1) OK, so Paris Hilton did not save her dog from nature. Taking that explicit position can you now explain your original offending remark, which I reproduce here:
I, as a farmer/rancher, have exerted my unique human gifts to remove animals from the unmitigated horror of nature and tend to their needs.
How are your self-described noble efforts different than Hilton's?
2) Ah, so nomadic hunter-gatherers saved Chihuahuas from the "dangerous existence of nature." Do you think about these things before you say them because it's rare to find such a bad case of foot-mouth disease, even on these forums. Chihuahuas would not exist if not for the intervention of human beings. Please, if you're going to attempt to condescend at least have the dignity of not being spectacularly wrong.
On why nature works as a moral baseline:
3) So here we have three sentences. The first is your original claim, the second is my counter and the third is your new counter-counter and I'm afraid I cannot characterize it in favorable terms. Here's the thing: even with domestication there are still animals in the wild, suffering. You need to somehow demonstrate that animals are somehow transported from the ravages of the wild onto your utopian free-range farm; that free-range farming serves as, well, a welfare program. What you're saying is just too obtuse for words.
4) It's already been mentioned a couple of times. Do you recall where Volatile said you could raise animals as pets? If domestication is so good for the environment and sustainability, then we could form a cooperative pact. Of course, that sounds ridiculous because it is: the real reason animals are domesticated is not to provide them a refuge, not to maintain the balance of ecosystems, but to slaughter and consume them.
Some of what follows is in Volatile's above reply, but I'll make a few comments, ask a couple of questions.
5) I did not say killing Jones causes "suffering"; I said it "constitutes a harm." I don't see how the bone cancer scenario helps your case, or what case you're trying to make. I would like to know how and what "higher faculties" are morally necessary for what I'll call a right-to-life. This standard of yours introduces problems you probably did not anticipate: the status of mentally disabled humans, children, fetuses. I'm not sure how you can so glibly privilege the "higher faculties" you seem to resent, but let's imagine two scenarios for Jones and his immediate interests. One involves presenting a lecture on justice-as-impartiality and the other involves ****ing a Brazilian supermodel's brains out. After doing each which do you think Jones is more likely to remark, "I could die happy"?
Now, now, don't get a big dick, I'll agree a life of deep meaning is -- for lack of a better word -- more meaningful than one based on, um, base pleasures. The film Groundhog Day makes a convincing enough case. But what you're saying is that the pleasures experienced and anticipated by non-humans are trivial, which somehow empowers you to kill them to satisfy more exalted ends, such as enjoying a hamburger. That's hubris. It's also arbitrary because for some reason you lend significant weight to animal suffering. Interests are a two-way street. Why should I give a crap about cow's pain?
What kind of plans are necessary? I'm pretty sure babies (and most toddlers?) don't have plans, so are they fair game?
Haha, funny stuff indeed.
1) I didn't realize I was dealing with a literalist, I apologize for taking artistic liberty, I thought I was speaking with reasonably well educated adults. I will not make that mistake again.
You may be shocked to learn that I am not actually a rancher, gasp.
I was speaking in a figurative sense. The concept of ranching, tending to animals puts humans in the place of caretaker over their flock. That flock came to be what it is over thousands of years. Without human intervention those animals that became domesticated would have continued to have off-spring, and those decendents would have been wild. Any domesticated animal (forgot you were a literalist--any domesticated animal treated humanely) is therefore better off because humans chose, long ago, to use their higher faculties to give those beasts a better life.
The other option to domestication is to simply never interfere. This would mean that ALL animals are wild. Observe two hypothetical worlds, one where animals are domesticated, one where they aren't. In the world of domestication animals will, in general, fair better than the world with no domestication. Yes, we humans, as arrogant as it may sound, have rescued a good many beasts from cruel, arbitrary nature. The fact that a specific animal, say Paris Hilton's dog, would not exist in the hypothetical world without domestication, whatever genetic lineage that led to the domesticated chihuahua would have led to a wild animal suffering in the wild.
2) This point reveals your simple, literal mind. The bluster with which you vomit out this childish tripe, however, is quite amusing. This point was answered in 1.
3) A rancher has no duty to care for animals in the wild, save to try and do as little harm as possible to the habitat. That wild animals should suffer says nothing about how we should treat animals we have chosen to care for. Ranchers have no control over birds of prey, they have control over their herd. That caretaker position bestows the responsibility.
Again your literal mind has you fluttering. If you only understand the domestication process in terms of the present, it may not make sense. But those animals were domesticated over thousands of years. If they hadn't been domesticate, that entire genetic line would have existed in the wild. Instead, it was cared for by humans.
Your point isn't even relevent, but you did prove to everyone that you can count to three, so I guess we'll count that as a victory for you.
4) Never did I say animals were domesticated BECAUSE we wanted to take care of them. I'm arguing simply that their domestication was immensely beneficial when compared with a world similar in all ways save a lack of domestication. We do make a pact with animals. We improve their lives, keep them fed, cure their diseases, and in turn, we eat them. The animals have no concept of the coming slaughter, so they don't suffer at all. It is only from an omnipotent perspective that it even makes sense to say they've been harmed, but no cow or any animal save a human can understand that perspective. They eat, crap, eat, crap, then the lights go out.
5) Hmm, I'm not as dumb as you, so I did actually anticipate that charge. I just guessed, "what would a third grader or Carlos Mencia argue here," and sure enough it was you bringing up your fellow tards.
Infants have the potential to become humans. Human life is more valuable than a cow's life for the same reason a cow's life is more valuable than a carrot's. Killing a helpless infant does deprive them of a future. Killing a cow means they have one year less of eating, crapping, eating, crapping. The difference is simply brain function.
Ah, now you're excited. I could practically see you spill your bowl of fiber sticks in soy milk. Why don't we kill mentally disabled people then? First of all, most special needs people haver higher functioning brains than cattle, but that's not the interesting case. What about seriously disabled people that can't function at all? This is simply a societal norm that needs no justification. We have decided that they share enough genetic material with humans that we should care for them. If, on the other hand, we decided to euthanize completely non-functioning humans, I wouldn't really have a problem with that. Of course I would leave it up to that person's caretaker to decide what to do.
So you've played a semantic game, falling back on a concept of "harm" that doesn't include suffering. Please explain why I should care that a creature has been deprived of something it has no concept for.