Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

LadyMitris

Scholar
Joined
Apr 11, 2008
Messages
60
I recently listened to the point of inquiry podcast about the ethics of vegetarianism and I'm puzzled by something. The argument, as I understand it, is that it's unethical to eat meat because it causes animals to suffer due to unethical practices like factory farming.

I agree that animals shouldn't be made to suffer needlessly. However, it seems kind of arbitrary to conclude that by not eating meat, one is leading a moral life. There are many, many things going on in the world that cause suffering...testing medications...blood diamonds...oil production...building homes...driving cars...the list goes on.

It seems kind of arbitrary to say that of all the things in the world that one ought to do to help sentient beings...not eating meat is the most important.

Really, it seems to me that not eating meat is merely the most simple thing do to. Basically, what I'm saying here is that vegetarians are lazy...and that's OK...I'm lazy too. However, what bothers me are some vegetarian who behave as they though they are somehow morally superior to meat eaters.

For example, there are vegetarians who get mad at people who won't eat veal, but will eat fish. They argue that fish deserve as much respect as baby cows...so neither should be eaten.

I say that both the vegetarian and the non-veal eating carnivore are equally good people. No one can stop all suffering. The best anyone can do is help as much as they can...and there are other ways to try to stop suffering that by dietary restrictions....those who give money to the poor...volunteer counselors...taking in stray animals off the street and taking care of them....all of these things are worthwhile and no one person can do them all.

So, why can't we just say that vegetarianism is a personal choice and one of many ways that one can do their part to help animals....not a moral imperative that everyone must follow.
 
So, why can't we just say that vegetarianism is a personal choice and one of many ways that one can do their part to help animals....not a moral imperative that everyone must follow.

Because 90% of the people in the world are hypocritical busybodies who want their personal choices inflicted upon others by force, and that includes 90% of vegetarians too.

Easy peasy.
 
Because 90% of the people in the world are hypocritical busybodies who want their personal choices inflicted upon others by force, and that includes 90% of vegetarians too.

Easy peasy.

And the Vegans are the worst of the lot.
And PETA Members are the worst of the Vegans.
 
Well Vegetarians seem to have no problems with the factory farming and mass slaughter of plants, so I'd say yes.

Of course the argument is that "Plants don't feel pain etc" however we can't know that for sure since while they don't have nervous systems like we do, they do seem to react to damage. Take the acacia for example. This tree can detect when a giffae is eating it's leaves and so will increase the tanins in them to make them inedible. It also will release a chemical into the air to warn the nearby plants of the issue, resulting in them also increasing their tanins without being eaten. This seems to be a very basic form of reaction to damage and comminications. Perhaps just because they aren't like us it doesn't mean they don't have their own systems that result in awareness of the world about them and if so, should we not be treating them with the same respect as animals?
 
I've never encountered one of these vegetarians who gets mad at meat-eaters, or tries to force their vegetarianism on others. And I've known kind of a lot of vegetarians and vegans. I'm beginning to wonder if this type of vegetarian is a myth that lives only in complaining posts on internet message boards.

The argument, as I understand it, is that it's unethical to eat meat because it causes animals to suffer due to unethical practices like factory farming.
That's an argument, yes.
I agree that animals shouldn't be made to suffer needlessly. However, it seems kind of arbitrary to conclude that by not eating meat, one is leading a moral life.
Has anyone come to this conclusion?
There are many, many things going on in the world that cause suffering...testing medications...blood diamonds...oil production...building homes...driving cars...the list goes on.

It seems kind of arbitrary to say that of all the things in the world that one ought to do to help sentient beings...not eating meat is the most important.
I doubt most vegetarians would say that not eating meat is the most important.
Really, it seems to me that not eating meat is merely the most simple thing do to.
It's a little less simple than you might think. I find it far easier to avoid buying blood diamonds than to avoid eating meat.
Basically, what I'm saying here is that vegetarians are lazy...and that's OK...I'm lazy too. However, what bothers me are some vegetarian who behave as they though they are somehow morally superior to meat eaters.

For example, there are vegetarians who get mad at people who won't eat veal, but will eat fish. They argue that fish deserve as much respect as baby cows...so neither should be eaten.
And what bothers me are meat-eaters who get upset when I won't eat chicken or beef. Oh wait. No, that doesn't bother me at all, because (like the angry vegetarians in your example), those people constitute a tiny minority of the population, and because why should I waste my time getting worked up about how someone else feels about the way I eat? Giving you the benefit of the doubt that these angry vegetarians you're talking about actually exist, why do you care what they think about the way you eat anyway?
I say that both the vegetarian and the non-veal eating carnivore are equally good people. No one can stop all suffering. The best anyone can do is help as much as they can...and there are other ways to try to stop suffering that by dietary restrictions....those who give money to the poor...volunteer counselors...taking in stray animals off the street and taking care of them....all of these things are worthwhile and no one person can do them all.

So, why can't we just say that vegetarianism is a personal choice and one of many ways that one can do their part to help animals....not a moral imperative that everyone must follow.
I doubt most vegetarians would disagree with any of this.
 
I recently listened to the point of inquiry podcast about the ethics of vegetarianism and I'm puzzled by something. The argument, as I understand it, is that it's unethical to eat meat because it causes animals to suffer due to unethical practices like factory farming.

That's a flat lie. It's incredibly easy for a person to avoid eating animals farmed under cruel conditions. Eat NZ beef and lamb; they grow out in lovely, grassy paddocks, free to roam wherever they want. No hormonal growth drugs, no factory farms, no feeding stalls, they grow at natural rates until they are carted off in nicely air-conditioned trucks until they arrive at the meat works and are whacked instantly to death with an electric pole-axe.

Humane to a fault.

I can't say I've ever heard the argument as a reason for vegetarianism, but there are plenty of people - including me - who won't touch meat not farmed ethically, or eggs obtained through factory farming.

However, what bothers me are some vegetarian who behave as they though they are somehow morally superior to meat eaters.

And what everyone else has said about opinionated begans, PETA and other animal nuts.

The whole situation has got so stupid that NZ is unable to find markets for possum-fur. Animals rights idiots are so stupid that they'd rather deny that possums are a noxious, disease-carrying pest whose demise is to the ongoing benefit of all other animals and fight the fur because an animal used to live in it.
 
That's a flat lie. It's incredibly easy for a person to avoid eating animals farmed under cruel conditions. Eat NZ beef and lamb; they grow out in lovely, grassy paddocks, free to roam wherever they want. No hormonal growth drugs, no factory farms, no feeding stalls, they grow at natural rates until they are carted off in nicely air-conditioned trucks until they arrive at the meat works and are whacked instantly to death with an electric pole-axe.

Humane to a fault.

I can't say I've ever heard the argument as a reason for vegetarianism, but there are plenty of people - including me - who won't touch meat not farmed ethically, or eggs obtained through factory farming.



And what everyone else has said about opinionated begans, PETA and other animal nuts.

The whole situation has got so stupid that NZ is unable to find markets for possum-fur. Animals rights idiots are so stupid that they'd rather deny that possums are a noxious, disease-carrying pest whose demise is to the ongoing benefit of all other animals and fight the fur because an animal used to live in it.

Please, please, please just don't mention Canadian seals.

Oh. Bugger. Sorry.:scared:
 
Nice to meet you Lady. Thanks for dismissing my ethical choice as lazy.
My reasons for vegetarianism in no particular order:
1. Ethically I feel it is wrong to kill animals, but not plants. That's a line I've drawn.
2. Environmentally, we can get calories from plants much more efficiently overall than from animals.
3. Health wise, vegetables are less calorie dense than meat in general, so I can eat more and stay fit.
4. Animals don't taste very good. I know others do not share this opinion.
5. Conditions on factory farms are indeed inhumane. Reducing the demand by one person is indeed a simple way for me to feel like I'm contributing. Along with not driving to work, buying local produce, not buying diamonds, choosing an elderly home, etc.

But feel free to rip on people whose point of view you don't bother to find out.
 
In My Spare Time said:
1. Ethically I feel it is wrong to kill animals, but not plants. That's a line I've drawn.
WHAT?! You didn't go all the way?!

We all know that you can't draw an ethical line without going all the way! You can't decide not to kill one kind of animal and then decide you can't kill plants and bacteria! It's written somewhere that you must consider bacteria, higher-intelligence animals, and plants as all equivalent in every way! I mean, if you consider a dog and a human close enough to care about a dog, then what prevents you from thinking the same of bacteria? HUH? HUH?! It's stupid! Didn't you know that?! And why are you saying that you're a vegetarian?! You arrogant (lazy) twat! Stop shoving your beliefs on others! By the way, you vegetarians should SO look into eating meat...





In case it wasn't the obvious, the above was not meant in seriousness, and no personal insult was intended.
 
Last edited:
Please, please, please just don't mention Canadian seals.

Oh. Bugger. Sorry.:scared:

Canadian seals weren't introduced and don't destroy the ecosystem around them. Possums in NZ are and do. They strip the bush killing vast areas of trees, they kill young birds and eat their eggs resulting in the endangering in numerous bird speices from Bellbirds to Kiwi. They are the number one threat to New Zealand's wildlife and the country would be far better off if we managed to eradicate every last one. Not only that, they are carriers of bovine TB and spread it cattle in the area, which can then infect humans via unpasturised milk and meat.

Possums are a threat to NZ both in ecology and to it's major exports, shooting and skinning them is the one and only good use.
 
I have encountered the "you're immoral if you eat meat" vegans, and I try to avoid them. I do occasionally encounter them online, though. I don't think they're the majority of vegetarians any more than "you really should eat meat" are the majority of omnivores. There are just some people who are threatened by those who choose to live differently than they do.

The one veggie-related thing that does bug me is: Flexitarian. It was the "word of the year" for some magazine or organization a year or two back; they defined it as, "A vegetarian who sometimes eats meat."

Okay, WTF is a vegetarian if it isn't someone who refrains from eating meat? To me, that definition (and the word itself) implies that there is some moral or cultural status to vegetarianism that is not limited to the dietary choice itself. That's like saying that "Fosher" is "an observant Jew who sometimes eats non-Kosher food." Que??

I have no issues with eating meat, but I don't do it much anymore. It's simple: I don't digest red meat as well as I used to, so I don't eat it. Even when we do have "ground beef", I substitute about 1/3 to 1/2 finely diced mushrooms--an easy way to up the fiber content, lower the fat, and improve the flavor. Middle age doth make diet-cowards of us all, it seems...

Best wishes, MK
 
It's always a pleasure to see that even among sceptics we are able to find the usual intolerance normally expressed among the self rightous religious. I am what I call vegetarian (some say Vegan), I consider myself ethical, logical in my choices and definitely tolerant of other's. I have born, suffered sometimes to the point of violence, the denigration, ridicule, caracterisation, haughty comments and outright threats from many ignorant individuals trying to show how much of a man they can be. I did not expect this from fellow sceptics. You may have encountered certain people claiming to be vegetarian/vegan and thus included the whole group in the same bag. May be, you just met the vocal ones trying to convince the whole world that they own the truth....You just didn't (want to) realize that not all will try to preach the "gospel". I have made a choice that is true to me and I have done so because of ethical, environmental and health issues and I know that it does make a difference for the better, even (especially) when not preaching.
 
Last edited:
Welcome to the board, deavman!

You said "sometimes to the point of violence" -- I'm curious... how violently were you treated?
 
Being an actor I know more than my fair share of Vegetarians/vegans. I've met a small hand full of the "You're evil if you eat meat types" and one who would go so far as to yell at you if you ate meat around her. (or at least she did it to me but I was back on the west coast after 11 years and it was my first double double in that time so let her cry.) These are the few and the idiotic and I would venture to say that few groups manage to escape these folk. Let them be stupid and pass the sauce.
 
I have three comments:

1) Vegetarians, in general, quite frankly, don't look all that healthy. It's actually difficult to get the complete protein a body needs without eating meat, which is why y'all look so skinny and guant. Flexitarians strike me as people who want to be vegetarian (for emotional/ideological reasons) but realise that if they adhere to it strictly, they will eventually be only slightly better off than your average Ethiopian.

2) How long is the intestinal tract of a typical carnivore? How long is it in herbivores? Omnivores? And how long is it in Homo Sapiens? Q.E.D.

3) "Koshering" meat is barbaric and cruel. If you're going to kill something, at least be quick and painless about it.
 
1) Vegetarians, in general, quite frankly, don't look all that healthy. It's actually difficult to get the complete protein a body needs without eating meat, which is why y'all look so skinny and guant. Flexitarians strike me as people who want to be vegetarian (for emotional/ideological reasons) but realise that if they adhere to it strictly, they will eventually be only slightly better off than your average Ethiopian.

I keep hearing this. "In general, vegetarians don't look all that healthy". I wonder if this suffers from confirmation bias; many of the vegetarians I've met looked just fine enough physically. Met one vegetarian that hadn't eaten meat almost all of his life, according to him, and he looked pretty well off.

Is there some way this claim can be supported in any meaningful way, or is it entirely reliant on the "personal observations" of the claimant?

2) How long is the intestinal tract of a typical carnivore? How long is it in herbivores? Omnivores? And how long is it in Homo Sapiens? Q.E.D.

Indeed, QED... no need to argue the issue anymore, I guess. :rolleyes:

3) "Koshering" meat is barbaric and cruel. If you're going to kill something, at least be quick and painless about it.
I don't have any real argument on this one.

I still don't support factory farming, however, and support less meat in the average diet, mostly for environmental reasons.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom