Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

1)I linked studies. They show that it is essentially the methane production that is the most harmful aspect of beef production, for example. This is an inherent part of raising beef, no matter what the process. This also adds some weight against your "better to have existed" argument, come to think of it.

2)I agree, which is why I never suggested land-clearance was an inherent problem (though it may be, given that the production of a calorie of meat protein takes much, much more acerage than a calorie of soy protein).

3)Are you serious? It's dead. It doesn't have to be. I consider the difference between being alive and being dead a detrimental one, don't you?

Or not exist at all.

"If couldn't sell my dog's legs for umbrella stands, I couldn't afford a dog" is a really terrible argument.

4)I didn't say it was impractical to eat meat, I said it was equally practical to eat vegetarian. This does not follow from anything I've said, and it certainly doesn't follow from what you've labelled as my "Point 3".

Are you in favour of animal cruelty laws, Wreck?

5)What do you think unnecessary suffering is? I think it is suffering that is inflicted unnecessarily - that is suffering caused in pursuit of a need that it itself unnecessary, or that can be sated in another way that involves less, or no suffering at all.

The animal was alive. Now it is dead. For no good reason. That sure sounds like a degradation in quality of life to me.

They're dead. For a trivial reason.


1) Look, there were herds of buffalo in the 19th century that were so large settlers watched them cross on their trail for 24 hours, running the entire time. There have always been animals producing methane, the only reason it is even relevant now is because of the added CO2 from humans. We cut our carbon emissions, the animals' isn't an issue. A great percentage of that methane comes from feed-lots and other mass-production techniques. Free range raising of animals is healthy for the animals and the environment they exist in. Ecosystems depend upon grazers.

2) This is an interesting topic. I see no reason why efficiency is relevant to a discussion of food practices. We have more than enough food to feed every person on the planet, even in its current overpopulated state. If anything our food production is too efficient, which is why we pay billions of dollars a year to keep farmers from growing crops.

3) You are conflating the depravation of life with suffering. I see no reason to think the two are the same. It is only a problem for humans because we can conceptualize our own mortality. That's why I included that Burns excerpt from earlier. In terms of animal rights, we have to figure out what is best for the animal, not an anthropomorphisized (is that actually a word?) concept of an animal. They may no longer be alive, but if no pain or discomfort was experienced, I see no harm. Nor has anyone been able to explain to me what exactly the harm is other than, "Come on, I mean come on, seriously."

4) It's possible I misread your earlier post, I'll go look at it again, apologies if I didn't get it right.

5) I think that unnecessary suffering must include...suffering. In animal terms this is pain or discomfort. Animals do not have the brain capacity to ruminate in a field lamenting the coming slaughter. They eat, crap, eat, crap, then the lights go out. No pain, no discomfort, no suffering. You are pretending that animals are like people and feel deprived of the chance to go on living, they are not capable of such sophisticated thought. The goal, therefore, is to make their lives comfortable, not gnash our teeth wondering if they are as terrified of the mystery beyond as we are.


Edit: let me also reply to this: "If couldn't sell my dog's legs for umbrella stands, I couldn't afford a dog" is a really terrible argument.

This is a complete distortion of the point at hand. This is a more accurate example: I have a pound that takes care of abused or abandoned dogs. We keep them healthy and try to find them owners. We don't have the funds to keep all animals alive indefinitely, if we tried, all of the dogs would suffer a lower standard of care. Thus, we have to humanely terminate a certain number of animals. Now another perspective would be to say that we need to terminate a certain number of animals and sell their parts for funds to keep the shelter operational. This is only horrible because of the sentimental position dogs hold in our society (one I ascribe to), but again, there is nothing immoral about said behavior. No suffering is generated and the animals fair much better than they would were they roaming about the streets.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, I'm finding your analogies streched.

That's good, in a way. If you find them absurd, then that was the intention. The key, then, is to try and understand if there is any substantive difference between these stretched analogies and that with which they are analogising? That is - if you find the behaviour in the analogy unacceptable, it falls upon you to show why the analogy doesn't hold.

Of course these things don't happen in the real world - they are intolerable. If you can figure out why they're intolerable, then you'll see what I'm trying to argue, I guess.

Can we keep this to what people actually do in the real world? It makes sense for this sort of thing to be illegal, since how can legislate that this is overall beneficial to the cows?
Since when did "overall benefit to the animal" become a criteria?

Why would we expend resources for that?
The farmer really, really enjoys killing cows.

Cruelty is in suffering, not lack of life, in my view. That's the central disconnect. I've tried to state this several times, yet you keep coming back with different examples. I don't have a problem with death, I do have a problem with suffering.
How can you define suffering in a way that precludes death?
 
Vegetarianism is harmless enough though it is apt to fill a man with wind and self-righteousness. ~Robert Hutchison, address to the British Medical Association, 1930
 
We vegans hear this alot. It's basically an argument that because we're not perfect, we shouldn't even bother trying. A tu quoque argument, essentially, and thus an invalid one.

Am I perfect? No.
Can I admit I am a hypocrite? Yes.
Am I doing something about what I believe can rationally be argued to be a problem? Yes indeed.

Which is usually at least two steps better than many of those making the accusations. No-one's perfect, least of all me. That's not an argument that undermines my arguments, though.
That was not the argument. I was not accusing you of hypocrisy. I think it okay for you to have tattoos, even though pit bulls are dying. I really, really do. This iwas not a rhetorical device. In my book, you are okay. I wanted to find out if you felt that your every whim should be measured against animal suffering. You do. That's all.

Certainly, if you think you owe the animals a life, but aren't doing something about it by foregoing some pleasure, it is still good that you aren't eating animals at well. As you say, half way is better than nothing.

As far as I can tell you are being logically consistent if you think you are obligated to forgo tattooing to give it to animals, whether or not you act on it. However, I am also being logically consistent if I think you don't owe the animal a life, and can eat animals if you want.
 
That's good, in a way. If you find them absurd, then that was the intention. The key, then, is to try and understand if there is any substantive difference between these stretched analogies and that with which they are analogising? That is - if you find the behaviour in the analogy unacceptable, it falls upon you to show why the analogy doesn't hold.

Of course these things don't happen in the real world - they are intolerable. If you can figure out why they're intolerable, then you'll see what I'm trying to argue, I guess.
See, I really do see what you are trying to say :) So far as I can tell. We just disagree. (I'm enjoying this discussion, btw)

Since when did "overall benefit to the animal" become a criteria?
It's my measure. It's how I decide these things. It seems the most reasonable way to decide things. We have to decide what practices we will allow. I suggest balancing the good of the animal with the good of the humans.

How can you define suffering in a way that precludes death?
Suffering is a process involving a functioning brain.
 
1) Look, there were herds of buffalo in the 19th century that were so large it took them 24 hours to pass. There have always been animals producing methane, the only reason it is even relevant now is because of the added CO2 from humans. We cut our carbon emissions, the animals' isn't an issue. A great percentage of that methane comes from feed-lots and other mass-production techniques. Free range raising of animals is healthy for the animals and the environment they exist in. Ecosystems depend upon grazers.

Grazing ecosystems depend on grazers. That point is tautological. As to the rest - we could eradicate a hug chunk of our planet's CO2 emissions were there to be a concerted switch to vegtarianism. Don't take my word for it, read the linked studies. The technologies to produce a comparable drop from other sources are more than decades away.

More bad arguments, I'm afraid.


3) You are conflating the depravation of life with suffering. I see no reason to think the two are the same. It is only a problem for humans because we can conceptualize our own mortality. That's why I included that Burns excerpt from earlier. In terms of animal rights, we have to figure out what is best for the animal, not an anthropomorphisized (is that actually a word?) concept of an animal. They may no longer be alive, but if no pain or discomfort was experienced, I see no harm. Nor has anyone been able to explain to me what exactly the harm is other than, "Come on, I mean come on, seriously."

See below. It is demonstrable that cows fear the slaughter, and that they have a sense of self-hood that includes a sense of the possibility of a future.

5) I think that unnecessary suffering must include...suffering. In animal terms this is pain or discomfort. Animals do not have the brain capacity to ruminate in a field lamenting the coming slaughter.

Are you quite sure about that?

http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar...&hs=6sH&q=fear cows&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ws

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...d=333848&md5=83347e61b4f6a174645b15bb5570d1f0

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...d=333848&md5=61523f384433f1316f3046b72aaec6e0

They eat, crap, eat, crap, then the lights go out. No pain, no discomfort, no suffering. You are pretending that animals are like people and feel deprived of the chance to go on living, they are not capable of such sophisticated thought.

The links above all suggest that cows have a basic sense of fear. You are wrong. I'm surprised that you would claim to have spent a lot of time around cows, whilst at the same time having no sense that they most clearly are capable of expressing a rudimentary sense of self-hood and of time.
 
It seems the most reasonable way to decide things. We have to decide what practices we will allow. I suggest balancing the good of the animal with the good of the humans.

Ah, OK. That's fine. I do too. I don't see how killing an animal is in any way taking into account any of its interests, though?

Suffering is a process involving a functioning brain.

Therefore - ending the functioning of the brain counts as suffering, right?
 
Who is being harmed in the latter case? It seems like you're comparing apples and empty sets.
There is no who. That doesn't mean we can't reason about the effects of various decisions. Say I have a genetic defect that I will pass on to my children. Should I procreate? If yes, a child will be born with some guaranteed suffering somewhat above the norm. If I don't, there is no "who". Depending on the defect, I can reasonably decide to procreate or not (a full life with a heart murmur vs 1 year of screaming agony followed by death).

To bring it back to meat, I've posted that if given the choice between living and becoming food at 35 (and I'm 42 now), or never existing, I'd choose the former (let's pretend time travel is possible) Volatile would choose the latter for me if it was put in his hands. He thinks that would be the best choice. I would do everything in my power to stop him.

I extrapolate from that and feel that a happy cow destined for eventual slaughter is not a bad thing.
 
1) Grazing ecosystems depend on grazers. That point is tautological. As to the rest - we could eradicate a hug chunk of our planet's CO2 emissions were there to be a concerted switch to vegtarianism. Don't take my word for it, read the linked studies. The technologies to produce a comparable drop from other sources are more than decades away.

More bad arguments, I'm afraid.




2) See below. It is demonstrable that cows fear the slaughter, and that they have a sense of self-hood that includes a sense of the possibility of a future.



Are you quite sure about that?

http://scholar.google.co.uk/scholar...&hs=6sH&q=fear cows&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=ws

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...d=333848&md5=83347e61b4f6a174645b15bb5570d1f0

http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...d=333848&md5=61523f384433f1316f3046b72aaec6e0



The links above all suggest that cows have a basic sense of fear. You are wrong. I'm surprised that you would claim to have spent a lot of time around cows, whilst at the same time having no sense that they most clearly are capable of expressing a rudimentary sense of self-hood and of time.

1) Again, that is only true because the studies do a very poor job of separating methods of meat raising. I take the fact that you haven't even tried to deal with free range grazing as evidence that it's a problem for you. Yes, the current state of the meat industy is horrific.

A leading factor in the Dust Bowl during the Great Depression was farming techniques that depleted the soil of essential minerals. I could say broadly that farming exacerbates droughts, therefore no one should farm. It turns out, however, that merely modernizing planting techniques by rotating crops fixed the problem.

2) I have to ask if you even read the articles you linked. Yes cattle are capable of fear and terror, if they aren't handled appropriately. If you'll notice, the first article showed that the farmer milking his cattle gently caused no fear in the cow.

Read about a heroic woman named Temple Grandin. She has devoted her life to creating slaughter techniques that eliminate the fear the animals experience during the process. Doing things as simple as making a circular ramp so that the animals cannot see what's happening in front eliminate their fear as gauged by adrenal response.

Furthermore, none of those articles dealt with the concept at issue here, namely that cattle suffer from the mere fact that they aren't allowed to live out their natural lives. I never argued that they don't experience fear or terror. In fact that's the basis of my argument supporting domestication as far preferable to living in the wild.

You are merely arguing against specific bad practices and using those practices to slander the entire concept of consuming animals. This is just sloppy.


Edit: I want to clarify my response to this, "The links above all suggest that cows have a basic sense of fear. You are wrong. I'm surprised that you would claim to have spent a lot of time around cows, whilst at the same time having no sense that they most clearly are capable of expressing a rudimentary sense of self-hood and of time."

You are consitently ignoring my arguments to argue against easier cases. You did so with respect to the environmental impact of free-range ranching, and now you have done so with my argument about cow's ability to feel terror or pain. Of course they can feel pain. Humorously, the articles you provided supported my contentions concerning appropriate treatment of the animals, but they had nothing to say about the cattle's ability to deal with conceptual angst like understanding mortality. A cow experiences no discomfort or pain from not being able to live out its natural lifespan. They do not have the brain power to feel deprived of the chance to live a few more years. Thus if the act of killing itself is not harmful, they experience no pain.
 
Last edited:
Therefore - ending the functioning of the brain counts as suffering, right?
No, it counts as ending the life of the animal. That act can be cruel or not in its own right, of course. It's different.
 
It's only parody if you're incapable of understanding the argument. Domesticated animals weren't always thus. You may be excited to learn that many years ago (yes, even before Jesus was born) all animals that we now recognize as domesticated, were wild. I know, I know, shocking, but that's really how it happened. Over the years selective breeding and evolution caused them to become the animals we know today. So yes, all domesticated animals were rescued from the perils of the wild at some point in their genetic history.

Wow. I think Amnesty International is going to have to send out an urgent action report because that is some tortured mutha****in' logic. Is this guy for real because it sure sounds like he's saying Paris Hilton rescued a chihuahua from the wild.

And as for "unargued moral assumption about background conditions," I was quite clear that the metric I was using involved suffering. You can't coherently argue that an animal in the wild suffers less than a well tended herd, unless you develop some bizarre anthropomorphic concept about animals expressing their true nature through life in the wild. Perhaps you even think they sing about it Lion King style.

I will readily concede animals in a "well tended herd" do not suffer as much as animals in the wild. Now what does that prove? Why should we take animals in the wild as some holy baseline if we already agree nature is cruel and capricious? It seems as though your conclusions here are contingent upon the "reasoning" on display in the first paragraph -- which is to say that the animals we do not breed for domestication would otherwise live in the wild. The problem with that belief is that it's, um, mistaken.

But how impressive for you to notice a minor spelling error. I guess if you're bizarre enought to think that animals suffer conceptual angst when years of their lives are deprived from them, you might think that focusing on unimportant nonsense passes for wit.

Well, let's say somebody kills Jones in his sleep. Does Jones suffer any "conceptual angst"? No, he literally did not know what hit him. That's certainly a preferable way to die compared to being shackled and tortured, but it still constitutes a harm.
 
1) Again, that is only true because the studies do a very poor job of separating methods of meat raising.

Not at all - because, as I said, the methane production of a cow is similar no matter how it is raised, and the CO2 levels used are always higher than well-planned methods of raising the same number of calories in vegetables.

I take the fact that you haven't even tried to deal with free range grazing as evidence that it's a problem for you. Yes, the current state of the meat industy is horrific.

It's not a problem for me at all. Fewer cows means fewer greenhouse gases. It's a trivially simple sum.


2) I have to ask if you even read the articles you linked. Yes cattle are capable of fear and terror, if they aren't handled appropriately. If you'll notice, the first article showed that the farmer milking his cattle gently caused no fear in the cow.

Read about a heroic woman named Temple Grandin. She has devoted her life to creating slaughter techniques that eliminate the fear the animals experience during the process. By doing things as simple as making a circular ramp so that the animals cannot see what's happening in front eliminate their fear as gauged by an adrenal response.

Furthermore, none of those articles dealt with the concept at issue here, namely that cattle suffer from the mere fact that they aren't allowed to live out their natural lives. I never argued that they don't experience fear or terror. In fact that's the basis of my argument supporting domestication as far preferable to living in the wild.

I read the abstracts. Now, the key point here is that if a cow is able to sense and express fear, it means it has a sense of future time. It is capable of understanding that a future existence without pain is better than one in pain, and by extrapolation that an existence alive is preferable than one dead. This suggests to me, and to those who have studied this issue (like Peter Singer, for example) that cows and other livestock have a stake in their own future existence, and thus your propositions that "they don't care" or "they don't know any different" don't add up. If cows were as incapable of expressing future interests as you claim, they wouldn't show fear - which, by definition, is an expression of future interests.

You are merely arguing against specific bad practices and using those practices to slander the entire concept of consuming animals. This is just sloppy.

No, I'm not. You, on the other hand, are engaging in some rather deft use of things like special pleading.
 
Vegetarianism is harmless enough though it is apt to fill a man with wind and self-righteousness. ~Robert Hutchison, address to the British Medical Association, 1930
Sure... I mean, those that point out how the "cud chewers" are wrong sure aren't filled with any wind or self-righteousness at all, no sir! :rolleyes:
 
Now that I've offered my opinion of what suffering is, I would love to hear you explain what you think it is.
No, it counts as ending the life of the animal. That act can be cruel or not in its own right, of course. It's different.

Perhaps "harm" is a more precise term to use, as suffering obviously conjures up images of prolonged torture. Feel free to replace any previous use of the word "suffering" by me with "harm" if it will clear up the crossed-purposes we appear to have been talking at.

Harm is interference with current or future interests. This brief summary of the principle of Nonmaleficence might be useful, although it acknowledges that harm is tricky to define.

I happen to think that being killed can be termed to be undergoing harm, even if the process of death is painless.
 
Last edited:
If a cow had more anthropomorphic features, the slavery issue would be bigger.

It is all somewhat arbitrary, or at least, quantifiable. I'm less comfortable enslaving humans and eating their flesh them I am with cows. Less comfy with cows than chickens; and so on down the line.

I draw the line at tits. If its got tits, I don't eat it.
 
If a cow had more anthropomorphic features, the slavery issue would be bigger.

It is all somewhat arbitrary, or at least, quantifiable. I'm less comfortable enslaving humans and eating their flesh them I am with cows. Less comfy with cows than chickens; and so on down the line.

I draw the line at tits. If its got tits, I don't eat it.

I'm more hardline. I don't eat anything with a face.
 
Wow. I think Amnesty International is going to have to send out an urgent action report because that is some tortured mutha****in' logic. Is this guy for real because it sure sounds like he's saying Paris Hilton rescued a chihuahua from the wild.



I will readily concede animals in a "well tended herd" do not suffer as much as animals in the wild. Now what does that prove? Why should we take animals in the wild as some holy baseline if we already agree nature is cruel and capricious? It seems as though your conclusions here are contingent upon the "reasoning" on display in the first paragraph -- which is to say that the animals we do not breed for domestication would otherwise live in the wild. The problem with that belief is that it's, um, mistaken.



Well, let's say somebody kills Jones in his sleep. Does Jones suffer any "conceptual angst"? No, he literally did not know what hit him. That's certainly a preferable way to die compared to being shackled and tortured, but it still constitutes a harm.



Are you really that dumb or are you involved in some kind of Andy Kauffman bit? Paris Hilton purchased an animal that was domesticated thousands of years ago. She didn't save it from nature, the first group of nomadic hunter-gatherers to take in the more docile wolves that eventually became Chihuahuas did. Yes, they rescued those animals from what otherwise would have been a dangerous existence in nature.

"Why should we take animals in the wild as some holy baseline if we already agree nature is cruel and capricious?" Because that is the state animals would exist in without human intervention. And I would love to hear your explanation of this mystical third way that isn't domestication and isn't life in the wild. Maybe you're arguing they never would have existed. This is true with respect to any given instance of a contemporary domesticated animal, but without domestication SOME animal would live. Either that or they would have been hunted into extinction like the Mammoth. I have no idea what you think this proves. The fact remains that domesticated herd animals live a much better life than wild herd animals. Calling free-range ranching unethical is bald ignorance or stupidity.

Jones is a human, therefore what he is being deprived of is human life. A cow's life is much different in the same way that a cow's life is of a different value than a carrot's. The actual act of killing, though, caused Jones no suffering. I would like to see you explain how and why depriving Jones of his life caused him suffering. It is equally likely that Jones was about to have his bone cancer diagnosed and the murderer saved him 20 years of tortorous pain. Understanding death in those terms is just silly. The value of human life is not gauged in a suffering/happiness distinction because we are capable of higher thought. Unlike any other animal we can view suffering as a means to an end, or simply an aspect of life that must be endured. For an animal pain and suffering are ends of themselves, they have no faculty of higher thought. A caretaker's only standard of care with respect to an animal is to limit pain and suffering. There is no need to attend to the higher faculties imposed on those animals by rediculous people like you.

Unless you're honestly arguing that the relationship between Jones and his murderer is no different from a cow and its farmer (which seems to be your level, so I shouldn't be surprised), the analogy is useless. A cow does not look forward, does not have plans that a murderer thwarts, does not have any emotion but the base need to eat and crap. It isn't wrong to deprive an organism of something of which they have no concept.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom