Is vegetarianism arbitrary?



​
Interesting (and apposite) choice of poem to quote.

Burns often gets slagged off, partly for sentimentality, but also often because English speakers find Scots amusing. But that poem is a striking piece of animal empathy, dated 17-what?
I'm truly sorry Man's dominion
Has broken Nature's social union,
And justifies that ill opinion
Which makes thee startle
At me, thy poor Earth-born companion
And fellow mortal.
​
And all in English, too, that verse.

Rolfe.

Uh...did you actually read anything I've written? That verse and the poem in general contradict nothing I've argued. The point of the stanza is that the mouse lacks the faculty to look into the future and fear, which is exactly what I argued. Sort of why I used the quote...
 
Uh...did you actually read anything I've written? That verse and the poem in general contradict nothing I've argued. The point of the stanza is that the mouse lacks the faculty to look into the future and fear, which is exactly what I argued. Sort of why I used the quote...


Er, sorry, but exactly where did my skill in the English language desert me?

I was complimenting you on an entirely appropriate choice of quote, and adding a bit more of the same poem for effect, and perhaps further illumination of the discussion.

Rolfe.
 
My goodness you're quick on the up take. What from my first, second, or third posts indicated otherwise, allowing you more than ample time and opportunity to clarify. I am so sorry for demanding precision with language, like any other non-educated adult. :rolleyes:

It's one thing to argue that my point wasn't made, it's another thing all together to not comprehend when figurative language is being used. You missed it completely, in a hilarious, embarassing way. Now you're trying to put the onus on me for not realizing I was talking to a man-child. Nice try, but in your haste and bluster you simply made a childish error.


And yet you still cling to this bad argument. One could argue that killing any animal in the wild has spared the world from generations of future misery. Indeed, a utilitarian argument could be made that killing an animal, even painfully, has on the balance done much, much more good than harm.

One could argue that, but one would be a fool if they so tried. Perhaps if each animal was understood to be an entity with no connection to the environment, you would be correct. Unfortunately, Animals exist in an ecosystem, so your idiotic Utilitarian calculation fails miserably. Sure, killing a single wolf may cause a net gain of good (hypothetically), but we completely lack the foresight to know exactly what will happen when we tinker thus. Which is why I reiterate that our duty to the wild is to act when we know of a beneficial result (controlled burning, for example) and otherwise try to interfere as little as possible. When dealing with animals directly under our care, the standard shifts.

Perhaps the only way I could explain this to you is if I borrowed a piece of paper and your box of crayons. The domesticated animals alive today would not exist if not for human intervention. Had we never "rescued" cows, pigs, sheep, nature would not have produced nearly as many of these animals. The same goes for Hilton's dog except instead of numbers, the TYPE of dog, let alone the individual animal, never would have existed at all. This should be obvious to even you.

Thankfully, later on you are explicit in your error:



This is fallacy of uninterrupted trends, and it's amusingly ironic because it's a type of mathematical literalism in that it assumes a 1:1 to transfer. This also betrays a paper thin understanding of genes.


Sigh, you still are arguing this rediculous point? I find it hilarious that you cling to this nosense.

Look, there was a point prior to domestication where all animals were wild. At some point they were domesticated and some percentage majority of the genetic decendents of those animals continued in domestication. Had they not been domesticated, that genetic lineage, whatever percentage of it that survived, would be in the wild.

Think of a simple adaptation. Say a mutation at generation 0 caused an elephant to develop a very useful trunk (yes, I know the process iwas more gradual, but we're doing what's called a "thought experiment"). All subsequent generations benefit greatly from that trunk: they have easy access to food, can keep themselves cool by spraying water, it helps fend off predators, etc. Now imagine a parallel world where that mutation never occured. All subsequent generations are trunkless. Certainly elephants with trunks would never have existed, but only a fool would try to argue that elephants haven't benefited from that apendage.

Domestication operates the same way. Without domestication the genetic line of animals that would have come into existence would have been impoverished in the same way that a line of elephants without trunks would have been weakened. Thusly we can sensibly say that elephants have benefited from trunks and cows have benefited from domestication.

No, you're missing the point. You might wanna try some of them there literalist readings. I'll repeat the crucial line for your convenience: "You need to somehow demonstrate that animals are somehow transported from the ravages of the wild onto your utopian free-range farm."

You think I need to do this. You have a silly, literal mind so you think it's important. See the argument above.


Thank you. It would also like kudos for being able to spell "relevant." Don't worry, I'll make sure you get an award for participation. Everyone is special.

Weak, you ape my joke without adding anything interesting. You really are like Carlos Mencia.


And you're failing to support that assertion. Also, the word "omnipotent" does not mean what you apparently think it means, which I only mention to segue here:



Um, infants are humans. Dee Dee Dee

Two bad choices of words: substitute "omniscient" for omnipotent, and "adult" for "human."


This does not explain the continuum of value, or how an infant has any interest in its future. Worse still, you fail to consistently apply your own standard: "Please explain why I should care that a creature has been deprived of something it has no concept for."

We other humans recognize that a child will eventually become an adult and take on their rights. Our caring for those children is based on that knowledge. Unlike cows, we know things. We have no trouble making a distinction between an animal that lives a subsistent mental life, and a child in development. I don't know why you even think this is important. A human child will eventually gain a concept concerning its mortality and future life, a cow won't.


Here you go magic-ing new rules and exceptions, making it up as you go along. What sort of moral principle do you derive from shared genes, and how on earth is that anything but an arbitrary threshold? Also, so what if most special needs people have higher brain functioning than cattle; what we're really looking for here is a difference of kind rather than degree. No, you have not thought through your answer. Suppose us vegans somehow convince the world that nobody should consume animals, and this eventually becomes a societal norm. Does that mean it needs no longer requires justification? So maybe you do want to eat meat in such a society, but we stop you, and you ask why. "Societal norm."


My point is simply that we can field arguments on both sides concerning what we do with people so retarded that they function less than a cow. I can see a reasonable argument for euthanasia and I can see a reasonable argument for keeping them alive. On some level it is up to a fully functioning adult to make the decision and care for the individual. In our society we have decided to keep them alive, fine. But I don't need to explain anything more with respect to dealing with cattle.

And it isn't right or wrong BECAUSE it is a social norm. If vegans convinced everyone to stop eating meat, I would have arguments against this position. That social norm would be challenged. I am simply noting that our current behavior towards the mentally handicapped need not be covered by the same rationale I use to justify the humane slaughter of well-tended herd beasts. It could go either way and I really wouldn't complain. That amounts to CONSISTENCY with my position towards animals.

But I'm not surprised your flew off the handle at that one. I should also point out that just because I think there is nothing deprived from a cow by cutting its life short, that doesn't mean I advocate that all cows SHOULD have their life cut short. If you want to keep one as a pet, go sick. The same thing is true with regard to SEVERELY disabled humans. Of course you can sometimes make an argument that such debilitated people (and pets as well) are only kept alive for the vanity of the caretaker, but that's neither here nor there.
 
Last edited:
Er, sorry, but exactly where did my skill in the English language desert me?

I was complimenting you on an entirely appropriate choice of quote, and adding a bit more of the same poem for effect, and perhaps further illumination of the discussion.

Rolfe.

Ahh, don't blame yourself, it's more likely that after a day of arguing I could only interpret your words as criticism. I believe I read "apposite" as "opposite." The apology is mine.

And I do very much enjoy old Burns.
 
Some people aren't good with killing stuff.
Some are. There's room for both types.

The grey area is the people that eat what they eat, with almost no connection to its production. maybe its good that we are generally far removed from what we eat.
 
I made no such claim. My claim is that it is a net good to bring a cow into the world.
Hrmm.

roger said:
I consider killing a lesser form of harm than not living at all, assuming a humane existance. It's just that simple.
It does seem to me that you made at least one such claim, if it's fair to infer from that comparison that you must consider not living at all a form of harm. But I take it you mean that it's good to bring someone into the world similar to the way that it's bad to take someone out of the world?

I'm not sure of your point. I am not arguing that we are morally obligated to bring cows into existance, just that if we do, it's a net good.
The obligation is suggested by the comparison in like terms to killing a person, and by a general obligation to make the world a better place. I certainly think that I'm obligated not to kill you (to the extent that I'm obligated to do anything at all), so if killing someone and failing to reproduce are wrongs of essentially the same kind (depriving the world of people leading decent lives), it does seem to follow that I'm doing something similarly wrong by not having children, and that we have an obligation to somehow fill the world with people. Maybe you don't think I have any obligation not to kill you, that I shouldn't kill you because of secondary considerations, but I don't think this view adequately captures the harm done in killing people.

The question we (I) am trying to answer is, "is it good to live, even if we end up as food". My answer, for myself, is yes. Getting tangled up over time travel, can you kill your mother, etc., misses the point. Is it good to live, even if we end up as food. I say yes. I'm willing to extrapolate that to a less conscious creature, such as a cow. Arguing that we can't time travel makes me go :confused:
I'm not merely pointing out that time travel is impossible. I'm saying that you are engaging in a confusion between potential people and real people.

What you've been saying is that you have a general preference for existence over non-existence. This is how you're arguing against retroactive murder, by invoking what is 'good for yourself'. You then universalize this derived value, applying it to other people (I assume), and to cows. Ok, let's assume for the moment that cows are sufficiently capable of holding themselves in mind as an object of desire that this makes sense. I'm with you--this is how I'd argue that it is wrong, generally speaking, to kill people.

But what you're failing to consider is that you are not merely universalizing this belief across all people, all cows. You are also generously including non-existent people, and non-existent cows. The cows that won't be created as a result of my actions do not exist, and cannot make moral claims upon me due to the fact of their debilitating non-existence. Once you are willing to give equal consideration to the teeming, infinite multitude of strictly imaginary potential people and animals, you immediately make nonsense out of our own comparatively petty desires. We are simply overwhelmed by numbers.

I think this argument suffers from at least two problems. First, as a factual matter, non-existent people and animals do not have any preferences about how they are treated. Second, if we were to treat them as if they did (for whatever reason), we are led to conclusions that are wildly counter-intuitive. So I don't think we can say that it is a 'net good' to create a cow, even if this view is initially seductive. This is why modern utilitarians typically drop the 'for the greatest number' from their credo--few are willing to commit to the conclusions.

Rolfe wisely avoided this problem by copping to a personal preference for a world with farm animals in it.

Please, argue fairly. This is an internet forum. I cannot address every last point ever brought up in every post - that requires a book. Failing to do so is not evasion. Besides, isn't that rhetorically useful for my point? More rodents, more life, unfortunately cut short for food reasons. Net plus, based on my reasoning. Am I misunderstanding you? Maybe you weren't addressing that to me.
I'm not accusing you of evasiveness, but I don't think it's unfair to revisit an argument the you yourself raised to point out that we are biased in favor of clouding the waters where doing so serves our interests. Anyway, if Davis is correct that more animals are killed in the production of crops than pasture, and you are correct that creating more animals is better (provided that they don't lead miserable lives), and I am correct in presuming that more animals being killed suggests that more animals live in the first place, then we can conclude that it's better to eat plant-based diets than grass-fed beef.

Since I don't think it's true that more life is better (all things being equal), since Davis is egregiously wrong (he's not even looking at the right numbers), since we aren't considering the problem that in the modern world pasture and field both encroach upon rainforest that might support relatively more animal life, I don't think we can conclude much of anything from this argument, except that even vegetarians must tangle with the problem of unintentional death and suffering.

I honestly don't think it is clear what the best possible thing is. I entered into this argument because of a claim that a microsecond of thought makes it clear that veganism is the moral choice. There are so many factors - industrial vs organic farming, effects of things like methane production, manure runoff, availability of things like hide glue (nothing else has it's properties), food, leather, pet companionship (feed a cat a vegan diet, you've got a dead cat), etc., etc., etc. It's very clear there are negative factors to a omnivorous diet, and I've brought them up unprompted. For me, so far, I come up with that it's a net good. The strongest counter-argument to that that I can think of is, if I am not sure, 100%, wouldn't it be better not to kill and eat the animals until I am sure? I find that counter argument modestly compelling.
One of the major problems with utilitarian calculation is that very few 'big picture' questions lend themselves to this kind of analysis--most of the time, the information spirals out of control as we've seen here, we run into problems that cannot be easily reduced to like terms, and so we lose confidence in the analysis, throw up our hands, and are forced to stand on principle.

I'm sure this is what volatile means when he says that it's immediately obvious that causing animals harm is wrong (because it violates a general principle against harming animals), and it's what I mean when I say we don't usually go data dredging in other, similar situations. Maybe it's sometimes good to torture people, but absent a compelling real-world argument, I'm not going to throw up my hands and say that it's too difficult to resolve the conflicting information, and that there's therefore room for disagreement.
 
I'm sure this is what volatile means when he says that it's immediately obvious that causing animals harm is wrong (because it violates a general principle against harming animals)
Going back and checking, I see that I'm badly misrepresenting volatile here. Apologies.

So I agree with you that it's non-obvious that more animals are killed in by the production of grass-fed beef than in the production of grain crops.
 
It's one thing to argue that my point wasn't made, it's another thing all together to not comprehend when figurative language is being used. You missed it completely, in a hilarious, embarassing way. Now you're trying to put the onus on me for not realizing I was talking to a man-child. Nice try, but in your haste and bluster you simply made a childish error.

Projection. My first post was unambiguous, so if there was any rush to bluster, it belongs to you (I believe your rant included "ejaculate"). Most recently you've been embarrassing yourself by misinterpreting Rolfe, which took some work. Please, get a clue.

One could argue that, but one would be a fool if they so tried. Perhaps if each animal was understood to be an entity with no connection to the environment, you would be correct. Unfortunately, Animals exist in an ecosystem, so your idiotic Utilitarian calculation fails miserably. Sure, killing a single wolf may cause a net gain of good (hypothetically), but we completely lack the foresight to know exactly what will happen when we tinker thus. Which is why I reiterate that our duty to the wild is to act when we know of a beneficial result (controlled burning, for example) and otherwise try to interfere as little as possible. When dealing with animals directly under our care, the standard shifts.

Well, I'm glad you think it's an idiotic argument because it runs in parallel to the one you've been making. You're talking about removing an animal from nature for domestication but how, with regard to the animals collectively condemned to the realm of nature, is that any different than killing an animal?

Sigh, you still are arguing this rediculous point? I find it hilarious that you cling to this nosense.

Rediculous. Nosense. Indeed. :rolleyes:

Look, there was a point prior to domestication where all animals were wild. At some point they were domesticated and some percentage majority of the genetic decendents of those animals continued in domestication. Had they not been domesticated, that genetic lineage, whatever percentage of it that survived, would be in the wild.

Think of a simple adaptation. Say a mutation at generation 0 caused an elephant to develop a very useful trunk (yes, I know the process iwas more gradual, but we're doing what's called a "thought experiment"). All subsequent generations benefit greatly from that trunk: they have easy access to food, can keep themselves cool by spraying water, it helps fend off predators, etc. Now imagine a parallel world where that mutation never occured. All subsequent generations are trunkless. Certainly elephants with trunks would never have existed, but only a fool would try to argue that elephants haven't benefited from that apendage.

Domestication operates the same way. Without domestication the genetic line of animals that would have come into existence would have been impoverished in the same way that a line of elephants without trunks would have been weakened. Thusly we can sensibly say that elephants have benefited from trunks and cows have benefited from domestication.

Jaw-dropping. Your ignorance, I mean. First, let's connect this back to the above: killing an animal spares its offspring from an "impoverished" stay in nature; it also arguably improves the material condition of the species in the area because there is less competition for resources. You could have a slightly stronger argument if you said that domestication reduced the need to hunt animals in the wild, so those beasts will get left alone. But you're not arguing that. Instead you're claiming that without domestication -- without the Adam and Eve taken into human custody -- all of their descendants would suffer an awful fate, and this number is supposed to be dramatically impressive. The problem is that you're assuming unchanged conditions. A second problem, one I don't think I bothered touching upon earlier but is obvious enough, is that you're ignoring the pain and suffering of animals that have been domesticated.

You think I need to do this. You have a silly, literal mind so you think it's important. See the argument above.

It's underwhelming.

Weak, you ape my joke without adding anything interesting. You really are like Carlos Mencia.

Oh... you were making a joke? I think you should stick to unintended humor.

We other humans recognize that a child will eventually become an adult and take on their rights. Our caring for those children is based on that knowledge. Unlike cows, we know things. We have no trouble making a distinction between an animal that lives a subsistent mental life, and a child in development. I don't know why you even think this is important. A human child will eventually gain a concept concerning its mortality and future life, a cow won't.

Now you're leaping into potentiality confusion. X might very well be a Potential Y, and we can make provisions, but it's still not a Y. I also recognize that a fetus and an embryo has the potential to become an adult. And is our caring based purely on that understanding? So if a baby has a terminal illness, then it's OK to kill it for food, right?

My point is simply that we can field arguments on both sides concerning what we do with people so retarded that they function less than a cow. I can see a reasonable argument for euthanasia and I can see a reasonable argument for keeping them alive. On some level it is up to a fully functioning adult to make the decision and care for the individual. In our society we have decided to keep them alive, fine. But I don't need to explain anything more with respect to dealing with cattle.

And it isn't right or wrong BECAUSE it is a social norm. If vegans convinced everyone to stop eating meat, I would have arguments against this position. That social norm would be challenged. I am simply noting that our current behavior towards the mentally handicapped need not be covered by the same rationale I use to justify the humane slaughter of well-tended herd beasts. It could go either way and I really wouldn't complain. That amounts to CONSISTENCY with my position towards animals.

But I'm not surprised your flew off the handle at that one. I should also point out that just because I think there is nothing deprived from a cow by cutting its life short, that doesn't mean I advocate that all cows SHOULD have their life cut short. If you want to keep one as a pet, go sick. The same thing is true with regard to SEVERELY disabled humans. Of course you can sometimes make an argument that such debilitated people (and pets as well) are only kept alive for the vanity of the caretaker, but that's neither here nor there.

This is certainly an improvement, apart from the underlined portion, but I will not quibble. It's no great difficulty to "simply" say that humans who have brains that function on the level of cows are accorded the protections very similar to cows. See, one sentence.
 
Projection. My first post was unambiguous, so if there was any rush to bluster, it belongs to you (I believe your rant included "ejaculate"). Most recently you've been embarrassing yourself by misinterpreting Rolfe, which took some work. Please, get a clue.

Your first reply was unambifuously mistaken. You missed completely a common literary tactic and in so doing revealed an amusingly literal mind. You can thrash and complain all you want, but it's there for everyone to see. When I make a mistake, as I did with Rolfe, I acknowledge my error and move on. Yet your petulent approach forces you to cling to your silly, silly error.


Well, I'm glad you think it's an idiotic argument because it runs in parallel to the one you've been making. You're talking about removing an animal from nature for domestication but how, with regard to the animals collectively condemned to the realm of nature, is that any different than killing an animal?

This is a joke, right? I don't even see how this is a response to my arguments. How is domesticating an animal any different from killing an animal in the wild? I don't even know what to say here. Your frivolous mind expressed through a frowning writing style has left me speechless.

"You're talking about removing an animal from nature for domestication but how, with regard to the animals collectively condemned to the realm of nature, is that any different than killing an animal?" I've read that sentence about 20 times and it still makes no sense. Unless you think letting an animal live in the wild is exactly the same as killing that animal, I have no possible explanation for the gibberish contained in that sentence.



Jaw-dropping. Your ignorance, I mean. First, let's connect this back to the above: killing an animal spares its offspring from an "impoverished" stay in nature; it also arguably improves the material condition of the species in the area because there is less competition for resources. You could have a slightly stronger argument if you said that domestication reduced the need to hunt animals in the wild, so those beasts will get left alone. But you're not arguing that. Instead you're claiming that without domestication -- without the Adam and Eve taken into human custody -- all of their descendants would suffer an awful fate, and this number is supposed to be dramatically impressive. The problem is that you're assuming unchanged conditions. A second problem, one I don't think I bothered touching upon earlier but is obvious enough, is that you're ignoring the pain and suffering of animals that have been domesticated.

"First, let's connect this back to the above: killing an animal spares its offspring from an "impoverished" stay in nature." Haha, ok, now I see that you really were making the silly argument I found above. Awesome. Please explain to me where I have ever advanced an argument holding that leaving an animal in nature was the same as killing that animal? From the perspective of an animal, domestication is preferable to a life in the wild.

You have such a bizarre understanding of this issue that I'm impressed you've been able to stick to it this long. Take the example of the elephant. I do not need to find a bunch of elephants without trunks in order to say that an elephant benefits from having a trunk. Sure, without trunks elephants either would have evolved differently or died out. That doesn't mean I can't call the appendage beneficial.

Domesticated animals fair FAR better than their wild counterparts. Compare free-range ranched cows with, say, wildabeast in Africa. One is an example of life under domestication, one is an example of life in the wild. Please find me something in the life of those domesticated cows that approaches the adrenaline fueled terror of a herd of wildabeast tryin in vain to escape the jaws of a 20ft crocodile while they ford a muddy stream. You can't. The fact is that domesticated life is simply BETTER for the animal. And by better I mean healthier, less painful, easier, and generally composed of less suffering.

"you're ignoring the pain and suffering of animals that have been domesticated." Sigh, of course I'm not. That is the last quivering death convultion of your comically misdirected reasoning. Of course there is SOME suffering in domestic life. On the whole the amount of that suffering is DRASTICALLY less than life in the wild. And if you're talking about mistreated animals, no one is debating the necessity for proper care. The mere fact that you brought this up simultaneously shows your desperation and bad faith. Charming.


Oh... you were making a joke? I think you should stick to unintended humor.

Are you going with the famous rubber/glue comedy routine next? You are completely unfunny. Countdown to, "Duh, You're even less funny."


Now you're leaping into potentiality confusion. X might very well be a Potential Y, and we can make provisions, but it's still not a Y. I also recognize that a fetus and an embryo has the potential to become an adult. And is our caring based purely on that understanding? So if a baby has a terminal illness, then it's OK to kill it for food, right?

First of all, abortion can be easily distinguished by pointing out that the choice belongs to the woman in which the embryo is gestating. So no, I'm not stepping into some pro-life position.

And no, this isn't confusing at all. Enfants eventually become fully functioning adults. If you can show me any other creature with the potential to develop the concept of mortality and future life, I will gladly argue that we should not willingly deprive such a being of its golden years.

Finally, if a child has a terminal illness and we can save it days, weeks, or months of pain, I have no problem with euthanasia. How we determine what is sufficient suffering vs certainty of death are all issues not relevent to this discussion. And what we do with the child's remains after it's dead is largely decided by custom. Remember your Herodotus. The Greeks were horrified that the Calatians ate their dead, and the Calatians were horrified that the Greeks burned theirs.

Once again you're flailing uselessly, trying to use extreme sounding nonsense, like child-eating, to smear my arguments. It's really getting sad (Countdown to, "but, but, you're sad...er.").

This is certainly an improvement, apart from the underlined portion, but I will not quibble. It's no great difficulty to "simply" say that humans who have brains that function on the level of cows are accorded the protections very similar to cows. See, one sentence.

What exactly was your objection to the underlined part? I think the humane slaughter of cattle is ethically appropriate because no suffering is caused. Cattle do not have the mental capacity to comprehend the life they are being deprived of, so from their cognative perspective, nothing has been lost. I don't need to deal with that rationale to argue either in favor of, or against whatever you think would be done to the mentally handicapped.

And I also love the sanctimonious, "ahem, well this is an improvement." Why don't you just admit that your argument against my stance was absurdely wrong. Especially since you just treated anyone unfortunate enough to dive into your grumpy prose to a whole bunch of nonsense about "social norms." I did express the same point that you acquiesced to in little more than a sentence, and you flew off on some bizarre tangent. Unless I explain things in great detail, you are lost. I guess you have some kind of an ego that needs coddling, but all the effort expended to avoid acknowledging the obvious is pathetic.
 
Your first reply was unambifuously mistaken.

OK.

You missed completely a common literary tactic and in so doing revealed an amusingly literal mind. You can thrash and complain all you want, but it's there for everyone to see. When I make a mistake, as I did with Rolfe, I acknowledge my error and move on. Yet your petulent approach forces you to cling to your silly, silly error.

You're such a joke. You can't even spell petulant and you pretend to lecture on "literary tactics." It's like seeing a dog bat around a fork. It seems as though you're now also waving this flag to try to wiggle out of your howler of a claim. It doesn't matter if we're talking about you or farmer John, the idea of "removal" is core here.

This is a joke, right? I don't even see how this is a response to my arguments. How is domesticating an animal any different from killing an animal in the wild? I don't even know what to say here. Your frivolous mind expressed through a frowning writing style has left me speechless.

"You're talking about removing an animal from nature for domestication but how, with regard to the animals collectively condemned to the realm of nature, is that any different than killing an animal?" I've read that sentence about 20 times and it still makes no sense. Unless you think letting an animal live in the wild is exactly the same as killing that animal, I have no possible explanation for the gibberish contained in that sentence.

"First, let's connect this back to the above: killing an animal spares its offspring from an "impoverished" stay in nature." Haha, ok, now I see that you really were making the silly argument I found above. Awesome. Please explain to me where I have ever advanced an argument holding that leaving an animal in nature was the same as killing that animal? From the perspective of an animal, domestication is preferable to a life in the wild.

Apparently one of your problems is that you write through a post before reading it, analogous to live-blogging. At first you waste my time with this blather about not understanding my argument, then I have to suffer through your claim to understand it. Worst of all, you did not understand it.

You have such a bizarre understanding of this issue that I'm impressed you've been able to stick to it this long. Take the example of the elephant. I do not need to find a bunch of elephants without trunks in order to say that an elephant benefits from having a trunk. Sure, without trunks elephants either would have evolved differently or died out. That doesn't mean I can't call the appendage beneficial.

Domesticated animals fair FAR better than their wild counterparts. Compare free-range ranched cows with, say, wildabeast in Africa. One is an example of life under domestication, one is an example of life in the wild. Please find me something in the life of those domesticated cows that approaches the adrenaline fueled terror of a herd of wildabeast tryin in vain to escape the jaws of a 20ft crocodile while they ford a muddy stream. You can't. The fact is that domesticated life is simply BETTER for the animal. And by better I mean healthier, less painful, easier, and generally composed of less suffering.

This goes to a second argument on baselines, one you take for granted rather than supporting. You're not addressing my argument, which I'll reproduce (one of the great benefits of getting something right in the first instance is to be spared future efforts):

I will readily concede animals in a "well tended herd" do not suffer as much as animals in the wild. Now what does that prove? Why should we take animals in the wild as some holy baseline if we already agree nature is cruel and capricious? It seems as though your conclusions here are contingent upon the "reasoning" on display in the first paragraph -- which is to say that the animals we do not breed for domestication would otherwise live in the wild. The problem with that belief is that it's, um, mistaken.

"you're ignoring the pain and suffering of animals that have been domesticated." Sigh, of course I'm not. That is the last quivering death convultion of your comically misdirected reasoning. Of course there is SOME suffering in domestic life. On the whole the amount of that suffering is DRASTICALLY less than life in the wild. And if you're talking about mistreated animals, no one is debating the necessity for proper care. The mere fact that you brought this up simultaneously shows your desperation and bad faith. Charming.

I think your problem is that you feel threatened and you're not very bright, so you resort to this kind of strained language, projecting your emotions on to me. Maybe a more concrete example will help. Let's say I go out into "nature" and rescue two cats, male and female, Adam and Eve. I provide for them a warehouse kittie heaven to mate and procreate, and their offspring mates and procreates, and so on and on, and when we do run out of space, we give the kitties to crazy cat ladies, open up new warehouses, etc. Does this mean that all of these animals enjoying domesticated life have been spared suffering in the wild? No. Chances are they and many of their offspring would have been constrained by the environment, either from predators, or lack of food. Do you think farmers have really spared billions of pigs from the wild? Billions of cows? No, because they never would have existed. Get. A. Clue.

Are you going with the famous rubber/glue comedy routine next? You are completely unfunny. Countdown to, "Duh, You're even less funny."

:rolleyes:

First of all, abortion can be easily distinguished by pointing out that the choice belongs to the woman in which the embryo is gestating. So no, I'm not stepping into some pro-life position.

And no, this isn't confusing at all. Enfants eventually become fully functioning adults. If you can show me any other creature with the potential to develop the concept of mortality and future life, I will gladly argue that we should not willingly deprive such a being of its golden years.

Finally, if a child has a terminal illness and we can save it days, weeks, or months of pain, I have no problem with euthanasia. How we determine what is sufficient suffering vs certainty of death are all issues not relevent to this discussion. And what we do with the child's remains after it's dead is largely decided by custom. Remember your Herodotus. The Greeks were horrified that the Calatians ate their dead, and the Calatians were horrified that the Greeks burned theirs.


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-17586.html

This argument is a bad one, even by first year undergrad standards. The first paragraph completely ignores the second one, and fails to demonstrate why a woman's interests in terminating a pregnancy trump what some believe are the rights of the embryo. I'm not saying the embryo does have rights, but you're encountering problems because you're already wedded to potentiality as a value. The third paragraph is delightfully inept. I'm not talking about sparing a terminally sick child pain. We've already established pain, human and non-human, is a significant moral value, so bracket that out for a moment and get down to fundamentals. Your invocation of the Callations has nothing to do with nothing. I am also familiar with this comparison, and I have used it more than once:

http://www.google.com/custom?q=call...=forums.randi.org&sitesearch=forums.randi.org

You also went out of your way to say something stupid by placing explicit emphasis on "the potential to develop the concept of mortality and future life."

What exactly was your objection to the underlined part? I think the humane slaughter of cattle is ethically appropriate because no suffering is caused. Cattle do not have the mental capacity to comprehend the life they are being deprived of, so from their cognative perspective, nothing has been lost. I don't need to deal with that rationale to argue either in favor of, or against whatever you think would be done to the mentally handicapped.

:rolleyes: If cows are having a wonderful time on ranches, if they love the environment that humans have provided for them, then why should we kill them? Volatile talked about this, I emphasized it in a previous posting, and you've been at a loss to come up with an answer: You only take into account one side of the equation, suffering.

And I also love the sanctimonious, "ahem, well this is an improvement."

It's condescending, not sanctimonious. You do know what the word "condescending" means, don't you? Because you sure as **** don't know what sanctimonious means.


Why don't you just admit that your argument against my stance was absurdely wrong. Especially since you just treated anyone unfortunate enough to dive into your grumpy prose to a whole bunch of nonsense about "social norms." I did express the same point that you acquiesced to in little more than a sentence, and you flew off on some bizarre tangent. Unless I explain things in great detail, you are lost. I guess you have some kind of an ego that needs coddling, but all the effort expended to avoid acknowledging the obvious is pathetic.

You see this is some kind of competition to you, and you're losing. Badly. Trying to salvage some remaining shred of dignity with all this fire. Your follow up, call it a clarification, was an improvement. I don't take issue with most of it, at least the important parts. I do not need you to explain things in great detail; in fact, you should consider shortening your posts and trying to get to the point... if you have one.
 
I vote that Cain and Tranewreck be given pistols or a rapier and get to duel it out.
 
You're such a joke. You can't even spell petulant and you pretend to lecture on "literary tactics." It's like seeing a dog bat around a fork. It seems as though you're now also waving this flag to try to wiggle out of your howler of a claim. It doesn't matter if we're talking about you or farmer John, the idea of "removal" is core here.

The refuge of the small mind is to fetishize minor errors. I write these post while engaged in other employment, obviously a proof read would clear things up. But, of course, none of your childish pointing out of spelling errors says anything about the idea-content, which has always been clear. No, once again, it was your idiotic, literal reading of a clearly figuraitive statement that began this exchange. Just admit your error and move on.

And "removal" is absolutely irrelevent to any discussion here. It's a dumb idea that you think is important.


Apparently one of your problems is that you write through a post before reading it, analogous to live-blogging. At first you waste my time with this blather about not understanding my argument, then I have to suffer through your claim to understand it. Worst of all, you did not understand it.

This goes to a second argument on baselines, one you take for granted rather than supporting. You're not addressing my argument, which I'll reproduce (one of the great benefits of getting something right in the first instance is to be spared future efforts):

I will readily concede animals in a "well tended herd" do not suffer as much as animals in the wild. Now what does that prove? Why should we take animals in the wild as some holy baseline if we already agree nature is cruel and capricious? It seems as though your conclusions here are contingent upon the "reasoning" on display in the first paragraph -- which is to say that the animals we do not breed for domestication would otherwise live in the wild. The problem with that belief is that it's, um, mistaken.

The question is what justification I need to argue that an animal has benefited. I am arguing that domestication is beneficial or preferable to life in the wild. Why on Earth would I need to examine the SAME individual animal in both circumstances to make that claim? I can say I am better off as a free man than one in prison without anyone having to "rescue" me from prison. Yours is an astonishingly idiotic concept.

Think of it this way, 1) whether or not there was domestication, the ecosystem has evolved such that there are massive stretches of land that NEED grazing animals in order to be healthy.

2) Those animals could either be tended to by humans or not (domestication is irrelevent as even wild buffalo herds are controlled by humans).

3) From the perspective of those animals they will be far better off if we humans use our superior faculties to tend to such herds.

4) One aspect of tending to a herd is to keep the numbers at an appropriate level. If the herd becomes too large it can destroy the local ecosystem (as we have seen grazing animals do in parts of India and Africa) and, importantly, those animals themselves become far less healthy. Overpopulation leads to starvation, weakness, and disease.

Therefore, 5) it is morally (from the perspective of animal suffering) and environmentally proper to raise herding animals, tend to their needs, and slaughter them humanely to control their numbers.

Your stance of keeping them indefinitely as pets is actually IMMORAL in the sense that it is bad for grazing-based ecosystems and causes a lower standard of living among herd members.


I think your problem is that you feel threatened and you're not very bright, so you resort to this kind of strained language, projecting your emotions on to me. Maybe a more concrete example will help. Let's say I go out into "nature" and rescue two cats, male and female, Adam and Eve. I provide for them a warehouse kittie heaven to mate and procreate, and their offspring mates and procreates, and so on and on, and when we do run out of space, we give the kitties to crazy cat ladies, open up new warehouses, etc. Does this mean that all of these animals enjoying domesticated life have been spared suffering in the wild? No. Chances are they and many of their offspring would have been constrained by the environment, either from predators, or lack of food. Do you think farmers have really spared billions of pigs from the wild? Billions of cows? No, because they never would have existed. Get. A. Clue.

Uh...so if the cats weren't rescued their decendents either would have died out or lived in the wild. How on Earth can you not say that domestication has BENEFITED that genetic line of cats? Domestication has benefited those cats in EXACTLY the same way the development of a trunk benefited elephants.

But keep up this retarded "removal" thesis. It's hilarious. It reminds of McCain's complaint about Obama saying he would pursue high priority targets in Pakistan with or without local approval. Obviously McCain agreed with the point and, in fact, it fell well in line with his general foreign policy position. But in a pathetic attempt to smear his opponent he became conceptually wedded to a silly view.

In the same way your initial failure to grasp my figurative description of what a rancher does has forced you to keep up this nonsensical position about "removal." You have wonderful intellectual peers. (Now I'm waiting for your doubtless HILARIOUS description of my intellectual peers).



This argument is a bad one, even by first year undergrad standards. The first paragraph completely ignores the second one, and fails to demonstrate why a woman's interests in terminating a pregnancy trump what some believe are the rights of the embryo. I'm not saying the embryo does have rights, but you're encountering problems because you're already wedded to potentiality as a value. The third paragraph is delightfully inept. I'm not talking about sparing a terminally sick child pain. We've already established pain, human and non-human, is a significant moral value, so bracket that out for a moment and get down to fundamentals. Your invocation of the Callations has nothing to do with nothing. I am also familiar with this comparison, and I have used it more than once:

My goal here is not to make that argument about abortion. I am merely pointing out that just because I recognize the uniqueness of human potential I am not forced pro-life commitments. That discussion seems off topic. I recognize the fully realized cognative potential of adults and yet support many forms of justified killing. You take simple statements with obvious ramifications and try your best to turn a reductio ad absurdum, but the result is so impressively random and goofy that I feel like you're trying out a new post-modernist style of discussion. You're like a rhetorical dadaist. And each time I read your posts I feel just as cheated as when I spent $15 to see a shoe Yoko Ono put on a table.


You also went out of your way to say something stupid by placing explicit emphasis on "the potential to develop the concept of mortality and future life."

No, I think that is exactly what separates an infant from a cow for the theoretic purposes of this discussion. If I deprive a cow of 2 years of life, I take away 2 years of eating and crapping. If I kill an infant I destroy a being who will eventually become a fully realized man.

Furthermore, somehow you seem to think that I'm arguing that it's ok to kill an animal for any reason whatsoever. This is not my point at all, perhaps I have not been clear enough in making it. I described earlier in this post why culling a herd is beneficial for both the herd and the local ecosystem. That is a positive argument in favor of slaughter. I see no such argument to justify the killing of an infant.


:rolleyes: If cows are having a wonderful time on ranches, if they love the environment that humans have provided for them, then why should we kill them? Volatile talked about this, I emphasized it in a previous posting, and you've been at a loss to come up with an answer: You only take into account one side of the equation, suffering.

Two simple reasons that I've given multiple times in multiple posts: 1) If we don't kill some number of them and sell the resultant products we cannot continue to tend to the animals' needs. It is expensive to be a rancher.

But let's say the world community of incoherent vegetarians gathers strength and raises massive funds to keep all ranches operating forever without having to sell meat products. Now those grazing environments will be destroyed by animal overpopulation. Either predators will have to be reintroduced to keep the numbers down, a fate for worse for animals than humane slaughter, or the grazing ecosystem will be destroyed. Thus, 2) culling is necessary to maintain the health of the grazing environment.



It's condescending, not sanctimonious. You do know what the word "condescending" means, don't you? Because you sure as **** don't know what sanctimonious means.

Apparantly you're the one with the definitional issues. I believe "hypocritcial devouteness" generally sums up your slimy attempt to pin responsibility for your childish error on me.


You see this is some kind of competition to you, and you're losing. Badly. Trying to salvage some remaining shred of dignity with all this fire. Your follow up, call it a clarification, was an improvement. I don't take issue with most of it, at least the important parts. I do not need you to explain things in great detail; in fact, you should consider shortening your posts and trying to get to the point... if you have one.

Haha, so let's sum up. You began by objecting to a figurative statement that you read humourously literally. Instead of apologizing, as I did when I made a similarly rediculous interpretation of Rolfe's post, you became irate and tried to blame my sometimes bad-spelling for your insufficiency. This, roughly speaking, is the difference between maturity and petul-A-nce.

Second, you think that the only sense I can say an animal has benefited from either human stewardship (as in the case of buffalo herds in the American plains) or domestication (as in the case of free-range ranching) is if I directly take an animal from the wild and offer it my care. This is, of course, stupid beyond belief. Once again, do I need to spend time getting violated in a correctional facility to say that I have benefited from my freedom? Please explain. You've avoided this consistently. Do you not think an elephant has benefited from a trunk or never incarcerated people benefit from freedom?

Finally, you are trying in comedic vain to imply that my arguments about the mental capacity of cattle somehow force me into pro-life positions or something like that. Once again, this is just stupid. I can argue, for any variety of reasons, that the destruction of a fetus is a justfied killing. I can argue that Charles Manson should have been put to death long ago. Neither of these arguments has any conceptual bearing on why I don't think depriving a cow of a few years of life is morally wrong.

But please, declare victory. I can see the "Mission Accomplished" banner waving in your front yard.
 
Last edited:
I find it more morally wrong to argue like this, over morality, than to just go ahead and kill whatever.

(and eat it, too, if you want)
 
I find it morally wrong to kill first and ask questions later.

Torture is much more satisfying.
 
The refuge of the small mind is to fetishize minor errors. I write these post while engaged in other employment, obviously a proof read would clear things up. But, of course, none of your childish pointing out of spelling errors says anything about the idea-content, which has always been clear. No, once again, it was your idiotic, literal reading of a clearly figuraitive statement that began this exchange. Just admit your error and move on.

And "removal" is absolutely irrelevent to any discussion here. It's a dumb idea that you think is important.

You write before you think. I thought I said a couple of times that I mis-read your "figurative" post, but it's instructive you would now claim the irrelevance of the idea you were advocating. What IS important is that you had engaged in some "literary tactic," and continually fail to take responsibility for your own murkiness, something that took you several posts to realize, and casually refusing to defend your idea. I do enjoy your over-the-top school boy taunts and the nervous tension, which indicates you have an inferiority complex... one that's not unjustified.

Since you for some reason agree my cat example is similar to yours with elephants, we'll discuss that now:

Uh...so if the cats weren't rescued their decendents either would have died out or lived in the wild. How on Earth can you not say that domestication has BENEFITED that genetic line of cats? Domestication has benefited those cats in EXACTLY the same way the development of a trunk benefited elephants.

No, you're not understanding it, as suggested by the underlined portions. The descendants likely would not have lived in the wild at all, so it's a mistake to say "that genetic line" or "those cats" would otherwise be facing very different conditions.


The question is what justification I need to argue that an animal has benefited. I am arguing that domestication is beneficial or preferable to life in the wild. Why on Earth would I need to examine the SAME individual animal in both circumstances to make that claim? I can say I am better off as a free man than one in prison without anyone having to "rescue" me from prison. Yours is an astonishingly idiotic concept.

No, the idea is still rushing over your head. As I have maintained, the original being transported from the wild to nature benefits, the metaphorical Adam and Eve -- that is, assuming a rosy view of domesticated life, which I'll be happy to do for the moment. So think of it this way, you can be in prison or you can be a free man. Naturally you, Adam, would prefer to be a free man, and let's say your descendants enjoy a happy and wonderful life. Great. The problem is it's a mistake to say your descendants would have been miserable in prison because, um, you would not have any offspring in prison. I thank you for the excellent example, and I wonder how much sooner you hit upon it than a monkey given a typewriter.


Think of it this way, 1) whether or not there was domestication, the ecosystem has evolved such that there are massive stretches of land that NEED grazing animals in order to be healthy.

The consequence of this is something you have continually failed to address. Assuming this land does need grazing -- or "NEEDS" it, if you prefer -- does this constrain the resources of animals in the wild?

2) Those animals could either be tended to by humans or not (domestication is irrelevent as even wild buffalo herds are controlled by humans).

Therefore, 5) it is morally (from the perspective of animal suffering) and environmentally proper to raise herding animals, tend to their needs, and slaughter them humanely to control their numbers.

Why not manage wild animals, culling them if necessary?

Your stance of keeping them indefinitely as pets is actually IMMORAL in the sense that it is bad for grazing-based ecosystems and causes a lower standard of living among herd members.

I think you're misunderstanding again. When I said keep them as pets, referred to Volatile's post, we meant keep your practices idyllic herding practices exactly the same, but just don't kill them. You don't need to name them, or play with them.

But keep up this retarded "removal" thesis. It's hilarious. It reminds of McCain's complaint about Obama saying he would pursue high priority targets in Pakistan with or without local approval. Obviously McCain agreed with the point and, in fact, it fell well in line with his general foreign policy position. But in a pathetic attempt to smear his opponent he became conceptually wedded to a silly view.

Does it remind you of that? Please go on. I just think this is endlessly fascinating.

In the same way your initial failure to grasp my figurative description of what a rancher does has forced you to keep up this nonsensical position about "removal." You have wonderful intellectual peers. (Now I'm waiting for your doubtless HILARIOUS description of my intellectual peers).

You're right -- it's "HILARIOUS." Hahaha, I just get a chuckle thinking about it -- double-rapid fire knee-slapper. Oh, you. Stop with the zingers.

My goal here is not to make that argument about abortion. I am merely pointing out that just because I recognize the uniqueness of human potential I am not forced pro-life commitments. That discussion seems off topic. I recognize the fully realized cognative potential of adults and yet support many forms of justified killing. You take simple statements with obvious ramifications and try your best to turn a reductio ad absurdum, but the result is so impressively random and goofy that I feel like you're trying out a new post-modernist style of discussion. You're like a rhetorical dadaist. And each time I read your posts I feel just as cheated as when I spent $15 to see a shoe Yoko Ono put on a table.

You would be much better off attempting to deal with the arguments at hand than straying off topic to make a fool of yourself.

No, I think that is exactly what separates an infant from a cow for the theoretic purposes of this discussion. If I deprive a cow of 2 years of life, I take away 2 years of eating and crapping. If I kill an infant I destroy a being who will eventually become a fully realized man.

Well aside from trivializing cows as animals who merely eat and crap, you're failing to work through the logical consequences of your argument vis-a-vis abortion. You're talking about destroying a being "who will eventually become a fully realized man," so I should think one needs a compelling reason for robbing that person of life, and, taking a phrase seen frequently in the above discussion, his "genetic line."

Furthermore, somehow you seem to think that I'm arguing that it's ok to kill an animal for any reason whatsoever. This is not my point at all, perhaps I have not been clear enough in making it. I described earlier in this post why culling a herd is beneficial for both the herd and the local ecosystem. That is a positive argument in favor of slaughter. I see no such argument to justify the killing of an infant.

You're failing to distinguish between intended consequences and secondary benefits. All too often meat-eaters come on these boards making grand claims about how the consumption of animals benefits us, benefits the animals and benefits the environment. Fine, I am happy to, for the sake of argument, get on board with most of these Panglossian empirical claims, but let's be clear: the main reason these policies are vigorously defended is for self-benefit -- that is, the taste of meat -- which I accord almost zero value. I think the well-being of animals and humans takes precedence, and the integrity of the environment is merely instrumental to these achieving those ends, not an end in itself. So, with all of this in mind, how is herding-for-meat consumption superior to herding (or managing wild animals) for the sake of the ecosystem----> animals/humans?

Perhaps this is all too abstract for you, so let's use a specific scenario:

But let's say the world community of incoherent vegetarians gathers strength and raises massive funds to keep all ranches operating forever without having to sell meat products. Now those grazing environments will be destroyed by animal overpopulation. Either predators will have to be reintroduced to keep the numbers down, a fate for worse for animals than humane slaughter, or the grazing ecosystem will be destroyed. Thus, 2) culling is necessary to maintain the health of the grazing environment.

OK, so let's suppose the entire world goes vegan for reasons of taste, and we no longer wish to eat animals of any kind. You still think it's important to have domesticated herd animals grazing on these lands, taken care of by human beings. If it's necessary, then it's necessary. If you say it's necessary to kill 5 million innocent people, fine, I'll agree for the sake of argument. But surely you do not believe the number of animals necessary to maintain local ecosystems is conducive to a meat-based diet. This is exactly how we should examine the issue -- bracketing out the self-interested human desire to satisfy a taste.

Two simple reasons that I've given multiple times in multiple posts: 1) If we don't kill some number of them and sell the resultant products we cannot continue to tend to the animals' needs. It is expensive to be a rancher.

And this is a lousy argument. It's probably true that people would not give money to poverty relief if not for a U2 benefit concert forwarding proceeds to OxFam. OK... but let's talk about what's moral. (Also, ranchers, at least in the U.S., make ample use of public lands, which requires management and oversight, and people doing all of those jobs could be more productive doing something else somewhere else. The industry exists because of demand for beef, and it would not look anything as it does if we were attempting to deal with environmental problems.)

This other stuff has already been addressed above.

But please, declare victory. I can see the "Mission Accomplished" banner waving in your front yard.

I do not advertise Mission: Easy doings.
 
You write before you think. I thought I said a couple of times that I mis-read your "figurative" post, but it's instructive you would now claim the irrelevance of the idea you were advocating. What IS important is that you had engaged in some "literary tactic," and continually fail to take responsibility for your own murkiness, something that took you several posts to realize, and casually refusing to defend your idea. I do enjoy your over-the-top school boy taunts and the nervous tension, which indicates you have an inferiority complex... one that's not unjustified.

Keep slinking away. If clarification was the issue you would have asked for it from the beginning. Instead you tried to make funny by acusing me of thinking that Paris Hilton took her Chihuahua from the wild. Your initial misdirected hostitlity was annoying, but this born-again feigned reasonability is just pathetic.


Since you for some reason agree my cat example is similar to yours with elephants, we'll discuss that now:

No, you're not understanding it, as suggested by the underlined portions. The descendants likely would not have lived in the wild at all, so it's a mistake to say "that genetic line" or "those cats" would otherwise be facing very different conditions.

You're not doing any better, this is still silly. What do you think "benefit" means? I've given you plenty of analogies that you ignore. The trunkless elephants would likewise be facing very different conditions. They would either go extinct or evolve differently. I can still say that a trunk benefits elephants.

Here's another example involving human innovation. The discovery of fire benefited humans. If our ancestors never discovered how to manipulate fire, the subsequent genetic line would have played out quite differently. We either would have died or developed some other means of survival. Please explain EXACTLY how fire was not beneficial to human survival? Do I need to find a caveman in the modern world and hand him fire in order to understand the positive nature of the discovery?

I'm seriously curious how you think about this issue. Please don't evade it again.


No, the idea is still rushing over your head. As I have maintained, the original being transported from the wild to nature benefits, the metaphorical Adam and Eve -- that is, assuming a rosy view of domesticated life, which I'll be happy to do for the moment. So think of it this way, you can be in prison or you can be a free man. Naturally you, Adam, would prefer to be a free man, and let's say your descendants enjoy a happy and wonderful life. Great. The problem is it's a mistake to say your descendants would have been miserable in prison because, um, you would not have any offspring in prison. I thank you for the excellent example, and I wonder how much sooner you hit upon it than a monkey given a typewriter.

I am astonished that you missed the point of the analogy that badly. The state of being incarcerated is obviously not genetic. Once again, you're absurd literal nature has forced you into a strange, unfortunate position.

The prison example is meant to get to the heart of what you or I mean when we use the word "benefit." With respect to animals in the wild you are arguing that a beast must first live in the wild, then be brought under human care to BENEFIT from human stewardship. This is equally as silly as saying I must first serve time to understand that I benefit from my freedom.

The genetic line analogy would be either the elephant's trunk or man discovering fire. Your intepretation of the prison example fails because, as I said earlier, children do not inheret their parents' criminal record.

But look, let's say a society passed a law that said once a person entered prison they and all of their decendents would be in prison for all time. Thus making prison an inhereted trait like an elephant's trunk or animals domestically raised. Now that the analogy is accurate, I would say the Adam's genetic line benefited ENORMOUSLY should he stay out of prison.

That was an awesome misuse of a simple, simple analogy. You have to break yourself of this literal crap.


The consequence of this is something you have continually failed to address. Assuming this land does need grazing -- or "NEEDS" it, if you prefer -- does this constrain the resources of animals in the wild?

First of all, prairies do need grazing animals. The first article is from research done in a tall-grass prairie 10min from my parents' house. The second is a giant database of citations of articles and studies focused on grassland health, should you wish to read more.

http://news.bio-medicine.org/biology-news-2/Mowing--Grazing-Of-Tall-Grass-Prairie-Increases-14695-1/

http://www.jdburgessonline.com/grazing/research.html

And yes, in many places in the world grazing has negatively impacted wild areas. This is merely the result of historical bad practices. Just like we fixed the poor farming habits that exacerbated the Dust Bowl in the 30's, we now understand how and where to use grazing appropriately. A great percentage of North America's land mass needs grazing to be healthy. Those plains held 60 million or more buffalo before the 18th and 19th centuries. Grazing is the wild state of that land.

So obviously we should stop grazing where, for example, in impinges on the rain forests in Brazil, but it should be expanded in the Great Plains.

Why not manage wild animals, culling them if necessary?

This would be my choice for the best way to go forward. The Konza Prairie near Manhattan, KS (referenced in that article above) has a herd of managed buffalo. Every year they cull a certain number to keep the group and land healthy. They reinvest the procedes from the meat sale into land management and research. This would be the ideal model.

But, of course, that means we have to do something with the millions of cattle. Though cattle aren't as good for the ecosystem as buffalo (they graze differently), free ranging is a solid solution. That still means killing a certain number, reintroducing predators, or letting them destroy the grassland. Seems that slaughter is the best choice.

I think you're misunderstanding again. When I said keep them as pets, referred to Volatile's post, we meant keep your practices idyllic herding practices exactly the same, but just don't kill them. You don't need to name them, or play with them.

That doesn't escape the ethical issue. If you don't keep the numbers of the herd down both the local ecosystem and the animals themselves suffer. Look what has happened with the deer population in many parts of the country. They are overgrazing, killing young trees and other plant life, and have become weaker and more diseased. It is better both for the animals and the environment to control numbers. This means reintroducing predators or culling.


You're right -- it's "HILARIOUS." Hahaha, I just get a chuckle thinking about it -- double-rapid fire knee-slapper. Oh, you. Stop with the zingers.

I don't think you read that part very closely.



Well aside from trivializing cows as animals who merely eat and crap, you're failing to work through the logical consequences of your argument vis-a-vis abortion. You're talking about destroying a being "who will eventually become a fully realized man," so I should think one needs a compelling reason for robbing that person of life, and, taking a phrase seen frequently in the above discussion, his "genetic line."

Of course I need a compelling reason. I would advance the needs of the mother of the pre-sentient bundle of cells as sufficient. As the fetus' ability to survive on its own increases, the importnace of the mother's needs (save if her life is threatened) decrease. We can go back and forth on the specifics, but we are in agreement that a compelling reason must be given to justify abortion, thus it is an irrelevent issue.

And please, provide me evidence of the majestic mental life of a cow.

You're failing to distinguish between intended consequences and secondary benefits. All too often meat-eaters come on these boards making grand claims about how the consumption of animals benefits us, benefits the animals and benefits the environment. Fine, I am happy to, for the sake of argument, get on board with most of these Panglossian empirical claims, but let's be clear: the main reason these policies are vigorously defended is for self-benefit -- that is, the taste of meat -- which I accord almost zero value. I think the well-being of animals and humans takes precedence, and the integrity of the environment is merely instrumental to these achieving those ends, not an end in itself. So, with all of this in mind, how is herding-for-meat consumption superior to herding (or managing wild animals) for the sake of the ecosystem----> animals/humans?

Humans evolved to enjoy meat. We used to need it to survive. Now we don't. Thus, to justify the continued eating of meat there must be a good reason. Raising, controlling, and slaughtering meat-providing animals is good for both the animals themselves (better health, generally longer life-spans, humane deaths) and better for the environment. So when I choose to indulge my genetically bread tastes I am causing no harm. I see no compelling reason to stop.

This point continues to escape you. In order to appropriately manage a herd of animals and the ecosystem they live in you must kill a certain number of animals. You kill too many, the herd dies; you kill too few the ecosystem struggles and the animals eventually suffer from starvation and disease. Proper stewardship of the land REQUIRES slaughter.


OK, so let's suppose the entire world goes vegan for reasons of taste, and we no longer wish to eat animals of any kind. You still think it's important to have domesticated herd animals grazing on these lands, taken care of by human beings. If it's necessary, then it's necessary. If you say it's necessary to kill 5 million innocent people, fine, I'll agree for the sake of argument. But surely you do not believe the number of animals necessary to maintain local ecosystems is conducive to a meat-based diet. This is exactly how we should examine the issue -- bracketing out the self-interested human desire to satisfy a taste.

More silliness. This is the devout hypocricy. You constantly whine about the tone of my posts, and yet you toss in killing 5 million people for no apparant reason. I'll put that in the same category as the useless reference to baby-eating.

Again, the number of animals that the Great Plains of North America can hold is mind-boggling. That being said, who knows how the numbers would actually work out. It's entirely possible that the current level of meat consumption couldn't be sustained, but it's entirely likely that it could. We would have to move to a fully range-fed system to ever know, but this isn't an argument about the proper amount of meat to eat, it's about eating meat as a moral issue. I know all my meat needs are met by free-range ranches.


And this is a lousy argument. It's probably true that people would not give money to poverty relief if not for a U2 benefit concert forwarding proceeds to OxFam. OK... but let's talk about what's moral. (Also, ranchers, at least in the U.S., make ample use of public lands, which requires management and oversight, and people doing all of those jobs could be more productive doing something else somewhere else. The industry exists because of demand for beef, and it would not look anything as it does if we were attempting to deal with environmental problems.)

Did you not finish that statement? It seemed as though you had something more to say after the extended parenthetical.

The practical details can be ironed out. Here's an interesting idea that deals with both humane animal treatment and the economy:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_Commons

But again, for humans to expend energy taking care of animals their must be some reimbursement. I am curious what you think should happen to the millions of domesticated cows. If we don't eat them, we won't have any money to care for them. They aren't like buffalo, they've been bread for docility, so letting them go free is a cruel idea. What should we do according to your morality?
 
Take care of them, let them die of old age, and don't breed a new generation.

Hey, whaddya know, I solved the supposed crisis.

Anyone got a cigar?
 
Take care of them, let them die of old age, and don't breed a new generation.

Hey, whaddya know, I solved the supposed crisis.

Anyone got a cigar?

Ok, then what do you do with all the grazing ecosystems? If you replaced the cattle with buffalo I'm all for it.

Where are you going to get the funds to take care of theses animals (provide medicine, fend off predators, give them those big salt-licks...etc.)?

Also, a death from old age or disease is going to involve more suffering than a humane slaughter. So if you're trying to limit suffering, you're making the wrong decision.

Are you going to sterilize the animals of breeding age? If depriving them of life is a harm, certainly depriving them of their genetic need to reproduce is a harm.

The problem is one of anthropomorphism. You think that the golden years of a cow's life are like the golden years of a human's. If you just want them to cease to exist under human control, the method that causes the least suffering would be to slaughter all of them.
 
Last edited:
Where are you going to get the funds to take care of theses animals (provide medicine, fend off predators, give them those big salt-licks...etc.)?
Oh yeah, we have a BIG problem with that now.

We can't support our cows now, nosirree... at least, not if we let them live a few more years on until old age! :D

Seriously, if you believe that we can't support the system NOW, why are we even talking about this?

Also, a death from old age or disease is going to involve more suffering than a humane slaughter. So if you're trying to limit suffering, you're making the wrong decision.
Heh.

Are you going to sterilize the animals of breeding age? If depriving them of life is a harm, certainly depriving them of their genetic need to reproduce is a harm.
lol :rolleyes:

The problem is one of anthropomorphism.

Right, and constituting the "genetic need to reproduce" as a harm isn't anthropomorphism at all. :rolleyes:

You think that the golden years of a cow's life are like the golden years of a human's. If you just want them to cease to exist under human control, the method that causes the least suffering would be to slaughter all of them.

Sure. But as long as they exist in the numbers that they're in, they constitute damage to the environment. So you're saying we humanely slaughter all of them now, and not breed in a new generation.

Well hot damn, okay. We go with your plan.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom