You write before you think. I thought I said a couple of times that I mis-read your "figurative" post, but it's instructive you would now claim the irrelevance of the idea you were advocating. What IS important is that you had engaged in some "literary tactic," and continually fail to take responsibility for your own murkiness, something that took you several posts to realize, and casually refusing to defend your idea. I do enjoy your over-the-top school boy taunts and the nervous tension, which indicates you have an inferiority complex... one that's not unjustified.
Keep slinking away. If clarification was the issue you would have asked for it from the beginning. Instead you tried to make funny by acusing me of thinking that Paris Hilton took her Chihuahua from the wild. Your initial misdirected hostitlity was annoying, but this born-again feigned reasonability is just pathetic.
Since you for some reason agree my cat example is similar to yours with elephants, we'll discuss that now:
No, you're not understanding it, as suggested by the underlined portions. The descendants likely would not have lived in the wild at all, so it's a mistake to say "that genetic line" or "those cats" would otherwise be facing very different conditions.
You're not doing any better, this is still silly. What do you think "benefit" means? I've given you plenty of analogies that you ignore. The trunkless elephants would likewise be facing very different conditions. They would either go extinct or evolve differently. I can still say that a trunk benefits elephants.
Here's another example involving human innovation. The discovery of fire benefited humans. If our ancestors never discovered how to manipulate fire, the subsequent genetic line would have played out quite differently. We either would have died or developed some other means of survival. Please explain EXACTLY how fire was not beneficial to human survival? Do I need to find a caveman in the modern world and hand him fire in order to understand the positive nature of the discovery?
I'm seriously curious how you think about this issue. Please don't evade it again.
No, the idea is still rushing over your head. As I have maintained, the original being transported from the wild to nature benefits, the metaphorical Adam and Eve -- that is, assuming a rosy view of domesticated life, which I'll be happy to do for the moment. So think of it this way, you can be in prison or you can be a free man. Naturally you, Adam, would prefer to be a free man, and let's say your descendants enjoy a happy and wonderful life. Great. The problem is it's a mistake to say your descendants would have been miserable in prison because, um, you would not have any offspring in prison. I thank you for the excellent example, and I wonder how much sooner you hit upon it than a monkey given a typewriter.
I am astonished that you missed the point of the analogy that badly. The state of being incarcerated is obviously not genetic. Once again, you're absurd literal nature has forced you into a strange, unfortunate position.
The prison example is meant to get to the heart of what you or I mean when we use the word "benefit." With respect to animals in the wild you are arguing that a beast must first live in the wild, then be brought under human care to BENEFIT from human stewardship. This is equally as silly as saying I must first serve time to understand that I benefit from my freedom.
The genetic line analogy would be either the elephant's trunk or man discovering fire. Your intepretation of the prison example fails because, as I said earlier, children do not inheret their parents' criminal record.
But look, let's say a society passed a law that said once a person entered prison they and all of their decendents would be in prison for all time. Thus making prison an inhereted trait like an elephant's trunk or animals domestically raised. Now that the analogy is accurate, I would say the Adam's genetic line benefited ENORMOUSLY should he stay out of prison.
That was an awesome misuse of a simple, simple analogy. You have to break yourself of this literal crap.
The consequence of this is something you have continually failed to address. Assuming this land does need grazing -- or "NEEDS" it, if you prefer -- does this constrain the resources of animals in the wild?
First of all, prairies do need grazing animals. The first article is from research done in a tall-grass prairie 10min from my parents' house. The second is a giant database of citations of articles and studies focused on grassland health, should you wish to read more.
http://news.bio-medicine.org/biology-news-2/Mowing--Grazing-Of-Tall-Grass-Prairie-Increases-14695-1/
http://www.jdburgessonline.com/grazing/research.html
And yes, in many places in the world grazing has negatively impacted wild areas. This is merely the result of historical bad practices. Just like we fixed the poor farming habits that exacerbated the Dust Bowl in the 30's, we now understand how and where to use grazing appropriately. A great percentage of North America's land mass needs grazing to be healthy. Those plains held 60 million or more buffalo before the 18th and 19th centuries. Grazing is the wild state of that land.
So obviously we should stop grazing where, for example, in impinges on the rain forests in Brazil, but it should be expanded in the Great Plains.
Why not manage wild animals, culling them if necessary?
This would be my choice for the best way to go forward. The Konza Prairie near Manhattan, KS (referenced in that article above) has a herd of managed buffalo. Every year they cull a certain number to keep the group and land healthy. They reinvest the procedes from the meat sale into land management and research. This would be the ideal model.
But, of course, that means we have to do something with the millions of cattle. Though cattle aren't as good for the ecosystem as buffalo (they graze differently), free ranging is a solid solution. That still means killing a certain number, reintroducing predators, or letting them destroy the grassland. Seems that slaughter is the best choice.
I think you're misunderstanding again. When I said keep them as pets, referred to Volatile's post, we meant keep your practices idyllic herding practices exactly the same, but just don't kill them. You don't need to name them, or play with them.
That doesn't escape the ethical issue. If you don't keep the numbers of the herd down both the local ecosystem and the animals themselves suffer. Look what has happened with the deer population in many parts of the country. They are overgrazing, killing young trees and other plant life, and have become weaker and more diseased. It is better both for the animals and the environment to control numbers. This means reintroducing predators or culling.
You're right -- it's "HILARIOUS." Hahaha, I just get a chuckle thinking about it -- double-rapid fire knee-slapper. Oh, you. Stop with the zingers.
I don't think you read that part very closely.
Well aside from trivializing cows as animals who merely eat and crap, you're failing to work through the logical consequences of your argument vis-a-vis abortion. You're talking about destroying a being "who will eventually become a fully realized man," so I should think one needs a compelling reason for robbing that person of life, and, taking a phrase seen frequently in the above discussion, his "genetic line."
Of course I need a compelling reason. I would advance the needs of the mother of the pre-sentient bundle of cells as sufficient. As the fetus' ability to survive on its own increases, the importnace of the mother's needs (save if her life is threatened) decrease. We can go back and forth on the specifics, but we are in agreement that a compelling reason must be given to justify abortion, thus it is an irrelevent issue.
And please, provide me evidence of the majestic mental life of a cow.
You're failing to distinguish between intended consequences and secondary benefits. All too often meat-eaters come on these boards making grand claims about how the consumption of animals benefits us, benefits the animals and benefits the environment. Fine, I am happy to, for the sake of argument, get on board with most of these Panglossian empirical claims, but let's be clear: the main reason these policies are vigorously defended is for self-benefit -- that is, the taste of meat -- which I accord almost zero value. I think the well-being of animals and humans takes precedence, and the integrity of the environment is merely instrumental to these achieving those ends, not an end in itself. So, with all of this in mind, how is herding-for-meat consumption superior to herding (or managing wild animals) for the sake of the ecosystem----> animals/humans?
Humans evolved to enjoy meat. We used to need it to survive. Now we don't. Thus, to justify the continued eating of meat there must be a good reason. Raising, controlling, and slaughtering meat-providing animals is good for both the animals themselves (better health, generally longer life-spans, humane deaths) and better for the environment. So when I choose to indulge my genetically bread tastes I am causing no harm. I see no compelling reason to stop.
This point continues to escape you. In order to appropriately manage a herd of animals and the ecosystem they live in you must kill a certain number of animals. You kill too many, the herd dies; you kill too few the ecosystem struggles and the animals eventually suffer from starvation and disease. Proper stewardship of the land REQUIRES slaughter.
OK, so let's suppose the entire world goes vegan for reasons of taste, and we no longer wish to eat animals of any kind. You still think it's important to have domesticated herd animals grazing on these lands, taken care of by human beings. If it's necessary, then it's necessary. If you say it's necessary to kill 5 million innocent people, fine, I'll agree for the sake of argument. But surely you do not believe the number of animals necessary to maintain local ecosystems is conducive to a meat-based diet. This is exactly how we should examine the issue -- bracketing out the self-interested human desire to satisfy a taste.
More silliness. This is the devout hypocricy. You constantly whine about the tone of my posts, and yet you toss in killing 5 million people for no apparant reason. I'll put that in the same category as the useless reference to baby-eating.
Again, the number of animals that the Great Plains of North America can hold is mind-boggling. That being said, who knows how the numbers would actually work out. It's entirely possible that the current level of meat consumption couldn't be sustained, but it's entirely likely that it could. We would have to move to a fully range-fed system to ever know, but this isn't an argument about the proper amount of meat to eat, it's about eating meat as a moral issue. I know all my meat needs are met by free-range ranches.
And this is a lousy argument. It's probably true that people would not give money to poverty relief if not for a U2 benefit concert forwarding proceeds to OxFam. OK... but let's talk about what's moral. (Also, ranchers, at least in the U.S., make ample use of public lands, which requires management and oversight, and people doing all of those jobs could be more productive doing something else somewhere else. The industry exists because of demand for beef, and it would not look anything as it does if we were attempting to deal with environmental problems.)
Did you not finish that statement? It seemed as though you had something more to say after the extended parenthetical.
The practical details can be ironed out. Here's an interesting idea that deals with both humane animal treatment and the economy:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffalo_Commons
But again, for humans to expend energy taking care of animals their must be some reimbursement. I am curious what you think should happen to the millions of domesticated cows. If we don't eat them, we won't have any money to care for them. They aren't like buffalo, they've been bread for docility, so letting them go free is a cruel idea. What should we do according to your morality?