LadyMitris
Scholar
- Joined
- Apr 11, 2008
- Messages
- 60
I recently listened to the point of inquiry podcast about the ethics of vegetarianism and I'm puzzled by something. The argument, as I understand it, is that it's unethical to eat meat because it causes animals to suffer due to unethical practices like factory farming.
I agree that animals shouldn't be made to suffer needlessly. However, it seems kind of arbitrary to conclude that by not eating meat, one is leading a moral life. There are many, many things going on in the world that cause suffering...testing medications...blood diamonds...oil production...building homes...driving cars...the list goes on.
It seems kind of arbitrary to say that of all the things in the world that one ought to do to help sentient beings...not eating meat is the most important.
Really, it seems to me that not eating meat is merely the most simple thing do to. Basically, what I'm saying here is that vegetarians are lazy...and that's OK...I'm lazy too. However, what bothers me are some vegetarian who behave as they though they are somehow morally superior to meat eaters.
For example, there are vegetarians who get mad at people who won't eat veal, but will eat fish. They argue that fish deserve as much respect as baby cows...so neither should be eaten.
I say that both the vegetarian and the non-veal eating carnivore are equally good people. No one can stop all suffering. The best anyone can do is help as much as they can...and there are other ways to try to stop suffering that by dietary restrictions....those who give money to the poor...volunteer counselors...taking in stray animals off the street and taking care of them....all of these things are worthwhile and no one person can do them all.
So, why can't we just say that vegetarianism is a personal choice and one of many ways that one can do their part to help animals....not a moral imperative that everyone must follow.
I agree that animals shouldn't be made to suffer needlessly. However, it seems kind of arbitrary to conclude that by not eating meat, one is leading a moral life. There are many, many things going on in the world that cause suffering...testing medications...blood diamonds...oil production...building homes...driving cars...the list goes on.
It seems kind of arbitrary to say that of all the things in the world that one ought to do to help sentient beings...not eating meat is the most important.
Really, it seems to me that not eating meat is merely the most simple thing do to. Basically, what I'm saying here is that vegetarians are lazy...and that's OK...I'm lazy too. However, what bothers me are some vegetarian who behave as they though they are somehow morally superior to meat eaters.
For example, there are vegetarians who get mad at people who won't eat veal, but will eat fish. They argue that fish deserve as much respect as baby cows...so neither should be eaten.
I say that both the vegetarian and the non-veal eating carnivore are equally good people. No one can stop all suffering. The best anyone can do is help as much as they can...and there are other ways to try to stop suffering that by dietary restrictions....those who give money to the poor...volunteer counselors...taking in stray animals off the street and taking care of them....all of these things are worthwhile and no one person can do them all.
So, why can't we just say that vegetarianism is a personal choice and one of many ways that one can do their part to help animals....not a moral imperative that everyone must follow.
