TraneWreck
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jun 9, 2008
- Messages
- 7,929
1)I linked studies. They show that it is essentially the methane production that is the most harmful aspect of beef production, for example. This is an inherent part of raising beef, no matter what the process. This also adds some weight against your "better to have existed" argument, come to think of it.
2)I agree, which is why I never suggested land-clearance was an inherent problem (though it may be, given that the production of a calorie of meat protein takes much, much more acerage than a calorie of soy protein).
3)Are you serious? It's dead. It doesn't have to be. I consider the difference between being alive and being dead a detrimental one, don't you?
Or not exist at all.
"If couldn't sell my dog's legs for umbrella stands, I couldn't afford a dog" is a really terrible argument.
4)I didn't say it was impractical to eat meat, I said it was equally practical to eat vegetarian. This does not follow from anything I've said, and it certainly doesn't follow from what you've labelled as my "Point 3".
Are you in favour of animal cruelty laws, Wreck?
5)What do you think unnecessary suffering is? I think it is suffering that is inflicted unnecessarily - that is suffering caused in pursuit of a need that it itself unnecessary, or that can be sated in another way that involves less, or no suffering at all.
The animal was alive. Now it is dead. For no good reason. That sure sounds like a degradation in quality of life to me.
They're dead. For a trivial reason.
1) Look, there were herds of buffalo in the 19th century that were so large settlers watched them cross on their trail for 24 hours, running the entire time. There have always been animals producing methane, the only reason it is even relevant now is because of the added CO2 from humans. We cut our carbon emissions, the animals' isn't an issue. A great percentage of that methane comes from feed-lots and other mass-production techniques. Free range raising of animals is healthy for the animals and the environment they exist in. Ecosystems depend upon grazers.
2) This is an interesting topic. I see no reason why efficiency is relevant to a discussion of food practices. We have more than enough food to feed every person on the planet, even in its current overpopulated state. If anything our food production is too efficient, which is why we pay billions of dollars a year to keep farmers from growing crops.
3) You are conflating the depravation of life with suffering. I see no reason to think the two are the same. It is only a problem for humans because we can conceptualize our own mortality. That's why I included that Burns excerpt from earlier. In terms of animal rights, we have to figure out what is best for the animal, not an anthropomorphisized (is that actually a word?) concept of an animal. They may no longer be alive, but if no pain or discomfort was experienced, I see no harm. Nor has anyone been able to explain to me what exactly the harm is other than, "Come on, I mean come on, seriously."
4) It's possible I misread your earlier post, I'll go look at it again, apologies if I didn't get it right.
5) I think that unnecessary suffering must include...suffering. In animal terms this is pain or discomfort. Animals do not have the brain capacity to ruminate in a field lamenting the coming slaughter. They eat, crap, eat, crap, then the lights go out. No pain, no discomfort, no suffering. You are pretending that animals are like people and feel deprived of the chance to go on living, they are not capable of such sophisticated thought. The goal, therefore, is to make their lives comfortable, not gnash our teeth wondering if they are as terrified of the mystery beyond as we are.
Edit: let me also reply to this: "If couldn't sell my dog's legs for umbrella stands, I couldn't afford a dog" is a really terrible argument.
This is a complete distortion of the point at hand. This is a more accurate example: I have a pound that takes care of abused or abandoned dogs. We keep them healthy and try to find them owners. We don't have the funds to keep all animals alive indefinitely, if we tried, all of the dogs would suffer a lower standard of care. Thus, we have to humanely terminate a certain number of animals. Now another perspective would be to say that we need to terminate a certain number of animals and sell their parts for funds to keep the shelter operational. This is only horrible because of the sentimental position dogs hold in our society (one I ascribe to), but again, there is nothing immoral about said behavior. No suffering is generated and the animals fair much better than they would were they roaming about the streets.
Last edited: