretty close.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom