Is vegetarianism arbitrary?

The only thing I would disagree with here is the idea that the construct is "arbitrary."

Just the description. Try "arbitrary within each society's construct". Groups for a moral code by majority and place arbitrary lines where immorality exists.

If by this you mean to say that 0 = 0, then I agree. However, these actions could then be said to be euivalent to any action which directly or indirectly causes the breakage of chemical bonds, either immediately or after a delay.

Yep. Just that.
 
Just the description. Try "arbitrary within each society's construct". Groups for a moral code by majority and place arbitrary lines where immorality exists.

I disagree. The place where those lines are drawn is heavily dependent on the circumstances of the culture. Pre-civilized societies were largely egalitarian. They drew the lines of appropriate behavior based on an immediate need to survive. Everyone had to participate. Compare that with heavily ritualistic societies like feudal Europe or Kamakura Japan. Rules of honor and engagement derived from the power structure.

It may be that we're simply having a semantic disagreement, but I can't think of a single example of a moral or ethical system that isn't logically (at least in retrospect) based on social and environmental circumstances.
 
Obvious even though you won't be able to articulate a coherent explanation of why veganism is morally superior. Ignore the easy case of feed-lots, nobody likes those. Explain how a vegan lifestyle is preferable to eating cared for animals that are humanely slaughtered.

I also have to wonder what these people use for shoes, wallets, belts, cosmetics etc etc.
 
I also have to wonder what these people use for shoes, wallets, belts, cosmetics etc etc.
So impossible to use non-leather belts! http://www.vegetarianbelts.com/unisex.html I mean, whenever I go shopping, I only see lines and lines of leather... oh wait no. There's plenty of non-leather belts, even amongst non-vegan sources. Wonder where you have to be to think they don't exist at all?

As for shoes, are sneakers really made of leather? Didn't know. Anyways: http://meganmcardle.theatlantic.com/archives/2008/06/vegan_shoes_the_decidedly_nond.php

As for cosmetics, there's definitely cosmetics that were not animal-tested (personally, I don't get much of the point for testing cosmetics on animals; I can understand biomedical concerns, but cosmetics? Guess you really need that eyeliner or jellyfish juice pumped into your lips...)

And, at the risk of belaboring my point, one can search in here for wallets: http://www.alternativeoutfitters.com/apparel/accessories/vegan-wallets.aspx

Hell, I'm not even a vegan, and I found this stuff with a second's worth of googling. The more I hear from the supposedly-superior anti-vegans, the more I want to become vegan...
 
It may be that we're simply having a semantic disagreement,...

I'd say so, because:

...but I can't think of a single example of a moral or ethical system that isn't logically (at least in retrospect) based on social and environmental circumstances.

That's what I'm saying.

I must check out my colloquial usage meter.

Good name you have - I had "Train Wreck" as a custom title for about a year.
 
Obvious even though you won't be able to articulate a coherent explanation of why veganism is morally superior. Ignore the easy case of feed-lots, nobody likes those. Explain how a vegan lifestyle is preferable to eating cared for animals that are humanely slaughtered.

Search for posts by me with the word "vegan" in them - I've laid out the case in excruciating detail in other threads.

To sum it up - veganism is the only dietary choice that is compatible with my other moral positions regarding animals (that they should not be harmed without good reason).

IMHO, non-dogmatic veganism is just about the only "rational" diet when you consider all the options (ethics, environmental impact, health concerns), unless you are able to be totally self sufficient. If you buy food that other people have produced, veganism it is.
 
Last edited:
I have to eat to live. Fewer animals die should I eat a plant based diet rather than an omnivorous one. A non-perfect vegan diet is better than one that does not even try.

This is obvious if you think about if for more than a microsecond.
It's not obvious to me.

You need to eat 2,500Kcal a day (say). You can get that from plants, animals, or a combination of both.

We know that harvesting plants causes animal deaths. We also know they these deaths are concentrated in the small mammals - rodents and such.

We also know that meat eating is concentrated in the large mammels - cows and such. I can get, what, 50 meals (pure guess) from one cow?

Since a vegan is not eating cow or other large mammal by products (milk, cheese), to meet their need for 2,500kcal they need to eat more plants to make up for it.

The question becomes: how many lives given per kcal in plants vs. animals?

I don't know the answer, but it is not obvious to me after a mere microsecond. Certainly the vegan choice leads to less mass of animal killed per kcal, but # of lives? Not obvious to me - I would have to see the numbers. How many insects die? Should they be included in the death count - are they "important" by your measure?

And then there is the related issue that the plant diet means killing animals that existed regardless of your dietary choice, whereas a meat diet means another animal got to live (the vastest majority of cows would not exist if they were not intended for human use).

Hey, I understand and respect your choices - but it is not clear at all that a vegan diet is "better".

If you have the numbers of # of deaths per kcal in agriculture, I'd love to see them.

edit: this post is motivated by statements (which I don't know if they are true or not), that any processed food we get inevitably contain body parts of insects and rodents. If true, it would seem the # of lives lost for plant harvesting exceeds the # of lives for meat. But, I want to see the numbers.
 
Last edited:
Search for posts by me with the word "vegan" in them - I've laid out the case in excruciating detail in other threads.

To sum it up - veganism is the only dietary choice that is compatible with my other moral positions regarding animals (that they should not be harmed without good reason).

IMHO, non-dogmatic veganism is just about the only "rational" diet when you consider all the options (ethics, environmental impact, health concerns), unless you are able to be totally self sufficient. If you buy food that other people have produced, veganism it is.

Well, I scrolled through a number of threads you posted in, but I was unable to find anything resembling an answer to this question:

I, as a farmer/rancher, have exerted my unique human gifts to remove animals from the unmitigated horror of nature and tend to their needs. In nature the animals would starve, die alone and terrified from a slight injury, suffer from disease, and generally live short lives frought with danger. When they are under my care I keep them safe from predators, heal their wounds, cure their diseases, and ensure that they are well fed. In exchange for that gift I humanely slaughter members of the herd which both allows me to eat well and also keep the population of the animals down, ensuring better health for all.

I would love to hear an explanation of how that is immoral. And to forestall the easy answer, I will fight along side any vego-nihilist-tight pants clad activist to destroy feed-lots and other inhumane treatment of animals.
 
edit: this post is motivated by statements (which I don't know if they are true or not), that any processed food we get inevitably contain body parts of insects and rodents. If true, it would seem the # of lives lost for plant harvesting exceeds the # of lives for meat. But, I want to see the numbers.

Your argument fails because it does not account for the fact that the deaths involved in killing your one cow for food is not, sadly, one. Cows eat - guess what - plants, which must be harvested / tended. I bet you that fewer animals are killed per calorie for plant harvesting than raising livestock.

Also - is this simply a numbers game? Is killing a cow directly the same as killing a field mouse indirectly? I don't happen to think so.

Now, I'm all for reduction in animal deaths in the production of my food, But obviously some deaths will occur. The question then becomes a more complex moral one, which has been discussed at length in other threads.

Can I ask you - are you, in principle, in agreement with laws which prohibit cruelty to animals?
 
Well, I scrolled through a number of threads you posted in, but I was unable to find anything resembling an answer to this question:

Here's my basic case for my rational veganism:

I became vegan because I examined diet sceptically. First, I stopped asking why vegetarians were vegetarian and instead turned the question on myself. The real sceptical question seemed to be "Why did I eat meat?"


I found I couldn't really answer that question, as I had never given my dietary choices any serious thought. They were as ingrained, and as unquestioned, as my earlier, lazy theism was. I had simply never sat down and weighed up the relative benefits of each possible dietary choice, starting from a neutral position. I don't think many people have.

So, that's what I did. I started to list the reasons why I should choose meat eating over vegetarianism. I couldn't think of a single one, other than "Meat tastes good", and that wasn't enough. I'll guide you through my thought process:

1) Health. Is vegetarianism / veganism "healthier" than an omnivourous one? Even if it isn't, it's at least as healthy, according to the ADA. There are lots of studies pointing out the relative health risks of red meat, processed meat and all the rest, but dietary studies are notoriously unreliable, so let's leave that aside and assume that the ADA is right and cutting animal products out of your life is at least not harmful. Of course, you need to eat a balanced diet, but even omnivores don't always achieve this.

2) Environment. "Livestock are responsible for 18 percent of greenhouse-gas emissions as measured in carbon dioxide equivalent, reports the FAO. This includes 9 percent of all CO2 emissions, 37 percent of methane, and 65 percent of nitrous oxide. Altogether, that's more than the emissions caused by transportation." and "70% of all grains grown in the US are fed directly to farm animals, unnecessarily adding enormous levels of pesticides, herbicides, and petrochemical fertilizers to the Earth year after year, and consuming more fresh water than any other human endeavor." (Source). It seems to me that meat consumption is more harmful to the environment than the alternative, plant-based diet. There are plenty of other ways this is borne out, particularly when you consider how wasteful it is to grow food to feed to cows to then eat! See also: over-fishing.

3) Animal suffering. I am not dogmatic or evangelical about this, and I do not believe that a) it is always wrong to kill animals, b) that animals and humans are equivalent or c) that killing animals for food is metaphysically, or morally, wrong. Nevertheless, I believe it is undoubtedly the case that animals do suffer in the production of food. Cows, pigs and chickens all feel pain. I wouldn't kill a cat or a dog or a horse for food, and so I believe that if avoiding animal suffering for other species is possible, it should be pursued wherever possible. This seems to be at least a generally tenable position given laws on animal cruelty etc. If I can live as healthily as I can on a meat based diet, but eliminate unnecessary suffering, then why shouldn't I? In this sense (and in many others), veganism just seems a sensible extension of my broader ethical stance.

4) Convenience. As I said, I am not dogmatic about my veganism, and I am certain that in some cases, having a small-holding and being self-sufficient is a "better" choice. Nevertheless, I buy my food at stores. I do not hunt, or grow my own vegetables. If the soy milk and the regular milk are right next to each other on the shelf, why should I pick the animal milk, given points 1, 2 and 3 above? If the dairy free and the real mayonnaise are right next to each other on the shelf and pretty much indistinguishable from each other, why pick the animal product given 1, 2 and 3 above?

Now, don't get me wrong - I love the taste of meat. It's just that, having considered the relative merits of both diets, I can't justify eating it. I also love driving my car really fast, but I don't because my personal preferences aren't always sufficient to justify potentially harmful behaviour. And in any case, I'm not starving or denying myself anything at all. There are vegan alternative and analogues to pretty much everything these days.

People always ask me why I'm vegan. I always turn it round and ask them why they eat meat, because when I asked myself that question I never had the answer. It's just about thinking about the way you live your life, and why you hold the beliefs you do. In my humble opinion, non-dogmatic veganism is the logical and rational dietary choice; though if anyone can make the case as to why I should eat meat, please do.


I, as a farmer/rancher, have exerted my unique human gifts to remove animals from the unmitigated horror of nature and tend to their needs. In nature the animals would starve, die alone and terrified from a slight injury, suffer from disease, and generally live short lives frought with danger. When they are under my care I keep them safe from predators, heal their wounds, cure their diseases, and ensure that they are well fed. In exchange for that gift I humanely slaughter members of the herd which both allows me to eat well and also keep the population of the animals down, ensuring better health for all.
So you care for them really, really well, right up until you get hungry?

if it was indeed your intention to "remove them from the unmitigated horror of nature", then you would keep them as pets until they died of old age. Your arguments that yours is a compassionate act do not hold water, given that your definition of compassion includes needless slaughter - and it is needless, because you could survive quite well without meat and you could keep the population numbers down by taking sterilisation measures. Yours is an enormously flawed argument, and it is internally inconsistent.

I would love to hear an explanation of how that is immoral. And to forestall the easy answer, I will fight along side any vego-nihilist-tight pants clad activist to destroy feed-lots and other inhumane treatment of animals.
It is immoral only because it is inconsistent with what I presume is your more general moral code - that you consider it immoral to harm or kill animals unnecessarily. It is immoral only by the more general standards with which you approach ethical questions of animals. You wouldn't kick a cat, or slit the throat of a dog, or boil a bald eagle alive, just for fun. Why not?
 
Your argument fails because it does not account for the fact that the deaths involved in killing your one cow for food is not, sadly, one. Cows eat - guess what - plants, which must be harvested / tended. I bet you that fewer animals are killed per calorie for plant harvesting than raising livestock.
How does a question fail? Cows around here are free grazers. In any case, I don't know the answer, do you? I wouldn't be surprised if your guess was correct, but I also wouldn't be suprised if it was wrong.

Also - is this simply a numbers game? Is killing a cow directly the same as killing a field mouse indirectly? I don't happen to think so.
That's for each person to decide - again, not a matter of "obviousness" after a microsecond of thought, which was your claim. Speaking for myself, I find the question undecidable - it's that un-obvious to me. I offered an argument that is preferable to kill a cow directly than a field mouse indirectly, which I'm guessing is the opposite of your conclusion (I don't know your conclusion here).


Can I ask you - are you, in principle, in agreement with laws which prohibit cruelty to animals?
Yes. I don't know where you are going with this, but I don't consider it cruel to raise animals for food, especially since they would not live at all if not raised for food. That presupposes humane conditions, naturally.
 
Well, I don't happen to think that "a field mouse might have died" to have the same weight as "a cow has definitely died". But I guess we can agree to disagree on that, particularly as my argument for veganism doesn't particularly rely on "less animals die" for support.

Yes. I don't know where you are going with this, but I don't consider it cruel to raise animals for food, especially since they would not live at all if not raised for food. That presupposes humane conditions, naturally.

OK, good.

You support laws which prevent cruelty to animals - the infliction of harm or suffering on them for no good reason. So the next question is: do you consider killing to be a form of "harm", and do you consider "I like the taste of meat" to be a good reason?

Note - this isn't about the raising of animals, which is not necessarily inherently cruel, but the simple fact of killing them (even "humanely", whatever that means) to satisfy a whim, which I contend is.

What is the difference between randomly killing a wild animal for sadistic pleasure, and deliberately killing a captive one for the pleasure of taste?
 
Okay, and to support my contention that body count is not obvious, a moment of googling showed that this is a hot and heavy topic in veganism. To wit, here is a link to a Steven Davis (Department of Animal Sciences, Oregon State University) arguing that we should eat large herbivores to cause least harm:
http://www.springerlink.com/content/r1277l2428v10637/

A rebuttal:
http://www.veganoutreach.org/enewsletter/matheny.html

Now, I haven't read these articles, and am not championing one over the other as correct. However, it's clear the topic is far from obvious. Hand picked organic vegetables vs chickens crammed in cages with manure feeding directly into streams will yield one result. Fully industrialized, heavily pesticized farming vs free range cattle will likely lead to a different result.
 
Now, I haven't read these articles, and am not championing one over the other as correct. However, it's clear the topic is far from obvious. Hand picked organic vegetables vs chickens crammed in cages with manure feeding directly into streams will yield one result. Fully industrialized, heavily pesticized farming vs free range cattle will likely lead to a different result.

Thanks for those links. The rebuttal addresses the key concern I mentioned above - that per calorie (or per consumer) - there are still fewer animal deaths.

The links the rebuttal provides to the various philosophical cases for vegetarianism are worth reading if you are interested; Singer and Regan are both very good books.
 
I, as a farmer/rancher, have exerted my unique human gifts to remove animals from the unmitigated horror of nature and tend to their needs. In nature the animals would starve, die alone and terrified from a slight injury, suffer from disease, and generally live short lives frought with danger.

This line of ******** always amazes me. Are you going out into nature and and raising animals you have personally rescued? If not then animals in "nature" have nothing to thank you for, except possibly encroaching upon their land and contributing to global warming. Those animals still endure injury and suffer disease. What you're likely doing is bringing animals into the world who otherwise would not exist, which is something entirely different than the self-congratulatory, borderline Messianic nonsense printed above.

The Atheist
The only point which matters here is that morality is a human construct, and therefore indefinable, other than by some kind of arbitrary consensus, which is pretty much how the world survives right now.Beyond those societal constructs, I don't believe morals exist.

Just because something is a human construct does not mean it is "indefinable" -- not that it matters -- and morality is not "arbitrary" but inextricably bounded up with rationality, which I suppose you can mistakenly denigrate as "human rationality." If you do take "a few" of those "moral positions" yourself, then you can at least be held to account for their consistency.

So you're ready and willing to take the position that a society that women should be subservient to men is no better or worse than a more egalitarian society because, after all, these are merely social constructs. A society that enslaves people based on birth or race is also no better or worse, and so on for all persecuted minorities, the non-religious, the faithful (wrong faith), homosexuals etc. Right? Well, OK, but why do the nincompoops who espouse this moronic view always come into threads on vegetarianism? Virtually every thread on the boards dedicated to morality, politics, social issues is ready to be unmasked. It's really just so silly and boring and adolescent.
 
OK, good.

You support laws which prevent cruelty to animals - the infliction of harm or suffering on them for no good reason. So the next question is: do you consider killing to be a form of "harm", and do you consider "I like the taste of meat" to be a good reason?

Note - this isn't about the raising of animals, which is not necessarily inherently cruel, but the simple fact of killing them (even "humanely", whatever that means) to satisfy a whim, which I contend is.

What is the difference between randomly killing a wild animal for sadistic pleasure, and deliberately killing a captive one for the pleasure of taste?
It is about the raising of animals. Almost all meat I eat was raised to be food. You can't remove that fact from the morality equation. I think it is good to give a cow, chicken, etc a chance at life. The more cows, the better. Fishing in the ocean I find far more ambiguous.
 
Why deny a morality continuum? Its a bigger deal to kill a large mammal than a small insect. At some point in size, we kill insects and mites without knowing it.
You don't even need a hunting license to kill bacteria.

Its just how it is. Dolphins should get more rights than rats.
 
It is about the raising of animals. Almost all meat I eat was raised to be food.

Dog fighting dogs were raised to take part in dogfights, and would not exist otherwise. Dancing bears are raised to dance. Circus elephants are raised to do tricks. Better to give them a chance at life?

What's your point?

Can you address my questions - does killing constitute a form of harm? The animal cruelty laws you support say yes. And is eating meat unnecessary? The fact that I'm not dead right now says yes.

* do you consider killing to be a form of "harm"?
* do you consider "I like the taste of meat" to be a good reason for the infliction of harm?
* What is the difference between randomly killing an animal for sadistic pleasure, and deliberately killing one for the pleasure of taste?

So how can you justify meat eating if you simultaneously support animal cruelty legislation? It is entirely contradictory to do so.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom