Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

Dog fighting dogs were raised to take part in dogfights, and would not exist otherwise. Dancing bears are raised to dance. Circus elephants are raised to do tricks. Better to give them a chance at life?

What's your point?

Can you address my questions - does killing constitute a form of harm? The animal cruelty laws you support say yes. And is eating meat unnecessary? The fact that I'm not dead right now says yes.

* do you consider killing to be a form of "harm"?
* do you consider "I like the taste of meat" to be a good reason for the infliction of harm?
* What is the difference between randomly killing an animal for sadistic pleasure, and deliberately killing one for the pleasure of taste?

So how can you justify meat eating if you simultaneously support animal cruelty legislation? It is entirely contradictory to do so.
I consider killing a lesser form of harm than not living at all, assuming a humane existance. It's just that simple. If the dancing bear is happy, great. Dog fighting constitutes a very unhappy existence, so no go on that. Culling herds can be quite humane. Putting down disease carrying raccoons is a gift to wild animals everywhere. Killing can be harmful, it can be helpful, both to the individual being put to death, and the world at large. In the specific example of animals raised for food, I argue it is a greater good. That's the point. That you can site some entirely different animal husbandry example that is cruel is irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
Why deny a morality continuum? Its a bigger deal to kill a large mammal than a small insect. At some point in size, we kill insects and mites without knowing it.
You don't even need a hunting license to kill bacteria.

Its just how it is. Dolphins should get more rights than rats.
If that was addressed at me, I wasn't denying it. I was inquiring into Volatile's measure. After all, he is the one who made the # of lives argument:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4241529#post4241529
 
Here's my basic case for my rational veganism:

I became vegan because I examined diet sceptically. First, I stopped asking why vegetarians were vegetarian and instead turned the question on myself. The real sceptical question seemed to be "Why did I eat meat?"


I found I couldn't really answer that question, as I had never given my dietary choices any serious thought. They were as ingrained, and as unquestioned, as my earlier, lazy theism was. I had simply never sat down and weighed up the relative benefits of each possible dietary choice, starting from a neutral position. I don't think many people have.

So, that's what I did. I started to list the reasons why I should choose meat eating over vegetarianism. I couldn't think of a single one, other than "Meat tastes good", and that wasn't enough. I'll guide you through my thought process:

1) Health. Is vegetarianism / veganism "healthier" than an omnivourous one? Even if it isn't, it's at least as healthy, according to the ADA. There are lots of studies pointing out the relative health risks of red meat, processed meat and all the rest, but dietary studies are notoriously unreliable, so let's leave that aside and assume that the ADA is right and cutting animal products out of your life is at least not harmful. Of course, you need to eat a balanced diet, but even omnivores don't always achieve this.

2) Environment. "Livestock are responsible for 18 percent of greenhouse-gas emissions as measured in carbon dioxide equivalent, reports the FAO. This includes 9 percent of all CO2 emissions, 37 percent of methane, and 65 percent of nitrous oxide. Altogether, that's more than the emissions caused by transportation." and "70% of all grains grown in the US are fed directly to farm animals, unnecessarily adding enormous levels of pesticides, herbicides, and petrochemical fertilizers to the Earth year after year, and consuming more fresh water than any other human endeavor." (Source). It seems to me that meat consumption is more harmful to the environment than the alternative, plant-based diet. There are plenty of other ways this is borne out, particularly when you consider how wasteful it is to grow food to feed to cows to then eat! See also: over-fishing.

3) Animal suffering. I am not dogmatic or evangelical about this, and I do not believe that a) it is always wrong to kill animals, b) that animals and humans are equivalent or c) that killing animals for food is metaphysically, or morally, wrong. Nevertheless, I believe it is undoubtedly the case that animals do suffer in the production of food. Cows, pigs and chickens all feel pain. I wouldn't kill a cat or a dog or a horse for food, and so I believe that if avoiding animal suffering for other species is possible, it should be pursued wherever possible. This seems to be at least a generally tenable position given laws on animal cruelty etc. If I can live as healthily as I can on a meat based diet, but eliminate unnecessary suffering, then why shouldn't I? In this sense (and in many others), veganism just seems a sensible extension of my broader ethical stance.

4) Convenience. As I said, I am not dogmatic about my veganism, and I am certain that in some cases, having a small-holding and being self-sufficient is a "better" choice. Nevertheless, I buy my food at stores. I do not hunt, or grow my own vegetables. If the soy milk and the regular milk are right next to each other on the shelf, why should I pick the animal milk, given points 1, 2 and 3 above? If the dairy free and the real mayonnaise are right next to each other on the shelf and pretty much indistinguishable from each other, why pick the animal product given 1, 2 and 3 above?

Now, don't get me wrong - I love the taste of meat. It's just that, having considered the relative merits of both diets, I can't justify eating it. I also love driving my car really fast, but I don't because my personal preferences aren't always sufficient to justify potentially harmful behaviour. And in any case, I'm not starving or denying myself anything at all. There are vegan alternative and analogues to pretty much everything these days.

People always ask me why I'm vegan. I always turn it round and ask them why they eat meat, because when I asked myself that question I never had the answer. It's just about thinking about the way you live your life, and why you hold the beliefs you do. In my humble opinion, non-dogmatic veganism is the logical and rational dietary choice; though if anyone can make the case as to why I should eat meat, please do.


So you care for them really, really well, right up until you get hungry?

if it was indeed your intention to "remove them from the unmitigated horror of nature", then you would keep them as pets until they died of old age. Your arguments that yours is a compassionate act do not hold water, given that your definition of compassion includes needless slaughter - and it is needless, because you could survive quite well without meat and you could keep the population numbers down by taking sterilisation measures. Yours is an enormously flawed argument, and it is internally inconsistent.

It is immoral only because it is inconsistent with what I presume is your more general moral code - that you consider it immoral to harm or kill animals unnecessarily. It is immoral only by the more general standards with which you approach ethical questions of animals. You wouldn't kick a cat, or slit the throat of a dog, or boil a bald eagle alive, just for fun. Why not?



1) I agree, there are no health benefits to vegetarianism as a pose to a diet that includes healthy meat.
2) This is a problem with our infrastructure, not with meat eating. As I said in an earlier post, once the nation's fuel problems are modernized, this no longer is a complaint against meat eating. Think of all the CO2 expelled during the process of harvesting grain. That isn't an argument against eating grain, it's an argument against the current out-dated infrastructure.
3) You dodged the important question. Herds maintained by ranchers suffer FAR LESS than animals in the wild. They can also be slaughtered by means that eliminate suffering. This point is completely irrelevent.
4) That may be an argument against YOU eating meat, but that says nothing about the MORALITY of meat eating, which was the point of my question.

And the flippant response to the way free-range ranchers operate shows either ignorance or a complete lack of seriousness on your part. The slaughtering of animals to provide food allows a rancher to be able to pay for the expense of keeping those animals healthy. Again, if suffering is your metric, a domesticated animal will suffer far less. So, too, will an animal slaughtered before the onset of old age.

All of these points completely ignore the heart of the matter. The only reason offered for the moral superiority of veganism is the lack of suffering. But you have not shown how an animal tended to on an open range and slaughtered humanely has suffered. Unless you're arguing that there is a sort of vague conceptual suffering in being denied a certain number of years of life, you have nothing. And even if you argue that point, no animal other than a human has the brain capacity to even consider such a thought. The animals, therefore, experience no suffering.
 
Last edited:
I consider killing a lesser form of harm than not living at all. It's just that simple. If the dancing bear is happy, great. Dog fighting constitutes a very unhappy existence. Culling herds can be quite humane. Putting down disease carrying raccoons is a gift to wild animals everywhere. Killing can be harmful, it can be helpful, both to the individual being put to death, and the world at large. In the specific example of animals raised for food, I argue it is a greater good. That's the point. That you can site some entirely different animal husbandry example that is cruel is irrelevant.

Pay attention, Roger. Killing is not inherently harmful - killing for no good reason is. This is the very definition of cruelty. You would not get away with 'humanely' killing your dog unless there was good reason to do so, even if that dog had lived the life of luxury. I suspect you would agree with punishments for people who raised and "humanely" killed horses (or even cows, in fact), because they got sadistic pleasure out of killing them. Indeed, I suspect that were I to set up a farm identical to the most humane ones currently operating, but did not sell or consume any of those animals' products for food (in effect running it simply as a way to take pleasure in the slaughter of animals), you would be outraged, and I could be prosecuted under the very laws you support. It is only when food production comes into the equation that these types of "better alive than never to have existed" arguments come into play. Why do you think that is? What is it about noble death for food that makes an animals' life so supremely worthwhile?

Oh - and why is dog-fighting an unhappy existence? From what I've seen, the owners often treat their dogs like prize boxers. Better to have lived, right? I'm just trying to point out that your argument is inconsistent, as it privileges one form of pleasure (taste) over others.

Also: even if it is better to raise animals otherwise they wouldn't have existed (though I don't happen to agree), it is trivially simple to think of a better situation. Raise them as pets, and don't kill them for food.
 
This line of ******** always amazes me. Are you going out into nature and and raising animals you have personally rescued? If not then animals in "nature" have nothing to thank you for, except possibly encroaching upon their land and contributing to global warming. Those animals still endure injury and suffer disease. What you're likely doing is bringing animals into the world who otherwise would not exist, which is something entirely different than the self-congratulatory, borderline Messianic nonsense printed above.

That is a sad, thoughtless response. It also displays a bald ignorance of how nature operates. Pre-domesticated cattle suffer on a level that VASTLY exceeds anything a tended herd could ever encounter. By domesticating animals we use our superior human faculties to protect them from the horrors of the wild. Your aimless, stammering anger caused you to ejaculate nonsense all over your keyboard. Of course there is a responsibility to care for habitats and ecosystems. What does that have to do with anything I wrote? Ironically, ecosystems like praries need grazing animals in order to maintain their health. So free range ranching is good all around.

And yes anytime there is a herd of domesticated animal it is because somewhere along the line humans rescued an animal from the wild. The only way humans are able to provide this service to the animals is by using them for food. If there were no meat eaters and no domesticated animals there would simply be a bigger population of animals suffering tremendously in the wild.

And if you define Messianic as simply being more capable than a cow, then yes, I have such a complex. But please, maybe you can take up the mantle and explain how an animal cared for in a herd and slaughtered humanely suffers.
 
Oh - and why is dog-fighting an unhappy existence? From what I've seen, the owners often treat their dogs like prize boxers. Better to have lived, right? I'm just trying to point out that your argument is inconsistent, as it privileges one form of pleasure (taste) over others.

Also: even if it is better to raise animals otherwise they wouldn't have existed (though I don't happen to agree), it is trivially simple to think of a better situation. Raise them as pets, and don't kill them for food.

You seem like a generally thoughtful person so I would just direct you to the case of Michael Vick. Dog fighting is an insanely cruel practice that requires owners to starve the fighting animals in order to get them to fight. Losing animals are drowned, electocuted, and suffocated. Yours was a very sad, ignorant statement.

As for the second part, are you going to adopt a herd of 10,000 cattle? The cost for maintaining the health of those animals has to come from somewhere. Hmm, maybe if we slaughtered them and sold the meat we could keep the herd from becoming over-populated thereby sickening the group and destroying the ecosystem, and we could continue to purchase essential nutrients and medication to ensure their health. But you're right, it's faaar more humane to simply let them starve over a long winter and get ripped to shreds by wolves. A true moral stance.
 
Last edited:
1) I agree, there are no health benefits to vegetarianism as a pose to a diet that includes healthy meat.

But you also agree there are no detriments? Good. Then we can proceed.


2) This is a problem with our infrastructure, not with meat eating.

Not at all, and not according to the studies I cited. Meat consumption, and the raising of meat for food, are inherently more damaging to the environment than plant-based alternatives. If you have any scientific studies which counteract those I cited, please provide them.

3) You dodged the important question. Herds maintained by ranchers suffer FAR LESS than animals in the wild. They can also be slaughtered by means that eliminate suffering. This point is completely irrelevent.

No, I didn't.

Cain covered this absurd point fairly well already., but the fact is that if you genuinely wanted to eliminate suffering, you'd keep them as pets. That you engage in actively harmful, unnecessary behaviour whilst at the same time claiming to want to reduce harm shows how irrational this stance is. You cannot with a straight face claim that you nobly wish to eliminate animal suffering whilst at the same time allowing this desire to be trivially overridden whenever you get hungry.

4) That may be an argument against YOU eating meat, but that says nothing about the MORALITY of meat eating, which was the point of my question.

It's an argument for the morality of meat eating within the framework of a broader moral system which acknowledges that harming animals unnecessarily is wrong. I take it that you are in favour of animal cruelty laws?

And the flippant response to the way free-range ranchers operate shows either ignorance or a complete lack of seriousness on your part. The slaughtering of animals to provide food allows a rancher to be able to pay for the expense of keeping those animals healthy. Again, if suffering is your metric, a domesticated animal will suffer far less. So, too, will an animal slaughtered before the onset of old age.

I'm very serious.

Suffering's your metric, as you're claiming that your motivation for raising meat is to reduce suffering. It is trivially easy to refute this, as you deliberately induce unnecessary suffering at the arbitrary point when your hunger gets the better of your nobility.

If you can't afford to keep cows as pets, don't keep cows. The same is true of any animal. You wouldn't buy the argument of someone who kills his cats and sells them to the local kids to make footballs out of if that was the only way someone could afford to feed his cats. Honestly, that's a really bad argument.


All of these points completely ignore the heart of the matter. The only reason offered for the moral superiority of veganism is the lack of suffering.

No. Strawman. Nevertheless, let's see how the rest of this "heart of the matter" stacks up to rational enquiry:

But you have not shown how an animal tended to on an open range and slaughtered humanely has suffered.

I think "being killed before my natural life is up" comes under the heading of "needless suffering". Don't you? Killing an animal for a trivial reason is unnecessarily cruel - and animal cruelty laws, and, I suspect, your general attitude towards animals, agree.

If I raise a cat and slaughter it humanely to make it into a footwarmer, are we cool with that?

And to think that you, as a farmer, can claim that "cows do not understand suffering" is terrifying beyond belief. Farmers, vets and those who work with animals are usually the most adept at understanding that animals suffer.
 
I think "being killed before my natural life is up" comes under the heading of "needless suffering". Don't you? Killing an animal for a trivial reason is unnecessarily cruel - and animal cruelty laws, and, I suspect, your general attitude towards animals, agree.

If I raise a cat and slaughter it humanely to make it into a footwarmer, are we cool with that?

And to think that you, as a farmer, can claim that "cows do not understand suffering" is terrifying beyond belief. Farmers, vets and those who work with animals are usually the most adept at understanding that animals suffer.


Still thou are blest, compared wi' me!
The present only toucheth thee:
But och! I backward cast my e'e,
On prospects drear!
An' forward, tho' I canna see,
I guess an' fear!

Yours is a bizarre concept. I would love to have you explain it to me. How does an animal suffer by being deprived years of living. Only humans are sophisticated enough to understand such a concept.

Cows eat and crap. If you tend to a herd, they eat well and crap without the persistent fear of predatory death. One day they're slaughtered. They neither look towards that day with aprehension nor are they even conscious of the event while it's happening.

You think they sit up in heaven wringing their hooves lamenting their lost years of eating and crapping?

Is your argument simply that a deprivation of life is, alone, morally wrong? Because animals in herds, even when they're slaughtered, have a higher life expectancy than wild animals. Largely because the birth mortality rate is significantly lower.
 
Pay attention, Roger.
I'm here for fun and discussion, not rudeness.

I suspect you would agree with punishments for people who raised and "humanely" killed horses (or even cows, in fact), because they got sadistic pleasure out of killing them.
You would be wrong. 1) I don't believe in legislating thought, and 2) I'm okay with many uses of animals that results in death, such as quail hunting farms. I have more examples below.

Indeed, I suspect that were I to set up a farm identical to the most humane ones currently operating, but did not sell or consume any of those animals' products for food (in effect running it simply as a way to take pleasure in the slaughter of animals), you would be outraged, and I could be prosecuted under the very laws you support.
I don't understand why you completely change a scenerio and then think whatever conclusion is raised somehow automatically applies to the original scenerio. I'm guessing you are trying to get me to look at something in a different light. But it just doesn't apply. I remember the tattoo discussions you've been in, where others said they didn't enjoy looking at them. Imagine if they retorted to you "what if somebody started juggling chainsaws in a crowded restaurant? You can't just do what you want in public". Naturally, you would not accept that for what ink you should be allowed to put on your skin. There are things we should be allowed to do in public, some things not.

I don't accept that food is a whim. Much utility is derived from animals. True, we can achieve that most of that utility in other ways, but that does not reduce it to the equivelent of killing for pleasure. You disagree - which I understand.

It is only when food production comes into the equation that these types of "better alive than never to have existed" arguments come into play. Why do you think that is? What is it about noble death for food that makes an animals' life so supremely worthwhile?
Not for me. There are plenty of animal acts that I support that can lead to their premature death. Search and rescue dogs. Dogs running the ididarod. Dressage. Animal testing. Draft animals. etc.

Oh - and why is dog-fighting an unhappy existence?
This is a rhetorical question to test my assumptions, yes? Are you serious? The snipped portion suggested seriousness. If serious, go to google images, type in vick pit bull, and prepare to vomit at the third image. Don't do this unless you are prepared to be very disturbed at seeing a torn up dog. It's indisputable that it's an unhappy existance. I chose that search term to bring up fairly innoculous images - there are far worse ones out there than that search brings up. It's entirely different than raising beef for slaughter, and thus cannot be used to decide beef ethics.


Also: even if it is better to raise animals otherwise they wouldn't have existed (though I don't happen to agree), it is trivially simple to think of a better situation. Raise them as pets, and don't kill them for food.
Sorry, I'm not going to raise cows for pets. That doesn't change the equation.
 
You seem like a generally thoughtful person so I would just direct you to the case of Michael Vick. Dog fighting is an insanely cruel practice that requires owners to starve the fighting animals in order to get them to fight. Losing animals are drowned, electocuted, and suffocated. Yours was a very sad, ignorant statement.

Before being starved, they're often pampered, right? I'm actually basing this only on what I heard about the Vick case...

The point of the matter is - is it truly better for an animal to have lived and died in the cause of human pleasure, or not?

As for the second part, are you going to adopt a herd of 10,000 cattle? The cost for maintaining the health of those animals has to come from somewhere. Hmm, maybe if we slaughtered them and sold the meat we could keep the herd from becoming over-populated thereby sickening the group and destroying the ecosystem, and we could continue to purchase essential nutrients and medication to ensure their health. But you're right, it's faaar more humane to simply let them starve over a long winter and get ripped to shreds by wolves. A true moral stance.

Why is the dichotomy "starved to death and eaten by wolves" over "killed so I can have burgers"? That's a fallacious argument based on a false dichotomy. I thought I was on a sceptics board here?

If you cannot afford to keep animals without eating them, do not get them in the first place. This goes for goldfish, budgerigars, rabbits, dogs and cows alike. Saying "but I couldn't afford to keep them if I didn't kill them for fun" is a really, really bad argument, and not one I suspect you would tolerate were it deployed in support of any other set of circumstances.

"I can't afford to keep this cat unless I kill it and make a hat out of it"
"I can't afford to keep this horse unless I kill it and sell its stuffed head"
"I can't afford to keep this dog unless I sell its feet to make umbrella handles".

It's a really, really bad argument.
 
That is a sad, thoughtless response. It also displays a bald ignorance of how nature operates. Pre-domesticated cattle suffer on a level that VASTLY exceeds anything a tended herd could ever encounter. By domesticating animals we use our superior human faculties to protect them from the horrors of the wild. Your aimless, stammering anger caused you to ejaculate nonsense all over your keyboard. Of course there is a responsibility to care for habitats and ecosystems. What does that have to do with anything I wrote? Ironically, ecosystems like praries need grazing animals in order to maintain their health. So free range ranching is good all around.

And yes anytime there is a herd of domesticated animal it is because somewhere along the line humans rescued an animal from the wild. The only way humans are able to provide this service to the animals is by using them for food. If there were no meat eaters and no domesticated animals there would simply be a bigger population of animals suffering tremendously in the wild.

And if you define Messianic as simply being more capable than a cow, then yes, I have such a complex. But please, maybe you can take up the mantle and explain how an animal cared for in a herd and slaughtered humanely suffers.

I see "thoughtless," "ignorance," "nonsense," and "ejaculate," but I don't see a response to my comment, so the only "irony" is that you would accuse me of "aimless stammering." The closest you get is the underlined sentence marked above and I almost mistook it for self-parody. Look again at what you wrote and cop to it (I'll add emphasis for ya, Columbo):

I, as a farmer/rancher, have exerted my unique human gifts to remove animals from the unmitigated horror of nature and tend to their needs.

You're not removing those animals from anything. The rest of your meandering rant rests mostly upon an unargued moral assumption about background conditions; moreover, you cannot spell "prairies" let alone conceive of an alternative scenario that does not involve raising animals for consumption.
 
since we can willy-nilly change the arguments into something entirely different, Volatile, how do you justify having tattoos? It is nothing more than a whim, for your pleasure, and animals die as a result. How - you could put the money you spend on tattoos into paying to move dogs out of pounds into no kill shelters. A small monthly fee will keep a dog in a private kennel. Sure, it's not a direct connection, as with food, but the end result is the same. You do things on a whim, to use your word, for your personal pleasure, and animals suffer and die.

I forget the ethicist, but a prominant one argues we should forgo everything except what is required to keep us alive and donate everything extra to reducing suffering - I didn't pull this out of my butt.

So, promise to never get a tattoo again, and donate the money to, say, badrap.org (they fight against dog fighting)? If not, why?

edit: I should make it clear I do not hold you are ethically bound to do this. I support the idea that we can make decisions, even if animals die, and that the calculus in these cases are sometimes very complicated, where reasonable people can differ. I interpret your statements that we can never cause or allow an animal to die for a whim or our pleasure. I recognize my interpretation may be wrong.
 
Last edited:
1)Not at all, and not according to the studies I cited. Meat consumption, and the raising of meat for food, are inherently more damaging to the environment than plant-based alternatives. If you have any scientific studies which counteract those I cited, please provide them.


2)Cain covered this absurd point fairly well already., but the fact is that if you genuinely wanted to eliminate suffering, you'd keep them as pets. That you engage in actively harmful, unnecessary behaviour whilst at the same time claiming to want to reduce harm shows how irrational this stance is. You cannot with a straight face claim that you nobly wish to eliminate animal suffering whilst at the same time allowing this desire to be trivially overridden whenever you get hungry.


3)It's an argument for the morality of meat eating within the framework of a broader moral system which acknowledges that harming animals unnecessarily is wrong. I take it that you are in favour of animal cruelty laws?


4)Suffering's your metric, as you're claiming that your motivation for raising meat is to reduce suffering. It is trivially easy to refute this, as you deliberately induce unnecessary suffering at the arbitrary point when your hunger gets the better of your nobility.

5)If you can't afford to keep cows as pets, don't keep cows. The same is true of any animal. You wouldn't buy the argument of someone who kills his cats and sells them to the local kids to make footballs out of if that was the only way someone could afford to feed his cats. Honestly, that's a really bad argument.


I put numbers in your quote to make it easier to respond to, I hope you aren't offended.

1) All of the studies I've read show the problem with the MEANS by which we reaise meat. For example, feed lots are horrific for the environment. Not only are they cruel to the animal, but the run-off polutes waterways.

In some countries herd animals have destroyed the ecosystem because jungle and forrest land has been clear-cut to accomidate the animals.

Again, these are all problems with the WAY animals are raised, not with eating meat. I would love for you to provide a study that shows the negative environmental impact of free-range grazing. In fact, a prarie needs grazing animals to be fully functional. Otherwise weeds and underbrush grow too rapidly and destroy habitats of animals that have evolved in a grazed prarie.

2) This is just wrong. How do I cause suffering in an animal if I slaughter it humanely? The animal neither knows it's coming, nor realizes what's happening until it's over.

Furthermore, the money made from the selling of animal products is what gives ranchers and farmers the funds to continue taking care of the animals. If they couldn't sell the meat product, those her animals would suffer in the wild.

3) But it's really easy to eat meat and animal products like milk and eggs that come from a healthy, free range environment. I have no trouble finding those products. So you saying it's impractical is just an argument for why YOU don't eat meat products. It has nothing to do with anything being discussed.

4) What is the unnecessary suffering? You keep saying that slaughtering an animal causes suffering, but you've yet to explain how. Again, the animal neither knows it's coming, nor do they realize what's happening while the slaughter is taking place. You may be shocked to learn this, but animals aren't slaughtered in the same way they killed that cow in Apocalypse Now.

5) If they gave the cats comfortable homes and killed them in a humane manner, I still don't see how the animals suffered. We may balk at killing cats because of social norms, but there's nothing apparant in your example that shows the animal has suffered in any way. If anything the suffering would be more emotional on the part of the owner.
 
You would be wrong. 1) I don't believe in legislating thought, and 2) I'm okay with many uses of animals that results in death, such as quail hunting farms. I have more examples below.

Sure, but then we nee to talk about the use of the word "necessary".

Are you seriously saying that a cow farm that was run for the pleasure its owners get from killing cows would be OK with you? I am almost certainly sure that this would be illegal, at least where I come from.

You're cool with that, though? Pampering until human whim dictates death, no matter what that whim might be?

I don't understand why you completely change a scenerio and then think whatever conclusion is raised somehow automatically applies to the original scenerio. I'm guessing you are trying to get me to look at something in a different light.

That is generally the purpose of an analogy, yes. If you could explain how they don't apply, then we could probably learn more from each other.


I don't accept that food is a whim.

Food is not a whim. Meat, however, is, given that one can survive just as healthily on a plant-based diet. In what was is that not a whim? It is a sudden fancy for meat.

Much utility is derived from animals. True, we can achieve that most of that utility in other ways, but that does not reduce it to the equivelent of killing for pleasure. You disagree - which I understand.

Not for me. There are plenty of animal acts that I support that can lead to their premature death. Search and rescue dogs. Dogs running the ididarod. Dressage. Animal testing. Draft animals. etc.

Animal testing is not a whim, because the results it produces are, on the whole, beneficial than the alternatives. I don't like it, but I accept it is necessary. The same is clearly not true of meat eating, which most certainly is not necessary for the majority of people in the Western world.

Search and rescue dogs are similarly necessary, and I support them. Dog racing and dressage are not, and I oppose them.

This forum is about rational thinking and scepticism - I'm building what I see as a rational case for veganism. Telling me that "well, animals die in animal tests too" is not a prick in that rational case. This is a position built on an internally-consistent set of principles. Yours, as far as I can tell, is not - because on the one hand you oppose needless cruelty, but on the other you accept animal death for what amounts to a trivial, necessary reason. Hence my accusations of irrationality.

This is a rhetorical question to test my assumptions, yes? Are you serious? The snipped portion suggested seriousness. If serious, go to google images, type in vick pit bull, and prepare to vomit at the third image. Don't do this unless you are prepared to be very disturbed at seeing a torn up dog. It's indisputable that it's an unhappy existance. I chose that search term to bring up fairly innoculous images - there are far worse ones out there than that search brings up. It's entirely different than raising beef for slaughter, and thus cannot be used to decide beef ethics.

OK, I'll accept that dog fighting dogs aren't necessarily pampered.

But I'm interested in why you are so vehemently against it? After all, these dogs got a shot at life (which is better than never having existed), right?

Sorry, I'm not going to raise cows for pets. That doesn't change the equation.

Yes, it does.

Would you think an argument of the form "I have to sell my dog's legs for umbrella stands, otherwise I could never have afforded to keep him" a good argument? Or would you consider that perhaps such a person should probably not have owned a dog in the first place?
 
I see "thoughtless," "ignorance," "nonsense," and "ejaculate," but I don't see a response to my comment, so the only "irony" is that you would accuse me of "aimless stammering." The closest you get is the underlined sentence marked above and I almost mistook it for self-parody. Look again at what you wrote and cop to it (I'll add emphasis for ya, Columbo):

You're not removing those animals from anything. The rest of your meandering rant rests mostly upon an unargued moral assumption about background conditions; moreover, you cannot spell "prairies" let alone conceive of an alternative scenario that does not involve raising animals for consumption.

It's only parody if you're incapable of understanding the argument. Domesticated animals weren't always thus. You may be excited to learn that many years ago (yes, even before Jesus was born) all animals that we now recognize as domesticated, were wild. I know, I know, shocking, but that's really how it happened. Over the years selective breeding and evolution caused them to become the animals we know today. So yes, all domesticated animals were rescued from the perils of the wild at some point in their genetic history.

And as for "unargued moral assumption about background conditions," I was quite clear that the metric I was using involved suffering. You can't coherently argue that an animal in the wild suffers less than a well tended herd, unless you develop some bizarre anthropomorphic concept about animals expressing their true nature through life in the wild. Perhaps you even think they sing about it Lion King style.

But how impressive for you to notice a minor spelling error. I guess if you're bizarre enought to think that animals suffer conceptual angst when years of their lives are deprived from them, you might think that focusing on unimportant nonsense passes for wit.
 
All of the studies I've read show the problem with the MEANS by which we reaise meat. For example, feed lots are horrific for the environment. Not only are they cruel to the animal, but the run-off polutes waterways.

I linked studies. They show that it is essentially the methane production that is the most harmful aspect of beef production, for example. This is an inherent part of raising beef, no matter what the process. This also adds some weight against your "better to have existed" argument, come to think of it.

In some countries herd animals have destroyed the ecosystem because jungle and forrest land has been clear-cut to accomidate the animals.

Again, these are all problems with the WAY animals are raised, not with eating meat
I agree, which is why I never suggested land-clearance was an inherent problem (though it may be, given that the production of a calorie of meat protein takes much, much more acerage than a calorie of soy protein).

2) This is just wrong. How do I cause suffering in an animal if I slaughter it humanely? The animal neither knows it's coming, nor realizes what's happening until it's over.
Are you serious? It's dead. It doesn't have to be. I consider the difference between being alive and being dead a detrimental one, don't you?

Furthermore, the money made from the selling of animal products is what gives ranchers and farmers the funds to continue taking care of the animals. If they couldn't sell the meat product, those her animals would suffer in the wild.
Or not exist at all.

"If couldn't sell my dog's legs for umbrella stands, I couldn't afford a dog" is a really terrible argument.

3) But it's really easy to eat meat and animal products like milk and eggs that come from a healthy, free range environment. I have no trouble finding those products. So you saying it's impractical is just an argument for why YOU don't eat meat products. It has nothing to do with anything being discussed.
I didn't say it was impractical to eat meat, I said it was equally practical to eat vegetarian. This does not follow from anything I've said, and it certainly doesn't follow from what you've labelled as my "Point 3".

Are you in favour of animal cruelty laws, Wreck?

4) What is the unnecessary suffering?
What do you think unnecessary suffering is? I think it is suffering that is inflicted unnecessarily - that is suffering caused in pursuit of a need that it itself unnecessary, or that can be sated in another way that involves less, or no suffering at all.

You keep saying that slaughtering an animal causes suffering, but you've yet to explain how.
The animal was alive. Now it is dead. For no good reason. That sure sounds like a degradation in quality of life to me.

5) If they gave the cats comfortable homes and killed them in a humane manner, I still don't see how the animals suffered.
They're dead. For a trivial reason.
 
Last edited:
Why is the dichotomy "starved to death and eaten by wolves" over "killed so I can have burgers"? That's a fallacious argument based on a false dichotomy. I thought I was on a sceptics board here?

If you cannot afford to keep animals without eating them, do not get them in the first place. This goes for goldfish, budgerigars, rabbits, dogs and cows alike. Saying "but I couldn't afford to keep them if I didn't kill them for fun" is a really, really bad argument, and not one I suspect you would tolerate were it deployed in support of any other set of circumstances.

"I can't afford to keep this cat unless I kill it and make a hat out of it"
"I can't afford to keep this horse unless I kill it and sell its stuffed head"
"I can't afford to keep this dog unless I sell its feet to make umbrella handles".

It's a really, really bad argument.


I overemphasized the dichotomy, but that doesn't mean it isn't real. Look, I grew up in the Flint Hills of Kansas. Because the soil is peppered with flint, it is impossible to farm; the plows simply break. It is thusly ranch land. The cattle are tended to and kept healthy on a level that could never be reached in nature, and the meet a humane end. Life in the wild is frought with peril at every turn. Disease, injury, mild hunger, all of these lead to violent death.

So no, animals in the wild don't immediately die or suffer, but the difference between the lives are hugely significant. Think of it this way: If I live in Baghdad I won't necessarily die or suffer, but my odds are a little higher than if my Dad is an hotel mogul in Beverly Hills.

And as for the second part, animals have something humans both need and want, meat. Now we could simply destroy them with no thought for their well being like a predator in nature, or we could give them pleasureable lives and a humane death. Two things nature could give less of a rip about.

In an earlier post I described what I view as three possible ways to deal with animals we raise for food:
1) Ignore them and let them exist in the wild. There they face the compassionless perils of nature.
2) Domesticate the animals and tend to their needs. They grow up healthy and safe. Periodically members are humanely slaughtered for meat.
3) Domesticate the animals and keep them as pets. We gain no value back from the beasts (save the emotional benefits of pet ownership). They die of old age or disease or whatever.

From the perspective of an animal both 2 and 3 are obviously preferable. But I would love for someone to explain how a cow even distinguishes between 2 and 3. And again, they have no idea that their life will be cut short. They just eat and crap in bliss until the lights go out.
 
You do things on a whim, to use your word, for your personal pleasure, and animals suffer and die.

We vegans hear this alot. It's basically an argument that because we're not perfect, we shouldn't even bother trying. A tu quoque argument, essentially, and thus an invalid one.

Am I perfect? No.
Can I admit I am a hypocrite? Yes.
Am I doing something about what I believe can rationally be argued to be a problem? Yes indeed.

Which is usually at least two steps better than many of those making the accusations. No-one's perfect, least of all me. That's not an argument that undermines my arguments, though.
 
I consider killing a lesser form of harm than not living at all, assuming a humane existance. It's just that simple.
Who is being harmed in the latter case? It seems like you're comparing apples and empty sets.
 
Sure, but then we nee to talk about the use of the word "necessary".

Are you seriously saying that a cow farm that was run for the pleasure its owners get from killing cows would be OK with you? I am almost certainly sure that this would be illegal, at least where I come from.

You're cool with that, though? Pampering until human whim dictates death, no matter what that whim might be?
I'm sorry, I'm finding your analogies streched. Can we keep this to what people actually do in the real world? It makes sense for this sort of thing to be illegal, since how can legislate that this is overall beneficial to the cows? Why would we expend resources for that? What is the potential for abuse (inhumane conditions, etc)? I'm not oblivious to the arguments or thoughts, and remember, I eat meat, I'm okay with raising animals for butchering. I don't find your idea as horrific as you think I do, or should.


Search and rescue dogs are similarly necessary, and I support them. Dog racing and dressage are not, and I oppose them.
Okay, we will never agree on the topic of veganism. Ever hitched up a dog team and took them on a run? I have. Get the gear out and the dogs are yelping with excitement. You have to stake them down so they don't take off. They are bouncing in their harness, trying to pull. It's a tricky business not losing your sled. Release the anchor, and they just fly down the trail, howling happily. It's beautiful. They are happy, so happy.

Now, either of us could modify this to the point where we'd both disagree with the practice - whip the dogs to make them run. Run them with injuries. We both have the goal of providing animals with pleasant lives. We have different goals in regards to judging whether possible death justifies the means/act.

I suppose I shouldn't tell you I skijor with my dog. She loves it. She could get hurt, as could I. I've never seen her more alive, or happy.

Yours, as far as I can tell, is not - because on the one hand you oppose needless cruelty, but on the other you accept animal death for what amounts to a trivial, necessary reason. Hence my accusations of irrationality.
Cruelty is in suffering, not lack of life, in my view. That's the central disconnect. I've tried to state this several times, yet you keep coming back with different examples. I don't have a problem with death, I do have a problem with suffering.


But I'm interested in why you are so vehemently against it? After all, these dogs got a shot at life (which is better than never having existed), right?
Suffering. They suffer horribly.


Would you think an argument of the form "I have to sell my dog's legs for umbrella stands, otherwise I could never have afforded to keep him" a good argument? Or would you consider that perhaps such a person should probably not have owned a dog in the first place?
I'm not bothered by fur coats and such. Again, for me, a life of suffering is unacceptable. A life, followed by death is acceptable. You can always find border cases - that does not influence the non-border ones. Should a search and rescue dog be used to find a skier that disregarded avalanche warnings? Hard to say - I could almost argue that by that point the dog's life is worth more than the irresponsible human. But that's a border case - we both agree to use dogs to find 9/11 victems.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom